00:00:17.8400000 Hello welcome everyone to today's seminar. Today we are going to be talking about the ethical concerns about social media and all the little tips and tricks maybe of how to use social media, how to use it safety safely and not violate your ethical obligations. While everyone is getting signed on and connected, we will go through a few housekeeping items here today. The first housekeeping item is when do you get that CLE code for your CLE credit? The CLE code will come at the end of today's seminar. 00:00:49.8600000 It will be auto populated into the chat feature feature here on Zoom. LexFID will put that code in within the last 10 to 15 minutes of the seminar. You will need to write down that code, exit out of today's seminar once it has concluded and enter the code into your individual Lexvid portal where prompted. You will then submit it to Lexfib. Lexfid will have 30 days to turn it around and submit your attendance here today to your respective jurisdiction and then your jurisdiction will put it on your CLD audit report if you do get one. 00:01:24.6000000 Obviously this process is not instantaneous since you have to submit your attendance. LexFit has to turn it around to your respective jurisdictions and then that has to come to where you can see it on your account. Therefore, if you do not see it on your individual account within 30 to 45 days, maybe then reach out to LexFit or your individual jurisdictions and see where it's at in the process or if something has occurred and where you need to correct it. But again, please allow lexvid some time to get those submitted. So just watch for that CLE code in the chat feature within the last 10 to 15 minutes of our seminar here today. 00:02:01.3400000 And if you do miss it there, do not worry, I will alert you of it once I am done speaking as well and repeat it orally verbally to you so that you can take it down if that is more your style. Or you can again go to that chat feature to get the code. In addition to that, if you have any questions throughout today's cle, please do not hesitate to ask those questions. You can put those questions again in that chat feature. I will try to monitor the chat as I am speaking and answer the questions simultaneously with the presentation if the content so allows. 00:02:35.4600000 If not, I will get to those questions after the seminar has concluded. Or you can always email LexVid and have them submit me the questions via email as well for me to respond to with that. Let's get started a little bit on our content here today. Oh but first I forgot I Have not introduced myself yet. If you have not taken a CLE with me, my name is Carrie Sheehan. 00:02:58.4500000 I'm assistant general counsel at Taft, Stentinius and Hollister law firm located in their Indianapolis, Indiana location. In my practice as assistant general counsel I deal with anything internal ethics, internal compliance, including the use of social media by our lawyers, by our firm, and you know, anyone who calls me for advice or calls me to help them on things. And so again, social media is in that wheelhouse of, you know, ethics compliance and everything like that. And yes, there are social media platforms that are old, there are social media platforms that are new. And some of us may have forgotten about social media as we started our career, but it is still here and, and it is still something that affects the legal practice, which means we have to know how to use it and stay competent in it. 00:03:51.8500000 If you don't know what social media is, I'm meaning the true definition or the definition of what it is, not just that it's, you know, the YouTube, the Facebook, the LinkedIns and all those things. It is a web based service that allows people to connect and network. And it's not the facetime networking that we have anymore really in our society. Networking now is done more online through social media platforms. If you think about it, if you were looking for a job or looking for new to move firms, or looking to see where someone works or do certain things, what is the first social media platform you think about? 00:04:31.7400000 LinkedIn? Probably it is where it's those networking connections, those connections where you can see people's bios, their resumes, what they do, where they, they worked, if they're open to work. And it's also a place where recruiters go to recruit new talent to different law firms. And there's job postings, there's job boards. It's not just, indeed it's not just newspapers or like the ABA platforms or those individual legal platforms are going out to each law firm's individual site to find job postings anymore. 00:05:05.1600000 Social media through LinkedIn can send it out across the country or the world and you can get multiple applications and a wider reach than you could just by posting it on your website. So social media is not just the Instagrams, the different things we think of in that realm, you know, that younger generations are using, that our kids are using, that students are using, that even some of us are using. It's also for networking and making those connections, which is where it can really become beneficial in the legal context and depending on what you're doing. In your practice. But we do need to stay safe when we are using any online platform or social media media platform. 00:05:49 A good rule of thumb is what I call good social media hygiene. It's not. If it's not something you can do in person, then don't do it online. There is no invisible wall, no invisible cloak, nothing protecting you online that is not there offline. For instance, say for instance, you want to get this new client. 00:06:11.7000000 You've heard there's been this multiple car accident. You know, this can be big cases. You know, you can't go solicit potentially in your jurisdiction to person like you can't go to the hospital, you can't be that ambulance chaser. Then you think, well, just send them a message on, you know, Facebook or LinkedIn or find their profile and you know, tell them to sign up. That way if you can't do it in person, you can't do it online. 00:06:36.2500000 And so again, just because it's online and doesn't have that human connection that we have when we're in person with someone, doesn't mean that it's not. The rules don't apply. The rules apply to our conduct online just like they apply to our conduct offline. And that means personally and professionally, because the rules of professional conduct apply to us personally and professionally. Go read the preamble to the rules of professional conduct. 00:07:06.5400000 Go reread the oath you took to become a lawyer and it will tell you that that is personally and professionally, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. We are bound by our actions to the rules of professional conduct. So we have to remember that and that we're not invisible online and that we have to still use our good ethics and our compliance. Because social media can be very harmful. It can be harmful to ourselves if we don't follow our ethics. 00:07:35.8800000 It can be harmful to our clients. It can be harmful to non lawyers, firms and companies. And this is because people just don't understand. They think they understand social media, they think they understand the Internet and the online presence, but it, they don't understand how it can negatively impact them. First of all, it's accessible 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and moves at the speed of light. 00:08:00.9400000 It's also not anonymous. You can track a nice little IP address back to a portal. Even if you don't put your name on something you post or something you like or, you know, something you put out there as content. It also there's this misconception that you can keep stuff private online, which you can't even if you think you're just sending something out to your friends and family or, or just posting it on your, you know, private blog account, there's always the chance that someone could see it, Even a friend and family member reposted on their account out to more users. They pick it up, send it out to more users, and then it goes viral. 00:08:40.3400000 There's also the screenshot and sending out too, to make something go viral. And so again, we have to remember that nothing we do is anonymous and nothing is private and also too, nothing is confidential and it can go viral in a heartbeat. So all these things can be very harmful. And that 24, seven hour access, the other thing I want to mention about that is that if you think about it, we are accessible to our clients, to our colleagues, to our opposing counsels, to our family 24 hours a day, seven days a week by one device. This cell phone device. 00:09:19.6900000 It has our emails on it, it has text messaging on it, it has all the social media apps on it. And then I want you to ask yourself, are you fully competent, as envisioned by the rules of professional conduct, to give legal advice, to be a lawyer, to respond to emails, even emails that make you mad when you first read them 24 hours a day, seven days a week? Probably the answer is no. Maybe you're tired, maybe you're not thinking clearly because you've had a few adult beverages. Maybe you're at a party and you didn't read the email, or you're, you know, transitioning or in traffic and, you know, trying to text and drive and not giving it your full attention. 00:10:02.0300000 It can be very, very dangerous to do those things. And that's why 24, 7 is not always a good thing. It also puts a lot of stress on us as lawyers. No more can we usually leave the office at 6, 7 o', clock, go home and disconnect. Because we didn't have our devices with us, we didn't have necessarily the Apple phone. 00:10:23.1200000 I remember the days of the BlackBerry and the flip phone, if anyone remembers back that far, but it didn't have the apps and the features that we have now. So you did have a sort of a disconnect to reignite your brain, to kind of give some downtime. Yes, you may have taken files home, but that was the hard paper files. If you remember, you had to lug him home in your briefcase. But nowadays everything's accessible, which means we as lawyers sometimes don't get the downtime we used to, which means our brains are constantly working and not regenerating and constantly on that overload. 00:10:56.9800000 So we do have to take time to sometimes disconnect from social media, from technology in general and just think about those things. With the practice of law, 24 hour access is not always a good thing. Sometimes it's good not to read your emails all weekend, makes for a busy Monday. But it's good to have that disconnect or when you do come home or stop working for the day to say, you know, I'm not touching my emails for the rest of the day. It is good sometimes to have that disconnect. 00:11:24.4700000 A problem that pops up at 11pm is still going to be there at 8am most likely. So again, sometimes good to have that disconnect. We also have to remember too, especially on social media platforms and this is that 247 hour access that we kind of get sucked into. How many of you and just think to yourself like to scroll at night or look at your friend's post or browse through LinkedIn and give thumbs up, give smiley faces, give the I heart you and it's stuff. Maybe you don't even read the full content, you just see, you know, your your spouse, your significant other, your friend posted something, you want to be supportive so you just go through and like stuff or smiley face. 00:12:04.0200000 We have to remember too as lawyers, since we're bound by the rules of professional conduct, anything we put out there that implicates the rules is going to affect us and our license potentially. This also includes anything you like, repost, tweet, post yourself, endorse, give a heart, give a thumbs up to give a smiley face. You are adopting that content as your own and if that content violates the rules, even if you were not the original poster, then you violate the rules. So you need to make sure that everything you like, retweet, repost, give a heart, give a thumbs up to whatever group, organization, club you join or whatever thing you're being supportive of your friends endeavors. You need to make sure it does not violate the rules of professional conduct or you violate the rules of professional conduct. 00:12:57.5800000 So something to really think about there too. So sometimes even when you're scrolling, maybe just don't like everything. Yes, I know you feel like not a supportive friend. I get it. I have the same thing. 00:13:08.0600000 I like to look through LinkedIn and see, you know, different things. But you can like stuff. Just read the content before you do it. I always like to endorse, you know, new friends, jobs or you know, different things like that. If there's any say controversial Conduct or content or things. 00:13:25.1800000 I always read it to make sure it's something I want to put out there, make sure it's not, you know, violating the rules, but you can do the things. You just have to know what you're liking, reposting, retweeting, endorsing, and then kind of make that balance with the rules of professional conduct as well. And so with that too, this all comes with one overarching ethical principle. We have to be competent. We have to be competent in social media, how to use it. 00:13:50.5200000 We have to be competent in the Internet and how to use it because it affects our clients and because our rules of professional conduct tell us we have to be competent in it. It's rule 1.1 of the rules of Professional Conduct, which states a lawyer shall provide competent representation to a client. Competent representation requires this legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. To maintain this too, we have to have the skill, knowledge regarding and including the benefits and risk of associated and relevant technology. That's in the comments to the rule. 00:14:30.4700000 Relevant technology is social media and a lot of other things. But social media, the Internet are relevant technology for the legal business, even if you can argue all day, well, I don't use it, so it's not relevant to me. It's relevant to your clients, it's relevant to your clients cases. It may be even something you need to ask for in discovery, like social media posts. You need to know how the different platforms work. 00:14:58.1000000 You need to know what is out there and how it interacts with your client's case and your practice of law. Do you need to know the algorithms and how it's all set up? Probably not. But you do need to know the basics. You need to know that potentially those Facebook posts or those wall posts are discoverable. 00:15:17.8600000 You also need to know that they can be deleted or things can go down private. Then if you're in, say, a litigation type of context and you're a litigator going in front of a jury trial that you know, can you search the jurors on social media? What are your boundaries there? So again, you need to know the different ins and outs and what's allowed, what's not allowed, and how it all works and affects your clients and your particular practice of law. And in today's day and age too, with generative AI and genai and our larger language models coming out, there's all kinds of new technology areas emerging that lawyers have to be competent in. 00:15:58.7500000 For instance, if you're an intellectual property lawyer, then you are learning about generative AI and you know, people creating things using say a chatgpt or a clot or perplexity and then claiming it as their own work or violating copyright or patents or trademarks. And so you are having to learn potentially if you're an IP lawyer, all the ins and outs of this new technology of generative AI. On top of everything else, we have to learn too with the social media and the other things that come with the Internet. So it is a constant learning phase in this knowledge that we have to have and be competent in. We also have to realize too, if you remember that golden rule, if you can't do it in person, you can't do it online. 00:16:42.2700000 That also means we can't violate client confidences online. A reminder that under Rule 1.6, a lawyer shall not reveal information relating to a representation, including information contained in a public record, unless authorized by a specific Provision of Rule 1.616 b is our exceptions to confidentiality. This means even if something is already public or public record, you as the attorney for that client or for that entity or person cannot go out and share it. Where I see the most violations here, particularly with social media, is jury trial, court trial wins or when you're going to a hearing. I know several plaintiffs lawyers across Indiana and across actually the country where I see them post all the time. 00:17:30.2900000 Big win, jury verdict, win for X client. You know, they maybe even post a caption. They post them out. My first thought is did they get client permission to post that? And sometimes they have and sometimes they haven't. 00:17:43.8900000 And when they haven't they say, well it's public record. The rule there is no exception for publicly available information. In Rule 1.6 it says you shall not reveal client information or anything regarding the representation, no matter the source. Which means even if it's public record, great third parties can go find it. You as the lawyer for that individual or that entity cannot reveal it to them. 00:18:10.9600000 And we have to take reasonable steps to prevent that disclosure of confidential information. There's no exception for getting the likes and clicks or wanting to post it on LinkedIn or Facebook or TikTok or Instagram. There's no exception to confidentiality for social media. There is nothing saying because it's public record, you can post it. No, you need your client's consent confirmed in writing to reveal client confidential information, no matter the source of where you got that information. 00:18:45.1700000 So anything regarding the representation we cannot disclose as lawyers unless we get our clients consent confirmed in writing. And this is kind of that misconception, where lawyers tend to forget just how broad confidentiality is in general. You can see her on the screen with my two circles and I probably should have another one for work product. You know, next to that attorney client privilege one, the confidentiality is everything in red and blue. It includes anything that touches or concerns the representation, no matter the source. 00:19:15.4300000 It includes meaning witness statements, stuff you find, evidence you know, stuff you collect, maybe wall postings from a Facebook page, Everything regarding the client representation, everything you learn in that representation is confidential. The misconception always is where lawyers think confidentiality just means the attorney client privilege, meaning the communication is directly between the attorney and the client. The attorney client privilege is very narrow. It is only those communications directly between the attorney and the client without the presence of outside, outside third parties that would break that privilege. Now, obviously there are some people who can be contained in that privilege if they are essential to the communication and furthering the representation. 00:19:58.5300000 But otherwise it's a very narrow subsection of the overarching confidentiality. So confidentiality is huge. It is massive. And we have to remember that. And the only person that has the key to confidentiality is the client themselves. 00:20:15.6500000 They have to give confirmed consent, confirmed in writing or impliedly authorized by law to give over the disclosure. Meaning impliedly authorized is not that you want to make a social media post to get more clicks or make a social media post to advertise to get more people to come to your firm. Impliedly authorized means if you're going into court and maybe arguing for the client or doing something to advance the client's interest, then that's that narrow exception to not having to get client consent. But again, that does not include in the general sense, posting on social media, advertising that you represent in the client, showing what you want for the client. We need client consent to do that, just like we would need client consent to use them in a paper, newspaper advertising, or post them on our website as a representative client. 00:21:07.0500000 We need client consent to post anything about them on social media, even if it's public record, because of just how broad confidentiality is overarching in that big red circle there. While the attorney client privilege, and that is just a smaller subsection of it, so something to always remember when it comes to that and don't get into that misconception that confidentiality is just the attorney client communications. No, it's everything that touches and concerns the representation. And we have to keep that confidential unless we have client consent confirmed in writing. So remember that when it comes to it, there's other ethical rules that are implicated with our use of social media or having a presence online. 00:21:52.3500000 The first one is Model Rule 5.5, the unauthorized practice of law. This tells us that a lawyer shall not engage in the unauthorized practice of law, meaning that we can't practice law in states or jurisdictions in which we are not licensed unless one of the exceptions of Rule 5.5 apply. Now, the risk with social media and UPL, the unauthorized practice of law is the fact that when you are online, maybe someone DMS you, which means direct message, or maybe someone sends you like a question through a messenger app or something like that, or even through like a formal TikTok post and tags you in it or anything of that nature. And you're looking at it, you answer the question. You give legal advice because they're seeking legal advice. 00:22:41.1100000 You give legal advice in your mind. It's just, you're just answering a one off question, trying to help someone out. Famous last words. Let me just help them out here for a second. What you're really doing is potentially engaging in upl. 00:22:55.8700000 Did you ask where they're located? Are you licensed in the jurisdiction in which they're located? And if you're not, then you shouldn't be giving legal advice in that jurisdiction or you've committed UPO one of the cases. And when I was learning this rule and when I was working at another law firm years ago that was kind of told to me was there was an attorney, it was actually here in Indiana whose uncle lived in Illinois. The attorney here in Indiana did not have a license in Illinois, was not licensed to practice law there. 00:23:27.6700000 The uncle, one of the, obviously his nephew to help him out. So the nephew, which was the lawyer here in Indiana, sent emails to his uncle's, say, opposing party or to help him out with this dispute he was having. All he did was send three or four emails to try to resolve this for his uncle. He's only licensed in Indiana, his uncle's in Illinois. The Illinois lawyer on the other side of his uncle's case turned the Indiana lawyer in for uplifting. 00:23:55.3900000 Just for sending those three emails and saying that he's representing the uncle in the dispute. No exception of Rule 5.5 applied. He got suspended for the practice of law for those three emails. We have to remember that if we are not licensed in a jurisdiction, we cannot practice law there unless an exception applies. And you will have to look at each jurisdiction's exceptions to Rule 5.5 to see if you fall under any exception. 00:24:23.3800000 But don't get caught into the trap of when you're going onto your social media accounts and then you see maybe a friend from high school sends you a direct message on Facebook saying, hey, I hear you're a lawyer, or I see you're a lawyer. Now I have a quick question. Those can be the biggest downfalls to your career. One, you're creating an unwanted attorney client relationship if you ask that question. Two, you may be getting into the area of upl. 00:24:46.9800000 And three, the people who are most likely to sue you for malpractice are the ones that are closest to you, statistically speaking. So again, be very careful of those direct messages coming in. Be very careful not to respond to them. Rule 5.5. The other downfall area too, which is may not be as popular anymore is chat rooms. 00:25:10.3500000 Chat rooms. If you go into chat rooms where people ask legal questions and you're responding to those legal questions, how do you know where those people are located? How do you know what laws apply, what jurisdiction? Again, UPL considerations and red flags across the board. We need to watch what we do in that context and answering legal questions online. 00:25:30.7600000 The disciplinary commissions also have what I call the kitchen sink rule. You're not going to find that in any rule of Professional conduct book, but it's Rule 8.4 of the Kitchen sink. We cannot violate or attempt to violate the rules of professional conduct or knowingly assist someone else to do so. Which means if we can't do it online, we can't ask our paralegal, our kid, our relative, our spouse, our significant other, our friend to do it for us. And so again, if we can't do it, they can't do it at our direction or for us either, or we violate the rules. 00:26:02.5700000 We also cannot engage in anything that's prejudicial to the administration of justice. And this is the kitchen sink part of this rule. Think in your head how you would define prejudicial to the administration of justice. There's no checklist. There's no. 00:26:15.8600000 These are things are prejudicial. These things are not. It's not a black and white. If a disciplinary commission wants to get you on conduct that it feels is unbecoming basically of a lawyer or not up to the ideals and standards of what we think a lawyer should be in a respective jurisdiction, this is what they're going to probably go under and tag under. Because prejudicial to the administration of justice is so broad. 00:26:41.5400000 The comments to the rule try to define it by giving you examples of what could be included in it. But that's not all encompassing and not all inclusive. We have to remember this broad provision is here and that we have to look at our conduct and think does this uphold the ideals of our oath that we took to become lawyers? That does hold promoting the justice system and being those gatekeepers to it and just the legal profession in general. And if it doesn't, then we shouldn't be doing it online. 00:27:12.6100000 So again, or in person or anywhere because of Rule 8.4d as in dog and some jurisdictions, not all have 8.4g as in girl, which I call the Title 7 or the Anti Bias rule of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Again, not all jurisdictions have 8.4g as in girl. You need to check your specific jurisdiction to see if it does or does not. What this rule does it says that a lawyer shall not engage in conduct in a professional capacity manifesting by words or conduct bias or prejudice based upon race, gender, religion, national origin, disability, sexual orientation, age, socioeconomic status, or similar factors. This means we cannot discriminate while practicing law. 00:28:05.6600000 This is the only rule that is confined solely to while you are practicing law. The other rules of the Rules of Professional Conduct, like I said earlier in today's seminar, are applicable to you personally and professionally. This is the only one that applies solely while you are practicing law. Practicing law can be defined as many different things and you would need to drop down to your comments of Rule 8.4 to figure out the definition of practicing law in your jurisdiction. In most jurisdictions it can include bar association events, intermingling with colleagues and coworkers. 00:28:48.3100000 Obviously, you know, being in front of judge, opposing parties, interacting with opposing parties, clients. Anything that touches the profession is going to be engaging in the practice of law, which means we cannot discriminate and there are protected classes and that our words or conduct cannot manifest that bias or prejudice. The reason this rule was confined solely to the practice of law and not affect us personally is that a lot of jurisdictions, when it was adopted by the motto Rules, did not like it. They did not like it because it felt that it had too much of an infringement on an attorney's personal freedom of speech, which you can see it could potentially too, because we all hold opinions. Maybe some of those opinions are biased or prejudice or just, you know, left or right or in the middle or whatever it is. 00:29:38.0200000 But they didn't want to fringe too much on those personal opinions and beliefs of lawyers. But they can. Since holding a law license is a privilege, it's not a right. They can require us to do certain things while we are practicing Law, because again, holding a law license is a privilege. It is not a right. 00:29:59.4900000 And so they put this restriction in a lot of jurisdictions on us back in about 2018 is when it came into the model rules. Some jurisdictions had it before then. Some jurisdictions added it post 2018. But again, we cannot, while engaging in practice of law, including posting stuff online, manifest bias or prejudice based on the protected classes. Again, look to your specific jurisdiction though, because each jurisdiction is a little different on that rule. 00:30:29.9700000 And some, like I said, don't even have it. So again, we need to make sure it's in your specific jurisdiction. We also need to make sure certain things don't affect us when we are litigating cases, especially interacting with judges, jurors, witnesses, and third parties online or what you do online affecting you in the courtroom. One of the biggest rules too, we have to remember is candor to the tribunal. We cannot make a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal or fail to correct a false statement of material factor law previously made to a tribunal by the lawyer. 00:31:04.8700000 Now, you may think, okay, well, if I'm making a statement to a tribunal, how is that tied into social media? Well, let me tell you a story of a young lawyer in Texas. This young lawyer in Texas went in front of a judge, asked for an extension of time to file a brief or response brief to something, said that her father had passed, that she was, you know, emotionally distraught. She needed this extension of time. And the extension of time was for a week just to get, you know, the brief done, to get it, you know, on file due to the passing of her father's death and spending with family. 00:31:40.9900000 And so judge granted, it felt really bad for the young attorney that was standing in front of him, was scrolling social media because judges scroll social media at night too. Just remember that. Or during the day they can. And found the young attorney's profile, which was public, meaning anyone could view it. So he didn't befriend her. 00:32:00.1100000 He didn't, you know, crossing his boundaries, just public information. And throughout the whole week and the weeks prior, there was no mention of the death of her father. Her father actually had not passed away. And she was drinking and partying. And this went on throughout the time she was supposed to be doing this brief with the extension. 00:32:17.6890000 Young lawyer came back into the courtroom at the end of the extension and said, you know, your honor, still, you know, overly fraught with grief. I didn't have time. I need a second extension of time. Will you please grant it to me? Judge said no. 00:32:31.0800000 Judge disclosed what he had seen online with this lawyer and the conduct and the partying, the drinking and that, you know, her father really wasn't deceased. He turned her into the disciplinary commission. She got sanctioned in the courtroom and the judge called her senior partners at her firm because it was a small community to report her conduct to them. We cannot lie. There's so many times, and this is just a one that's really kind of egregious when it comes especially in front of a judge. 00:33:01.7100000 But there are several times, if you think about it, do your co workers or your staff lie about being sick and taking off work? Have you ever gone out and checked their public? Don't befriend them, just their public facing Facebook post to see if they're really sick or are they at Kings island or at an amusement park or, you know, doing something fun. There was one time a co worker actually of mine called in sick for work. And this is actually another lawyer said he couldn't work, he was just sick. 00:33:30.3500000 You know, can I cover his hearings, his cases, all those things? For the couple days he forgot he was friends with me on Facebook and posted him and his family at Kings island and going to amusement parks. He wasn't sick. He just didn't want to do his caseload and lied about it. So again, we cannot lie. 00:33:49.9100000 Duty to the candor, to the tribunal is paramount. But we also have other duties as well to opposing counsel, to that, to being truthful and honest. We also have a rule of model, rule 3.5, impartiality and decorum. We cannot seek to influence a judge. We cannot have ex parte communications with judges or jurors. 00:34:15.5390000 We can't seek to influence jurors either. And we can engage in conduct that would portray these things. One of the biggest questions, especially when social media was coming about, was can lawyers look up jurors on social media during the jury selection process and war deer to see different things. A lot of jurisdictions said yes, and some even require it as being competent to look at potential jurors online. Now the line has to be drawn of looking them up to view what is public versus looking them up and asking them to be your friends so that you can see what is private. 00:34:53.6900000 The former, the looking them up. Just viewing what is public is usually always allowed, except in a few minority jurisdictions. And I will get to those in just a second and sometimes even required to look up jurors to meet your competence level of what is publicly available about those jurors. What is not allowed in almost all jurisdictions because it's considered an improper communication. Is befriending meaning sending a friend request to those potential jurors or jurors so that you can see their private information or the stuff that they've left private and not allowed the public to view that area. 00:35:33.7200000 We do not venture into, we only can view what is public. Same thing with judges. I always say the judge rule, and this is for judges staff too. Do not befriend a judge just because you're presiding in his or her courtroom. Only befriend a judge if you have an outside connection or are not in their court. 00:35:54.5200000 For instance, if you're both in the same cat club and you've known him for years, or your family summer together or vacation together, okay, fine, you have an outside connection with this judge and it's not going to have the appearance of an improper ex parte communication. But if you are just befriending the judge or befriending the bailiff or the judge's staff just solely because you were in their courtroom or are in their courtroom, that's going to tend to go to that perception of improper ex parte communication. Be in cat club with them, have an outside relationship, have an engagement outside of that, and then potentially you can have that friendship online if you want to be friends or have them in your network online with judges and jurors. So again, just kind of keep those things in the back of your mind just about friending judges and jurors. Not really proper, just more go what is public about them and watch those things now to get to that minority jurisdiction. 00:36:55.8400000 It was when it first started happening. New York had a rule that says yes, you can search jurors across all public platforms and see what is public. However, New York had an exception. It said if the juror knows that you are searching them and can see that you looked at their profile, then that's an improper communication with the juror. Now here's where your knowledge and competence of the different social media platforms really has to come into play. 00:37:25.3600000 Which platform allows the person who owns the page to know if you're searching them? LinkedIn, you can go on and see who searched and viewed your profile. So if you were in New York and you were searching jurors or potential jurors, you couldn't search them on LinkedIn because they would be notified that you were viewing their profile or had viewed their profile. So that would have been a ex parte communication or improper communication with that juror because the jurisdiction said it poses a threat or makes the juror feel violated or makes the juror like, you know, tense about, you know, these opposing counsels viewing their stuff. So if the platform gave them that notification, it was off limits to search the jurors. 00:38:12.6300000 If it didn't give it the notification, it was just a public platform, then you could so check your specific jurisdictions to know what the limitations are if it comes to searching jurors, having those things, or if it's required, not required, or if there's limitations like the minority of them, like New York there, where you can't search jurors on platforms in which they know you are searching for them. So again, just make sure you look at those different things so you know what's proper in your specific jurisdiction. There is a formal opinion, ABA formal opinion 462. It does talk about, you know, judges participation in social networking and how everything is evaluated kind of on a case by case basis. But we do have to remember our own ethics. 00:39:00.2100000 Judges have their own ethics. We have our ethics. And we just don't want to have that appearance of an ex parte communication or an improper communication with a juror. So just keep that in mind. Some jurisdictions even go further than the minority jurisdiction or just the general rule I gave you here just a few minutes ago. 00:39:20.2100000 And they just outright prohibit friending judges online, even at club with them. But again, it's just trying to take away that appearance of impropriety. That's what we want to guard against. And so use your best professional judgment, but also look to in your specific jurisdiction to make sure you understand the rules and parameters for where you are particularly licensed in practicing. This is just a slide on that for jurors, which we've already talked about. 00:39:48.8300000 You may view their social media contact, may not view the private portions. And then two, watch out for those specific jurisdictions that automatically notify them. If you're in one of those jurisdictions that don't allow that, you need to be competent in the different social media platforms to know when and when they don't apply and how you can search jurors or befriend judges or vice versa, or all of the above. You need to make sure you understand what your jurisdiction requires. Also to look at any court orders. 00:40:19.8000000 Sometimes courts have their own rules. So maybe look at local rules, maybe look at judge's preferences. Maybe it's in your case management order. The judge can further restrict your use of social media or broaden it if they want to, so long as it doesn't, you know, violate the rules of professional conduct. And so Sometimes you do have more restrictive court orders or imposed restrictions coming down the different judges and jurisdictions in which you are practicing. 00:40:46.8400000 So please make sure that you look at those as well. Now, with representative parties, the Internet and social media, the networking, the connections can also pose a risk. Obviously, if we cannot talk to someone represented about the subject matter of that representation in person, we can't do it online either. We also have to make sure that we are not trying to be anonymous online and trying to trick people. We can't ask them questions pretending to be someone else or having a fake name or fake profile to kind of circumvent that rule of talking to a representative person. 00:41:22.3100000 We still have our duties of honesty. We still have our duties to make sure we don't give any misconceptions or fail to disclose the material fact or any of those things. So again, if we can't do it in person, we can't do it online. And we just need to remember those rules because there will be times sometimes that may be opposing party will find the opposing counsel online and they're represented, but they're late at night and they're just mad at that opposing counsel. So they reach out to them directly if they're represented. 00:41:55.2390000 Just because it was directly to you through an email, through an instant messenger, or through a social media platform doesn't mean you can talk to them if they're represented. So we still have to use our common sense and remember that golden rule of if we can't do it in person, then we can't do it online. So we need to make sure that we do that. This is just kind of summarizing some of those rules for you. No communication without client's consent to represented parties applies online as well. 00:42:23.3000000 And prohibition extends to agents as well as ours. We can't again make that fake profile, have someone else ask at our direction to do it for us. We can't do that. That's going back to that rule 8 4A, which we discussed a little earlier. And we don't want to befriend them either. 00:42:39.5000000 We don't want to befriend our peop the people who are represented if our only connection to them is the representation and they're just a witness or an opposing party. We don't want to be going out there friending them and, you know, trying to get into their private content. If it's public, fair game. If it's private, we don't want to enter that befriending zone. So again, use common sense. 00:43:03.3100000 I always say Too kind of that golden rule again. But also think about if you were one of the parties or think about if this was you not in the lawyer capacity, but you as the client capacity, what would you want done to you? How would you feel if the lawyers were doing this to you and you were in that client capacity or that witness capacity or that juror capacity or whatever capacity. Put yourself in the other person's shoes. I know sometimes we lose the ability to do that because we get so one sided in what we practice and what we do and advancing our clients objectives without thinking about putting ourselves in that other party's shoes. 00:43:42.4000000 But we really need to put ourselves in another party's shoes and become that person in a way to understand, okay, this is probably crossing a line. Usually that gut intuition starts to kick in and if you wouldn't want it done to you if you were in that capacity, then don't do it to someone else. Again, the rules of professional conduct, if you actually read them and sit down and read the comments, it's basically common sense. It's common sense, that gut intuition and just doing unto others which you would have done unto you. And so it all comes down to those golden rules when it comes to it. 00:44:16.6400000 Also too, anything publicly accessible is generally allowed. Avoid interactions that are more private or getting at private conduct or content when it comes to those representative parties. For unrepresented parties, again, we have to be truthful. If we reach out to someone who's not represented or talk to them online, we can do that if we can do it in person. But we still can't lie. 00:44:39.4900000 We still can't pretend to be someone else. We still can't have a fake account. We still can't say we're disinterested when we're not. We still have to have all those bells and whistles of saying, I'm representing so and so. This is my interest. 00:44:52.9300000 You know, here are my questions. We can't imply that we're anything but that. So again, the rules that apply to us in person when we're talking to unrepresented parties apply to us online as well. Do not imply that disinterest. Correct any misunderstandings, don't give them legal advice, especially sometimes. 00:45:14.8900000 I don't know how many of you have pro se opposing parties. They're the worst and most dangerous opposing party is the pro se. And that is because if you think about it, they are going to ask questions to you, the opposing counsel, because they have the right to talk directly to you since they're Refereeing the son of themselves, pro se. And sometimes they ask, well, what should I do here? Well, what's your opinion? 00:45:36.2000000 Now we're getting into giving the pro se legal advice. And so same with someone unrepresented. Maybe it's a third party, maybe it's a witness and they start asking illegal questions. We can't answer those legal questions. If you can't do it in person, you can't do it online. 00:45:52.7000000 Same thing. View only publicly available content. Don't get into the befriending or into that private access content. Just stay away from that. Just look for what is public and that is going to protect yourself when it comes to being online. 00:46:09.3400000 Don't try any trickery, deception, false pretenses. Don't try to lie, don't try to make fake accounts or fake instas or fake things. I know if you have teenage, younger children or college age children or even young adults or no friends or maybe you have it yourself. A lot of people have a fake account, the one account they don't tell their parents about and then they have their real account or that they only post clean content that their parent sees. We can't be fake account makers. 00:46:38.0300000 We can't do what our potential children, grandchildren or, you know, significant others, friends and family are doing with all these other fake instas or fake accounts or fake facebooks or having names and aliases. We have to be honest. We have to set forth what we're doing online and not seem disinterested in not creating fake stuff. Otherwise we can be disciplined for personal and professional conduct. The world rules apply to us 247 personally and professionally. 00:47:10 So keep that in mind when you want that fake insta account to seem cool to your kids or grandkids or, you know, significant others, friends and family. We need to stay on the side of honesty and on the side of nothing deceptive. So this is just kind of a little example here to kind of play that out. A prosecutor created a fake Facebook profile to communicate with defense witnesses intended to discredit alibi testimony in a murder case with the information they got from this fake Facebook account befriending these defense witnesses. Case was withdrawn by the prosecutor, prosecutor was fired and a one year suspension for creating that fake account to try to talk to defense witnesses when it was improper conduct. 00:47:53.9200000 So again, stay away from those fake accounts, stay away from anything like that. Just be upfront and honest. Always the way to go when it comes to our conduct and less chance of violation. Here we have another prosecutor in Pennsylvania create a fake Profile called Britney Bella to befriend witnesses and defendants encourage staff to also use the fake profile to help her gain information. So it was kind of like a office fake profile for the prosecutor's office. 00:48:23.9700000 The prosecutor was lost the real estate reelection, significant professional fallout when this came to light, as well as disciplinary actions taken against the prosecutor. Fake accounts are a no. And you would think this is common sense, but I actually had probably about five or six calls from various lawyers in the community saying hey, I want to create, you know, a fake account because I need to talk with this witness or find out information or I don't have a Facebook account but I don't want to put in my name. Can I do a fake One answer is no. If there's any fake or dishonesty or anything that can perceive that way, the answer is no. 00:49:01.6900000 We need to follow truthfulness, honesty and not seem disinterested when we truly are interested because we are the lawyer representing one of the parties. This was the one I've already told you about the Facebook with a lot of grief. Just kind of a slide on that too when it comes to it. Another thing I did want to talk about here is we're winding down on our hour. We have about 11 minutes left. 00:49:25.4800000 Pitfalls of personal post Now a lot of times we like to post things personally, which means you know, your personal contact, maybe you're a big LinkedIn poster. There's tons of them. There's tons of people blog, legal blogs, lawyers who post a lot of content on LinkedIn that I do follow and I follow them, meaning I'm friends with them, I read their content. Sometimes I think it's educational, sometimes I think and I wouldn't oppose to that but again it's okay. We just have to remember that we can't bring in client confidential information. 00:49:58.1000000 So we want to respect our clients confidentiality. So we don't want to be creating a platform where we're posting stuff about clients. If you're going to be that legal blog creator or that Facebook poster, that LinkedIn poster, do stuff generic or you know, new laws, new regulations. Don't bring in the client confidential information in the cases you're working on unless you get client consent confirmed in writing. Also to make sure that you respect your law firm's brand, make sure that you respect, you know, I put in here the Taft brand because task my law firm. 00:50:34.6300000 But if you are going to be posting content then make sure that it's in line with the professional reputation and perception that you want to put out there for yourselves. A lot of times firms have their own social media policies, so you would need to check your specific firm on any social media policy. But not just that. What do you want and how do you want to be perceived as a lawyer in your community and in the online networking world? If you're okay with that in the content you're putting out, then perfectly fine. 00:51:04.9600000 If you're not okay with that, then maybe you need to change up your content a little bit, respecting your law firm's brand, respecting, you know, your personal brand and how those two coincide, and then taking into consideration any policies. There's nothing in the rules of professional conduct says we can't post online. We just can't violate the rules or post client confidential information. But you can be a thought leader. You can do thought pieces, you can do legal blogs. 00:51:30.8000000 Just watch out for those violations that come through the ethical rules. Best practices in that avoid discussing client matters or pending cases. Review posts or professionalism before publishing use of privacy settings, but assume posts can become public, separate personal and professional accounts when possible. It's hard. It's hard to do that. 00:51:52.2400000 Usually anything online is going to tend towards both because you're going to post where you work or what you do, and then it's going to go a little bit professional. But try to keep. If you want, like Facebook to be more personal, don't post anything about work or even your job title. You want LinkedIn to be professional. That's where you post your professional content. 00:52:08.8200000 Maybe keep Facebook for kids, grandkids, friends, family, however you want to do it. But when you start intermingling them, then everything's considered that professional post. And it could even be an advertisement, a lawyer advertisement. We haven't even talked about that. Lawyer advertising applies to your social media postings and what you do on social media as well. 00:52:28.8200000 So unless you want to comply with all the advertising rules, let's not be advertising the law firm online. Because what you do in person is the same. You can't do it. Excuse me? If you can't do it in person, you can't do it online. 00:52:40.8800000 So if you think you can get around advertising rules online, think again. So again, something to really consider another area too. Negative comments. I don't know if you have Google reviews or Yelp reviews or Avvo reviews online there for you. And maybe some of them you like and some of you dislike. 00:53:00.2400000 And a lot of lawyers, when they see one that they feel is a liar, they don't like, they want to fight back, they want to respond but responding, you cannot reveal client confidential information. So you've got to watch out for Rule 1.6. It's not an exception under Rule 1.6b, establishing a defense or that that's been already debunked. It's already been down. ABA formal opinions 496 says no. 00:53:24.0400000 If we get negative opinions online about us from clients, even if they're false, we cannot respond with our side of the story. We have to stop and think about can we respond? And if so, we cannot violate Rule 1.6. So we want to stay away from responding with our side of the story. Stay away from setting that record straight and fight every urge you have to give over client confidential information, including the name of the client or things that are public record. 00:53:52.1300000 Because remember, public record is no exception to Rule 1.6. How we can respond to negative comments online is by saying one of the three phrases. Respond that due to your ethical obligations, you're prevented from providing a detailed response. You can state that you have reviewed the claim or comment and would be happy to discuss via telephone and provide your contact information for the poster to reach out to you don't obviously confirm who the poster is or state their name because client's name is part of confidentiality. And then you could respond to if you know the name of the poster, obviously don't state their name or, you know, if their name is on there, you can tell who it is. 00:54:31.8600000 You can state that you were reviewing it and you'll reach out to them shortly. Again, don't state their name and just say you're going to reach out to them if you have or know their contact information already. But you have to keep it very neutral. We cannot respond with our side of the story. We have to fight every urge to, you know, tell our side of the story and fight back. 00:54:50.6800000 And so we want to make sure that we do this in an appropriate manner. Some other options to request the search engine, website, platform remove the post or counterbalance of positive negative reviews. If you do request the platform remove the post by saying it's inaccurate, they're going to say, well, why is it inaccurate? How do you know this? We can't give the platform confidential information either. 00:55:13.4000000 So sometimes that's not always the best route and not the most effective. You can have positive reviews, obviously push it down, but just know the more attention you give a post, the more it comes up on Google Search and the more it's going to be top of that search page. So if you just leave it alone, it's going to get pushed down. So then when someone searches your name, it's not going to be the top thing Google gives them. It may be on page three or four. 00:55:34.5600000 And we all know not everyone or minority or the majority of us don't scroll to pages 3 and 4. We look at the first search page of Google. If you don't like what we see, we enter another query. So again, leaving it alone can help bury it too. On the Internet, that's one way how the algorithms work that can work in your favor. 00:55:54.7800000 Just a couple of attorney examples here to close out our session. This is the first one. This was an attorney. It was actually a criminal defense attorney. She had a really bad day in court and got punched by one of her criminal defense clients. 00:56:07.9000000 She had a little PTSD from that event, started to see the therapist, created a blog as part of a journal to get some of her emotions out. However, the blog was public and she talked about her clients in it. Now, to her defense, she did not give the clients names, but she did give their department of Corrections numbers which then allowed people to go find the client and all the details. And she spilled details like her client showed up high in court or was high on cocaine or he did XYZ or he lied to the judge and then gave the DOC number. That's revealing client confidences. 00:56:43.0300000 She was suspended for 60 days for that reciprocal suspension in another jurisdiction in which she was licensed in Wisconsin. And she's also the proud winner of being part of ABA formal opinion 480 of what not to do on social media regarding client confidences. So if you want to live in infamy, do something really dumb and get yourself part of a formal public ethics opinion of what not to to do. We also have another example of this is attorney Sean Conway. He decided he had a bad experience with a local judge. 00:57:14.6000000 The judge was saying either go to trial in two weeks or give up your right to speedy trial. He was a criminal defense attorney. Well, he didn't like this. He thought it was unconstitutional and against the law for the judge to do this. But instead of turning the judge in through the proper disciplinary channels, he went on to a public blog post and posted things about her, calling her an evil, unfair witch. 00:57:35.3600000 There's nothing honorable about her very whole paragraph degrading her in the judiciary system. Turned into the disciplinary commission for his public comments online. He only got a public reprimand in Florida and a twelve hundred dollar fine. And that is because there was some meat and some substance to his allegations against the judge. And they were accurate, but his choice of how to go about them was the wrong thing to do and the wrong platform to air his grievances. 00:58:04.8900000 So again, we have to look at platform and content with that. We have about a minute and a half left, so I do want to make sure you verbally get your CLE code which has already been posted in the chat feature. I will retype it to bring it down to the bottom as well so you don't have to scroll up to see it. But that code is B as in Boy, R as in Rainbow, Y as in Yellow, L as in lion and the number 3B as in Boy, R as in Rainbow, Y as in Yellow, L as in lion and the number three that again is posted in the chat box. It is down, so it brings it down to the bottom. 00:58:47.8400000 If you scroll up just above it, you will also see the instructions of what to do with that code once the CLE is over today. Once it is over, you will need to sign into your individual LexFit account via the web browser to enter the code. Go to the home, then to my CLE courses and you will see a place to enter the code and submit it. Enter the code and once it's successfully submitted, you'll be taken to the course review page. Once this is completed, the certificate will be emailed to you automatically and LexVid will start the process of reporting your attendance to your respective jurisdictions. 00:59:26.0200000 With that, I hope you've enjoyed the seminar here today. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to reach out to Lex Fit or myself, and I hope to see you again at future seminars. Thank you.