00:00:00.7200000 A guy. 00:00:21.2800000 Hello, everyone. I'll wait just a few seconds for everybody to make their way in. 00:00:37.9400000 Super. Welcome to today's program. Your most powerful trial tool isn't what you say, it's how you say it. I'm Mike debliss. For those of you who don't know me, I'm a trial attorney, had my start in the public defender's office, am now in private practice, continuing to do a lot of criminal defense work. 00:00:59.5300000 However, I also maintain a vibrant practice in personal injury, tax law and real estate. So it, it keeps me grounded in many ways. So many of these presentations that I've done have been an amalgamation of my experience as a public defender. Trying a lot of cases, litigating a lot of pre trial motions, and really getting experience, firsthand experience in the trenches. So much of what I learned, I, I was surprised did not so much come from my experience in mock trial when I was in law school, but the experience that I gained in the real trial work, specifically in trial prep, I, I think that that can be very under. 00:01:56.0800000 I, I think that that can be very, very much ignored at times. But the trial prep process reveals so much. You learn so much about the other side's case, what their arguments, their likely arguments are, how to rebut those arguments. And even when cases resolve after weeks and weeks of, never look at the trial preparation process as a waste. In essence, it helps to identify the issues for subsequent cases that are trial bound and that really do go to trial. 00:02:33.6600000 So it's about the, it's about training your eye to identify the salient issues in the case, identify theories and themes, shallow defenses work with facts, which are very stubborn things, as I know you all all know. And that can lead to many different inferences, especially when they are combined with other facts. This presentation is born out of the, the, the realization that I came to after trying cases, just a few cases, that my body and my voice were giving off more information than the actual words that were beneath them. And wanted so desperately to map my voice to my intentions and my emotional life so that it would be extra impactful and my voice would convey the conviction that I had. And that was easy for me to state, but not so much in a way that was expressing the, my core belief and my convictions behind it. 00:03:51.1400000 So I guess in a short sense it was easy for me to wring the meaning out of words instead of infusing them with life so that the jury could hear how passionate I was, for example, and how much I cared about my client, how much I believed in the defense, how much of a zealous advocate I was to prove to them that this defense was valid and that these facts failed to rise to the level of beyond a reasonable doubt. So, so much of that. This presentation is going to combine these elements that are sometimes viewed as the soft side of. Of trial preparation because it's one that we don't spend a lot of time on. We spend all the time in the world on crafting the arguments, on drafting our cross examination and all of those things. 00:04:51.6000000 And then we get to court. And I think many of us fail to recognize that we are the delivery systems for these words that are on paper. And if it were a brief that we were submitting to a judge, that's one thing. But trial advocacy relies on the spoken word. So we have to be as strong vocally as the words are on the page. 00:05:19.5900000 And so infusing those words with life so that they match the intention that you're. That you have is the goal, the overall goal of this presentation. So, without further ado, let's jump right in. 00:05:38.0500000 Why voice matters more than you think. Jurors don't experience your case on paper. They experience it through your voice. What is the voice? Well, the voice on a very simple level, consists of rhythm. 00:05:53.9800000 It consists of pauses. It consists of inflections. It consists of pitch. It consists of the pacing. All of these things combine to lift these words, these black, squiggly lines on paper, to life. 00:06:14.3000000 A flat delivery forces jurors to work harder. A dynamic voice does the work hard for them. This is very similar when you look at audiobook narrators and the work that they do with the script. They bring it to life in a way that hooks in the ear and makes you. Makes you an active listener, one who is. 00:06:39.7000000 Who actually feels that they've been transported into the actual story itself. This is what good narration can do. So, needless to say, we can spend countless hours refining what to say in an opening statement, facts, themes, and structure. But again, jurors don't experience the case on paper. They experience it through your voice. 00:07:06.1000000 And your voice, when used intentionally, becomes something more than sound. It becomes guidance. Like a lighthouse cutting through fog, it directs the jury to quietly, subtly, toward meaning. This presentation will show how to apply effective voice principles, some of which we've already discussed. Pitch, pace, pause, and emphasis in a way that transforms your opening from a recitation into an experience. 00:07:38.3500000 So again, jurors don't process information logically. They respond to rhythm, contrast, emotional cues, and silence. The four voice tools every trial lawyer must master consists of 1, pitch, 2 pace, 3, pause, and 4, emphasis. It is important when we set off on this journey to recognize that these are always being used interchangeably in our normal speech patterns. Depending, of course, upon the person we're speaking to and the type of discussion we're having, they naturally and organically combine to bring you to every conversation that you are in. 00:08:26.5300000 When we are working with a script, as we are when we are doing an opening or a closing argument, it of course, is our words on paper, but it is now the. The attorney's job to memorize those words and to speak them in a way that, that makes the jury feel like you are speaking them for the first time. Even though if you did all your homework leading up to this point, you would have been, you would have brought this up on its feet to rehearse this statement or this argument at least a dozen times before you're doing it for the jury. So this idea of creating spontaneity with words that are rehearsed and that. And that might now feel as if they're being delivered or if they're being recited, my approach to any type of memorized argument is that it is alive. 00:09:32.7300000 And even though you've memorized the same text each time you deliver it, as I'm sure you find in your own experience when you are rehearsing it, each time is a little bit different. Why? Because it lives in the moment. These, these topics, these ideas that you've organized are meant to inspire you, are meant to help you to organize your thoughts around the facts that you have and the themes that you are advancing to the jury. So when you are truly working at an optimal level, you aren't going to be so scripted to or tethered to your notes. 00:10:20.1000000 Your notes are going to be inspiration to create new ideas that form in the moment. The more immersed you are with the subject matter of your opening or closing, and the. And the deeper it has had to. The deeper of an opportunity you've had to sit with it, the sharper the arguments are going to be, the quicker and more nimble you're going to be able to be, to shift and to take facts and use different facts in, to make different points, to marshal different facts up. But again, this comes from an inordinate amount of preparation. 00:11:02.5800000 It will, of course, look like it's being spoken in the moment, but that's because you have done your work well in advance. So pitch, this is your emotional register. Pitch is the rise and fall of your voice. Again, this Is something that organically happens in any conversation that you're having with another person. The lower the pitch, the more serious we become, the more credible we become, the more authoritative, the higher the pitch, the more urgency and the more tension that it brings. 00:11:40.4400000 Mid range is well suited for conversational storytelling. Used correctly, pitch allows you to signal emotion without saying it. Instead of saying, this was serious, your voice makes the jury feel that it was. And this is an important distinction. It is often easier to state the emotion then to let it infuse your emotional life so that the jury can feel it from the subtext or from the soup, from what we might refer to as a supertext of the words, from the sound of your words. 00:12:21.8500000 There was a famous acting teacher who described the emotional life of a person as being the river and the memorized words as being the canoe. And the metaphor was that when you are connected to your emotional life, in this case, the conviction of the cause, in the case you're arguing, your words that are memorized are going to. Are going to be wholly dependent on your emotional life. The more placid and calm your emotional life, the more placid and calm the delivery of those words, the more urgent you, you, you find yourself being, then the more tumultuous the sea is going to become, and therefore the words are going to become. I think it's a beautiful metaphor because it teaches us that we don't have to be so intentional. 00:13:23.3400000 To script, if you will, the pitch or the pace or the pause. Based on the different sections of your statement, opening statement or closing, you can let those come up organically. And those shifts can happen based on your connection with the jury. That is the best connection that you can ever have. When you are open to what you're receiving from the jury, and what's going on in them is showing up in you where, and vice versa, what's happening in you is somehow showing up in them. 00:14:00.8100000 That is the beauty of a conversation. And the more conversational reality we can bring into the courtroom with us, the more the jury is going to feel that you're talking to them. And we all know what it's like to be in an audience of several hundred people, perhaps where there's one speaker on stage, but their words are pierce through the audience and you feel as if they are speaking directly to you. That builds credibility, that builds likability. You begin to root for this person and champion them, and then you, you begin to follow them to wherever they take you. 00:14:46.1300000 It is no different in a courtroom. So we have pitch we then have pace. Pacing is designed, is not just speed. So I want to make that distinction. It's more control. 00:14:59.7200000 If we use a faster pace, it is going to plunge an audience into action, chaos, unfolding events. A slower pace will indicate importance, reflection, meaning. At this point, I think it's helpful to identify where we live habitually. Every one of us is habitual in one or more of these subcategories. Within these four, I know people that speak quickly and that is their default. 00:15:36.8500000 They are, they're speaking very quickly all the time. And for those people, it's very interesting to challenge them with, with going slow because when they're challenged to go slow, immediately there's a shift in their, in their energy. And you can feel like something important is about to happen because the shift to a slower pace is essentially the highlight. Just like we would highlight words in a brief to help distinguish one argument from another. The slow pace amidst the sea of a fast pace helps what is about to come on the heels of slowing down. 00:16:22.3900000 That lifts it to a level of importance and helps it to stand out for a jury. And that would, that could be used intentionally when the attorney gets to a point in their argument that they want to make sure will resonate with the jury. So it's a great tool to work with in the preparation process to see how it is being received by others. And this is why I cannot say enough times, if you can gather people from your office, particularly non lawyers, to listen to your arguments and you can create an environment where they feel at ease and they feel comfortable to provide objective feedback. The information that you get will be so helpful for you as you begin to, as you begin to work on your delivery because there's only so much information you can get from yourself. 00:17:29.7700000 So many of us, including me, are blind to the things that we do habit that that I do habitually. And it's not until somebody brings certain things to my attention that I'm able, if I truly can take it as objective feedback that I can, I can make some shifts that are going to help parts of my speech to stick out more than they otherwise would if I maintained the status quo throughout. So this is why shifting pace is very important. I think that the default most people would fall into if they were to highlight or come to a point where they want to highlight something, the default that most people would naturally come to is by increasing their voice or their pitch level. And I think while that could work, I do think, however, it's nice to play with pace as well, because I have seen attorneys playing with pace in a courtroom and slowing down on the heels of something important that literally captured the jury and put them in a spell state where they were hanging on every syllable that came out on the heels of that slower pacing. 00:18:48.5500000 So it's not always a rise in pitch that's going to help what is about to come to stick out more than what else is, what else has come before it. You can play with pace as well. Yes. So again, when everything is delivered at the same speed, nothing stands out. And this is about clarity. 00:19:08.7200000 It is about being understood. It is about the jury being able to in real time, understand your arguments and how you're organizing them and following you. But when you're, when you vary the pace, you decide what the jury notices and what they remember. Pause is the third tool. It is so underrated. 00:19:34.7500000 Most lawyers fear silence. And I think there's an element of a vulnerability involved in the pause, because when we pause, there's utter silence in the courtroom, save, of course, people moving around in the pews or coughs or things of that nature. But there's dead silence. And eyes that might otherwise have been wandering throughout the gallery on the part of the jurors immediately focus to you. Because we all, as humans know that this is something that is deeply profound. 00:20:18.6400000 When a person stops and pauses, a myriad of things could be going on inside them. And instinctively, we know this as human beings. Is this person thinking? Are they reflecting? If so, that is more interesting for an audience to watch a person in deep thought and reflection than it is for a person just speaking words and at a, at a, at a quick pace. 00:20:51.0500000 The act of reflecting is something that makes people feel is authentic. You are taking the time to, to, to think your way through something deliberately and intentionally without giving it just, you know, without a knee jerk response that in today's society, so many of us do. Now, that's not to say that people who are speaking fast aren't having those moments as well. They're just happy having them quicker because they intuit quicker. We as lawyers routinely have an ability to intuit quicker than other people because we are so immersed in the, in legalese and in our case that these words come freely. 00:21:42.2700000 We are able to marshal facts, apply them to the law and, and quickly analyze them. But when there's a witness, for example, that's in a role of educating the jury, such as an expert, we want them. And if they are quick thinkers as well, we might want them to take their time and go slower because what, what a quick thinker can indicate to a jury is someone who hasn't taken time to deliberate and and thoroughly analyze both sides of an issue. And so that can give off some information that might be completely opposite to what the expert is intending in that moment. But a small shift such as slower pace can actually cure that. 00:22:32.3100000 And it would just of course, require some practice with that witness. Pause, the most underrated tool. So we're already on this. It signals importance, allows ideas to land, creates anticipation. What's going to happen next? 00:22:46.4100000 If they see the person in thought, what is he going to say next? What's going on inside him? It's no shock or surprise that the thinking man statue is one of the most popular statues of all time. And all it is, if you know, using all in a very loose way, all it is, is a person is a man, you know, with his chin in his hand pondering something, obviously something deep, you know, because he is in this position. But it just goes to show that there's such great beauty in thought and that it immediately signals importance to an audience. 00:23:28.3700000 Emphasis. Jurors prefer to arrive themselves light stress, not heavy handed. What we're talking about here is that emphasis must be light and not heavy handed. A slight stress on a word, a fractional pause before a phrase, that's enough. Anything more might feel like persuasion. 00:23:54.4000000 And jurors resist persuasion. They can see it doesn't mean that there aren't going to be moments where we're forceful. I am advocating, however, to bring in a little bit of each because if we are heavy handed all the time, then it's the equivalent of telling your, you know, your eight or nine year old child, you've got to do your homework before you go outside. You can't do this until you do that. Those things people shut down to, not just eight and nine year olds, but even us as we grow older, we don't like to be told you have to do this or you have to do that. 00:24:36.9700000 We like to come to conclusions on our own. And if we recognizing that we can work backwards as attorneys by recognizing that in order to get a person to have these light bulb moments, these discovery moments on their own, we have to think outside the box and we have to turn everything upside down. Instead of pounding C, we have to actually look at the full equation. And perhaps the full equation is at A plus B equals C. For a lawyer, C might be the inference, the factual inference that you want the jury to draw. And A plus B might be the strongest evidence that supports, when combined together, supports that factual inference. 00:25:34.5100000 So how do we, if we adopt this approach of being discovery oriented, how do we get the jury to make the discoveries on their own? We emphasize A, we emphasize B and we put them together and allow the jury to do the rest. It is similar. We do this all the time. I'm just basically creating a framework for it. 00:25:59.0600000 It's like in a mistaken identification case where the victim is walking under an, an overpass in a forest at night and the defense is going to be that it was. That it wasn't my client, it was somebody else, and that it was so dark under the overpass and the victim was so distracted trying to perhaps get to the mace in her purse to ward off the attacker that she never got a good look at him. So instead of confronting the witness by saying, you mistakenly identified Johnny, my client, which of course she's going to push back on you take all of the good facts that are available to you in the case, which might be a pitch black overpass because it was 7 o' clock at night and there are no lights in the, in the overpass, underneath the overpass, it is surrounded by bushes and shrubs. What was the victim doing 10 minutes before? Was she in a restaurant with a few friends gathering for a party where she was having a few drinks? 00:27:12.2200000 Was she slightly tippy? Was. Does she wear glasses normally to correct nearsightedness? And was she not wearing those glasses and not wearing her contacts on this specific evening? So those are your A's, but plus B's plus C's that when combined are going to lead the jury to the inescapable conclusion that this was a mistaken identification. 00:27:39.9500000 Of course, there's other facts as well. There's the alibi, which is a lot of trouble in many ways because they tend to be family members and easily susceptible to impeachment. So from flat to powerful, the typical opening, the evidence will show that the defendant was misidentified and was not present at the scene. Now there are of course some positives that come from this typical statement that gets, launches the jury into this case. Is it clear? 00:28:17.2600000 Yes. But is it memorable? No. Think about it. If you were reading a story to your, you know, to an eight year old and it started out by saying that the evidence will show that Peter Rabbit was, was, was, was attacked and by Mr. McGregor, who, who saw him when he was out tending to his garden, it's not going to have as much impact. 00:28:50.4400000 Attack. I like, I like because it had. It's a verb, but it's not enough specificity and detail in Order to launch the jury in. We want to, in the first phrase of an opening, launch the jury into this story. Because the first, the beginning of anything is always an opportunity for what we call for what psychologists refer to as primacy. 00:29:18.6600000 It means that what is stated in the beginning is going to be remembered more than other stages of a speech. What is stated at the end is referred to as recency, and it has even more impact than what is stated in the beginning. So this example teaches a lot of lessons. It is normal, I think, in many courthouses throughout the country for attorneys to start out with greetings and salutations, but we need to dispense with those things and go right into the case itself. To go, to spend time with salutations is to be inefficient with the scarcity of the jury's time and the low attention spans that we're dealing with today in 2026. 00:30:11.1400000 So a voice driven opening. Imagine the delivery this way, ladies and gentlemen, this case is about a mistake. Now, that doesn't contain a lot of information, but it certainly is short and it piques interest. And then you might pause. A mistake that felt certain in the moment. 00:30:37.0700000 Again, the effect here, the jury leans in, the idea breathes because you've paused and you've let some time for it to, to, to, to settle on the jury. The theme lands. 00:30:57.7400000 You create contrast. So fast versus slow, loud versus quiet, high versus low. Contrast creates attention. And this is, I, I would, I would describe this as probably the number one thing that is, that is lacked by most openings and closings, the lack of contrast. 00:31:23.4000000 We stay at the same level. And in staying at the same level, again, the jury doesn't know what is important versus what isn't as important because everything has the same weight. There aren't the hills and the valleys that organically arise in a conversation where you are an active participant, even if you aren't the one speaking, but you are the listener. So we need to work towards creating contrast. And here's the tricky part, I suppose, that we can all recognize, okay, contrast intuitively. 00:31:59.6800000 I get that, Mike, I get that. But how to create the contrast so that it's not manufactured but organic, that is taking it to another level. Because you can tell, can't you, when there's a speaker who is manufacturing something just for the sake of trying to create contrast versus one where the contrast happens organically by what he or she is experiencing from the audience. So there's a big difference. When you manufacture something, it's very easy for an audience to pick up a sense of fakeness or imposter like syndrome. 00:32:47.4200000 Whereas the true organic nature of shift to contrast is going to appear as, as I just said, organic and convers. 00:33:04.2300000 Two. You guide without forcing. This is another very important element. Your voice highlights what matters without announcing it. The strongest persuasion is the kind the jury doesn't notice. 00:33:17.5900000 Three, you build credibility, measure delivery, signals control. Control signals confidence. Quiet confidence reads as truth. Four, you turn information into story. Facts alone never persuade. 00:33:32.0900000 Experience does. Voice is what converts one into the other. As you are speaking to the jury, they are assimilating the information that they are getting. And like it or not, and notwithstanding the jury instructions to the contrary, the jurors are taking in this information and comparing it to their life experiences and how they, they, they. How they, how they see the world and how it works. 00:34:08.4000000 These frameworks have been passed down since the time they were young. These were the things that shaped our personalities during those tender years. But that's the filter that they are constantly going to be comparing the facts to. If you don't give them a story to organize these disparate facts that are coming in out of order and that are in different forms, whether it be testimonial evidence or physical evidence out of necessity, the jury will create their own narrative framework. And the danger that that poses is if you are going to surrender the storytelling part to the jury, whereas where you just throw out the facts and hope that they catch them and assemble them in the, in the order that you, that you need them to assemble it in to win your case. 00:35:04.1700000 You are you, you, you, you, you are at a, you're putting yourself at a disadvantage. Your job is the, as the attorney is to marshal those facts together and create the story, the narrative framework for them to see this reconstructed reality of past events. Obviously they weren't there and if they were, they couldn't be sitting on this jury. But you are going to relive these, these, the facts of this case through the story that you tell them and through the witnesses that come into court. And this narrative framework is the one that you want them to see your version of the facts through. 00:35:46.9000000 Because in advance you've analyzed it and you viewed it through this lens and this in, in your preparation has led you to the belief and to the decision as the trial attorney that this is the winning narrative. And this is the perspective I want the jury to see these facts from. The lighthouse principle. 00:36:12.1300000 One of the most powerful ways to think about voice is this. You are not pushing the jury. You're guiding Them like a lighthouse guiding a ship. Your voice illuminates key ideas, signals direction, keeps the jury oriented. If your emphasis is off, you don't just lose clarity. 00:36:30.5600000 You risk guiding them somewhere you never intended. Practical tips you can use immediately mark up your openings. Don't just write your opening. I like to score it like music. I will add pauses, emphasis points, changes in pace. 00:36:48.5600000 But I want to be very clear. While I will do that, I will not be so scripted as to demand that those moments absolutely call for a pause. Why? Because if I'm truly alive and in the moment, in the speech that I'm giving, it is going to take on a life of its own. If I am truly open to what I'm getting from the jury, someone in the first row, for example, might, you know, might look at me and, and, and, and smile a little bit. 00:37:28.0800000 That's going to inform something inside me if I'm open and receptive to it. So I'm not suggesting that you put in scores or notes and you, and, and you, you at all cost anchor yourself to them. They are just there as guidance. They're just there for. To trigger your memory and your recollection that you are getting to a point, for example, in the speech that is very important and that this point has to be lifted and has to be made more operative than what has come before it. 00:38:06.8300000 That's all. So if you put a pause in the margins as that, as a moment for pause, and a pause doesn't come out, but you. Your voice takes on a different tone, then that is valid for that moment, because that was, that was what was going on in the courtroom. That was your experience with the rest of the jury, and that informed that moment. So don't feel like you're anchored to these notes in any way, shape or form. 00:38:35.2800000 They are just suggestions. Identify three to five key moments that deserve vocal weight. Not every line deserves weight. Choose your theme, your turning point, your conclusion. Then build your vocal strategy around those moments. 00:38:54.1600000 Practice out loud, never in your head. It's okay to start out in your head. I used to be, because I'm so task oriented, I would write up, type up my opening statement. And the moment I got it to the point where I liked it, I would, I would check opening statement off on the list of trial tasks that I had to do, never to come back to it, sadly, until maybe a night before the trial. 00:39:28.0400000 It's difficult. It's difficult to say this because I know how overwhelming it is and how much time goes into just ordinary trial prep. But I cannot, I cannot emphasize enough the importance of getting it up on its feet. That's the, the phrase that I use when I, when I'm done writing it. I now AM Only really 40% of the way there when it comes, for example, to opening now I need to get it up on its feet. 00:40:02.5300000 Because the spoken word and the written word are diametrically opposite from one another in many ways. You know, we write on paper in long phrases. And those phrases, while easy for a reader who is sitting down in their office to read and process because they can read at their own pace, they can go back a paragraph before to refresh their memory about something. You have to recognize that when it comes to the spoken voice and it comes to jurors, they don't have the luxury of having the transcript in front of them so they can't go back if they get lost. And so the emphasis should be on shorter statements. 00:40:49.6700000 The emphasis should be on, if we do go into longer thoughts, always coming back to the main topic. And, and I guess a great principle is to tell them what you're going to tell them. Tell them, then tell them what you told them. So viewing thoughts as journeys, for example, through the forest. And like a journey through the forest, you can sometimes get lost when you come up to a fork in the road, like Yogi Berra would used to say. 00:41:23.8600000 And then he said, take it. But yes, thoughts can sometimes go in divergent ways and then you get back on track again. But if you always hold or suspend the point that preceded that thought such that you can bring it back, that will be your lighthouse, that'll be your guiding light beckoning you back and allowing you not to lose track of the main point. And that's what's, that's what happens to a lot of us. Losing the main point, getting, getting lost in the forest because of the analysis, the tedious and meticulous analysis that we're doing with the facts going in that very narrow lens view and then having to go wide out is not easy to do. 00:42:14.1300000 It's not something that we do in everyday life. In everyday life, we talk a lot in generality. But in the closing argument, it's not a Starbucks conversation. We're getting narrow with the legal analysis. And then we've got to get the aerial view from atop Mount Everest and always allow. 00:42:33.4300000 And that way it allows the jury to follow us along and to be able to have those light bulb moments. Okay, I can understand now what this argument, the overall topic that this argument is supporting, eliminate the monotone Trap. If everything sounds the same, nothing matters. Force, variation, slow down where accounts speed up where it moves. Respect the pause. 00:43:01.1790000 The thing with the pause is there's an element of having to earn the pause. It's, it's interesting because Shakespeare, I do a lot of Shakespeare and I remember in my early days of Shakespeare, I, I would do, I would make the rookie error of pausing to thinking that I was creating a weighty moment. But what I didn't understand is that the pause had to be earned. And if I started to use the pause, if I started to litter the pause around then a, it was irritating because people would view, began to view it as being condescending and arrogant, that I was, you know, just pausing for self indulgent reasons. That's how it seemed. 00:43:50.9300000 And then when, when there were moments when the pause was truly necessary and I, I took that pause, it lost its complete meaning because I overused it in other part parts of the speech where it wasn't necessary. So be very specific and respect it and use it during those times where it really merits, where it, this, this point really does need to resonate and be lifted. 00:44:23.3100000 All right, let me just see here. 00:44:33.3100000 So before I get into this hypothetical, the final thought I have is next time you prepare an opening, don't just ask, what am I going to say? Ask, how will the jury experience this? Because in the courtroom, your voice isn't just a tool. It's a difference between being heard and being remembered. I'm always jury oriented and I like to, and this is a helpful reminder to me so as to never keep any juror out in the sense that I always want to make eye contact with every single juror and not just quickly. 00:45:12.4600000 I want to really make sure that I've seen every juror in that box. As a criminal defense attorney, I never know who might be the one holdout, the one person that is holding firm to their belief that in this case, for example, the prosecutor has not sustained their burden. And just imagine what it must be like to be that one person in a room where everywhere, where the other 11 are unanimous in favor of guilt and that one person is there essentially holding back Niagara Falls. I can't even imagine. And honestly, I don't know if I would even myself be brave enough in that same situation to, to, to maintain my position. 00:46:09.6000000 But there might be one person in this box who is in that position. And looking at it from that perspective makes me really see every juror, not just scan them, not just look over their head, because I don't Want to. I'm embarrassed or ashamed of making eye contact, but really see them and, and, and speak to them. That is the best thing, because that could be the last. That could be the very last, the very last thing that's holding them on to that core conviction that the prosecutor hasn't sustained their burden. 00:46:53.3400000 Here's a hypothetical case. It is a. An armed robbery. The defense has mistaken identification. The theme is that certainty can be created and be wrong. 00:47:07.3400000 So this might, these are just some suggestions how we might start. You have opening line, low pitch, and slow pace. Remember, low pitch is going to put you in, you know, in a lower register and is going to automatically create a sense of this is serious and that this person is credible. Ladies and gentlemen, this case is about a mistake theme. Subtle stress on felt certain. 00:47:43.9100000 A mistake that felt certain in the moment. An action sequence. Faster pace and rising pitch. A man runs a hood pulled tight. A voice demands money. 00:47:56.9200000 The pace here is going to accentuate the actual content of what we're saying. So a man runs. That connotes action. It connotes something that is happening quickly. And so if our pace mirrors the content of a person running a hood pulled tight, a voice demanding money, it will accentuate how quickly this happened. 00:48:29.8700000 Because at the end of the day, quickness is going to be a powerful theme in the sense that this person did not have an opportunity to get a good look at the actor because of how quickly all of this happened. And then you compound that with the darkness. You compound that with perhaps intoxication. All of these elements come together. All these inferences are being marshaled together to lead to the inescapable inference of this person mistakenly identified. 00:49:07.3400000 Johnny. Defense theory, lowest pitch and fragment control. That man, they say, is Daniel Ortiz. Closing, slow, clear, restrained. It is about what is actually true. 00:49:27.3000000 Okay, Yes. So again, it is. The powerful opening is again, not just well written, it is well delivered. Jurors decide based on what they felt, what they understood, what stayed with them. 00:49:54.8200000 All right, we talked about this. 00:49:59.2200000 All right, I'm going to just stop, share. I have a few more slides that I'm going to put up here. 00:50:30.7000000 Just give me one second. It. 00:51:07.9200000 Okay. 00:51:19.3600000 I always like to end this topic with a short discussion about rhetoric. I am a huge proponent of rhetoric. We use this all the time, specifically when we are in closing, but also throughout other aspects of the trial. So what is rhetoric? Well, on a very basic level, it's heightened language. 00:51:49.3900000 This was discovered by Aristotle. Aristotle believed that there were three main ways to influence an audience, and he called those Pathos, logos, and ethos. Essentially, logos was the logical appeal to a person's reasoning to win the argument. Pathos was a. Was more of an emotional appeal to the person's heart. 00:52:24.3000000 And then the final one was ethos. And I just want to get that definition. 00:52:43.3400000 Yeah, so. Yeah. So pathos again, was the act of evoking emotions in the audience. Logo was the appeal to rhetoric. And ethos is the act of appealing to the speaker's or writer's authority as a means of persuasion. 00:52:58.3300000 There are rhetorical tools that we all use in everyday speech and we probably don't even know it. It's helpful, though, to put labels to them, because that way we can use them more intentionally when we are writing out our arguments. 00:53:20.4100000 A few that we know very readily are antithesis. It is the act of comparing one thing to the other. It was the best of times, it was the worst of times. What I think is beautiful about antithesis is that as humans, we tend to understand A and B better or individually when they're offset or contrasted to one another. And this is something that we do all the time in closing, when we are comparing a. 00:53:58.3600000 A feudal argument that is being advanced by the other side to an argument that we are making to show how incredulous the adversary's argument is. But the beauty of the antithesis is that the emphasis falls so effortless on one key word. And there's always usually one key word on each side that are being set off from one another. So, for example, going back to the first example, it was the best of times, it was the worst, best and worst. To be or not to be. 00:54:39.9700000 So it's actually, you know, contrasting those two deep metaphorical ideas. Metaphor, speaking of metaphor is yet another form of, of rhetoric. Assimile is another form. And there's. Here's a whole list right now. 00:55:02.1400000 Repetition, battered, or repetition, or triplets, rather battered, beaten and abused in a case involving a battered woman. Enumeration, first, second, third, fourth, and fifth. There is great power in labeling things, and we can do this even on cross examination instead of just randomly going or transitioning from one question to the next. We can always preface what we are going to ask the. The adverse witness by saying, I'd like to turn to this topic. 00:55:43.7200000 I'd like to move now to this topic. And that's a great placeholder because it allows the jury in their mind to now prepare for what is next to come. So the questions that are going to follow, the jury knows is going to fall under the umbrella of this topic. This Is again, a useful way of keeping the jury along, allowing them to follow along and losing anyone. We have irony, we have vowels and consonants. 00:56:19.9400000 Again, we do this unconsciously, but to be able to put labels to these will allow us to use them more intentionally. Obama use, uses and has used repeating sounds or repeating words at different parts of his speeches. The one that I remember that stands out to me the most is his use of repetition in his 2008 speech, yes, we can. Then again, yes, we can. And that it's also a triplet, isn't it? 00:56:55.8500000 And the emphasis on each new iteration of yes, we can would always fall on a different word or different words. And that wasn't accidental. He knew that this was being repeated, and he knew that it couldn't be just ironed out into a flat way of saying it because the audience is hearing the same phrase over and over, but that the emphasis was going to be changed each subsequent time. 00:57:35.3600000 Triplets parallel structure. Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country. The emphasis naturally and organically falls on the syllable without you even having to intentionally pre decide where you want it to fall. Articulation is very important. 00:57:59.4400000 Tongue twisters are very helpful to get your voice and to get the articulators. Onomatopoeia is a literary device, and then we have to stop. It's a powerful literary device that the word sounds like the very thing that it's connoting. So, for example, splat or boing. It immediately gives you this sense of, you know, something that is falling to the earth and, like, breaking. 00:58:31.6200000 Maybe it's an egg, you know, that's being dropped. And so these are powerful ways of reinforcing those concepts that we want the jury, that we want to resonate in the minds of the jury. In fact, it harkens back to the pace that we were using to describe or to help, to help, to help instill this idea that the robbery happened so quickly we increased the pace of our voice. That is a form of onomatopoeia, where we are using our voice to help add more meaning and context to the content of the words that we're speaking. Slap is yet another one. 00:59:19.8100000 Then we have simile. We have direct, which is a direct comparison of unrelated things, like using like or as. Metaphor is a figure of speech in which a word or phrase literally denoting one kind of object or idea is used in place of another to suggest a likeness between them. And then there's examples. So again, it's nice to have a little bit of, a little bit of background on this so we can use this intentionally when we are preparing our closing argument. 00:59:48.3400000 So we are all through. I'm going to give you the code for today and let you on your way. Oops. Let me just. 01:00:00.0300000 Stop my share for a second. 01:00:23.2300000 The code for today is the number 6 capital L as in Larry, capital C as in Cat, 7 capital V as in Victor. I will also put it in the chat too. 01:00:42.4700000 And I'll recite it two more times. It's the number six capital L is in Larry, capital C is in cat, the number 7 capital V as in Victor. Last time, number 6 capital L as in Larry, capital C as in cat, the number 7 capital V as in Victor. Super. So happy to have you along. 01:01:05.4500000 Thank you for joining me and hope to see you at a future presentation with Lexid. Bye now.