[Course Name] 00:00:02.4000000 Hello everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. If you have any other questions throughout today's seminar on any of the topics that we are discussing or anything else regarding ethics compliance, diversity, equity, inclusion, or anything you just want to ask, please make sure you get those questions into the chat feature so that I can see them and answer them if I don't see them when you submit it. I will try to get through those questions at the end of today's seminar, but I do like to try to answer them simultaneously with the presentation because then that usually makes them more relevant regarding the topics we're talking about and the things we're discussing at that time. And that kind of concludes our housekeeping items here today. I did want to also introduce myself. 00:00:51.0100000 If you've never taken a seminar with me, my name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant General Counsel of Taft and Tinnius and Hollister law firm. I'm located in the Indianapolis, Indiana location. So here in the Midwest, in my role as assistant General counsel, I do anything regarding internal ethics compliance, reviewing client outside counsel guidelines, assisting with conflicts of interest, and basically anything that touches the rules of professional conduct. This can include issues regarding diversity, equity and inclusion, especially when clients demand that we have diversity, equity and inclusion, also known as DEI in our law firms and law practice. 00:01:36.4900000 Because a lot of clients want their lawyers to be diverse. They want to hire a diverse law firm and so they will have their own terms and conditions where that is imposed upon us and they want us to report our DEI statistics to them. So we're going to talk about a little bit about that here today. And just what is DEI or Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and what does it look like in the business world, especially in our legal context? So again, if you have any questions throughout today, please do not hesitate to put them in the chat box. 00:02:16.6700000 It makes the day more interesting. It makes the hour go by faster. And then you get also your question answered as well. So the first thing we're going to talk about is just understanding what data DEI is. And it can mean different things to certain people, but it really is recognizing the values of diverse voices and having inclusion and not necessarily equality among all the employees, but equity. 00:02:47.4100000 So having key factors for success for each person may be based on their needs and where they're at. So it is really something to look at and embrace, especially within your company and, and how you are going to make this work across the board. And we'll see in a coming slide too. It's not equality because equality means that we're all equal. And we're not all equal. 00:03:13.3100000 And as hard as that maybe is to hear or to think about it, or if that statement enrages you, that is fine. We're all entitled to their own opinions on what equality is. But if you think about equality, we're. That means we're all equal. We get all equal shares. 00:03:30.8800000 We have all equal contributions. We're equal across the board. But human beings by nature are not equal. We are all different. We each have different gifts, different talents, different things we're good at different knowledge. 00:03:48.8000000 And we're not equal in those gifts and talents. I cannot go out and race in a swimming race like, you know, or Olympic swimmers or go run a marathon. I do not have those talents. So I am not equal to someone who has those skills. So we're not equal as human beings. 00:04:10.4300000 Some of us are not equal in our intelligence levels and our IQs and how we process information, how we read, how fast we read those different things. Human beings by nature are not equal amongst all of us. But that doesn't mean we can't have equity where we can't look at each of our, you know, unique factors. And when we put all our unique factors and personalities and talents together, you have a collective that can move mountains. And that is really what companies and clients are wanting us to do, is to have all these different perspectives because we are not all equal, but they want all of our perspectives to come in and work on their cases and have the unique perspective in the firm. 00:05:04.4900000 So it's not just a one trained mindset. Because if you think about it, and I know there are law firms out there that do this, sometimes they're referred to as, oh, that's the such and such firm, or though that's this religion firm, they're all go to this same church or temple or whatever it is. Oh, they all went to the same college. Oh, they're all, you know, women, or they're all men, or they're all this. And so firms can get classified and clients are wanting diverse. 00:05:34.1900000 They want men, women, other genders, different religions, different cultures, all of them coming in to work on their cases because of the unique abilities and talents of that diverse perspective. But we get so sometimes pigeonholed in who we hire and how we do our firms that we can't get outside of that. And that's not necessarily your fault, because it's programmed in our brains. And I don't necessarily have slides on this, but when I teach business ethics or ethics classes at different universities here in Indianapolis, one of the Areas we teach is that program into our brain. The very back of it is a part of the brain that is kind of our fight or flight. 00:06:22 But with that fight or flight, what it does is when we see something that's different from us, when we see something that's not similar to us, say like a lion or like something scary, it's like, ooh, that's not like me. That's not like, you know, human or, you know, my taste. That's not like me. We tend to push it away, and it's our brain pushing it away, saying, dissimilar, dissimilar, scary, scary. Push it away, push it away. 00:06:49.5600000 And then when we see people or things like us, see our values, see the things that we, you know, can connect with our brain sets off neurons, and those neurons light up our brain and make us happy and feel good. And so we start to collect the people and things around us that set off those neurons that are most similar to us. And this is programmed in our brain. It is part of our brain. It's in the very lower back corner. 00:07:21.0500000 And so we have to think about those things and work against that. When we are thinking about diversity, equity, inclusion, especially the diversity piece, and recruiting diverse candidates, recruiting diverse staff to help make up a diverse law firm, and it may be uncomfortable at first because your brain's telling you it's uncomfortable, and it may not be what you want. Want to hire that buddy from the same college or the same fraternity or sorority or from the same, you know, church. I get it. We all want that familiar, cozy, warm feeling because we know what we're getting. 00:07:57.7100000 They're like us, they think like us. But clients are wanting a team of lawyers or a law firm where the lawyers aren't all the same in those respects. They are wanting that diversity within their legal team. And that's what we need to start thinking about, too, that just how does this diversity, equity, inclusion impact our business? And just this changing of the workforce? 00:08:27.0400000 And so we've got to think about how to retain, motivate, and develop some of the brightest diverse talent and get out of that mindset that we all have to be from the same college, the same church, the same temple, the same, you know, organizations, live in the same neighborhoods. All those things, those are what are going to hold our firm back and hold us back as lawyers, especially as we progress forward. Diversity, too. And having those diverse perspectives and diverse thinking can improve business outcomes, because maybe one person's really good at this and then another person with a different background is great. At something else. 00:09:10.0700000 And when you put them together, you have a force that can't be reckoned with. But if you wouldn't have stepped outside your comfort zone and maybe hired that one person, or stepped outside that comfort zone and hired, you know, someone who you mainly not have hired normally, then maybe you wouldn't have that dynamic force. So we really have to think about what does each person bring to the table, because we're not all equal. And we should each be given an equitable chance at the table, an equitable chance to prove our talents. And if our specific talents are going to be beneficial and make up a whole within the company, then that is something that we should consider when we're hiring people, investing in people, and really taking pride in that work and organization and ownership, especially if you're a leader of your firm, of what is going to be needed. 00:10:06.4600000 Diversity can be strategically also aligned with your business goals. It does sometimes require investments. Maybe it's not going to be the cheapest route to take. Maybe you're going to have to hire different managers or promote different people or different things. But embracing these challenges and bringing everyone together is going to work tenfold for your clients and your business. 00:10:33.3400000 I will say one of the things that I do at my firm is I have the pleasure, if you want to take that sarcastically, of reading all the outside counsel guidelines that come into the firm from our clients. If you don't know what outside counsel guidelines are, as I referenced them earlier, they are terms and conditions that the clients want us, the lawyers and law firm, to comply with. So it's kind of like the client's engagement letter to the law firm. And normally probably 85% of those terms and conditions have a diversity, equity and inclusion provision in them. And a lot of times they say that the client, their business promotes, dei, wants their lawyers to have DEI or promote it to. 00:11:21.7390000 They want to have us report our diversity statistics to them on a quarterly or annual basis. They want to know if we're ranked or we hold any different things within the DEIC space. They want to know those things. Some of the provisions even go as far as saying that they want at least one female or one Hispanic or one African American on the team or more than that, or that there can only be one of a certain gender on the team. Clients want you to have diversity in your workforce, to have those different perspectives and to have that collaboration and backgrounds, because it's going to better serve them and it's going to better serve you in getting clients in the door and showing Them, hey, we value this as much as you do too. 00:12:11.6000000 We want inclusion of everyone. We want to show you we have a representation and value each person's individuality. They may not all be equal, but they each have that gift. And we are promoting that gift that they each have. We are using it to the advantage of our firm and to them, the client. 00:12:31.6000000 Now there can be classifications of diversity, meaning diversity internally within the company, externally, like outward, like what do you promote different things like that. And then also too if you hire outside contractors or experts or different things, trying to find diversity if possible within those external hires and external outward things as well. There's also organizational diversity. This can be across the entire organization. That internal can be internally, maybe just within a department too. 00:13:07.1100000 If we go back up to that number one. And then worldview diversity too. Again, that can go out to if you are a big firm or a big company, you know how, how do you help or what charities or what, you know, things are you involved in? It can also be as simple as to do you promote and let people off on diversity holiday such as Juneteenth or different things like that. Like how does it catapult into your business? 00:13:36.0900000 And so it's not just necessarily hiring talent of all different backgrounds, ethnicities and all that stuff. It can also be too where do you invest, where do you have programs? Do you promote this? Are you part of, you know, maybe the pride organizations or different donations, different places. So you can also show different things like that on how do you value another thing too with internal diversity can also come through your policies with your firm. 00:14:08.4500000 Do you promote a maternal leave policy when a mother has a child, so a maternity leave, do you call it parental leave? Do you classify people by gender within the firm or do you use more general neutral terms? I know I've read some firms policies internally within the firm and instead of just the he she designation, they do he she they which shows that they really do promote diversity or that inclusion of everyone within the firm and company. So there's little things like that you can do internally too. Not just the outward external stuff is going to be very important. 00:14:50.7700000 Especially because obviously employees, if they leave or if they stay, if that is one of the sticking points where they didn't feel included or they felt like the outcast or not understood for their specific gift and talent, they're going to probably post a review about you and that's not one you want to be out there. Especially when clients are. You're trying to attract clients to the firm and then to, you know, fighting with the client, wanting you to have diversity, equity, inclusion within your company as well. So things to think about on that. And I will say too, this is kind of just a side note, I do teach at the law school here locally as well as at our Kelly, excuse me, at some local business schools. 00:15:36.1900000 I haven't done those for about a year, though, just the law school. And one of the things when I was teaching dei, especially at the lower collegiate level, is I always advise students when they are interviewing for jobs. I know a lot of them just take jobs for the money. But even young lawyers, when they're going out there and picking what firm they're going to do that summer clerkship with and picking that first firm out of law school, again, I know they're going for the money, whatever they can get. They're low on the totem pole. 00:16:04.5200000 They understand that. But I told them as they get older, as they get more experience and, you know, maybe our lateral hire, or maybe they have the confidence to do it right off the bat during that interview process, if DEI is important to them, if it is something they are looking for in a place of employment to ask about it, just like our clients ask us before they hire us. And I always caution them, watch for the lip service. A lot of firms have programs where they promote programs, have them on their website, say they belong to all these charitable organizations and all these things for dei, when they really don't. Maybe there is a subcommittee, but they haven't met for years because no one's really into it. 00:16:51.6900000 And they give money every so often, but it's really not a priority. But there's a webpage for it out there on their website. And so I always caution students, especially law students or business students, if this is an important thing for you, the dei, diversity, equity and inclusion, then you need to ask about it. And it's not just necessarily in the interview because the interviewers are going to say whatever it is to get you in the door, they want you sometimes. But people who are working there, people who are off the record, and so looking at those different things too, can help understand if the company does have a good diversity, equity and inclusion policy or just promotion, maybe there's not a formal policy. 00:17:38.0400000 Now, how does that parlay into you working for a law firm? Make sure if you have these programs or these different things or you promote it, that you actually promote it and that there's things behind it, whether it's that internal diversity, having maybe a maternal paternal leave policy or parental leave policy if it's organizational, like different things that your organization does, if it's external by who you hire, third parties, if it's a worldwide contribution or something, make sure there is meat and teeth behind it. Because these younger generations are really. This is really important to them that having that equity inclusion. And they want to work with a diverse team. 00:18:23.7900000 They want to get those broader perspectives and those broader insights and, you know, have everyone bring their specific talents to the table and not be with a group of people where each of your talents is the same thing. Like, we want the diversity in our teams, especially legal teams, because sometimes maybe someone's upbringing is the key to the case or they know a perspective of the client that no one else would know because of the same culture. So we do want those perspectives. Some components too, of inclusion can include just making sure everyone, no matter their background, no matter where they're from or, you know, what their talent is, has access to all the necessary resources they need to flourish. And again, that may look different for different people. 00:19:13.5300000 It's not saying be discriminatory. It's not saying, you know, well, this is the one size fits all. We don't want a one size fits all. We want an equity approach where, okay, maybe this person needs a little more here and this person needs a lot of less here, but needs a little more here. Like, you have to look at the individual and make sure they have access to the resources that are going to help and promote the most and the diversity within the team, also to making sure everyone feels valued and accepted and promoting the different things. 00:19:48.5600000 There are people with many different religious backgrounds, different cultural backgrounds, and just making them feel that they're not the outcast. Like if someone takes off for a religious holiday, that's not the mainstream norm. As long as it's a valid believed one, then be okay with it. Have a policy to where they feel they don't have to hide, you know, that side of them. They don't have to hide the religion or their culture or their background or what they do. 00:20:19.3600000 And they just feel valued and accepted for their skills and talents and not feel like they have to change themselves to this certain image that the law firm's trying to put out. Is a great. Is a great way to build inclusion within a law firm too. Also having a collaborative environment. I know it was actually recently one of my friends was interviewing with a company, and the company just kind of had a reputation of being more of an older white male collective in the company. 00:20:54.0600000 And she was not that she was a diverse candidate in many respects regarding her background, her culture, ethnicity, all of those things. And I said, you know, you should interview, you should do it. But just know they have this reputation that this is the mold that they're trying to fill. And she didn't get the job. And there was about probably she said about six or seven candidates which she learned out later who they were just through round of the mill and she was the only diverse candidate in the bunch. 00:21:27.3200000 The rest of the best fit the mold of what I warned was kind of the mold of this company over time. And when we saw who actually got the job, it fit the mold and the 100% across the board. And it wasn't any surprise, it was kind of just what you expected. But that company necessarily didn't value diverse because if you looked at all of them, they all came from maybe the same college, the same church, the same, you know, fraternity, sorority mold. And there wasn't a lot of females in it either. 00:22:03.8400000 And it was just kind of not eye opening but not shocking. And it should start to shock us when we don't see diversity because kind of the old school ways of like that company was doing is shouldn't be the mainstream norm anymore. Someone should not be shied away from applying saying, oh, I'm not going to get it because I'm not a, you know, this, this type of mold or fit. We should be open in our firms and open in different companies to making sure we have the inclusion of everyone and that everyone, if they're applying, if their employee feels valued and heard and that creates that collaborative environment, even if it's not your opinion or the way you would have done it or you know, how you were, you know, taught to do it doesn't mean it's, it's wrong. Being open to different ideas, being collaborative and not saying this is a one person show or a one way show is going to help too. 00:23:00.2000000 That's why they call us teams of lawyers. A team is everyone has a different set of skills. When we combined all those skills, we can have a winning season. And so it's the same thing with a team of lawyers. Each lawyer is good at something. 00:23:17.4100000 Maybe one's brief writing, maybe one's oral arguments, maybe one is putting on a trial, maybe one is just client relationships, who knows? But when you put all those people together, it's a team, a collaboration and it's a winning season. And so that's what we need to think about too when we're hiring people and thinking about diverse backgrounds is that collaborative environment that winning season, making them feel like they have that sense of belonging and that everyone deserves a season at the table. There's no worse feeling than rolling up to a table, and I'm using this figuratively, or having a seat at the table, or you think you have a seat at the table but then you actually don't because it's not a collaborative environment. You're not valued and accepted for who you are. 00:24:05.9500000 You are just a number. You are just to feel, fill, fill, excuse me, fill a diversity seat to satisfy client obligations. There is no worse feeling than that. So if we are going to have diversity, equity and inclusion, if we are going to have, you know, comply with our clients terms and conditions where they want us to have those diverse teams, then we need to make the diverse teams feel valued, accepted and knowing. No matter what your background or what your skill set is, you have a seat at the table and your voice is going to be heard in that collaborative environment. 00:24:43.4800000 It's not a one person show. We have a collaboration. Now I understand you have to have a leader to make a final decision, but at the same time it should be a collaboration of many different views and ideas coming into how, how best to proceed and have that winning season. Having that sense of belonging can also help with employee retention. You're going to have employees stay longer, which means not as high of turnover, which is great because we all know when you hire someone new, they're not profitable right away. 00:25:15.0300000 And so having that sense of, you know, employees feeling value, heard that the company cares about them as a person and they're not just a number to check a box for a client is going to be very important in any plan for dei. And as I was talking about earlier and as on the screen in front of you here, equality is kind of that one size fits all system. And that's not what DEI is, it's equity. Equity means that we don't all have the same needs, we don't all have the same perspectives, but we're all treated fairly for us and where we're at. And so it's not a one size fits all. 00:25:55.5900000 Well, Jane did it this way, you need to do it this way. That's not the case. And it really does take effort and time because you have to get down and look at the individual, the individual lawyer, the individual employee and what do they need and to meet them with those needs and find out what best fits them. Again, it's not that one size fits all, but it can have great benefits if you take the time to do These things within your company, within your law firm, some of those benefits are posted here on the screen in front of you. It can have improved understanding of those you work with and those around you. 00:26:37.8800000 It creates an environment that allows everyone to reach their full potential. I mean, these things should not be any surprise to you. Provides multiple perspectives for problem solving. And sometimes, again, one person's way may be better. I can't tell you how many times I've been in meetings and someone say, well, this is how we've always done it. 00:26:57.3900000 This is how we've always done it. It doesn't mean it's the best way. Getting out of that. This is how we always do it. Mindset is going to help you so much. 00:27:09.9100000 And sometimes maybe the way you've always done it is the best, but sometimes it's not. And having that open mind and that collaborative perspective to listen to the new voices coming in, to listen to the different diverse backgrounds and people can probably help you problem solve even better than you did before. Getting you those better outcomes. Increase employee productivity because if employees feel valued, if they feel included and if they feel heard, they're going to be more productive and loyal to you because they're going to be happier. They're going to enjoy coming to work, they're going to enjoy working for the firm. 00:27:47.6100000 They're going to enjoy all those things. And we want to promote that and encourage it. It's also going to help with those retention rates, as I was saying earlier, not as high of turnover and really just keeping a solid workforce, which is what every company wants, because turnover, as I said, is very expensive. It's also going to boost employee morale because they're going to feel like they're valued. I can say that most unhappy employees are the ones that feel like they're not valued, not heard, and that they're just a number or just someone's, you know, means to an end. 00:28:25.3100000 They want. Employees want to use their creativity, they want to use their minds to help, especially lawyers. Now, I will say there's those outliers who just aren't going to be invested in any job they have. But most employees, if they feel valued, heard, and are contributing in a collaborative way, it is going to boost the morale among them. It's also going to improve those customer relations, meaning customers, our clients. 00:28:53.2900000 Because again, clients are wanting diversity. They are wanting their law firms to promote the ideals of DEI within the company. And don't just check a box, don't just have a webpage out there that says you promote diversity, equity Inclusion, but then not show it in your policies, not show it in your contributions and what you know, organizations and what you know, those things that you push out to the community, you have to show it, show it to your employees, show it externally, show it regionally, locally, you know, nationally, whatever works. But we have to show it to get those improved customer relations and not just check a box when it comes to will also probably reduce your complaints and internal grievances from your employees because you may not have as many claims or potential employment claims against the firm or company. Because if you promote it all, promote that equity, meet people where they're at, do all those things, then they still complain. 00:29:56.5700000 There's no grounds to complain. You've given them every single advantage, every single thing to make them successful, making them feel included, collaborative environment. And so complaints and grievances overall will go down and, and if they do come about, it's a harder, stronger defense to it. So again can help with there too. And just the last one on the screen, that last box down there. 00:30:20.6800000 DEI can just be the right thing to do sometimes. Treating people with equity, not just equality or thinking of equality as the one size fits all, but equity, promoting the talents to make a diverse team to help propel the client's case and have that winning season, have the winning dream team, have that winning team where everyone knows their role and is okay with saying, oh, that's a great project. You know who's great at that? That's their talent and that's so and so's talent. And making sure you funnel and really feed the talents on your team is going to really help with the DEI overall in your firm and company. 00:31:03.3800000 So the role of this obviously in law firms and incorporations, as we've been saying throughout the seminar today, and we're going to continue to say as we continue this seminar, is just to increase that fairness, creativity, innovation, get those new perspectives, get those new mindsets and different things coming in and free flowing like just having a different way of thinking about it. Because I can say the most, sometimes beautiful thing is being in a meeting and the people aren't just all yes, yes, men, women, or whoever it is in the meeting. It is more of a, well, why don't we try it this way? Well, this is how I used to do it at my firm or this is how I used to do it here from my background and culture. This is how the client's going to want it because they're like me when maybe someone else wouldn't have had that same insight Having that diverse team, having those diverse insights can really help get the creativity juices flowing, maybe get some creative settlements or creative perspectives going. 00:32:04.5800000 And it would just be ideal for you, your company, your attorneys as well as your clients are going to absolutely love it. And so just think about how that can really promote your firm, that bottom dollar. And just going through. Now, the next thing we're going to talk about here is just maybe a little historical context, but also getting into how do we get the diversity within the firms? Do we have affirmative action programs? 00:32:33.4700000 And we know the new administration has had some strong words on affirmative action programs. And if we should use them, if we shouldn't use them, they really don't like them, as we know the Trump administration. And so just. But basically, we're not going to argue the politics. I'm not going to argue which is better. 00:32:51.4300000 Trump, Biden, whatever, I don't care. We are just going to talk about what affirmative action is and then two, you make the decision for your company and firm how you want to move forward. I do know there's all the political noise in the background right now, especially with big law firms. But again, this CLE is only just to educate you on what these things are. And then you can take the political noise as you see fit. 00:33:18.7900000 But affirmative action is nothing new to the country. And we all know that it was as early as, if not earlier than 1961, that JFK signed an executive order establishing that affirmative action was going to be required by government contractors. Now, affirmative action is allowing applicants who are of a certain race, creed, color, national origin, or have a certain characteristic to kind of get, if you want to call it a boost or an extra point towards actually getting hired within the company. So it's not a you will fit this mold, so you get hired over everyone else, even though you're less qualified. That was not the intent of it. 00:34:01.6000000 The intent was to give underrepresented individuals and groups a boost to get into the positions. They still had to have the qualifications. They still had to meet all the other requirements. It was just like an extra point if you were tallying points towards maybe getting in the door or getting the interview or getting the job. And so that was what it was meant for, to kind of bring more inclusion into the workforce. 00:34:30.7200000 And it was meant to be a good thing. But obviously it has gone back and forth, back and forth in political realms for years on. Is it legal? Is it not? Is it moral? 00:34:42.2800000 Is it not? Like, what is it? And we have tons of legislation that can kind of revolve around affirmative action too, such as Title 6, Title 7, Title 9. They all are kind of getting at the, the concept that we cannot discriminate based on certain race, color, national origin and different protected classes, which really goes into what affirmative action kind of stands for, is like you can't not hire someone because of these things. That's discrimination. 00:35:13.4000000 But affirmative action is saying, okay, they do have these characteristics or are part of this underrepresented group. And if the government or a private company has a policy or follows affirmative action, then maybe that candidate gets a boost in the application process or that extra point. But it can't be the deciding factor. It can't be too much of a boost. There's a leveling out point is how it was originally envisioned. 00:35:38.5800000 And so also too here on the screen, 14th amendment kind of goes towards that maybe legality of affirmative action program saying, you know, we're all equal, you know, bridging that we can't be deprived of liberty. So all these things regarding, and we'll even go back the discrimination. And this kind of tells us that affirmative action, while it may not be favored, it probably is legal to do so long as it's done the right way with certain parameters. And one of the biggest things a lot of companies, corporations and law firms and people forget is affirmative action programs were never meant to be permanent when they first were coming about and really hitting the government and the private companies full force. They were supposed to be put in place for a specified period of time and only until diversity of the workforce was achieved and then the affirmative action programs were to be dismantled or go away from that particular company or that particular agency. 00:36:42.0300000 Now the going away part is what really hasn't occurred. And the question is, when is diversity achieved? Is there a benchmark? Is there a goal mark? And there's really no fine line of when that achievement has been successful. 00:36:57.8800000 So that was kind of an issue with it too is that it came about, but it wasn't necessarily as well defined as a lot of, you know, type A and business people and that and lawyers wanted it to be. But what is it necessarily? I'm sure we're all familiar, but just in case you're not, again, as I was saying earlier, is the program's designed to achieve more of a representative distribution of people within a business or educational setting by giving preference to women, people of color or historic discriminated against groups. And its goals were to remedy past discrimination and promote diversity, inclusion into the workforce or diversity. And then the companies have to do the inclusion and equity part of the DEI framework. 00:37:44.7400000 Now, the other question that always hits, and this is one that I always taught students or we discuss with students in business ethics classes, is it moral? And there's a case that it is moral. And those counter arguments that affirmative action is not moral. And again, I don't care which side you're on, I'm not here to pick a side. I'm just here to present you with, you know, the two different sides of the coin when it comes to affirmative action and dei. 00:38:11.9900000 So affirmative action is the case for being moral, is it's compensation for centuries of harm caused by people who were previously discriminated against. And some of you who do not like affirmative action may say, well, it's not us that did the discriminating, or it's not, you know, us here that are now having to live with it. And that's exactly the counter argument you just named it, if that came to your head. So one side's going to say that, one side's going to say the other thing and kind of like thinking about that compensatory justice, you know, how do we compensate them for past discrimination when us here today are not necessarily ones that previously discriminated against them, but now it feels like we're being punished for it in a way. And there's no good answer to that because what's the alternative? 00:39:00.9200000 How do we figure it out? How do we get a more diverse group? Or how do we ensure diversity in our workforces when human nature and our brain, remember the brain at the beginning of the seminar has pushed against it, has told us, no, this is scary, this is not like us. And so again, how do we do it? But there is a moral case for it by saying, you know, that remedying past wrongs, if you study utilitarianism, which I know most of us may, may not, but utilitarianism is the greatest, for the greatest amount of good. 00:39:34.8900000 So the more happy people at the end is what we want to do. We're not going to make everyone happy, but we don't care about everyone maybe happy, we just care about the good. Greatest number of people being happy in utilitarianism. So with this, affirmative action does promote public welfare, welfare, which could decrease poverty, which makes more people happy. But again, the counter argument is, can't we address poverty in a more race and gender neutral way? 00:40:03.6300000 Or another argument for the morality and inclusion of affirmative action, does it lead to a lesson? Race conscious society. But do, does the benefits outweigh the social costs and there's back and forth and back and forth and our court system and our government is still going back and forth. If you look at the cases from Bakke to the University of Michigan to all the ones even down in Texas, University of Texas I think had one too where they, even the law schools were challenged for their affirmative action programs and letting applicants into the school. And even in University of Michigan they decided one way at the lower, like undergraduate level. 00:40:48.2900000 And then the law schools came up and they decided another way. And then the Texas court followed what they did. And so it just goes back and forth and back and forth. And so there is really no true answer on is it moral or is it legal. But there are arguments both sides and legislation that could be used to support it. 00:41:11.5900000 Another one too to look at too, the justice argument for it. Justice assumes there is a lack of equality of opportunity or lack of equality of opportunity for people of certain races and groups. And so we kind of use affirmative action to create more equality. But equality is a one size fits all. We need to use it to promote equity, to have that diverse in there. 00:41:36.8000000 And of course the counter argument is, isn't this reverse discrimination? Counter argument to that is discrimination means you have a bad motive. When this is not a bad motive, it's trying just to promote that. So again, you can go back and forth till you're blue in the face all day, no matter what side you're on. But the question is, how do we get DEI into the workforce and what do our employees, what we know, what some of our clients think, it's in their terms and conditions. 00:42:06.3100000 But is it good and is it bad? And this is just a quote from one of the textbooks that I teach from or I've taught from in the past. And this was a quote from a 45 year old electrical worker in a Westinghouse plant. So just a blue collar, you know. And he was just saying that he doesn't care what race, color or anything. 00:42:25.0300000 It's just the quotas. And that's what a lot of people get at with affirmative action. And it is supposed to be no quotas, meaning don't set out to have a DEI policy to get that diversity into your company by saying we're going to hire 20% of this race and 10% of this race. That's where a lot of companies go wrong, is they have this mindset of we have to have five of this, we have to have five of that. Now they're not people, they're numbers to you. 00:42:53.2100000 They're checking that box, diversity, equity and inclusion is to get in the diverse workforce, to have the collaboration, the inclusion part of it, and then equity to meet them where they're at so they have the things to succeed, and that it is not a one size fits all. And so we have to look at those different things. And quotas would not fit that understanding of it. Another argument, oops, skipped too far. Affirmative action implies that people of color and women need extra help, which was kind of the quote on the last screen. 00:43:28.0900000 And that's not the case either. And so the counter argument is sometimes people say it's still better than discrimination, but again, depends on who you're talking to. So it's a, it's a lose lose, or it's a win win, however you want to look at it. But there are arguments back and forth both ways. So if your firm has affirmative action, or if they don't have affirmative action or something to help promote that diversity, it doesn't mean you're wrong. 00:43:55.4600000 It doesn't mean you're morally corrupt or morally better than another firm who promotes it or does it a different way. There is arguments on both sides of it, which is what we see in the political noise around us over the years since it's come about, and everywhere else. And again, just different quotes that you can pull from different people. And again, these are from textbooks that I've taught from. And so it boils down to is it moral, ethical for lawyers to have affirmative action programs or for our clients to impose upon us? 00:44:29.3200000 And there are power, powerful arguments both ways. It's still unresolved in a lot of context. I know political figures are trying to resolve it one way, whichever favor they want to go, but it's still unresolved. And so it's not good, it's not bad, it's not better one way or superior the other. It's okay. 00:44:51 And if it helps you get that diversity, and then once you get the diversity, you promote the equity, the inclusion within the company, then that's what matters. The happy employees promoting the fairness across the board. Think of it more as fairness and not equality, because that's what really we're striving for. We just tend to intermingle the words a lot when we use them. Now there are different requirements depending on if you're a private company or a government company that have been pushed out over the years. 00:45:24.1800000 These requirements may have changed, especially with the fluctuation in administrations, but normally affirmative action programs are voluntary and you may be okay, and they may withstand a reverse Discrimination claim. If you're worried about that, so long as you meet certain criteria within your policy or how you're implying, or how you're putting forth affirmative action, and it's a may withstand a reverse discrimination claim, there's no guarantees, obviously. Make them reasonable, make them for the correct purpose. Don't, you know, institute them in certain ways, make them narrowly tailored, don't have those quotas, really focus them for that limited period of time in which they're needed to achieve the diversity. Then focus more on the equity, the inclusion. 00:46:11.1900000 And once you meet the diversity, do away maybe with the formal policy. And just now it's a mindset. Now it's the natural. We've broken that mind barrier where we're pushing away different things and we're going into this is normal. And so again, it can be set for that amount of time. 00:46:30 If you're a government actor, government agency, or someone listening like that, then there's a little different standards that have been pushed out over the years too, but just something to really take a look at and consider. And again, with the political noise, look, look for the newest, brightest things too, from the different administrations coming down as well. Some of the things. And I know we have about 12 minutes here left, so I want to get to everything. So I may fly through a little of these or just reference them. 00:46:58.9490000 And if you want more information on them, you're more than welcome to go out and look up the different cases for your own education and then to, to just see what they are. But there are some recent challenges to DEI programs that have come about and that we should be cognizant of. And there's even more recent ones that I think that are in my PowerPoints here today. So don't take this as the end all, be all inclusion of everything. Just take it as some guidepost for things to look for. 00:47:26.4800000 There was one in 2023, six three vote that Harvard's admission practices were unconstitutional, in violation. Again, these are kind of bouncing off of those old University of Michigan ones, the ones out of Texas, the ones in different places like that. So something to take a look at there. Then there was reverse discrimination litigation. There was a case Davento vs. AT&T Services, the citations there on the screen in front of you. 00:47:56.0900000 This was regarding layoffs in part, you know, to fit the goals of a diversity and inclusion program. There was motions to fit Smiths, all different arguments. The case was actually settled in June 26, 2024, and it was settled outside of court. So we didn't see the full undertaking of it. But if you want to go look at those filings and see the arguments both side and at and t was trying to meet a diversity and inclusion plan, but that plan included laying off people, which was not always the greatest way to implement a plan to begin with. 00:48:33.5300000 Here's one just regarding a shareholder derivative action. This was out of the Eastern District of Washington. This was challenged to Starbucks DEI policies including a goal to achieve a quota, basically representation of at least 30% of all corporate levels and 40% of all retail manufacturing roles by 2025. Motion to dismiss was filed and granted. And so judge stated from the bench that a shareholder derivative suit was an improper forum of making political statements. 00:49:05.8600000 This one got a lot of national attention too. So another one to kind of take a look at if you're interested in those as well. These are more about targeted programs again from 2024. Like I said, there's probably even more out there that I have not collected yet are seen to put in a PowerPoint. But these are other ones just to take a look at too. 00:49:26.1700000 Where the companies had targeted programs, eligibility criteria for certain classifications or groups that were challenged in court to as being illegal or reverse discrimination in those ways as well. Diverse training too. This is where a plaintiff alleged that he was subject to a shaming session after expressing negative opinion on dei, meaning that he was saying this is wrong or you know, expressing the views. So another case to look at there because you are going to have people really push against potential DEI programs in your organization or in your law firm if you do have them, and then you're going to have others celebrating it. Like I said, it is not a settled thing. 00:50:13.3400000 This is one of those areas that brings up such strong emotions. And it's also one of those areas which I don't necessarily like lecturing on because it brings up such strong emotions. And so I really do try to stay neutral and just kind of show you the different sides of it because it can bring up such strong emotions in anyone viewing it. But one of the strategies you could have, and this is kind of what I wanted to get to here in the last 10 minutes that we do maybe want to think, do you want a DEI policy and that is a personal choice of your law firm or if you're a solo practitioner or, or just a small firm, whatever you want to do. And they, what they do is they typically cover in those policies, recruitment, hiring, employee training, development, promotion, retention, workplace culture, communication, addressing instances of discrimination, harassment, bias. 00:51:05.9100000 And you may think to yourself, I already have Kind of piecemeal some of these topics. But do you have a DEI policy addressing, you know, how this is going to be given for that equity and inclusion across the board? So maybe you don't necessarily need a policy titled DEI policy. Maybe revamp some of the policies you have. Again, I don't know how your firm's set up, but just maybe something to go back and take a look at. 00:51:32.7000000 What do you have on the books? Where do you need to update it? What do you need to do? And those different things can maybe go a long way, too. And then when you're implementing your policies, whether they're brand new, whether they've been on the books for years, whether you're just updating them to provide new information, training, don't just update or have a policy and throw it in that bottom drawer or do a quiet rollout is what I call it, meaning, okay, we've approved it at the board, we've approved it at management committee or executive committee, or, you know, the firm partners have approved it. 00:52:08.0600000 But don't tell anyone we have it. We'll just pull it out when we need it. No, train on it, push it out. Give that leadership perspective, educate. Be a commitment to allocation of that, sponsoring it, making sure everyone's aware of it and how it's going to be implemented, and then just don't have it and set it on the shelf like I was talking about those maybe initiatives or programs you put on your website. 00:52:34.6200000 Make sure you follow it, make sure you prove with your actions that the DEI is important. Because it's one thing to have a policy and forget about it and throw it in a drawer. And it's another thing to kind of follow through with it and put your mouth kind of the money where your mouth is and, you know, really push that forward in making sure that you get it out in your employees and your staff and lawyers and everyone else trained on it and that they understand how it promotes equity, how it promotes inclusion and diversity and all the things that should make up the DEI policy policy, or the different policies with those aspects included in it. Keep metrics, too, to track your progress, especially if you have it only put in place for a while, or if your clients are requesting you report your statistics, you need to have a tracking system to do that. Especially when clients are demanding we report our DEI statistics to them. 00:53:33.1300000 This is something, you know, we want to track and push out to maybe take surveys, monitor how it impacts your employees, you know, what barriers they're coming up with. Where is the resistance to Change that ineffective communication, all of those things are something to really consider with it too. If you want some examples of some successful DEI programs, I would direct your attention to some companies that over the years have had successful ones. Maybe they may not be now or maybe they've changed, but just in the past some of these companies have had success in promoting a diverse workforce, aiming for that inclusive. And they're not necessarily law firms, they're other entities. 00:54:15.6000000 But it could be Google is one who's had really data driven insights training program, diverse hiring practices. Microsoft is another one I've seen with core values, integrating global dei, community, engagement, accountability. Some elements too just of your, maybe your own successful one. Leadership, employee involvement, clear goals, metrics, tailored trainings, culture, accountability, flexibility, adaptability. Just know it's an ever changing field and that you have to think about it, you have to think how it's going to work for your company, your firm pushing those ideals forward and then to really having that equity, inclusion and follow up in the background to making sure we get that also too within the policies as you're creating them. 00:55:09.6300000 Understand that it is not necessarily human nature or humans are not going to outright say I don't like diversity, I don't like this or I'm biased towards this. They're going to say yeah, I'm open to everything, yeah, I want a diverse environment that's just is the norm or what is socially correct. But we all have what are called implicit or unconscious biases that sometimes we're not even aware of. And it usually comes maybe from our upbringing or how we view the world or that back part of our brain which tells us what's good and what's bad and pushes stuff away. But we all have our own stereotypes. 00:55:48.6100000 We may think oh he dresses that way, then he's this type of personality or he looks like a CEO or the thing, you know, oh, she has blonde hair. Well, she has to be ditzy because she dresses in pink too. Like those are different stereotypes and implicit and unconscious biases that could come up and influence hiring, firing, evaluation process and all those dynamics and really take away from diversity. Because even though you may train your employees, your managers, your hiring staff, your partners, their unconscious biases are never going to go away unless they are aware of them, consciously think about them and work against them. And this could be they're going to sit in an interview and they're like well yeah, I just didn't like them because of this when it really was a stereotype they had where they see a name and they say, oh, that reminds me of a mean teacher I had. 00:56:43.5600000 I can never work with another, you know, Karen or another Joe or another Jim or whatever. And so those are unconscious attitudes or bias or stereotypes. And it's really hard to fight against those because every person has different ones and people don't like to admit they have them and people don't like to recognize they have them. So you're going to have managers or you're going to have attorneys sitting in interviews, hiring other people that are going to really have. You're going to have problems getting diverse in if they keep pushing away people that are qualified, but then they have some stereotype or phobia against some other little thing with that person. 00:57:22.3400000 So something else to train on and fight about or, you know, work against as well. Also too, in your policies, look for general neutral pronouns that can help with inclusion, kind of revamping those things. Like we've heard, maybe have a DEI committee too, which has a cross functional team. A DEI committee should not just just be people of underrepresented minority. You should also have more submajority people on there as well. 00:57:49.5200000 You have to have that cross section or cross functionality to have a diverse perspective. We can't just start kicking out what's always been the majority or mainstream. We have to blend all together for that team and environment. Have them there to assess goals, review policies, promote that accountability across the board, to maybe have a therapist if you have the funds for that, for your staff, to make them feel safe or speak up or have a safe hotline or something that's private, confidential, where they can speak out if they see something, kind of say something environment. This can drive inclusion camaraderie too, and just teamwork overall. 00:58:32.5000000 If you do have hybrid workspaces, make sure that you promote DEI through those. It's a lot harder, especially if they're not in the office. But proximity and where you're at can be a barrier or bias too. There's a lot of times where if someone's remote, they're thought about differently and stereotyped than if someone's in the office every day. And that's the type of discrimination, especially if they're doing the same job or the same work. 00:58:57.9700000 So we have to also combat that with inclusive virtual meetings, communications, not leaving out our remote workers, if that's something your company has gone forward with. If it is, then you should include them really working for that inclusion. Maybe also too having support groups or resource groups within the firm or outside of the firm where your employees can go get those resources they need, but it is an ongoing journey and with small changes we can really get to where we need to be. And I don't see any questions or anything in the chat feature. I thank everyone for joining us today and hopefully you got a little insight or just made you spark some thinking on your own. 00:59:42.9800000 So I will hopefully see everyone again in a seminar, but if not, have a wonderful afternoon.