00:00:14.4000000 Hello, everyone. Welcome to Listening as Advocacy. How trial attorneys can use different types of listening in the courtroom. I'm Mike debliss. I'm going to just wait a few more seconds for everybody to make their way in. 00:00:38.3600000 Super, super, super, super. 00:00:44.4400000 Great. So you're free to keep cameras off. This is very informal. I'm so happy that you've joined me today for this program. I'm. 00:00:56.3300000 It's a new topic altogether and one that I've discussed a little bit in prior presentations, but haven't really done as big of a deep dive as I wanted to. For those of you who don't know me, I'm a trial attorney, been practicing law. Oh, boy. I don't want to date myself, but it's about 18, 19 years, and my first job out of law school was as a public defender. I. I knew I wanted to be a public defender from an early age because my dad, who is also a trial attorney, started out in the public defender's office and went. 00:01:39.3000000 Eventually went into private practice. But he tried a lot of cases, and I, as a youngster, really longed for the times he would come home from a busy day in court and share some of his experiences. Also, back then, when newspaper paper, newspapers were big, I would oftentimes see his cases and see pictures of him in the newspaper trying big cases, homicides, robberies, you name it. So I knew at an early age that that's where I wanted to go. I also loved Hollywood movies that portrayed legal dramas. 00:02:24.1400000 So A Few Good Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, My Cousin Vinnie, all of those movies really appealed to me. And I guess in hindsight, as I look back, it really isn't so much of a surprise that I went not only into litigation, but also I eventually found my way into the performing arts. So many of the programs that I'm bringing to you today, I don't think I'd be bringing to you today if it wasn't for getting into the performing arts. I was fortunate as a young public defender to have a colleague in my office who had recommended that I attend the National Criminal Defense College. It's a program based in Macon, Georgia, that works with trains federal defender and state public defenders and those who do pool work. 00:03:23.1500000 And they do it in a boot camp site, a boot camp environment where you go down there for a long weekend or for two weeks, and not only do you get immersed in. In lectures around opening, closing, cross examination and direct, but they do something unlike any other program out there. They hire actors, come in and to play the roles of Witnesses and jurors so that you can, you can put it up on its feet. That's an expression that we use when we go into breakout groups, small groups of about six or seven attorneys, and we try out the. We try out all of the practice practical techniques that have been introduced to us by the, by the instructors during the lecture period. 00:04:21.2900000 So it's broken up, it's bifurcated between lectures and breakout groups of about five or six attorneys where you get feedback and what we might also refer to as side coaching from the attorneys that are supervising your small breakout room. You get recorded. And it's all in a very safe collaborative environment. It's not, you know, you should have done that or, you know, why didn't you do that? It's, it's more, it's, it's not like you've done this wrong or you've done that wrong. 00:04:59.5700000 It's, it's, what can you do? What might be better under, under these circumstances? What might be a better choice? Because the choice that you've chosen in this moment might not be standalone, a bad choice. It just might be better timed for a different part of the opening or closing. 00:05:22.8700000 So instead of looking at things in black and white, what is good and what is bad, it's what might work better under these circumstances. And staying flexible to those things also brings out the best in each individual attorney. So that you're playing to your strengths at all times. And you are constantly, you know, gathering, gathering information and putting it to use and finding what works for you and what doesn't work for you. And that's gold. 00:05:56.3700000 Because as trial attorneys, we don't have that freedom in a real trial. You know, if we make a mistake and fall flat on our face, then that's going to have serious consequences for the person that we are representing. So to have a safe place to try out new things is something very special for a trial attorney. And I wish that there were more programs like this. And it is certainly, you know, a germ or a seed of an idea that I've had in the back of my mind for expanding these type of cles into more interactive work. 00:06:35.6600000 But again, so these programs are based predominantly on my trial experience as a public defender and then also as a private attorney doing not just criminal, but civil cases. My experience as a classically trained actor, having done a lot of Shakespeare over the last decade, and then the experience that I've amassed in the National Criminal Defense College, as well as working with the Jerry Spence Trial Lawyers College. So a lot of These topics get a little bit of play in traditional CLE programs, but what I like to do is go deeper because I feel that there is so much more to explore in a topic like this one. Listening as advocacy. So let's dive right in. 00:07:24.3400000 Trial lawyers are trained extensively in speaking. In fact, you know, if you look at opening statements, examinations, objections and closing arguments, it's all about what is coming from this, this person. We are always the vessel, the instrument for the squiggly lines that make up words on a piece of paper. But how about now stepping back and looking at a little known area, which is enormously important, and that is listening. It is very easy to over anticipate certain things, especially when you're cross examining an adverse witness, because you have everything written out on your notes. 00:08:19.4300000 And you are, you are maybe tunnel vision in the sense that you know where you want to go and what questions are going to get you there. But what about the witness who provides an unexpected answer that is favorable to you? And that could actually open up a new affront, if you will, a new chapter, as we call it, for cross examination. You don't want to be in a state where you're not absorbing what you're hearing and you are not like a sponge in terms of hearing it. You don't want to be so focused on what your next question is that you have. 00:09:06.5500000 You've closed yourself to an answer that could be gold, pure gold. I had an issue like this come up in one of my first trials. It was with a detective who did a very thorough examination and was responsible for the forensics on collecting fingerprints at the scene and taking pictures. He did everything meticulously. And one phrase came out that was completely unexpected. 00:09:42.4700000 And it was how he labeled or referred to my client, who happened to be an African American male in his early 20s. He referred to him collectively as one of these people. Now, of course, in hindsight, nothing could have revealed a deeper or more latent bias on his part that came out. I'm embarrassed to admit that even these, all these years later didn't land on me. Why? 00:10:19.3900000 Because I was so tunnel vision and so focused on the next question that I wasn't, I wasn't listening. And it doesn't take a lot of effort to listen. We listen passively every day to other people that we are involved in conversation with. And we listen on different levels. And that's the beauty of this topic. 00:10:43.9900000 We're going to unp the type of listening that we as human beings possess and then talk about the different types and when they would be important to us in different stages of a trial. So again, far less attention is paid to listening in the courtroom. Yet in trial practice, listening is not passive. It is an active, strategic skill that directly shapes examinations, objections, credibility, and persuasion. Always be mindful that the number one thing that you possess as an attorney in the courtroom is your credibility. 00:11:25.7600000 That is what. That is the overarching trait that you need to establish in the minds and the hearts of the jury. And the thing about credibility is that you can spend a whole trial being so deliberate and so forthcoming so that the jury feels that they can trust you. And in one moment, in one moment, when your guard is down, you can leave something out, perhaps, that your adversary then uses in a cross examination. And I'll give you an example of this, and in one fell swoop, your credibility is erased. 00:12:14.4200000 The example that comes to mind and that I like to use is one involving a defense, a criminal defendant who you're representing, who is hell bent on testifying and notwithstanding all of the, all of the discussions with that client, to talk to them about the peril that might be involved in this in testifying, especially if there are, if the client has explosive disorder or can be tweaked very easily, and especially if the evidence is overwhelmingly in the state's favor. And then thirdly, if they have a, if they have prior convictions, obviously there's a sanitization hearing to try to keep out those that are too remote and that might be too close to the actual crimes that are charged in this case as to be overly prejudicial. But at the end of the day, it's a client's choice. And sometimes, you know, they are, you know, hell bent and adamant about testifying. So in this hypothetical, say that Johnny insists on taking the stand, and after the sanitization hearing, you learn that at least that two of his convictions, his priors are going to come into evidence. 00:13:35.7600000 Well, now, in this example that I'm giving, let's say that you've spent the entire trial currying favor with the jury and being forthcoming, even at the expense of disclosing negative things about your case that might not be, that might not be favorable and that you might not otherwise want the jury to be aware of, but you've done this in the name of credibility and trustworthiness. Then we get to the direct examination of Johnny Depp, and you conveniently leave out the two prior convictions that you already know are fair game and that your adversary now on cross examination, seizes upon and asks the Johnny about them. So now the jury hears for the first time that Johnny has two prior convictions. The jury is smart, though, and you never want to underestimate them. They know that when the other side is up that bad things are going to come out against your client. 00:14:37.3100000 Why? Because it's. It's obvious we're in a trial and there's two competing versions of this event, and it's going to be which competing version is more truthful than the other. So the jury recognizes this. But. 00:14:53.9500000 And they. And they will probably. 00:14:58.3300000 The shock of hearing about the prior convictions is going to swing so far against you on the level of you as the attorney, not having elicited it from your client on direct examination, than it is for. Than it is for it to be resonating in the courtroom for the first time when your adversary asks about it. So this is what I mean about credibility. Credibility, credibility. You have to always. 00:15:30.5900000 Jerry Spence has a great expression where he says a. A disclosure coming from your mouth is. Is. Is better than a. 00:15:44.3500000 Better than a point brought up by your adversary. It's. I'm paraphrasing this, but what we're saying here is that even a negative fact that you have that you can draw out on your side of the case is going to come out in a more positive way because you've been the one to disclose it than it would be if you potentially hide it, as the jury might think in that example I gave you. So back to listening. Here, the trial attorneys listen with purpose, discipline, and intention. 00:16:25.0100000 Understanding the different types of listening and knowing when to deploy them can materially improve courtroom performance. So let's talk about the different types of listening. And this is all psychologically based. So the first is informational listening. Hearing the facts beneath the words. 00:16:44.2100000 What is this? Informational listening focuses on accurately receiving and processing factual content. The goal is comprehension, not evaluation or rebuttal. Where does this matter in trial? Direct examination of witnesses, opposing counsel's questions, judicial instructions, rulings and comments, expert testimony. 00:17:09.7900000 How should trial lawyers use it? Trial lawyers often listen only for the moment they can object or respond. Informational listening requires resisting that impulse. Instead, the attorney listens carefully to exact word choices, chronology quantifiers such as always, never, sometimes. I think I'm probably preaching to the choir to point out these quantifiers as being moments where your radar should go up. 00:17:47.5400000 Any blanket statements such as always, like never, all the time, forever, things like that. Blanket statements like that, that are so that swing the that. Swing the. Oh boy, the that. That basically swing the clock I'm trying to think right now in so far in one direction are basically reminders are great ways to stay alert that there might be an objection somewhere there. 00:18:32.0900000 Because as I said, I mean it is so black and white and it, and it is so extreme in one direction or it's a pendulum. That's what I'm thinking of. The pendulum has swung so far in one direction or another that to, to make such an assertion when they're, you know, when facts are very stubborn things and they can be, and inferences can be drawn in completely different directions by just taking that one fact and putting it in relation to another fact makes you want to look out for these quantifiers as potentially objectionable content. 00:19:14.2200000 Unintended admissions or inconsistencies would fall under informational listening as well. This type of listening allows counsel to catch misstatements in real time. Spot openings for follow up questions, preserve issues for impeachment or closing. A practice tip here is that during witness prep, discipline yourself to not write your next question while the witness is speaking. And I mean this goes without saying, you would write your questions out during the preparation phase. 00:19:50.8400000 When you are in the courtroom, you obviously want to have a, want to have the questions on a legal pad and so that you're able to look down and keep the momentum going. What I will say, since we're, we're talking about this already, is that a lot of attorneys, myself included, find it more challenging to memorize a cross examination then we do an opening or a closing. For obvious reasons. When you are doing a cross examination, it's not just you speaking to an audience of people. Here, the jury, you are, you are reacting and relating to another person, that being the adversarial witness. 00:20:44.9500000 And so it can be difficult to memorize, summarize all of your questions. There is no rule that says that you can't have a pad and you can't have those questions written down. I will say that one of the, one of the tools that I strongly encourage attorneys, no matter how small the cross examination might be to do, to organize your cross into chapters. And in doing so, it is easier to smoothly transition from one topic to the next. You also will know where you are and where you've left off whenever your adversary lodges an objection that requires perhaps a sidebar to argue the admissibility of that, of that leading question. 00:21:49.0200000 So organization is a key, key, key thing on cross examination. And the beauty of being a trial lawyer is that not, is that not only are you the writer of what you are asking. And not only are you the actor in this trial, as the conduit for, for all of these words, but you are also the director. And as a director, you're able to organize things and you're able to set the scene, if you will, just like a director of a streaming film can do with a Netflix or Hulu or Amazon Prime. You're able to determine the order of your chapters. 00:22:39.4400000 You're able to determine the questions that you want to ask, to establish each of the overarching points. That is powerful. That means that you're able to control the dissemination of information, not just the substance of that information, but how it comes out. And as I. As I said, I mean, if you look at what good directors do in order to draw audiences in, they don't always tell the story in chronological order. 00:23:12.6900000 One of the. One of the biggest things to come out of Better Call Saul and Breaking Bad, two of the biggest streaming shows that went on for such a long time, I think, I don't think it was originally on Netflix. I think that AMC had the rights to it and then Netflix bought the rights to it. But they would tell the story. The director told the story out of order. 00:23:38.8100000 So you would start. The first three minutes of Breaking Bad would be a scene from a different time sequence in the, in the, in the overarching narrative, and it was oftentimes later than where you actually were in that episode itself. And that, that, that, that created so much suspense and interest that many people would tune in, more people would tune in for those first three or four minutes of suspense on what was going on. You know, what body is floating in a, you know, in a pool of water or what, you know, cigarette or doll, I think it was, was floating in a, in a, in an, in ground pool in the backyard of someone's home, you know, then the actual episode itself. So, again, this is powerful. 00:24:34.8400000 The way information is disseminated is so important in the courtroom now more than ever because of how we have become in 2026, more of a visually oriented society. We are not as auditory as the Elizabethans were, you know, back in Shakespeare's day, and where they had to rely on the spoken word and they were able to follow along quicker because they could intuit quicker, and they were able to get general senses of ideas and thoughts conceptually, it would come to their senses quicker and effortlessly than it does for the average person, person today. So recognizing that we have to do yeoman's work and we have to go to the ends of the universe to make things easily digestible for an audience in 2026. That A has short attention spans. I think they say the, you know, people look at their cell phones every 10 seconds now for social media, texting and everything. 00:25:42.4800000 And secondly, the fact that we are not as auditory as we were in prior generations and we are more visually oriented. So the combination of that and then adding in, just adding in all of this evidence that's coming in from different sources, from physical exhibits to oral testimony to other forms of evidence, out of order or all of this lends itself to complete chaos and confusion in the minds of the jury. I like to use the metaphor of opening up a closet. And if you open up like your teenager's closet and you see stuff thrown and strewn about all over the place, jeans, belt, T shirt, you know, tie, all of these things represent chaos and confusion and disorganization. And to the extent that we just rattle things off and we don't take the time to organize the flow of information, we are basically committing the same, the same mortal sins that our, our kids are doing in the sense that we are just throwing everything out there, throwing it up against the wall and seeing what sticks, or basically saying, here it all is, here's all the, here's, you know, the wardrobe from inside the disorganized closet. 00:27:08.3700000 Jury, now you sort it all out. And the danger that this poses is that the jury is, is going to need to organize it just like you would have had to do if you undertook that, that responsibility. And, and in doing so, they're going to come up with a story to do it because they can't take, it's too much information, they're going to resort to a story. And the danger is if you haven't given them the narrative, a framework from which you want them to see your case and you just, you just put all of these, throw all these things out there. They might come up with a narrative that is, that is good for them, but it goes against your, goes against your case and goes against how you want them to find in your case. 00:28:06.4100000 So for all of these reasons, it is so utterly important that we, we organize material. We organize the flow of the information in a way that things transition smoothly and that if we do change the order of certain things, that discoveries can be made by the jury later on so that they get the aha moment about what you were talking about earlier. We never want to leave them hanging out there, you know, with a confused look on their faces of where are we going? Did I miss something? Because that's the number one thing. 00:28:49.7600000 They've got to be with you. You've got to have them with you. It's like holding onto a toddler's hand at a busy street. The toddler metaphor is the jury. You're holding onto their hand and you're helping them cross the busy street. 00:29:06.2000000 Another metaphor is that the jury's so overwhelmed, they feel like they're lost in a forest. And you are going to be their guide. You're going to take them by the hand very gently and guide them out of the forest. You're not going to pick them up and carry them because we want to lead them with some autonomy to make discoveries on their own. Discoveries are more meaningful for a jury and for an audience in general than when you tell them it has to be A. 00:29:39.8700000 But if you lead them to A through a strong foundation that essentially is so narrow that when you take maybe B and C, that leads to the inescapable inference of A. And that is going to mean that they get to make the conclusion in their own minds and they take more ownership of it. So I'm throwing a lot in here, but all of this, all of this is so interconnected with listening. So during witness prep and, you know, we want to make sure we are listening not just to, you know, not just to one or two things, but here we have a clue, we have some clues that we want to listen in for. These blanket statements, quantifier statements, those are very, very important. 00:30:35.1300000 Every single word that the witness says is going to be important, that we have to. We have to be listening as though our lives are. Are depending on it. Analytical listening, this is critical listening. Critical listening is evaluating credibility and structure. 00:30:55.1300000 So what is it? Analytical listening evaluates the logic, coherence and reliability of what is being said. The great thing is that this type of listening is honed in lawyers, probably disproportionately more than other forms of listening based on our legal training. Where does this matter? Cross examination. 00:31:18.0900000 Expert testimony, Prosecutorial or opposing counsel arguments, Bench conferences. How should trial attorneys use it? Here the lawyer listens for internal contradictions, unsupported conclusions, gaps between facts and opinions, assumptions masquerading as evidence. Analytical listening enables the attorney to dismantle testimony methodically rather than emotionally. Instead of reacting to what is said, the lawyer evaluates a how it is constructed. 00:31:51.3000000 This is essentially critical when dealing with experts. The most effective cross examinations arise not from memorized attacks, but from listening carefully to how an expert explains or avoids explaining their methodology. A practice tip here is ask Yourself, silently, does this answer actually support the conclusion being offered? If not, the gap becomes your next question. You know, it's interesting because this can also backfire. 00:32:23.7400000 As an attorney, we are so programmed to, we are so programmed to listen, as I said earlier, for internal contradictions, unsupported conclusions we often will make, will often make assumptions that the person's response, whether it's an expert or any other, any other witness, is in response to the question that we've asked. And I want to, I want to, I want to encourage everybody, just like when we are analyzing something under the hearsay rules and we don't want to miss step one, you know, which would be, is it an out of court statement? So too when a witness answers a question, I would say don't overlook the threshold question in your mind, did this witness actually answer the question that I asked? I have found myself in times in trial where I've actually had to expend more energy dealing with an answer that was not, that was, that was unresponsive and wasn't the answer to the question that I was actually asking. And as a result, I went down a rabbit hole with a witness into, into, into essentially an irrelevant area when in fact I look back at the transcripts afterwards because it turned into, it was a hung jury. 00:34:06.4000000 And so I had to go back through all the transcripts before the second trial. But I realized that that question that probably created more anxiety in that entire court day and created more energy as far as expending energy towards thought was a non responsive answer to the question. And so I could have saved myself a lot of effort and kept everybody on the same page if I was just listening to whether this question had answered, whether his answer had answered the question that I had asked. So again, a threshold issue. 00:34:50.1500000 And with experts, does this answer actually support the conclusion being offered? If not, that gap becomes your next question. So much. So much. So much as a, so much of my experience as a defense attorney has been spent in finding those gaps that I'm talking about here between, between a, a conclusion, the gap. 00:35:25.0200000 Actually, I want to just go back because this is an important point. Okay, Okay. Gaps between facts and opinions. Yes, gaps between facts and opinions. This area is so rife for cross examination fodder because the other side, and we all do this, but we've lived with our case so long, and we are over years of, you know, perhaps being a prosecutor in the prosecutor's office, or over years of being a criminal defense attorney, we can sometimes become biased so far towards our Side that we will mistake. 00:36:32.5600000 We will make assumptions to leap from facts to opinions instead of relying upon the evidence to get us there. It's. It is a. It is. It's. 00:36:50.3900000 It can be dangerous, as I said, to get. So to get. When you're doing one job for so long, to get in a rut with that. But it's possible where you can, you know, insert an assumption where there really needs to be another piece of evidence to connect, to go from a. The fact to see the conclusion or the opinion. 00:37:14.5100000 And so you can exploit those gaps. That's the point I'm trying to make. You can exploit those gaps when you start to. When you start to analyze all the discovery. And you see. 00:37:26.0290000 And you see it in police reports if you do criminal work all the time. Jason ran when I approached him at the corner. And, you know, and that could very well be the theme that the arresting officer is relying upon for the probable cause to arrest Jason and to run after him. When in fact, there's case law where I practice in the state of New Jersey that says that flight is not evidence of. Is not any form of probable cause to support an arrest. 00:38:02 The New Jersey Supreme Court has recognized that, you know, people, you know, are nervous around police officers, and just because they run doesn't mean that you can base your arrest, that you have probable cause to arrest the person. So there has to be other indicia of probable cause in order to support the arrest. So exploiting these gaps that there is so much to mind between facts and opinions because of how biased on both sides, not just one side, not just the prosecution, but also on the criminal defense. I've done this myself a lot of times, and you need that other evidence. The other evidence in this example would be the officer pointing out other things that aroused his suspicions about there being some criminal activity afoot. 00:38:53.5500000 And usually they have it. But, you know, there are always those cases where it's just the running away. And you oftentimes wonder, you know, how long is this officer been patrolling the streets of Newark or Asbury park if they're relying exclusively on flight as their basis for a stop. 00:39:17.7400000 Okay, so strategic listening, we are transitioning from analytical to strategic. What is it? Strategic listening focuses on where testimony or argument is headed and how it fits into the broader theory of the case. Where does it matter most in trial? Opening statements, long narrative answers, Redirect, examination, closing arguments? 00:39:38.8800000 How should trial lawyers use it? Trial lawyers must listen with the end in mind. Strategic listening asks, how does this testimony advance or undermine the opposing theory? What will the jury remember from this? How can this be reframed later? 00:39:59.2200000 These are guideposts, by the way, that are very helpful if you are ever in, if you're ever getting some writer's block on writing your cross examination. A great rule of thumb is that you don't want to ask any questions of an adverse witness unless they accomplish one of three objectives. They advance your theory or theme of the case. That's number one. Number two, they dismantle the opposing side's theory or theme of the case. 00:40:39.1900000 And the third reason is that it's necessary to discredit. It's evidence that will be used to discredit or attack the credibility of the witness. If the question that you're asking or the questions that you're asking are not advancing one of those three goals, then introspectively, you need to ask yourself objectively, why am I asking it? When I first started this as a criminal defense attorney, I felt obliged to stand up and to ask questions even when there were witnesses that only really needed a chapter or two of cross examinations. And what would happen is that I would start to cover, recover the same questions that had been asked and answered by the prosecutor on direct. 00:41:41.7000000 Not only was it painful for the jury to hear those same questions and answers for the second, for the second time, but I was also committing a, I was also making a, committing a cardinal sin in the sense that the jury, you know, recognized that bad stuff was going to come out on the prosecutor's case. But they don't expect the same to happen when the criminal defense attorney is standing up and eliciting questions from that witness. It has, it has this effect of you, of you, how can I put this? It has an effect of you endorsing it as a criminal defense attorney if you are eliciting bad testimony from the adverse witness. So this rule of one of every question that I'm asking, having to advance one or more of these three things is a very useful rule. 00:42:47.7400000 And what will the jury remember from this? In every trial, it goes without saying, the emotional stakes are very high. And just like a director when they are, or just like a playwright before we even get to the director, but just like a playwright has, has put a scene in there for a reason and not just put it in arbitrarily to take up space so that they can have a full two hour matinee or three hour matinee at Radio City Music hall. So too, do you need to be that specific as well? And what I like to do with all of my, with all of the state's witnesses. 00:43:30.0500000 And even when I'm doing personal injury case, especially when I'm doing personal injury cases, I look at a witness and I say to myself, I ask myself two questions. A, why is the other side bringing this person in? And inevitably, that's going to answer that's going to lead to the next question, which is, what part of the case, of my adversary, of my adversary's case is that witness coming in to tell? Is it the bystander that was on the corner at the time of the car accident who is coming in to testify? As to how the, as to how the tractor trailer ran the red light or the stop sign, you need to know in advance why your adversary is bringing that witness in to testify. 00:44:23.0700000 And then B, once you identify why that witness is being brought in by your adversary, you now have. It opens up some new insight into how am I going to structure my cross examination to accomplish one or more of those three goals. And next, I also want the jury to be left with a feeling after I'm done cross examining this witness. Now, is it going to be a Perry Mason moment where the witness, the victim witness, for example, you know, bares their heart and says, no, Mr. De Bliss, I was wrong. I misidentified John, you know, as my attacker in the robbery. 00:45:12.7200000 It wasn't John. I knew that I should have known this all along. Of course not. Of course not. However, even a fact witness is going to, as a human is going to, is going to have a vibe about them. 00:45:30 And to the extent that I have choreographed or synchronized, what points I'm going to make with that witness with an intended feeling that I want to leave the jury with after they've listened to his or her testimony, I want to go there. And of course, I won't know the type of personality that every one of my witnesses has, unless, of course, they were interviewed and it was recorded, then I have a sense of what I'm dealing with in terms of psychology. Psychology. But even just with the content of what I'm asking, there will be inevitably themes that come up in just the content of the questions that I'll be asking that witness. And as a result, to give you an example, if it's a snitch, and the points that I'm making with the snitch are that I want the jury to be left with the impression that he was lying in order to save his own hide, then I have a clearer idea of where I need to start and then where I need to go to get to that point. 00:46:43.3200000 And I can tell you that it's not going to be general blanket statements that get the jury to actually, I'm even going to be more specific with what feeling I want them to come out with after hearing the snitch. It's testimony. I want them to feel as if. And it's. And I'm. 00:47:00.5600000 And I label it this way so that I put extra. I put extra responsibility on myself to marshal up as many facts as I can and organize it as best as I can. I want the jury, after they've listened to a snitch testify, I want them to get, you know, I want them to feel like they have to take a shower. I want them to feel as if this person is so. Is so incredibly untrustworthy that I, I'm literally, I'm just, you know, I don't feel good. 00:47:34.0500000 Like my, I feel like I've got, you know, I feel like I have, you know, like an ant going up my arm. Like I'm just getting a bad sense of it. That visceral feeling is going to help me to, to put together a cross examination that's going to get into specifics and is going to be organized in a way that's going to lead the jury to the inescapably inescapable conclusion that this person was lying and that it's going to be done in a way also to show that this is the most logical explanation as well. So we'll be touching on ethos, pathos and logos, which is what Aristotle wrote about in rhetoric. In his book on rhetoric ages and ages ago, he talked about that to influence audiences and groups of people, you need to appeal to three main things. 00:48:30.7800000 Logos, which is logic. Pathos, which is the emotional appeal, and ethos, which is a broader concept and one that I don't have the definition at my fingertips for. But those three things. The more of those three things you can appeal to when you are. When you are cross examining a witness and using this technique of what feeling do I want the jury to be left with after they hear me cross examine him? 00:49:03.8000000 That is going to help guide you in the content and the substance of your cross. 00:49:12.3700000 The form of list. This form of listening allows counsel to make real time decisions whether to object, let an answer linger, or save it for closing. Not every damaging answer should be challenged immediately. Strategic listening recognizes that some testimony is best neutralized later when context and perspective can be restored. A great friend of mine, colleague in the public defender's office, used to say, never shoot, never Shoot a mouse in the butt with a cannon. 00:49:48.4900000 I never understood what that expression meant until after my first trial. I learned that what that expression meant, at least in his world, was that there are undoubtedly going to be times in a witness's direct where they contradict something that they said earlier. And once you get into, once you get comfortable with the stages of impeachment, you can get trigger happy about wanting to impeach that witness on everything that they say. The problem is of course, that if you, if you impeach on even the tiniest contradictions, when you get to the big ones, they are going to be so diluted by over impeachment that it's going to be lost on the jury, that their importance is going to be lost on the jury. So this is why listening is so important. 00:50:49.6100000 You're going to have to make decisions on the fly. The more immersed you are with the case, the quicker it's going to be to make these decisions on the fly. About an inconsistency, for example, how big is this inconsistency? I would recommend using those same three guides that I gave you earlier about does this advance my theory and theme of the case? B, does this undermine my adversary's theory or theme of the case? 00:51:22.2200000 And see, does this discredit the credibility of this witness? Those three things, I think, are great guiding posts for determining whether this testimony, this segment of testimony, is material enough to be impeached. Practice tip. If an answer hurts, you pause mentally and ask, is now the best moment to fight this or is later better? This is another good point, that there is this compulsion, I think, and I feel this a lot too, despite having done dozens of trials, I still feel that once the judge has told me it's my turn to cross examine, that I feel a button has been pressed. 00:52:20.4500000 It's like the button on a treadmill. And now I feel like I'm off. Like, like the, the gate has opened at the, at the Meadowlands and the thoroughbred horses now have left the gate. And now it's just like, I gotta go, I gotta, I gotta just keep galloping and I gotta go gangbusters all the way to the end of my cross examination. You don't, you don't. 00:52:45.4900000 And while silence can feel uncomfortable, especially when you are searching for something that you don't have the answer to and where you are, you know, mining the recesses of your mind to make some, some, some big decisions on where to go with, with certain testimony, I can tell you emphatically that two seconds in our mind, I'M sorry that what we think is a, what we think is a millennium of time that we're pausing is usually only four or five seconds. But because we're so used to and so accustomed to the constant flow of words, words, words, words, words, even pausing for a couple seconds feels like it's an eternity. And I use that, you know, just to, in my own mind, reinforce that. But when you can get comfortable with the silence, you realize that you have more agency over how this is going than you might otherwise have thought. You are not beholden to anybody. 00:54:00.7100000 Of course there's a judge, and of course there is, you know, a time. There's time issues that come in. But when it's your turn to cross examine a witness, you, it is your, it's on your dime. There is no nobody, you know, with a gun to your head saying, it's got to get done right away. And sometimes in the pause comes some really valuable thoughts that help to, that help you to take in what you've just heard and use it. 00:54:34.8900000 If we listen well, but we don't give our enough and we don't, but we don't take time to pause and gather our thoughts, it can be no different than if we didn't listen well. So it's a combination of really listening and it's a combination of not fearing the pause. And if you want further justification, again, in this world that we are in, of being so visually oriented, in this world where, you know, we are not used to listening for stretches of time like we, like we impose on a jury for a long trial, it will be helpful for the jury to have those pauses as well so that they can catch up to you. When we're going a million miles per hour, chances are we will have left the jury, or if not the entire jury, we'll probably left a few jurors in our wake. Just like, you know, when water skiing, you know, and you know, you, you get, you fall off your water skis and the boat has left the water skier in its wake. 00:55:48.0700000 Every juror is so important. It's like we are a sheep herder, and even one sheep that is lost out there needs to be brought back in. And the metaphor here is that you never know if it's a criminal case, which juror might be your only holdout in a case where the other 11 are so convinced, lock, stock and barrel of your client's guilt. But that one holdout is, is creates, and that one holdout leads to a, leads to the judge ordering a hung jury and, and for the trial being no outcome. So this is why it's so, so important to every juror, is important to us. 00:56:42.3800000 We don't know which one might be the only one left holding, holding down, you know, anchoring themselves and not. Not, you know, not surrendering to the. To the overwhelming majority. Okay, And there's a good point here. 00:57:13.7500000 All right. 00:57:17.8300000 Empathic listening, understanding the human element. What is it? Empathic listening seeks to understand emotions, motivations, and perspective without necessarily agreeing. There is compassion and there is empathizing. Empathizing is more like not only am I listening to what you're saying, but I'm actually putting myself in your shoes and imagining how I might have experienced this same incident. 00:57:56.6600000 There are some of us that fall more on the empathetic side than the compassionate side. The compassionate side is I can understand what you're going through. I can appreciate how. How this has. How deeply this has impacted you, but I'm not taking an. 00:58:16.7000000 Any deeper step into this. I'm able to hold space for you, but I'm not going to step into your shoes to actually be a martyr, you know, to, To. To. To. To. 00:58:29.7900000 To. To experience it myself. So it's more like there is, you know, a little bit of distance and a little bit of safety between you and the other person and path. Empathy is. Is very important in any case that you have because understanding motivations of people. 00:58:50.5000000 You can understand motivations of people by spending time imagining what. That. What they are going through and why, perhaps, and why. That might explain perhaps a witness coming in with an attitude or, you know, or a victim coming in with their mind made up when there is contradictory evidence to suggest that they were not as competent as they sound today when they were called into the police station to make the identification. 00:59:29.7800000 Where does this matter in trial? Direct examination of your own client. Cross of sympathetic witnesses, victim testimony, sentencing hearings, how trial attorneys should use it. Jurors and judges are acutely sensitive to tone. Empathic listening allows the attorney to one, adjust questioning style in real time, avoid appearing cruel or dismissive, build rapport and credibility. 00:59:59.2500000 I can remember in a trial that I had many years ago, the victim was. Was a woman in her, I want to say, early 70s, and it was a purse snatching that because of the force that was used, was. Was upgraded to a robbery. And the. The. 01:00:25.9500000 I had seen the video of the woman victim in police headquarters being interviewed, and she was a very sympathetic witness. She was grandma coming in and she had a southern accent, and she was very. She was very sympathetic. And I realized in that moment, that notwithstanding the fact that there was a lot of questions that I could ask her and a lot of facts that went towards mistaken identification, I stepped back for a second to recognize that she was still the victim of a purse snatching and that my job wasn't to convince a jury. Well, my job as a defense attorney isn't to convince them of anything. 01:01:25.4400000 It's the prosecutor who has the burden all the time. But my job wasn't to convince the jury that there was no robbery. My defense was specifically mistaken identification. It was that Johnny, my client, wasn't the one, wasn't the actor who actually took the purse. And recognizing that gave me some insight in that I wasn't going to come at this witness hard first. 01:01:57.3600000 Even if she wasn't, you know, like a grandmother and she was, you know, perhaps more hardened than that, there was still the status issue that would not be erasable in the minds of the jury. That here's a young male that is getting very, that that is getting adversarial and is getting rough with an elderly female. There's that status, of course. But number two, this person really did suffer a something. She had her purse snatched and she was frightened and scared out of her, out of her mind. 01:02:42.6300000 So I had to understand that, that this had to be a soft cross. Not in the sense that I wasn't going to ask the tough questions, but in the sense of how I was going to treat her. I wasn't going to ride over her and, and, and, and, and, and be loud and abrupt and, and intimidating. That would backfire against me and the jury would bleed with her. So I had to adopt the tone, the proper tone for this witness that wasn't going to result in the jury hating me more than anything else after I was done, while at the same time making the type of points that I needed to make to argue in closing. 01:03:29.4600000 And there were ways of doing that. 01:03:33.6200000 So this is especially important when examining vulnerable witnesses. An attorney who listens and empathetically can control the courtroom without alienating the fact finder. Empathy also informs strategy. Understanding why a witness believes something often reveals how that belief can be respectfully challenged. A practice tip here is match your pacing and tone to the witness's emotional state before gradually steering them where you need to go. 01:04:04.1000000 You see a lot of, in courtrooms throughout the country, you see a disproportionality or an incongruence between the emotion that is that the witness is under and what the cross examining attorney is bringing in. And I mean everybody's got their own style, of course. But in my world, I always place a premium on being jury centered. And what jury centered means to me is that I never want to alienate myself from the jury. I never want the jury thinking, oh my God, this, this attorney is just absolutely, you know, ruthless with this, with this, with this victim. 01:04:57.3000000 I fear that that is going to create a negative perception of me that is going to, is going to overshadow the other points that come out that are favorable. And so I really, I really am mindful of this status in a courtroom of a cross examining attorney and a witness, while at the same time not being a wallflower, of course making the points that I need to make. But I've always found that I can make those points without becoming, you know, without becoming disrespectful, without losing my professionalism, without going into the gutter. And, you know, I again, everybody has their own style. And there will always be witnesses, different witnesses that are trying in different respects, but getting into a shouting match is not helpful to either person. 01:05:56.3300000 Usually both people come out dirty in some way. So the more that you can actually stay composed. When you have a witness who is being difficult, the psychology of the courtroom is very interesting. A jury should never be underestimated. When you have a witness who is recalcitrant and who is just being difficult for the purposes of being difficult, there are ways that you can bring that witness under control in a way that's respectful and courteous. 01:06:31.1400000 And it's always going to leave you, leave the jury feeling as if you are looking better than they are. And even in the end, when the, when the witness is still fighting you and not giving you that answer, that you've basically brought them to the edge, or that there's an inescapable conclusion from the facts that that witness has already answered yes to that established that conclusion. The jury can see that. The jury can see that they might not be lawyers. This might be the first trial that they've ever had, but they're humans. 01:07:05.4700000 Every juror is an expert at being human. And while they might not intuitively be able to say, oh, you know, I analyze it in, like Sigmund Freud might analyze it, this person is showing deceptive behavior. This person is being defensive. Even though they, they consciously might not, might not come to that conclusion, they will intuitively figure it out because of the feeling that they get. All people were like octopus. 01:07:40.0500000 We have antennae that are out probing other people. And the same thing goes for jurors. They're getting feelings they're getting impressions of you, of the witness, of your adversary, of the judge. And they, that you don't have to beat them over the head. When they see somebody who is being difficult and pushing back, they will inescapably come to the conclusion on their own that this person is being recalcitrant and is being difficult. 01:08:13.1000000 They can read that from a mile away. 01:08:23.1800000 Okay. 01:08:27.3400000 5. Judicial listening. Listening for signals from the bench. What is this? Judicial listening focuses on the court's reaction, verbal and nonverbal, to what is happening in the courtroom where it matters in trial. 01:08:39.0800000 Objections and rulings, bench trials, sentencing hearings, motion practice. My gosh, judicial listening comes in a lot when, I mean, for me it was huge with 404B evidence. There wasn't a case that I tried in my last few years as a public defender where the state wasn't attempting to introduce some form of 404 B evidence that was in my mind, always overly prejudicial. But that would also, in my, in my humble opinion, feel like they were trying to bootstrap something in that was, was really character evidence and that they were using 404B as the, as the Trojan horse, if you will, to bootstrap it into evidence. And so this was something that I became more and more knowledgeable of. 01:09:41.6000000 And as a result, I would analyze it in a, like a 4, 4 prong test to be able to challenge all prongs and not just like the most obvious one. How should trial attorneys use it? Judges constantly communicate preferences through interruptions, follow up questions, body language, tone of rulings. I, I once had an attorney in my office who said, when you know, even though it's rare, but when you are starting to get, when you're starting to get signals from the bench that suggest which way the wind is blowing. This attorney spoke in metaphors too. 01:10:27.3600000 He, he said he would tell me. He said, you then know when you can sit down, when you should sit down. I will say that the perfectionist side of my head, but also the one that wants to make a complete record all the time, will sometimes overlook these cues that I get from the bench and keep arguing. And it's not to say that you shouldn't because you still have to make a record, of course, but in some cases, when you've read the room and you know which direction the wind is blowing in and you still have a few arguments left, you might want to just make those argument, condense those arguments a little bit more so that we can, we can all move on to something else. It's hard because as a criminal defense attorney, I'm so used to losing all the time that when a judge is actually going to throw me a bone, it's hard for me. 01:11:21.1600000 Even when I hear them explicitly say, I'm leaning this way and this way is in my favor, I still sometimes feel like I've heard him say just the opposite. So you have to take some time, listen, and maybe pause for a second and say, oh, the judge is actually with me here. What do I have left? I have a few arguments left. Let me just condense them and finish up the argument so that we can, we can proceed with, you know, the next witness for cross or what have you. 01:11:54.0400000 And this is what I, what I'm talking about here. The attorney who listens carefully to the judge can adapt instantly, shortening arguments, reframing objections, or changing examination style. Similarly, with judges, you get a sense of what. Of what types of things they are looking for and what types of issues make them more conscientious. Just like we get to know. 01:12:25.9500000 See, for me, I tend to think that it's easier to get to know getting to know the pet peeves of the judges that you are in front of so that you don't run afoul of them and wind up in the proverbial doghouse than it is to become focused on those things, those legal matters, those evidential issues, those objections, those forms of testimony that the judge has sustained other. Has sustained your adversary's objections for. But that is as crucial as gathering all this information about the judge's pet peeves so that you don't upset the apple car. Ignoring these signals risks irritating the judge and undermining credibility. Practice tip. 01:13:17.5800000 Treat every ruling as information. Oh, this is interesting. He just sustained an objection on this line of questioning. And let me go back and look at this line of questioning. Oh, I can see here I have a few blanket terms that were too blanket and that really required more specificity. 01:13:40.6600000 And so even an adverse ruling tells you how the judge is thinking. On this note, I think it's very important since we've been talking a lot about cross, we've been talking about all these listening things in the context of cross examination as well as, to a lesser extent, to opening and closing. But because we've gone into cross examination, I think it's very important to recognize that with cross examination, it's something that we don't do every day because in everyday language, we view our words as information delivery or conveyance mechanisms. We want to get the words out just so that we can get the information behind those words out to the receiver. So if, for example, I am. 01:14:39.1900000 I'm running to the supermarket and I'm in my mom's house and I yell, hey, Mom, I'm just running the supermarket. Can you wash the dog while I'm gone? I want the message to get to the listener. I am not as preoccupied and is concerned with did it reach that particular listener in a way that is going to resonate with them deepest? I just wanted to get the words out there in perhaps two seconds time for the sake of getting them out there and putting that person on notice. 01:15:11.7800000 But in a closing argument and in a cross examination, we're not talking about a Starbucks conversation. We are talking about specificity and use of words. And the word that we choose is going to convey as much information as the word that we didn't choose in that phrase or in that thought. So we've got to be more deliberate when it comes to our word usage. And we also have to recognize that because of these short attention spans and because of how visual our society is today, that just speaking something is not enough and is not enough to assure yourself that it has landed in the sense of it being received by the jury. 01:16:11.8800000 You can take something that on paper is so persuasive and is maybe one of the best arguments in a brief, and then you can speak that same sentence out loud in a way that is. That is monotone and that rings the meaning right out of it. And then the jury doesn't understand the significance, the gravity of that statement. So what are our tools in our toolbox? Well, just like when we were in law school, and we'd have a different color marker, I was visual or visually oriented, I used a different color highlighter for my facts than I did for my issue, than I did for procedure, than I did for the law, than I did for the analysis, than I did for the holding. 01:17:03.4100000 In the spoken word, we don't have different highlighters. And so we have to use with our voice, our body, our gestures, our physical expression. Those are what our highlighters are in the spoken word. And more than getting the thought out is how am I going to say it in a way that the audience here, the jury, gets the full. The full meaning of this thought and understands its significance. 01:17:40.4600000 And so we're talking as much. We're talking about the surface text of the words because the words mean what they say. We're not talking about subtext of the hidden meaning underneath something. We're talking about what these words actually Say, and in today's world, we use expressions like I'm gonna kill you or you know, that's ridiculous. Words are overused. 01:18:03.8400000 The genuine is I'm genuinely dissatisfied. You hear words that have big meaning get thrown around so much that they've lost their meaning. Well, today what we need to do is we need to warm up our voices and we need to bring some congruence between our gestures and our movements and our words so that there's a synchronicity between the two. Because after all, no matter how advanced AI becomes and I, and it's gotten pretty advanced, right? I think we can all agree the human, a human being standing in front of other human beings is the most persuasive, persuasive organism that exists and has existed from since time immemorial. 01:18:58.0300000 Human beings standing in front of massive, massive crowds of people have persuaded soldiers to go back into the trenches and continue a fight when the enemy was on its last, you know, on its last breath. Despite the odds and despite knowing that they could die and not never come back. Human beings have spoken words in speeches, in public arenas and spaces. Our politicians. And of course the power, the power that that wields is one that, that, that, that, that, that needs a check and balance. 01:19:38.6100000 It needs responsibility. And in today's world, we are seeing how vitally important that is. But if you look at some of the greatest orders of time, Martin Luther King, Winston Churchill, Barack Obama, they had the power to rally crowds and they were using all of this rhetoric that we talked about before. And they are not underestimating or taking anything for granted. Their emphasis on certain words, their pauses have all been worked out ahead of time and are also living in the moment based on how crowds and how audiences are responding to them. 01:20:20.5200000 So it's never a one sided assault from them to the audience. It's always a conversation where even though the audience may not be speaking back verbally, they are responding back through their gesture, through their body language, through, you know, their facial expressions. All of these things contain information that if we're open to and if we will receive, will inform what next comes out of us or will color what next comes out of us in a way that makes the jury feel like we're talking directly to, to them. And that's another overarching principle of public speaking. There are public speakers and then there are good public speakers. 01:21:05.3400000 The ones that I think are the few and far between and the ones that, you know, people will pay hundreds, if not thousands of dollars to go see are the Ones where, despite how large the audience is, audience members can say that they felt as if this person was speaking directly to them. And that's something that we would, that we should all want to want in a jury. Want a jury to experience and feel for them to say, wow, this attorney was so sincere and so genuine. And I could feel as if they were speaking directly to me. And think about how that would inform one holdout, you know, to hold their ground amidst a sea of all guilty, you know, of all. 01:21:56.3600000 Of all 11, of all other 11 that have determined the guilt already of the defendant. 01:22:06 Okay, Jury centered listening Hearing what the jury is hearing. What is this? Jury centered listening involves monitoring how testimony and argument likely land with jurors checking in. There is no rule that says you can't check in with the jury when, even when you're not doing opening or closing. I'll give you some examples. 01:22:33.7000000 Cross examination. There are opportunities in cross examination, despite it being awkward to do so, where you can break the proverbial fourth wall. Breaking the fourth wall is a, is a theater term where it basically means that the actor on stage turns to face the audience and addresses the audience directly. Shakespeare used this in a brilliant way, especially with his villains. For the villains to speak their truth to an audience in the sense of telling the audience what they are planning, what they're plotting to do. 01:23:24.2000000 And as a result, the audience now was made privy to something that the other characters in the play did not know about. And so it's like the equivalent of you as an audience member now knowing something that a pivotal character in the play doesn't. And the power of this is taking the, taking the scene from Psycho, the shower scene from Psycho where Norman is coming into the hotel room, where Mary, I guess, is taking the shower. You know, he's in there without even seeing, without even having the camera fall on him. The music is bringing up the stakes. 01:24:13.8000000 And now your heart's beating out of your chest because you see Mary in the shower, who is completely oblivious to Norman being in the room, and, and leave it to Hitchcock to give us the rest. But there you go. It's a case of the audience knowing something that the actor doesn't. 01:24:37.2300000 It's not as deep an issue when it comes to a trial of breaking the fourth wall. All we're doing essentially is breaking eye contact with the witness that we're cross examining to look at the jury. And if you think about it, we're going to use some logos here. What might be a logical time to check in with the jury during cross examination, if you are using the ten commandments of cross examination, which I really hope you are, a prime time to check in with the jury and break the fourth wall would be after asking a leading question that is, that has significance and that is beyond just for example, setting some, setting the background or setting the stage for what is to come. I, I, I, I, I, I attempted, I attempt to do this and I put conscious attention on this by even putting a note in my cross examination look at jury. 01:25:47.7800000 And the reason why is because as a public defender, I never had a second chair. I was the, I was, I was every chair, I, you know, I was the only one trying the case. We didn't have the manpower to put a second attorney in to a trial. So I had to be my eyes and ears even when I was up. And I wanted to not be in a bubble or a shell, so to speak, so that I would be open to what I was receiving from the jury. 01:26:25.2300000 And there would be times, and I'll be the first to admit that I was losing the jury. And after a question that I asked that I thought carried a lot of weight and significance and was the climax for a chapter, I really thought that I was going to have jurors leaning in. And when I broke the fourth wall to look at them, I was seeing yawns and I was seeing glazed over eyes. And in that moment it was tough, it was a tough pill to swallow. But I transitioned to a different chapter because I realized we were close to the end of the day and they had been sitting for hours and that this was, this was a point that was lost on them. 01:27:11.4000000 So this was a truth check on myself because if I didn't take a second to look at them, I might have otherwise in my shell have thought that I scored that point when in fact I didn't. So it is so important, especially after questions that contain a lot of importance to break the fourth wall, look at the jury, take them all in. And you know, if you think about it, you've put the question out there in leading form which you're hoping to get an affirmation of from the witness. You don't need to maintain eye contact with the witness. You put that question out there and you are already programmed to what answer you're expecting, expecting from it. 01:27:58.6000000 It doesn't mean that you are closed off from something else that the witness might say if it's not the yes that you're expecting. But you can do both. It's kind of like this, you know, you're you're tapping your head and rubbing your, or tapping your stomach. No, no, tapping your head and going like this on your, on your tummy. You can do it though. 01:28:19.0400000 It, it's a little bit of multitasking, but the information that you get if you remain open to it is invaluable. 01:28:30.3100000 All right. This matters in all phases of trial, especially openings and witness exams, how trial attorneys should use it. Listen with a juror's ear. Is this confusing? Is this boring? 01:28:40.8700000 Is this emotionally off putting? Trial lawyers often overestimate how much jurors understand or remember. Jury centered listening keeps counsel grounded in clarity and persuasion. If you find yourself confused, the jury probably is too. You know, I do a lot of Shakespeare. 01:29:01.1100000 One of the things that I learned from one of my very first teachers, because of the iambic pentameter and because of how condensed and how much information is put into shorter lines, we were taught that we had to be so audience oriented and that we had to, we had to go extra lengths to make sure that they understood because even. And so we paraphrase a lot and we would speak the paraphrase out loud to make sure that we understood, understood 110 to 120% what we were saying before we actually fell back on Shakespeare's words. No doubt Shakespeare's words were the words that were, that would have to be spoken in the play itself. But if I didn't understand what I was saying, and if I didn't understand, after I understood what I was saying, why he chose certain words and why this order was constructed, then I was also going to lose some of its meaning when I spoke those words. So we would call it a, like a 50% differential. 01:30:27.3600000 It was like if the actor speaking these words understood it at 120%, you'd be lucky for the most, for the most avid Shakespeare person in the audience to understand it at only like 80%. And I challenge attorneys to look at their closing arguments in the same way you've been living with them for weeks on end, you've been living with the case for weeks on end. But are there gaps? Are there jumps that you're making and from A to C, without actually connecting the dots with other pieces of evidence to get you there, are those gaps going to be too wide for the jury to understand without those intervening facts to get them from A to B? All of that, I think is very important because at the end of the day, we might not be speaking Shakespeare in the courtroom, but it is heightened language, just like Shakespeare was heightened Language, legal, especially legal analysis and reasoning, which we are relying upon relentlessly in closing is based, is a heightened language. 01:31:49.5300000 The beauty though is that the very same tool that were available to Shakespeare and that were handed down from Aristotle are available to us in the courtroom. And that's another course called rhetoric in the courtroom. But nonetheless, it provides an insight into how we can take arguments and instead of flattening them out, actually raise them to a level that is going to keep the jury fully engaged. More so than any avatar or artificial intelligence or cartoon image that could be rolled out on a green screen in place of you. You are ever so more powerful than any one of those. 01:32:37.2400000 And this, after all, is happening in the moment. It is revealing itself in the moment. And just like an audience in the theater is, you know, there's a sense of, oh man, you don't know what's going to. What to expect in the next scene. Not only is the play written so well that there's going. 01:33:00.2100000 There's heightened that there's. That the stakes are inherently high. But the audience is also sitting back there thinking, boy, anything could happen right about now. You know, this actor could lose their line or this set could fall down unexpectedly. How are they going to react to that? 01:33:17.1400000 There are no do overs. Just like on the stage in the courtroom, there are no do overs. And that creates an intrigue, that creates a suspense in the minds of the jury. And the high stake nature of it is already there by virtue of the case, whether it's a criminal case involving a defendant who stole, who assaulted, allegedly stole, assaulted, robbed, conspired to steal something. All of these things are inherently high stakes. 01:33:56.3800000 This is why producers and directors will go out and pay people for their stories so that they can take them and turn them into something to. Something to show on Broadway or in, in any other theater house in this in New York or Chicago. The Bronx tale based on a true story is. Was one of the biggest hits on Broadway. So all of these things you already have high stakes. 01:34:29.7300000 And now it's in the telling of this story. Everything is already there. You have you as the most powerful conveyance form of, as the most powerful instrument to get this information out there. And you've got high stakes by virtue of the facts. In this case. 01:34:47.5500000 There's going to be two different sides to that, to those bare facts that, you know, form the allegations. But nonetheless, it's high stakes. 01:34:59.2400000 Okay, we are at time and I am so sorry. I sometimes get carried away over here. I just want to double check something just so I am. Good. Okay, we're going to end. 01:35:14.6000000 Let me get you the code for today. I'll get you on your way. 01:35:26.3700000 All right? 01:35:30.5300000 All right. Code for today's program is S. Capital S is in sam, capital V as in victor, the number six. Capital d is in David, the number six. Let me just get this into the chat for all of you, Okay? And there it is in the chat if you haven't already, you're good to go. 01:35:58.9400000 Capital S as in sam, capital V as in Victor, the number 6. Capital D as in David and the number 6. Capital S as in sam, capital V as in victor, the number six. Capital d as in david and then the number six. Great. 01:36:13.1800000 Okay. Well, thank you so much for joining me. I'm so sorry about the time. Just get carried away. But hope to see you at a future program with lexvid and have a wonderful weekend. 01:36:23.9000000 Bye now.