00:00:12.4000000 Hello, everyone, and welcome. Hello and welcome. I'll give you all time to get logged in. Hello and welcome. So I'd like to welcome you to a very interesting CLE today. 00:00:29.6800000 This CLE is employee mental health and workplace risk. And we're also going to discuss compliance, privacy, and employer liability. So today we're going to go over employee wellness plans. And I'd like to start by asking how many of you are aware that May is Mental Health Awareness Month? Are many of you aware that May is Mental Health Awareness Month? 00:01:04.4900000 So since May is Mental Health Awareness Month, we wanted to present this CLE because many employees might be contending with mental health issues. And quite frankly, a lot of employees suffer with mental health issues in silence due to fear of discrimination in a workplace or feeling as if they will be judged. Or sometimes people may have family members that are suffering with mental health issues. And think about our ethical rules. If an attorney has mental health issues, perhaps they may be concerned that they will jeopardize our law license. 00:01:50.9800000 So there are a whole host of reasons why. Why if an attorney in fact has some type of mental health impairment, he or she might not disclose that. Also, if you are a business owner, are any of you business owners or do you supervise employees? If you could note in the chat, are any of you business owners? Do you supervise employees? 00:02:18.3900000 Please note in the chat if you are a business owner or if you supervise employees. So let's see if we have any business owners or supervisors. And don't worry, at the end, I will provide the CLE code so you will receive that. So let's see where we are in terms of business ownership. So Philip is a business owner. 00:02:43.2600000 Martin is a business owner. 00:02:47.4200000 Steve is an attorney, also business owner, new employee. So solo practitioner, perhaps. Dan is business owner, possibly has employees. Sarah, business owner. Business owner. 00:03:01.1200000 Those of you who mention business owner, do you have employees? Solo practitioner. The reason why I'm asking is because we are going to discuss at length today employee wellness programs. So if you are a business owner, guess what? The only way to truly make money in America, unless you have a trust fund and you're born into it, is someone else is working for you to make money for you. 00:03:31.0900000 You can't duplicate yourself and use individual labor to make a whole lot of money, right? So most of us will need to hire employees to duplicate. Duplicate our labor to sell our products. That's the pro. The con is people are humans until we have a fully automated system. 00:03:53.4600000 When you hire human beings, you're going to have to contend with possibly the following statutes contingent upon the number of employees you have. Some employees might have disabilities, so you might have to contend with the Americans with Disabilities Act. If your employees might need to leave due to what we are discussing, disabilities, the employee may have a disability, the employee may have a mental health issue, the employee may have a family member with a mental health issue, then you might have to understand fmla. If you are offering an employee wellness program, because human capital is the most important capital for any business owner, then you're going to have to make sure that if you are capturing data about employees and asking questions about their genetic background to host an employee wellness program, that you are not violating gina, which is the Genetic Information Non Discrimination Act. Also, if you grow to the point where you're offering employee benefits, because most employees these days are looking for an employer that is not only offered offering payment, they're looking for benefits. 00:05:24.2400000 So if you're offering benefits, that means you're probably offering health insurance. If you are sponsoring an employer health insurance plan, then you're going to have to understand hipaa, which is H ipaa. So these are some federal statutes that you would need to understand as a business owner. And if you are going to understand the employee mental health and workplace risk landscape, it is far too much for us to understand, dissect, pull apart, regurgitate and have a grasp within an hour. So see the hour together today as a framework or many frameworks of various statutes. 00:06:18.0100000 And then as your business sets scales, you can learn more about each statute. The mental health accommodations might fall into the brackets of Americans with Disabilities Act. So every employee that has a disability, it might not be mental. Some employees might have a physical disability. So if it is a mental disability, then perhaps it would fall under ada or it could be related to a family member that would be fmla. 00:06:50.1800000 If you're collecting genetic genetic information and it's related to a mental health disability, then it would implicate gina. If your employer sponsored health benefits plan is offering employer covered mental health benefits, then you would have to make sure that you are protecting that health information. Most employers, quite frankly, outsource this to a third party third party vendor that will handle employee benefits. And if you do that, since most of you are probably small business owners or sole practitioners, and as your business scale, then perhaps you would consider offering employee benefits. If you outsource to a third party that will handle your employee benefits, it also will decrease some employer liability. 00:07:55.4200000 Now, what's the downside of outsourcing? You'll have to pay the third party vendor and then when you're paying that third party vendor, you'll have to be very cautious. So if the third party vendor is using AI tools, most of them are. You want to make sure that you have an indemnification clause that if that party is held responsible for, for any type of AI bias, AI infringements, AI data privacy, your business is not held responsible. If your company or if you're working with a vendor that's offering digital health tools, you want to make sure those tools are first of all legal and make sure those tools are doing what they're supposed to do. 00:08:47.3100000 So let's do a very quick true and false. Is it illegal for digital health tools to capture data? Like if your employees sign up for a mental health tool and that tool captures data and then that party sells the data to another company in America, is it necessarily illegal for mental health apps, for example, to broker data from users? What do you all think? And if you are the employer and you are, for example, providing an employee wellness program, and then you offer employees, try this app, use this app, unbeknown to you, the app is then brokering this data to a third party vendor who's then selling this data. 00:09:50.1700000 So I'll tell you all this. Digital health tools, whether they're physical or mental, like the physical digital health tools are some of the health apps that will help you track your miles. So let's do this. I'll make it very easy to understand how many of you exercise regularly, right? I'm not asking you all age because of the ada, ADA statute, the age discrimination statute. 00:10:18.9100000 So I won't ask how old you are. But if any of you are over 30, 35, most of us are told we should exercise right? And if you're below 30, then you're exercising for vanity. If you're above 30, you're doing it to stay alive. But just a general poll. 00:10:36.7100000 Do any of you use health apps to help with exercise? So I'll start us off. I use health apps to help me in terms of tracking steps, right? So there are a certain number of steps and I'm going somewhere with this. And then how many of you possibly use like affirmation apps or good positive mood apps? 00:11:00.9000000 Because lawyering is one of the most stressful professions in the United States. Did you all know that our profession is one of the most high stress professions in the usa? So I use both mindfulness apps. I won't call it mental health because there's a difference between wellness apps and mental health apps. And we'll go over that soon. 00:11:31.2500000 So there's a difference. And then there's also just your physical apps. So when you are using these apps first for yourself, you want to be aware that sometimes these apps have what is called a dark pattern where you are unbeknowingly giving them information that can be sold and it's possibly not even illegal. Your information can be brokered because if you don't go into the app and opt out, then they're able to sell your information. So where am I going with this? 00:12:11.7400000 If you scale to the point where you're offering mindfulness apps, employee wellness programs, digital health tools, make sure that you have a clear opt out program. Because if it is ever disclosed that employees say, well, we didn't know this app was tracking where we live, where we go, what we do. We didn't have an opportunity to opt out. And all of a sudd. This app is caught up in an FTC breach of privacy issue. 00:12:46.8400000 You will be aware as of right now, it is not illegal for most health tools or health apps to capture that data because health apps are not covered under hipaa. Health apps are covered under the ftc. So HIPAA covers health programs like health insurance, but it doesn't cover apps. Apps are covered by the ftc. And the difference is the app is considered a health tool, not a health program. 00:13:27.1700000 And HIPAA only covers entities that are offering health insurance programs. So you want to be very careful if and when you scale or even if you're sponsoring programs or you're working in health law or you're representing clients to be very careful with health tools or health apps versus a health insurance program and then emerging privacy risk. A lot of the emerging privacy risks are around AI data privacy breaches, even with your traditional health insurance companies. I don't know if many of you have ever heard of Kaiser Permanente. Do I have any Californians online or any persons from out west? 00:14:19.4900000 Have any of you ever heard of the HMO Kaiser Permanente? And I am not at all poking on any particular company, but just providing context. So even if it's not a health app, you also want to be careful if your insurance company or if you're representing insurance company. A lot of insurance companies now are using apps, whether it's a hmo. Most private doctors don't offer apps. 00:14:51.4600000 Usually if it's a health insurance organization, they're using a lot of apps. It could be a dental organization or using apps. A lot of data breach lawsuits, for example. If you want to review such a lawsuit, Kaiser Permanente has been recently involved in litigation regarding data privacy. That's a part of the emerging privacy risk when patients or clients go in to sign up for so the health apps provide lab results, you can schedule doctor's appointments, you can schedule mental health appointments. 00:15:33.2000000 And can you imagine if a doctor, a lawyer or a person doesn't even have to be a professional, but they might not want their mental health information shared? Correct. So if you're using HMO app or health organization app or an insurance company app and for some reason there is a privacy breach, then that private information could be shared. So a lot of concerns around using digital tools, whether it's AI or not, and privacy risk. So before we go on, I want to help you all understand the difference between AI and apps and tools. 00:16:21.3100000 Quick poll. I like to get you all involved. This is a quick poll. P o o L When you hear terms in the health landscape as digital tools, AI or health apps, do you all think that if you hear the term mental health app or mental health and AI tools, is that the same thing to you when you hear terms such as, let's say if you see mental health and I'll give you an example of a mental health app. Do we have any veterans online or any veteran families? 00:17:04.3400000 I'm going to give you an example of a mental health. Any veterans or veteran families. Anyone served in the military. Veteran family. Thank you for your service. 00:17:18.1000000 So do you all know about the va? The Veterans Administration mental health app is absolutely free. That's an example of a mental health app. So the VA mental health app, anyone can log on and if you all want to take a few minutes, if you have your smart device or if you're at a desktop, you can type in Veterans Administration mental health app. And it provides a lot of tools because a lot of veterans, of course, course, go through boot camp regardless of the military branch. 00:17:56.0800000 They're moving from place to place to serve our country. Some suffer from ptsd. You have wounded warriors, great sacrifice. So there's a mental health app. Where am I going with this? 00:18:09.4400000 The point is a mental health app, you can log into that app and it provides various data points. The app is what you actually can use to provide information. 00:18:25.3900000 The app is different from AI. So when you see mental health and AI tools. So AI is actually the system. I like to take time to explain definitions before we dive in. So always remember that AI is going to be the artificial intelligence system. 00:18:52.0700000 So AI is going to be the artificial intelligence system. So AI, for example, in the VA app would be the system that is used by the veteran administration on the back end, when you enter the prompt, it's going to be the system that's on the back end is processing the information, the icon that you see and the data output the results. That's going to be the actual app. So those terms are not interchangeable. And this is important because when you scale your business or as attorneys, when you're talking to AI vendors, please read and understand the terms because you don't want to be overcharged. 00:19:44.2200000 You want IT people to know that you know what you're talking about. And then this will also help in terms of workplace investigations, documentation and liability. So remember, AI is the actual back end system. The digital health tool is what we can see. It's the icons and the buttons that we push. 00:20:06.7800000 And then the emerging privacy risk is that when we as the users input our information into the AI system using the tools, we would hope that A, our information is protected and B, only those persons who are supposed to have access to the information will have access. And if it is used beyond those purposes, then we are aware and we have the opportunity to opt out. Now, that's in a utopian model that does not always happen. So when there is a breach, you might have workplace investigations. If you are offering employee mental health and some type of tools in the workplace, such as mental health benefits, employee benefits, or employee wellness programs. 00:21:05.6100000 So hopefully taking time to go through the parts will help you all to see how this works together in terms of takeaways that you will have after our time together, because 60 minutes is quite limited, you will have hypotheticals, you will have risk mitigation materials. So risk mitigation can come in different areas. It's not always litigation. What are some other areas of risk mitigation insurance? Whenever you're dealing with mental health, you definitely want to offer insurance insurance because people might be out of work and they need to be covered. 00:21:47.4900000 You also need to have workplace insurance because unfortunately, with mental health, you're also thinking about workplace accidents, workplace violence. Things can happen. So there are various type of risk. So in addition to litigation, there's a need for insurance. There is another type of insurance called EPL insurance. 00:22:14.6400000 Any litigators, have you all ever heard of EPL insurance? So EPL insurance is the type of insurance that every lawyer should know about, especially if you have a law firm, because this is the type of insurance that you need if you're ever sued. So if you have employees that work for you and they file a lawsuit, hopefully you have EPL insurance to cover lawsuits. So can you imagine all of the lawsuits we see in society if employers did not have insurance to cover lawsuits, they probably go bankrupt. So lawsuits includes risk mitigation litigation as well as workplace safety. 00:23:01.4700000 And the other type of risk mitigation is the moment we are in business, someone is looking to either take your business or soil your business. So you want to have goodwill, you want to have PR and good public relations and then governance. Governance is going to include PHI protected health information in terms of your employees data governance and good old fashioned board governance if you have oversight from a board and and good old fashioned workplace governance. So some of the issues to consider in terms of employee mental health are triggers in terms of exposure. So ADA deals with disabilities related to injuries, reasonable accommodations and confidentiality protections. 00:23:54.0800000 The main thing with mental health is during this month of May is to know that one in five Americans were purportedly suffer from a mental illness. Based on a research compiled from nami, which is the national association for Mental Illness. If you all had to take a guess, what do you think are the top two in terms of the percentages of mental illnesses in the United States or mental disorders that people in the United States suffer from? So remember, whatever is going on in society will seep over into the workplace. But if you all had to guess, what do you think are the top two? 00:24:42.2100000 So some of our yes, anxiety is number one, depression is number two, and based on, from what I can remember, bipolar disorder, ptsd, and then it was ocd, and then it is schizophrenia. Funny thing is we hear a lot about autism, but did you all know that autism is technically not included along with the other mental health disorders in terms of categorizing it with the traditional mental health disorders. So it kind of surprised me when I did the research that autism is not in the scale with the other mental health disorders, but do know that there appears to be a rise in either awareness or diagnosis of autism, even to the point where we have a lot of shows on television about autism. One show in particular, Love on the Spectrum. I'm like, wow, autism is becoming mainstream. 00:25:55.6600000 There's even a Netflix television show about autism. So we know that there is awareness. But pop culture and awareness doesn't always equate to it being truly understood and diagnosed and then being able to be fit neatly into a bracket in terms of law. Why am I saying this? Because it could be a mixed bag in terms of ada, fmla, gina, hipaa, eeoc. 00:26:33.1400000 So if you are representing an employer, or if you are an employer and you are made aware of autism, even if you do the research and the researchers are still trying to figure out how exactly where to place autism, do know that it is considered a mental health disorder and it should be treated as such. And persons who are possibly disclosing because remember it's self disclosure, autism should be given the same level of confidentiality and respect as the other disorders that are being recognized by NAMI and other mental health organizations in terms of the top number of percentages. So FMLA is mental Health leave eligibility. So if an employee has a mental health issue, FMLA might provide leave. State laws also provide leave. 00:27:37.0400000 So FMLA is Federal Family Medical Leave Act. But then many states, for example California also provides disability and family medical leave, a different type than federal, so it's state. So check in your jurisdiction for disability benefits as well as mental health disability and leave disability if you're representing clients. GINA is federal law which protects against discrimination based on genetic information. And of course, HIPAA protects health insurance information based on certain entities, such as a plan sponsor. 00:28:18.6200000 But it's limited. HIPAA does not cover, for example, health apps and some other provisions. If an app is considered a wellness app, then it's probably not covered by the ftc, the Federal Trade Commission. But if it is called a health app, then it might be covered by the ftc. Even if HIPAA does not apply, then EEOC enforcement, that's the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, also sets priorities in terms of enforcing the Americans with Disabilities act to make sure that people who have mental health disabilities are not discriminated against. 00:29:08.7400000 In addition to the ADA, there is the Rehabilitation act from 1973 that preceded the Americans with Disabilities Act. So the ADA was passed by President George Bush, the first President Bush, in 1990. It was passed in 1990. The Rehabilitation act was passed in 1973. So when you see the Rehabilitation act act, it's not an amendment of the ada, it's a separate disability act. 00:29:45.1700000 But it differs from the ADA in that it was limited in scope. The Rehabilitation act only applies to federal government agencies or public entities or perhaps federal contracts. But the ADA covers both public and private entities, so that's the differentiating factor. And also it should be noted that the ADA has been amended as of 2008. Now, with respect to the ADA, there are disability definitions and they have been expanded. 00:30:21.8900000 So in your own time, perhaps you could go back and review some of these expansions in terms of accommodation, protection and inclusion. I'd like to stop here to note if you suffer from a mental health disability, if your family members suffer from do know that a person should not feel compelled to disclose this information, but if you need to seek an accommodation, you would have to disclose this information to seek an accommodation. And this accommodation is usually sought through providing information from a health care provider. And you would have to fill out information. And this is both in a workplace context as well as in an education context. 00:31:14.9600000 But a person should not feel compelled to disclose any information. That's the accommodation piece. The protection piece is once an accommodation is applied for, the employee or the student will have to go through the process. And if it is approved, then that employee or student should be allowed protection under the ada, and that would mean inclusion to be treated like everyone else. Now, it should be noted that the employer is for all intents and purposes providing an accommodation, but the employer is also running a business or the school has a responsibility to other students as well. 00:32:05.0200000 So the accommodation, of course should be dignified and respectful to the person seeking an accommodation, but it should not unduly burden the workplace or the employer or the school to accommodate students. There are federal funds and there should be state funds to help families and to help schools for students with disabilities. And quite frankly, employers should do all they can to assist employees who are capable, willing and able to perform workplace duties. But they in fact suffer from a disability. So it's a very delicate topic. 00:32:50.8800000 We do hope that in America, if a person is able, willing and seeking employment, they will not be discriminated against. But there is a delicate balance in terms of the needs of needs of the employer and the other employees and balancing that with the needs of the disabled person who is seeking work or who is currently working the ADA interactive process. There's one failure to engage, and this is one that is most often litigated. So the employer duty to initiate. Upon knowing of a potential disability, employers must actively begin the interactive process without delay or waiting for employee request. 00:33:42.3900000 So if the disability is known, then there should be good faith engagement. Both parties must participate meaningfully in open dialogue. And I will start here. It is quite uncomfortable because most employers and as a person who works in a hybrid mode, I work part time for myself, part time as an employee, the entrepreneur and the business owner in me trembles at the fact of having a dialogue with an employee or a contractor upon knowing the person has a disability or potentially has a disability because you're thinking lawsuit. If you make a misstep, then your business could be sued and you could lose everything you work for. 00:34:37.4600000 So make sure your house is in the name of an LLC because you Want to be very careful. Lawsuits and litigation is dangerous. It's very dangerous. So you want to be insured. You want to make sure your assets are protected. 00:34:55.1400000 Because once you go down that slippery slope, anything could happen. In terms of open dialogue, I personally as the business owner would not do that. I would hire HR or trainer or someone who is capable and who is trained as a disability coordinator and who understands how to have a dialogue regarding ADA interactive process, ADA steps. Because well meaning conversations can lead to horrible lawsuits. So my suggestion is to have in your HR space someone who understands disability, understand both state and federal laws and how to have dialogue. 00:35:50.5500000 Otherwise it could go bad quickly. Once you have that dialogue, you want to exchange information. You want to have information about limitations, about job requirements and possible solutions. You also want to make sure there are reasonable accommodations for mental health. You want to consider solutions such as modified schedules, remote work options, reduce workload and job reassignment based on employee capabilities. 00:36:24.4400000 Now I have to stop here. The beauty of cles is we have the opportunity as lawyers and HR to have difficult conversations that hopefully will not cost us whole lot of money and will not cost us a law license. But one of the biggest fears I think most people have about mental health that we could probably discuss in a CLE that we could not discuss in society and open, certainly not in person, is people are afraid of violence and they're afraid of the same stigma, number one. Number two, there's this assumption that if a person has a mental health disorder, contingent upon what it is, is it going to mean that the workplace is no longer safe? Do you all still feel there is a stigma around mental health in 2026? 00:37:33.6100000 And if you knew that the employee next to you has a mental health disorder, would you feel comfortable working with that person? Or do you think someone else. Let's use someone else, not yourself. You're not answering for you. Let's say the reasonable person in society. 00:37:57.0900000 I remember in law school you never use first person. But let's use the hypothetical. Let's say the all American Joe. What about all American Joe? Is someone brave enough? 00:38:10.9700000 You can even come off the mic if you'd like. But I'd like to hear from you all because I think the concern around mental health. What about when we hear about workplace shootings in America, when we hear about schools or workplaces for all intents and purposes, do you automatically wonder, is something amiss in terms of is someone okay? Do you think there's like this assumption and it's a bad assumption or a stigma and If a person discloses that information, do you think it will be filed away and held against them? What do you all think? 00:38:56.5500000 Or do you think that people are even afraid to discuss this topic? What are the dangers of even having workplace training around mental health? 00:39:08.4600000 So I'll start us off. I think one of the biggest issues is going to be stigma. I think people are afraid of being judged. What about for lawyers? Do you think lawyers are afraid to possibly admit or speak out? 00:39:28.3000000 So let's see if I can unmute. How do I unmute? Maya, please. Hi. I was just gonna say I do believe there's still a sigma, but I do think there are generational differences because I do work with a lot of younger people and they're always talking about their mental health. 00:39:49.1800000 They talk about their mental health like people talk about allergies. And I think that is good in one case, and then in another case, sometimes they're not actually getting the help they need. They're just kind of commiserating. So that's also not helpful. But I do think there is still stigma and people still need to be more open. 00:40:09.7200000 And I think depending on what the mental health issue is, people would be nervous working besides somebody with certain mental health problems. And Maya, that's an excellent point. And we are very solution focus. And I suppose, Ms. Hallman, that you're also an attorney. Is that a correct assumption? 00:40:31.6300000 Yes, I am an attorney. And if you are, if we are to have these conversations in the workplace, say HR training, or if you were doing an HR training, what's probably a culturally sensitive way to provide HR training about mental health and not offend those who may be suffering in silence. 00:41:00.4300000 Any suggestions? Anyone? How would you approach it? I would say, in my opinion, we could possibly approach it by, first of all, it should not be coercive. You don't want to force anyone to attend these trainings. 00:41:15.8700000 You don't want to put an undo hardship on the employer because that would violate several rules in terms of the law. And here we have undue hardship assessment. So we want to evaluate whether the accommodation in terms of. And most of you are typing and you're saying, yes, the stigma still exists and Ms. Hallman works in this space or has knowledge of it. So we're all in agreement. 00:41:43.0200000 It's something that we all know, we think we feel, but it's the stigma. And then the employer has to do the balancing of undue hardship doing the assessment. And then in terms of the law, if you're offering EAPs, you all know, the employee assistance programs, they can't be coercive. So if you're offering EAPs, you can't make it mandatory. You can offer it in a way that it would help promote peace, harmony, safety in the workplace. 00:42:14.1600000 So number one, if you're doing training, you want to make sure it's voluntary, not coercive. Three, you're going to refer back to the employee handbook. So the employee handbook is going to be your saving grace. And you always want to wrap it around federal statutes or state statutes. You always want to put it in the context of ada. 00:42:40.5600000 ADA provides for assistance for people who have disabilities, want to protect people from discrimination. So as long as you're referring back to established laws, then you're not singling anyone out. And then if it's tied to other protected categories, race, sex, and then also, I don't know if you all are aware of Ames vs Ohio. Thank God in America now we don't have any preferred categories because with respect to mental health, it affects almost everyone in America. Black, white, Asian, all groups. 00:43:20.7600000 And According to Ames vs Ohio, there isn't one preferred group. A white person can bring a lawsuit. Black person, Hispanic person. So we can say this is inclusive for everyone. We have EAP for all. 00:43:37.2000000 So as long as you make it open to everyone, you're referring back to statutes and you're making sure that it's not coercive, then you are definitely in great shape. So in terms of some of your comments, I want to read some of your comments because this is great stuff and I think if we have more of these conversations, people would be less afraid. So Stephen mentioned people are afraid to discuss it, rightfully. So stigma. Stigma remains an ace. 00:44:10.1000000 Sarah. Yes, there's a stigma, but enough available knowledge that one should feel. One should not feel unsafe just because of a diagnosis. I agree there is a whole lot more, especially after COVID 19, because so many people suffered from anxiety and depression during COVID 19. And in California, I'll tell you all a little joke. 00:44:32.9400000 Almost everyone has a, like a handheld puppy and a therapist, especially during COVID So it became so, you know, almost like it's not a stigma. But that is a very progressive state. I think it's also where you live in America, but that's another cle. It may be held against them in the future, but hopefully keeps the employer open to being helpful and attentive. Definitely afraid of stigma. 00:45:04.3600000 Yes, I agree, Martin. Unfortunately, I think there is still a stigma, but I think the average person is much more comfortable. And this is from Jill with working with someone who might have a mental health illness. Because for all intents and purposes, if a person is provided proper support and treatment, most people are able to lead and as some therapists might say, what is normal. Right. 00:45:31.0900000 But what is normal and people who are treated are able to function. I think in a workplace setting, people are hesitant to discuss. You're absolutely correct, Elizabeth. So if you're having trainings in the workplace, we want to have it probably remote because people feel safer behind computer, not in person, workplace remote and also again, voluntary. And they do not have to participate in terms of engagement. 00:46:05.7400000 They could listen. So great point, Elizabeth. Stigma still exists, especially for older attorneys. Absolutely. Dan and Maya mentioned that generational, the younger people are much more aware and they're using ads and much of the stigma is still internal where people believe it is a weakness. 00:46:27 I would probably do a workshop like this month to talk about resources. Absolutely. So very good. We are coming down to the wire. I love the participation as we wrap up here. 00:46:44.6800000 Know that Gina is going to protect Even if a person discloses to you in the workplace about a mental health disorder, do not share the information because it's protected. And if you offer a wellness program, if you have wellness programs, there could be hidden traps. Just make sure that you disclose to protect your employer and to protect yourself that this information is voluntary. You do not have to disclose. So sometimes the health apps or the health applications will ask, is there a history of depression, anxiety or diabetes or any other physical mental disorder. 00:47:32.5600000 Always make sure that those who are filling out these forms know a voluntary, compulsive, no coercion, and quite frankly you don't have to participate. And then guard that information. Make sure there are firewalls if you have phi, which is protected health information, extra rules if it's HIPAA coverage, HIPAA applies if it's a medical insurance plan, if it is some type of app, meaning wellness app, HIPAA might not apply. But again, this is legal education, not legal advice. So I would ask you to please speak to an attorney in your jurisdiction about when HIPAA does and does not apply to employer sponsored plans. 00:48:22.1500000 EAP is an employee assistance plan that's different from an employer sponsored plan. So know the rules regarding the different types of employee benefits. FTC Health Breach Notification applies to non hip HIPAA health apps and services. This requires notification of breaches involving unsecured health information not covered by hipaa. And here's a bolo. 00:48:53.0100000 Be on the lookout if you are in states such as California and if, if any of you are in these States, please note to chat California. Do we have any Californians? Illinois. Anyone from Illinois without the S. So Illinois is a French word, so it's Illinois. But if it's more than one of you, then I'm going to add the S. Any of you here from the great state of Illinois, and if it's more than one of you, please put it in the chat. 00:49:30.8000000 Because the biometric data law in Illinois is the most litigated in the country. State. It's called bipa. Illinois is a heavy privacy state. Illinois has sued everybody from Six Flags to Facebook. 00:49:49.4400000 So in that state you have a lot of privacy protection. Texas is another state with privacy protection, as well as Utah, Colorado and Nevada and many others. A lot of the southern states up and coming, but you have some federal protection as well. So it's state to state. We don't have a federal framework, hopefully that will come along in the future. 00:50:16.7600000 In terms of EEOC enforcement, the most we have is through the ada. And usually if it's egregious, the problem with mental health discrimination claims, they have to be so egregious because unfortunately, the stigma that we talked about, a lot of people who have mental health disorders unfortunately are not employed. There is a huge, unfortunately, push to hire people who have mental health disorders. It is contingent upon the degree of mental health, but you can imagine there is a failure to accommodate in terms of the degree of anxiety, the degree of depression, the degree of post traumatic stress syndrome. So a lot of miss days from work leave and such. 00:51:14.4500000 So there's a lot of EEOC assistance and guidance, but a whole lot more work to do in terms of this space. So employee wellness programs rely on voluntary participation. There are penalties if an employee tries, employer tries to compel or coerce employees to participate in these programs for your assistance. I have pulled so much information for you all. Please don't penalize me for all the trees that may be lost if you print out all the attachments. 00:51:52.5300000 But I provided for you a copy of this PowerPoint and I believe you have 11 supplements, including AARP versus EEOC. And this is a District of Columbia case that found that large incentives tied to employee wellness programs create coercive pressure that violates the voluntary participation principle and can constitute discrimination under the ada. So I pull that case for you and it demonstrates if you have an employee wellness program, meaning you're representing employers, or if you one day scale your business and you have an employee wellness program, please keep it voluntary. Because if you don't, you could be sued and employees can rely on this case, AARP versus eeoc. So I pulled that case and the complaint for you so you can review that case and then I've pulled information for you regarding AI and digital mental health apps. 00:52:57.8200000 Those appear to be the rave. There is a NAMI video n a m I about mental health apps and how those can be used, but I pulled this information for you as well as information about behavioral monitoring and surveillance, a lot of concerns about who's watching me if I'm using these apps, and vendor management. So a lot of this is high tech. But it's for you to understand some of the issues around mental health apps such as confidentiality access and who has access to mental health information through these apps. As we end, make sure if you're ever involved in a workplace investigation, it should be based on performance issues, not mental health. 00:53:54.1600000 If you go directly to mental health, that could lead to separate legal issues in terms of an ADA discrimination claim. So if someone is behaving badly in the workplace and if in fact there is a mental health issue, focus on performance first. Then you want to document. Then you want to do a fitness for duty exam. Then you want to cover yourself to make sure there isn't a retaliation risk. 00:54:25.1700000 And as we conclude, I provided tips for you in terms of management critical training and because you want to work closely with HR to a of course protect employees, but also protect management in terms of possibly working with both both employees who are well and who are not neurodivergent as well as employees who might be neurodivergent. As we end, I provided for you hypotheticals so you can understand some of the issues that may be involved with the mental health population. So you have three hypotheticals, Hypothetical one, Hypothetical two and hypothetical three that you can review after our CLE today. And how do you mitigate some litigation risk that we discuss? Constant employee policy audits, Update your employee handbook that would be first continuous HR manager training and provide employee training scale in terms of vendor due diligence and data minimization and always, always accurate and adequate documentation in terms of data governance, meaning collecting PHI protected health information and using apps in the workplace or employee health programs. 00:55:54.8500000 Collect information carefully. If you're storing it in the cloud, make sure it's encrypted and safe. You want to retain data that you need to retain and delete what you don't need, but make sure it's deleted and destroyed properly. Share carefully. Be very careful with sharing over emails. 00:56:14.4500000 Use data carefully and only use it when needed and have proper IT professionals to help you come up with the proper data governance model. As we end during our last three minutes, here's your employer checklist in terms of legal compliance and you can use this after our CLE today. For your own office ADA checklist. You should have an ADA checklist. You should have an FMLA checklist, a GINA checklist, an Employee Wellness Program checklist and a Data Governance Privacy checklist. 00:56:52.6100000 And also ethical obligations under the ABA for attorneys such as yourself make sure that you are competent in this area. You are following confidentiality rules. You are supervising non lawyers and paralegals and reminding them to keep health data confidential and providing ongoing counseling to avoid malpractice lawsuits. Our key takeaways are mental health. Legal compliance involves ada, fmla, gina, and privacy obligations under state and federal law. 00:57:30.8600000 AI and digital health tools can amplify legal risk while helping employees. Data governance is not optional. It's a must do. But avoid data breaches and finally, proactive counsel wins. You always, always want to mitigate litigation exposure and protect your employees. 00:57:55.4900000 With that, I am attorney Tracy Sanders Rucker. It has been my pleasure to present this CLE for you today on behalf of lexfib. Your completion code is as follows and I will leave it on the screen for three to five minutes. A as in Apple D as in David 7K as in Kate E as in Edward A as in Apple d as in David 7k as in Kate E as in Edward thank you all and have a nice evening. 01:01:09.2200000 It's. 01:02:00.2800000 It.