00:00:14.2400000 Hello everyone and welcome to today's seminar. I see everyone still getting signed on, getting their volume connected. So you can at least listen to today's seminar. If you're not necessarily watching it intently, you can at least listen to the content. So we'll go over a few housekeeping items here to begin with. 00:00:31.4900000 First and foremost, the most asked question is when do you get that CLE code for your CLE credit? Well, the CLE code comes at the end of today's seminar. It will be populated into the chat feature here on Zoom by LexVid within the last 10 to 15 minutes of the seminar. There's no precise time, just somewhere in that time frame, you know, quarter till the top of the hour is when you may start to see that get auto populated into the chat feature along with that code. There will be instructions on what to do with it. 00:01:03.8800000 What you have to do with the code is you have to write it down, memorize it, screenshot it somewhere where you can regurgitate it later and then you exit out of today's seminar, log into your individual LexFit account, go to your seminars or the place where it lists the ones that you have attended or are attending and and there should be a place in there for you to type that code in and hit submit to LexVid. LexFed then has 30 days to take that, take your attendance and turn it around and report it out to your specific jurisdictions. Again, they do have 30 days to do this, which means your attendance here today will not be instantaneous on your audit report from your specific jurisdictions, but it will be there eventually. If you don't see it there within the next 30 to 45 days, then reach out to LexVid, see where it's at in the process, see if something you know is held up at the state or maybe on their end and then figure it out. LexVid does keep a record of your attendance here today as well as they can tell when you sign on and sign off of the seminar here today and how much of it you attended with those different sign on features. 00:02:14.3400000 So again they can reproduce or recreate if you did attend, if there is something that went wrong in that submission process process. If you have any other questions about the content here today or anything about the seminar or just general questions, I do encourage you to put those in the chat feature as well. I try to kind of monitor it while I'm speaking, but sometimes I just wait and answer questions at the end of the seminar just for flow and just because it fits better depending on what questions are Asked. Excuse me, but I do encourage you to put those questions in there. But if you have any of them. 00:02:50.9900000 Excuse me, I do have a getting over a sore throat, so I have my tea and coffee here and cough drops to get through the presentation today with that. If you have not had a seminar with me before, My name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant general counsel of Taft, Stentinius and Hollister law firm located in Indianapolis, Indiana. In that role, I do anything regarding ethics compliance questions from our multiple attorneys across our various firms regarding their duties under the rules of professional conduct. And some of those deal with what we're going to talk about here today, client communication control and just, you know, working with clients in general. 00:03:30.9000000 So again, I encourage you to put any questions into the chat feature and we will get to those as they come up with that. Let's get started here today. And going over just that. Attorney client relationship. Now, we always have to remember who is the boss in the attorney client relationship. 00:03:49.9000000 So this, this is maybe going back to basics for everyone here or a lot of you on the call, but who is the boss? And the reason going back to basics and answering this question is important is because sometimes we forget that we as the attorney are not the boss in the attorney client relationship. We are the advisor, we are the counselor. We are the person who advances the objectives of the client, but we are not the boss. And so Rule 1.2 tells us that we're not the boss. 00:04:26.3390000 It basically says that the client controls the objectives of the representation and we advise on the means to get to those objectives. Now, 1.2 also has some other provisions in it too. Like we can't counsel clients in anything that is criminal, anything that is fraudulent, or anything against the law. And that we can limit the scope of our engagement of what we're advising on or counseling on. And then two, that we, you know, we have to be authorized to carry out acts again with that client being the boss. 00:05:00.1400000 You can see there in 1, 2A, a lawyer may take action on behalf of the client that's impliedly authorized. But otherwise we need permission. So we shall consult, we shall abide by a client's decision in certain matters. And that shall is that mandatory standard of 1.2 a. Now what decisions would be more impliedly authorized versus we need affirmative client consent to do something. 00:05:29.0900000 Well, if you look at it this way, since we're advisors and counselors, counseling the client on the means to get to their objectives, their ultimate end goal, things that could be implied. The authorized is arguing a Motion in front of a judge, responding to a motion that's filed within the deadline, doing those things that are just inherent to keep the case moving forward, to get to those objectives. But even with that implied authorization, it doesn't mean, you know, to keep the case moving forward, you hire a $20,000 expert without the client's consent, because ultimately the client's going to be responsible for that fee of paying the expert. So in that instance, we need client consent to hire the expert, but then once it's hired, we're impliedly authorized to work with the expert, get the opinion, you know, give them guideposts and parameters of what we want. So it's kind of like a balance between when we need consent from client and instruction from our boss there, and when we're impliedly authorized to act without getting that specific instruction or that specific consent to move forward. 00:06:39.1300000 Another place where we do need the client consent is with any settlement, with any plea agreement, with anything like that, we need client specific consent. Even if we get a settlement offer in and we think it's going to be better than anything they would get at any time at trial, anytime elsewhere, like even on their best day, this is better. If the client says no, the answer is no. We cannot override that client discretion, that client decision. What we can do is counsel the client of why maybe they should accept it, outline those reasons, and if they choose to go against our advice, document our advice, send it to the client, or just keep it in the file so later on the client can't come back and say, once they lose at trial or don't get as good a settlement at trial or, you know, verdict, they can't come back later and say, well, you never told me. 00:07:35.3700000 I should have taken that. That's your fault, attorney. And you say, no, no, no. Here's this writing, here's this documentation. You didn't follow our advice. 00:07:44.1700000 We didn't commit malpractice. You just made a bad decision. Don't say it like that. But you get kind of the point when it comes to it. And so we do want to protect ourselves when our bosses, meaning our clients, don't follow our advice. 00:08:00.2800000 Especially nowadays with Google Generative AI, there are so many clients out there, laypersons, just general people in society who think I call them the Google lawyer or now the Generative AI lawyer, because they say, well, generative AI told me you should be doing this and that's not what you're doing. So you're wrong. So now they're kind of testing us or you know, working against us, our own clients working against us, saying that Gen or Google, you know, knows better about the law than we do. Well, again, just document your advice. If they go against it and want to follow the Gen AI or want to follow the Google, then that's on them. 00:08:41.1800000 At that point we can document, we can advise, we can protect ourselves. But ultimately the client is the boss and we just advise and counsel on that, counsel them of how to get to their ultimate goal, whether that be a million dollar settlement, a new enough money to buy that new boat, or just an apology from opposing parties, who knows? But we are the counselors, advisors, not the dictators, not the final decision makers. Even though we maybe should be in some instances we are not. So we do have to remember that. 00:09:16.9500000 We also have to remember too, in this advising, in this counseling, that's kind of where these other parts of this rule come into play. We cannot shall not their 1.2 D, as in dog counsel our clients on anything that is adverse or against criminal law or civil law or any law, state or federal, or assist the client in doing anything criminal or, you know, against any code or regulation or anything like that. We have to maintain our independence from that. Otherwise we're going to be sitting beside them in jail as an accomplice and not on the other side making money trying to get them out of jail. They're not our best friend. 00:09:59.8400000 Hopefully not. But if they are, you know, that's a decision you have to make. But again, I use that because sometimes they say, you know, your best friend's the one sitting beside you in jail. We don't want the client to be that best friend. We're not going to sit beside them in jail. 00:10:14.2400000 We're going to make sure our legal advice and stuff is not being used for fraud, criminal or fraudulent conduct. And if it is, we're going to cease that representation, follow any obligations we have potentially to report it out to authorities if we can, under our confidentiality rules and do what we're supposed to ethically don't allow our clients to bring us down as lawyers. We need to help raise them up and how they conduct themselves. If your clients also ask you to litigate or take any position that is just repugnant, you do have the right to say no. Just because they're the boss and they want you to do something, you do have the right to say no. 00:10:58.6900000 And when you say no, yes, it may cause some friction with the client. You can articulate why you don't want to do it. And if that friction is still there. There's probably a breakdown in the attorney client relationship and maybe it's time for termination or time for you both to part ways. It's okay to terminate a client, especially if they're asking you to do something repugnant against state or federal law or something else against our rules of professional conduct. 00:11:28.1600000 Because if they're asking us to do those things and we do them, we can't later claim, well, they told me to, that's not a defense. We know better. And so we're going to get in trouble under our license. And you have to ask yourself and is the client worth risking your license and doing the repugnant thing, Doing the thing against the rules of professional conduct that they're asking you to do. And that's again, a personal choice to me. 00:11:53.0300000 It's not, you know, I want to keep my license and not have it in jeopardy. But we have to remember that. And we can fire clients. A lot of attorneys think I can't fire a client. How am I going to fire a client? 00:12:05.3500000 You just fire them. You send them a termination letter. You outline if there's any upcoming dates and deadlines, you follow any court rules or local rules. If there's a notice provision that you have to give the client, say, 10 days notice before termination, you get leave from the court. If there's an active case pending, you just follow the rules and procedures. 00:12:26.5000000 If you want to know what rule it is under the ethics code, it's rule 1.16. That's the termination of clients rule. Comply with it, comply with any local court rules and procedures, and just don't prejudice the client. And you can terminate a client for any reason at any time. Prejudicing the client can include things such as holding the client's file hostage when they've hired a new attorney just because you want paid before you hand over the file. 00:12:54.7100000 That's called holding the client's file hostage. That could potentially prejudice the client because for the new attorney to get up to speed for the new attorney that the client's now hired, or for their representing themselves pro se, they may need the file and the file contents to move forward. And the file is technically owned by the client, not by us. So when the. When we terminate the relationship and the client ask us to send them their file in writing, we need that request in writing or send it to a third party, a new attorney. 00:13:30.2000000 Again, we need that request in writing from the client. We need to promptly and diligently comply with it and send them over the documents and items they're entitled to. If we have outstanding attorneys fees, if we have outstanding invoices in arrearage, we don't be petty and we don't say no, no, no, no, this is my file till you pay. That could be prejudicing the client, which would be in violation of termination or the rules of ethics. What we do is we go through the proper channels to assert an attorney's lien. 00:14:02.5300000 Kind of like a mechanics lien. If you've ever hear we send notice to the client or now former client, their new attorney if they have one in a letter. And if there's a court case pending, we can also file notice with the court of our outstanding attorney lien. Then we're like any other lien. And if there's a settlement, if there's a verdict, if there's something like that involved, our lien has to be satisfied out of those funds because we've put everyone on notice of the lien. 00:14:35.2400000 So if that comes into a situation you're in, look up attorney lien in your jurisdiction, see if there's any special parameters around that. But that's kind of the bare bone basics of how we would get that attorney's lien on the file. Now does it mean you're going to get paid? Well, if there's a settlement or verdict, potentially. But if there's not or they lose, you may have to write off that work or it's just going to be a lost cause. 00:15:00.3500000 But we still cannot prejudice the client by holding that file hostage. So we need to think about all these things and remember that our client is the boss. We have to counsel them or advisors. But we can push back if they ask us to do criminal fraudulent things, anything adverse to the rules of professional conduct or anything we just feel is repugnant and we do have the right to fire them. So again, we need to kind of take ownership of our own actions and kind of work with them. 00:15:31.0600000 It's a relationship, it's an attorney client relationship. Just like any other relationship you're in personally and professionally, it's a two way street. You have to give, they have to give, you have to communicate back and forth. So we have to remember that concept. A lot of times in business you think, well I'm the one that went to law school, I'm the one that has the knowledge, they have no idea what they're talking about, so I'm just going to do it. 00:15:56.0600000 We can't have that mentality as lawyers. It's not set up that way under our rules or how they envisioned us working with clients. So we do have to consult with them, we do have to talk to them, but we do have some autonomy in certain decisions we make with courts and different things. And we have to follow our other rules too, like candor to the tribunal, like I said, the client can't ask us to do anything that's adverse to our rules of ethics, which if they ask us to lie to the court, that would be an implication there too. So again, we do have to make that balance. 00:16:30.7800000 Now where the problem kind of comes in with this too, when the attorney ask us to do stuff is sometimes attorneys just don't know when to let go, kind of going back to that termination or they don't realize that they need to ask for consent in a certain circumstances, like they feel like they have authority already, or they feel like they have that implied authority or actual authority. The only way you actually have actual authority, excuse me, actual authority is if it's express. Say for instance, when I was a plaintiffs litigator, we would always talk to the clients, especially if we were getting ready for settlement, and we knew in our head the number, the minimum number they take. And then we were pre authorized to make demands or take amounts within a range they gave us. Now obviously we tried to get to the top of that range for the most benefit of the client, but we had a pre authorized express authority range of settlement. 00:17:31.9800000 If anything was outside of that range, we had to go back and communicate with the client because they have to consent to the settlement to get the authority if it was outside of the pre authorized amount that they told us to get. So you do have to look at too sometimes where it's not implied authority, like you know, moving the case forward, talking to the court, talking to opposing counsel, it can be that actual express authority, and that is fine too. I do recommend though, getting any express authority like that settlement authority in writing if possible, or at least a quick email confirmation or something like that, because you don't want to later come back, say they gave you authority, opposing counsel offered it, you said, we accept, you know, my client will accept that, send over the paperwork. And then you go back and the client's like, no, that's the wrong range. And you're like, no, that's what you told me. 00:18:27.7100000 And then we have a he said, she said. So if there's anything like that where you're getting express authority beyond what's implied just by nature of being a lawyer, try to get that in writing. So there's no discrepancy if you do choose to exercise it. Also, too, we have to remember that opposing counsels and other third parties, when they know we're representing a client, either an entity or a person, if we tell them something like, yes, my client will consent to that, they perceive us as having the authority to make that statement. And that's a reasonable perception on their part because we're the agent of our client. 00:19:04.1400000 But if we actually don't have that authority, and we're just kind of guessing, we could have just bound our client to something that they don't want to be bound to. And now we're not probably going to be able to untangle it, and the other side could potentially enforce it. So again, you don't want to step outside your authority and get yourself in that situation where now you could be liable to your own client because you stepped outside of your authority bounds and obligated them to something they didn't consent to or agree to, which they have the right to under the rules. So we do need to keep that balance as well. This really kind of gets a little sticky when it comes to authority to represent an organization. 00:19:46.9700000 When you're representing an organization, it's the organization itself is the client, but it operates through its duly authorized constituents, as you can see there at the top part of the slide. But your job is to first and foremost protect the organization. Where this gets a little sticky is when you're doing stuff either implied authorization or representing the organization, you start to become friends with those duly authorized constituents. They are the ones you communicate daily with. They are the ones that, you know, you go to to get the consent. 00:20:20.0900000 But at the end of the day, if that duly authorized constituent that you are, you know, the, the liaison with for your client, the corporation, if their interests ever go adverse to the corporation, your duties of loyalty lie with the corporation because that's your client. So if that person you're communicating with is stealing, conducting fraud, they're not your client. They never were. The organization was. And so you do have to kind of keep those relationships separate in your mind, even though it's hard to, because a lot of times those duly authorized constituents or the top executives that you communicate with every day become your personal friends. 00:21:00.8900000 And then they say, hey, just to let you know, you know, I, you know, took $20,000, embezzled it, but don't worry, you're my attorney. You're like, no, I'm not your attorney. I'm the corporation's attorney. So we do always have to Define who our client is so that we know, you know, what we can do and who we're advising. We're not advising that person personally. 00:21:22.7300000 We never were. We were advising them because they were running the corporation. The corporation. This entity, this, you know, can, you know, this big entity is who, you know, we have the duties to protect. With diminished capacity clients. 00:21:38.5400000 We do have to treat them as if any other client. So we have to kind of keep as normal as possible attorney client relationship with them. We still have to communicate with them. Now if they can't make decisions or have been deemed incompetent by court or by a doctor or you have, you know, some way to know that they cannot make their own decisions. And it's not just, you know, mom, brother, sister, grandma, husband saying, oh, they're crazy, don't listen to them. 00:22:05.3500000 If you do that assessment kind of yourself a little bit. But there's always good to get, you know, a court saying, yes, they're deemed incompetent, or a doctor saying, yes, they're deemed incompetent that can't make decisions. And then you can work through the guardian ad litem, the conservator or whoever's there. But we do have to try to keep the relationship as normal as possible. And having diminished capacity can also just be being a minor child in some instances. 00:22:32.6900000 And minor children are not. They're not dumb, they pick up on stuff. They, you know, are intuitive. They can talk to you. They can kind of know what they're feeling and thinking. 00:22:43.8900000 And yes, I know their brains are not fully developed yet and all those things, but we still have to communicate with them. If the minor child is our client, we can also talk to the minor child's parents if that's part of the relationship, and authorize, you know, depending on the age of the minor child and how, you know, it's set up. But we have to remember who's our ultimate client because that's the one who we owe the duties to, to follow their consent, to talk to them, to keep them advised of their matters and to do all those things. We can't just set those people aside or those entities aside and say we don't like talking to them. So we're going to talk to them over here because they're, you know, more communicative. 00:23:26.1400000 We can't do that. The client that hired us, the client that is who we're representing, is the one we owe these duties to and the one that is the boss of the relationship ultimately. So you do have to take each relationship separately and kind of look at who you owe those duties to. One of the big duties, like I've been talking about, getting consent is just that, communicating. To get consent, you have to communicate. 00:23:52.4500000 So it's pretty simple on that part. But the rule in front of you, just for reference, because I know all of you read the rules every single day, you have them out on your desk. But I'm sure for those who don't, we just have to remember that we have to promptly inform our clients of any decisions or circumstances or with respect in which we need their informed consent. We have to consult with our client on those means to get to their objectives, like we were talking about under Rule 1.2, we have to keep them reasonably informed of the status of their case, promptly respond to reasonable requests for information, consult with them on any limitation to our services, and explain a matter to the extent reasonably necessary to permit them to make informed decisions. So there's a lot here in this communication role, a lot. 00:24:41.4900000 The stuff that's going into it, but the things, how it boils down to is that we have to communicate in a prompt, effective matter and give the client enough information to make an informed consent and actually be the boss of their relationship. And that means you have to meet the client as you find them. This is one of the things that when I speak with younger associates or new attorneys, you know, coming into the legal profession, they're coming from sometimes these Ivy League law schools and these law schools where you've learned all these wonderful Latin legal words, all this new terminology. You learned a K, capital letter K can stand for contract. If you're doing shorthand. 00:25:25.0500000 You learn what motion for summary judgment is. You learn what pro se means. You learn all these wonderful new big words and, you know, stuff specific to the industry. And then they try to go talk to a client and they use those big words. They use the things and the legalese and the language and the high level speaking that they used in law school with their colleagues and professors, you know, to sound smart and to get the A. 00:25:50.3100000 And the client's sitting there like what they just don't understand. Our communication rule tells us that we have to gear our communications to the sophistication and the understanding level of the client, so. So that they can make those informed decisions and participate and be the boss. Which means if you have a client who has no clue about the legal system, doesn't know what interrogatory stands for, doesn't know the definition of a motion for summary judgment, you're not using Those terms, you are explaining it to them in a means by which they will understand what you're doing. For instance, motion for summary judgment. 00:26:33.8800000 Sitting down with a client who doesn't know that phraseology. You could say, we are going to file a document with the court to try to get the judge to throw out the case and decide in your favor prior to trial. Motion for summary judgment. I didn't have to use the words. Yes. 00:26:55.1600000 Was that a lot more words and a lot more effort on my part to explain it? Probably. But I satisfied the rule of gearing it to a sophistication of a client who may not have understood the phrase motion for summary judgment. You can also, you know, say it in the broken down way and then say, this is commonly referred to as, and say, you know, what we commonly refer to it as so that you can help start educating them, especially if it's going to be a long process and then eventually they're going to learn and it's going to be an easier way to communicate. There was one client I had once that, you know, that we had co defendants in the proceeding. 00:27:34.6800000 And I remember I kept saying, yeah, the co defendants. Yeah, the co defendants. And the client looked at me and he goes, what's a co defendant? He had no idea what that meant. And I just, you know, took it. 00:27:44.8400000 I was a younger lawyer at the time, didn't even think about how someone could not know what a co defendant is, because that was our normal speak. We saw that every day, and we're so ingrained in it, and we kind of get that jaded, like, oh, everyone knows all this stuff. No, they don't. And so we do have to stop and think about how we communicate so that we can break it down to that client level, their sophistication level, so that they can participate in addition to that, too. Just remember, bad news does not get better with age. 00:28:17.4100000 And so if you do have bad news to deliver to a client, doing it promptly is probably going to be the best policy. Now, when you deliver the bad news, I would recommend kind of sandwiching it. Say, here's what we did. Here's the unfortunate result, but here's how we're going to fix it. So we have a. 00:28:35.5300000 Here's what we did. We were positive. We have this negative setback, but we've got a plan. Don't go to the client without that plan or something there to counterbalance, you know, the negative. Now, sometimes that's going to be hard because maybe you've just lost the final appeal or Maybe there's no recourse. 00:28:53.5200000 Post that. So then you've got to figure out how to communicate that to the client. But you still have to tell them. If you can use the sandwich method and do it in a proper way, like good, bad, good, then maybe that's a different blow to it. Another thing too, when communicating with clients, sometimes the client has more than one relationship with attorneys in your firm. 00:29:17.8900000 Sometimes I've noticed, and I mean, I've even done this myself with my cases, is we figure out who has the best relationship if we're delivering bad news and then that person draws the short straws because they can communicate better with the client. So you kind of play this game. We're kind of playing lawyer psychologist. But what we don't want to do is keep that news from the client. We don't want to lie about it. 00:29:43.9900000 We want to deliver it promptly, deliver it effectively, and deliver it without confusion. Don't be one of those people that, you know, sugarcoats it so much. And then it's like say you were trying to tell them that, you know, we lost a motion for summary judgment and by the end their takeaway is oh yeah, they just haven't ruled on it yet. No, we've still got to get the point across. So you can't sugarcoat it or talk around it that much. 00:30:10.1600000 But the approach you take, you just need to make sure it's geared to the client in that effect. Any other thing that needs to go to the client, same thing. We just need to make sure it's communicated and communicated effectively. Here are some non triggering events that could that are most likely going to trigger a communication with the client, meaning we need their consent, we need to tell them about it. And it starts, it's not just stuff with litigation or with their case. 00:30:38 It also starts with that fee arrangement and scope representation. The engagement letter. While engagement letters are not always required in every jurisdiction or for every type of engagement, they are highly, highly recommended across the board for any client matter. And having that communication there, whether it be verbal or preferably in writing, is going to be something you need to communicate. Because the client needs to know the fees, they need to, we need to set forth the scope and we need to set forth anything else that we need to clear up before we undertake that representation. 00:31:12.9200000 We also have to go to the client to get consent for objectives. You know, how do we get. Well, we got to get the objectives so that we can advise on the means to get there. So that client has to give us those objectives. So we have to talk to the clients and ask them, what do you want? 00:31:27.4800000 What are you looking for in here? Or they come to you and say, here's my issue, you know, do I have a case? And you've got to look at it and say, well, here's, you know, the realistic in this. And then those objectives are set and then you counsel towards them and those objectives are, can change to the client, can change their mind just like any other human being. Some other things that require us to talk to the client if we're going to arbitrate, mediate, settle, go to trial, spend $20,000 on an expert, you know, have you fly halfway across the country to depose someone on the client's dime. 00:32:02.2600000 Those are things that need consulted with the client on because it's at the end of the day, it's coming out of their checkbook, their pocket, either through the contingency fee or their expenses on monthly invoices. And so you do have to talk to the client. A lot of clients also require you set a budget, communicate, if you go outside of that budget, that they have to sign off on it. And all of those things. And clients know us lawyers are bad at communicating. 00:32:31.6500000 We're bad at getting those updates, we're bad at getting those budgets. We're bad at communicating the negative things. We're bad at just going back to the client or returning their calls or requests for information. And you may sit there and think, well, I'm not. Well, at some point we've all done it, we've all procrastinated, we've all dropped that call, we've all forgot to respond to that client or we just didn't want to. 00:32:54.9200000 And the thing is, we ethically have to. And it's a lot easier just to get it done than let it sit and fester. You can also set certain parameters in your workplace or in your client engagement letter. You can tell the clients that you only take client meetings on X days at certain times and then send them a calendarly invite. If you use calendarly, where they can go on and pick the convenient time based on your schedule. 00:33:21.6100000 Not their schedule, your schedule. And you know, they can fit them in. If they call, say on a Monday and you're at trial, you can have your assistant say, you know, so and so is out. He'll get back to you on xyz, you know, when he's back in the office and then get back to them, have your assistant leave you a note. Your assistant could also say, you know, they're Out. 00:33:43.9100000 However, he wanted me to schedule a call with you. Let's get something on the calendar. And then they have a date on the calendar and it's on your calendar. These little things of utilizing our assistance, communicating back, help the attorney client relationship and also stay them off from filing a disciplinary complaint against you. Because the thing that people hate the most, and this is just people in general, probably including yourself or some people on the call, is when you feel ignored. 00:34:11.7100000 Say, for instance, you call a doctor, you call an expert, your expert witness, you call someone and you leave a message. And then five days go by and you haven't heard from them, you start getting mad, you want to call back, you do call back, they still don't answer. You send an email, they still don't answer. You do it, I do it, we all do it. And our clients do it to us. 00:34:33.7490000 So if we can just learn to manage those things, we can reduce down or cut down on the constant communications from the client. If we just make them feel heard, make them feel like their case is important to us. Communicate with them on the status. Set a cadence, set parameters, set boundaries, and then they know what to expect. They know you're going to call when you say you are. 00:34:57.0800000 They know you're going to send that 30 day status letter when you say you are. They're probably not going to call you as often and they're not going to bug you as often and they're not going to sit up at 2, 3am in the morning. Find the disciplinary commission's website in your jurisdiction, find out that all they have to do is fill out an online form and hit submit and then turn you into the disciplinary commission for failure to communicate. We don't want that to happen. And so again, we have to communicate. 00:35:26.2400000 We have to set those boundaries, set those expectations and initiate the conversations, provide them with what we need and so that we can provide effective assistance of counsel. Some other policies here to consider. You know, return calls within 24 hours. Send your client drafts of things. That's a communication. 00:35:46.5100000 You can say, hey, we're getting ready to file this tomorrow. Just when you have a copy. I've actually had clients in their own terms and conditions sent to me or to, you know, our firm state that they want all drafts that are going to be filed 72 hours in advance of filing. Like, our clients know we're so bad at communicating, or people in general know lawyers are so bad at communicating that they are now having their own terms and conditions to tell us how to not be procrastinators. That's how sad it can get sometimes. 00:36:18.1400000 And so you want to make sure you comply with any clients terms and conditions, but also set your own standards. You know how you're going to communicate, how well and how often you're going to communicate and then stick to that. That's going to be very important. This also can help with you not violating diligence. Diligence is another rule that's not often talked about in seminars because it seems again pretty self explanatory, pretty, you know, like okay, common sense, we have to be diligent. 00:36:47.5600000 But when you actually get down into the rule and this is the model rule on the screen in front of you, it says a lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client. Common sense, we have to do stuff, we can't miss deadlines, Right? Right. But the comments go into so much more than just not missing deadlines. Comment 2 even specifically states a lawyer's workload must be controlled so that each matter is handled competently. 00:37:18.0100000 Now think about that. How many of you, and I can't see your hands and you don't have to call or tattle on yourselves, think your workload is controlled? Meaning do you have the perfect amount of cases where you're not missing deadlines, not filing, extension of time, getting everything you need done on a matter and in a prompt, efficient way, not feeling like, oh my gosh, I got to spend 20 hours at the office, I got too many clients, too much to do. Is your workload controlled? And that's going to look different from everyone because each of us work differently at different paces and each case is different. 00:37:53.4400000 A controlled workload could mean you have two really high profile cases or you have 50, say Social Security disability cases or more. Each one has a different complexity. 50 Social Security Disability cases may have the same work and put into them papering time, investment as two big high profile criminal defense cases. And so you do have to look at the types of cases you have, what you're doing for them and make sure it's controlled. So we're not missing deadlines, so we're not procrastinating off of files, so we, so we're not telling clients constantly. 00:38:30.1800000 I don't have time to talk to you. I don't have time to talk to you. Our workload needs to be controlled so we can communicate with the client, so we can do our job effectively and so that we can be clear, competent in what we do. And then if that's not enough to tell us to control our workload. Comment 3 even tells us that there is no other professional shortcoming that is more light, widely resented than procrastination. 00:38:53.6800000 So it's even telling us, hey lawyers, we know you procrastinate and we're telling you it's a bad trait. They actually had to spell that out for us in the comments to tell lawyers that procrastination is a bad trait for our profession to have. To me, that's kind of sad that they had to put it in black and white print. And the model rules and a lot of the local jurisdictional rules, who adopted the model rules verbatim or a variation thereof. But again, if you kind of look at this hand in hand, all the rules start to overlap. 00:39:22.9700000 And if you violate one, you're probably going to violate another one. If we don't communicate, we probably violated Rule 1.2 by failing to get consent at some point. So communication and 1.2 go hand in hand. 1.4 and 1.2, but then 2, we probably have diligence tact on there, especially if we missed a deadline or something. So they all start to overlap. 00:39:46.8700000 We need to learn to control our caseloads. We need to learn to not procrastinate. We need to learn to communicate better. We need to learn to build attorney client relationships so they trust us and so that they won't, one, sue us, file disciplinary complaints, but also two, maybe be reoccurring customers. It's easier to do work for an established client than it is to bring in a new client. 00:40:09.8000000 It takes less effort. So again, we need to think about these things. Some other things to think about too, with these shortcomings of procrastination and controlling the workload is sometimes we can think we have our workload controlled and then life throws a curveball at us. There's a death in the family, there's a death in the law firm. There may be. 00:40:30.3600000 It's your death. And the other lawyers you know in your firm have to pick up your cases. Something happens, we anticipate. We didn't anticipate getting influenza A or B or Covid, or having kids that came home with snotty noses every day. And now we're sick constantly. 00:40:44.6400000 And then the expense, the effort, fatigue, and then you don't have the cases, and then you can't keep the lights on, you can't pay your assistant. We get it. Life happens. It's an up and flow. But that still doesn't mean that you can shirk your responsibilities of diligence. 00:40:59.0400000 Communication and talking with the client. So if life is throwing you curveballs sometimes that means we need to delegate. We need to say, okay, my workload's not controlled. I can't get back to my clients. I'm under so much stress, I feel nauseated just, you know, going into the office of all I have to do. 00:41:19.4400000 We need to delegate. Now, if you're a solo practitioner, that's a little harder because delegation is going to mean referring it out to another firm. If you're in a firm with associates or other partners or other attorneys, maybe see if other partners or other attorneys or associates can take on the work. Keep what you need to do, but delegate out the rest. Delegation is not micromanaging. 00:41:42.4000000 Delegation means you give it to them, you trust them to do it. You let them run with it. Micromanaging means you give it to them. You don't really trust them. They have to send you all their edits and drafts. 00:41:52.5700000 You need to review it, you need to make edits, you need to send it back to them. Then you want to see it again before the final product goes out. But then you don't want them to send it. You want to send it so it gets on your to do list. Do you see the difference? 00:42:02.8900000 Micromanaging? I didn't lighten my workload. I actually increased it because now I'm managing someone else and giving them instructions instead of me just doing it myself. Delegation, it's off my plate. I trust the person I gave it to. 00:42:15.9300000 To manage workload, to manage. You know, the shortcoming of procrastination. If we need to delegate, we need to learn that skill. But I will tell you, delegation, for some reason is very, very hard for attorneys. Because of our confidence, because of our egos, because of the qualities that make us good lawyers. 00:42:36.1700000 And that is because we feel that we can do it better than anyone else. Or someone doesn't do it the exact way we would have done it, then we feel it's wrong, even though it's not really wrong. I will say some of the best mentors I've ever had or the attorneys I've worked with, they delegated and they understood that I may do it a different way, but we ultimately each got to the same end result. My way of getting there was maybe different, slightly or largely different than their way, but we both won in the end, and they were fine with that. As long as the end journey resulted in the same conclusion. 00:43:13.3300000 The path each of us took to get there didn't really matter. Sometimes you can argue, yes, it does because of cost, expense, and all those things. But if you look at it kind of on a parallel, no two people are going to do the same task identical. There's going to always be slight nuances. And when you delegate something and when you work with other attorneys and they have the same education as you, they may not go to the same law school. 00:43:37.8600000 I get it. But we're all lawyers. We all do cases. We all do these things, and we all work together, hopefully, especially if you're in a firm. And if you're going to give them a case and trust them, then trust them with it, delegate it. 00:43:50.4200000 If you're mentoring them like they're a younger associate, obviously you can have, you know, the oversight review. You need to, to not implicate the other ethical rules. But still, at some point, you have to let those associates fly on their own. If you continually micromanage them, even three, five, seven years in, they're never going to be a fully developed lawyer. And they're probably going to resent you and hate you at that point because they feel like you are constantly hovering over them. 00:44:18.2100000 So we have to learn to delegate when it comes to that. Some other things here, too, you can abandon clients, meaning not do an official withdrawal. Abandoning clients, obviously, you can obviously fire them, but also, too, by not doing work on them or not doing work on their cases or not following up with them, that's kind of an abandonment of the relationship as well, which can lead to, again, disciplinary complaints. So we need to remember that as well. Here's just kind of an example of a scenario. 00:44:51.3300000 And then we're going to get to some specialty topics here because we do have some time. I tried to hurry through a lot of this because I want to talk about some specialty topics that relating to clients and communications we need to make to clients that are relevant today and happening right now. But before we get to those here, here we have a lawyer client. This is a criminal defense relationship. So the client, per the accused of the crime, they have the right to retain or appointed counsel at all critical stages and the right to capital sentencing, hearing and appeals. 00:45:21.7400000 Now, with an appointed counsel, I use this example is if you're an appointed counsel, you still owe the duties to the client that you're appointed to represent that you owe to any paying client. If you're doing pro bono, if you're appointed by the court at a nominal governmental rate, you owe the same duties to that person, you're appointed to that person, you're doing the pro bono work for that you would owe to someone paying you $1,000 plus an hour. So if you think that that, you know, appointment or pro bono means lesser standard of care or you don't have to do as much effort because again, you're not getting paid, you're sorely mistaken. You can get in just as much trouble and even more trouble for abandoning or not working on those files as you would the thousand dollar an hour paying client. So if you can't devote the time you need to the thousand dollar an hour paying client, don't do the pro bono work. 00:46:20.8200000 Yes, you may say, well, I want to do it. It looks good on my resume. It looks good when I, you know, report my bar, you know, at the end of the year and renew my license. Yeah, it does. But also bringing in money and moving up and making sure you're effectively representing your clients is also good on your resume because then it means you don't have a disciplinary complaint against you. 00:46:40.6600000 So you do have to take that balance and learn. And I was actually at a seminar the other day, I attended a leadership summit here locally and one of the presenters said that no is a complete sentence. And I was. And I started to think about that and I was like, well, it is kind of no can be a complete sentence. Maybe not in the legal field as much, but again, no can be a complete sentence. 00:47:05.6500000 So sometimes even though we want to help, we have this, you know, this, I guess, guilt, maybe lawyer guilt to help and do all these pro bono things and be on the boards and attend all the bar association events and do all this ST stuff. No can be a complete sentence and you can say no to those things. We have to control the caseloads, we have to work for our clients. You need to find the balance that works for you to make sure you don't violate the rules we talked about. Otherwise you are going to get hit with that ineffective assistance of counsel, which is a two prong test. 00:47:40.9600000 The case that is normally cited, that's been in since I was even in law school, Strickland v. Washington, that our performance falls below the reasonable standard of care and that the client or the person was entity was prejudiced by our actions. It's a case by case determination. To avoid that. Let's communicate, let's be honest with our client, let's give them the bad news. Let's comply with all of the rules of professional conduct, like conflicts of interest. 00:48:09.3200000 You can see there on the screen, just as an example, let's make sure that we act with diligence, that we act with communication, and that we work with our clients, and we do that in a very effective manner, otherwise we are potentially going to get in trouble. Now, that kind of ends kind of the main topics here that were pre programmed today. But I added this slide right before the presentation because there's a few things here that are really popping up in just in general, across the legal profession. One is the case of United States of America versus Hepner. And if you never heard of United States of America versus Hepner, that's okay. 00:48:51.6300000 It didn't come. It's not even an official case. The case is actually still going on. But the judge issued an opinion on February 10 in the Southern District of New York of this year. So February 10, 2026. 00:49:04.2400000 And it was actually regarding generative AI. And in this opinion, what had happened was there was a criminal defendant in this case who had been using Claude, a generative AI model to input information and have the generative AI produce out things. And then he would take those things and give them to his attorney. And what happened was there was a federal raid or raid, you know, to confiscate stuff or, you know, do a search warrant in that, and they seized all these outputs and all these things from the generative AI that the criminal defendant or the defendant had given to their attorney. Obviously, the attorney moved to have these protected, say they're privileged, that they can't be used, that they're confidential. 00:49:54.4900000 And in this February 10th opinion from the judge is the first opinion to come down to say that no, those outputs that the client, that the defendant asked the generative AI to produce were not part of the attorney client privilege or attorney client communication and were not protected under that. And that is because when you go down to the letter of the rule, the attorney client privilege, it's communications directly between the attorney and the client. These were communications generated directly between the client and a generative AI model, not the attorney. Just because they then took them and gave them to the attorney, did not then put the protection on them, is what the court said. And this is something that I wanted to bring up here, because this is the first case that has come down with this ruling, this holding, to really tell us how are we going to treat these generative outputs and inputs when clients are doing it and then sending it to us. 00:51:00.5400000 So they're trying to be their own attorney and then sending it to us. And so here, now, this, in my mind, and this is kind of the advice of the court and the articles that are coming out on this, too, is now we have a duty, kind of like when social media came out. We have a duty to tell our clients not to leave Facebook posts, not to do that stuff for fear of spoliation of evidence and that anything they put online can be discoverable. This is a communication. Now, we need to add to that repertoire and to the communications with our client that anything they input in or is outputted to that generative AI could be discoverable, could be requested now in discovery request. 00:51:39.9500000 I haven't seen it yet, but I think with this, as it's making its way across the country, you know, is this opinion coming down? You may see that more in discovery requests. So this is another communication. We need to start advising our clients, communicating with them on the risk and benefits of these generative AI tools and how it could potentially affect their case, become discoverable, and affect them adversely in any litigation or anything like that moving forward. So something to think about there to add to it. 00:52:11.8500000 The other one, Anthropic, which, if you've never heard of Anthropic, just Google it. This is one where the federal government, Pete Hegseth and the Trump administration actually wanted Claude, because Anthropic is part of Claude, to allow it to use its generative AI or its model to help with military strategy for locations, you know, sighting of things, and open it up for that use. Because Claude Anthropic had a restriction on the use for that effect. And Anthropic said, no, we're not going to do that. The federal administration said, you know, yes, you are. 00:52:51.5600000 You know, we need to open this up or we're not going to use you. And then they put a ban on any federal agency, federal government, or anything like that from using Anthropic for defense contracts or for contracts with the military or contracts with the federal government in that sense. Now, right now it's very limited on this, but we don't know what's going to happen. There was actually, I think it was two cases filed this week or last week, at the end of last week, early this week, one in California against the government, and I think one in D.C. was the other one challenging this ban or challenging this directive from Hegseth and the federal. Federal government regarding Anthropic. 00:53:33.5300000 Now you may think, well, how does this affect me? Well, it could. If you represent the federal government, if you represent federal contractors that have contracts with the military or with the federal government, if you meet in any of those categories, your clients are in any of those categories where this ban has been put in place, and then you have to look at are you using Gen to assist that client on those files? And if you are using Gen, are you using one that has anthropic in it or is powered by anthropic like Claude? And if so, then you probably can't use it either. 00:54:10.8900000 So if your clients can't use it, you can't use it. And so again, we have to look at too, not only what's directly affecting us as lawyers and our duties of ethics and confidentiality in these things, but we also have to be competent in stuff that could affect our clients and then communicate that with our clients and disclosures and different things, you know, tell them the risk and benefits. So we can't always just put our head in the sand and be like in this hole and not talk to our clients or think, I don't have to watch the news, I don't care what's going on with xyz, because what's going on with XYZ could affect our clients, which is going to affect if we have to communicate with them because it may affect those objectives over here and we have to advise on the means and how XYZ just affected those means or affected that advice we gave. And now we need to change our objectives or now we need to pivot in the strategy to get to those objectives. So you can see that even technology is something we need to communicate with clients. 00:55:12.4400000 It's not like a, you know, they offered $50,000 or $500,000. It's hey, this case is going on in the background. We need to watch it because could affect how we litigate your case. Hey, I know you keep sending me stuff that you put into a Gen model. Just know it's discoverable and don't do it. 00:55:31.4900000 Hey, if you're using that note taking device, the one that, you know, records the meeting, makes a transcript and then sends it you the transcript that could be discoverable, don't use it, those types of things. So we have to under our competency rule, rule 1.1, no, anything that touches or concerns our client we have to know about and then be able to effectively communicate to the client. And it's not just changes in the law, like you know, now it's $500 fine instead of 600 for, you know, running a stop sign. But it's also the technology, it's also what's discoverable. It's also what can you discover in your discovery request because now maybe you want to update your interrogatories to include something that says, hey, if the opposing party ever put anything to a gen AI, please list what it is, give us the prompt, search history, give us any outputs that are in your file. 00:56:28.6200000 Give us all that stuff. That could be a new interrogatory request, that could be a new request for production. We need to stay competent on these things and we need to make sure that we advise the clients, we communicate with the clients and that they understand the risk and benefits that anything that could affect their case. So there's all kinds of stuff, communication too. Again, protect yourself. 00:56:54.8400000 If you advise on something of the risk and benefits, make sure you put it in writing. Maybe have a set form, a policy, something that's uniform across the firm. Maybe do internal trainings too to kind of help with that as well. But just communicate, don't procrastinate. Communicate, stay competent and understand that our clients are how we make money. 00:57:16.5000000 If we didn't have clients, none of us would make money unless you have some outside business that runs itself or investment or something else. I get all that. But the core of how attorneys make money is from clients. So we need to keep treat our clients like we would want to be treated. And we need to communicate with them and we need to do it effectively because ultimately when they get paid, we should get paid. 00:57:39.0700000 And that's what we ultimately want in the end, and to uphold our ethical duties. Of course, that's another benefit. But again, we need to communicate with our clients with that. The code has been put in the chat feature by LexFit and myself. You can find it there. 00:57:53.1900000 I'll also announce it verbally. It's K as in kite, the number four, the number eight, E as in elephant and J as in Jack. Again, that's k as in kite, 4, 8, e as in elephant and J as in jack. Make sure you write that down. And with that you are free to go about your day. 00:58:17.4700000 You have about 30 seconds left on the hour, so I think you're all good to get your credit. So exit out, write that down and thank you for attending today.