[Course Name] 00:00:00.8000000 Hi, everybody. This is Mike DeBliss. Welcome back to part three of collection due Process. So this is a dense topic, and we started it out last time just by talking a little bit about this whole idea of collection due process and why it's even relevant. 00:00:25.8400000 In a nutshell, the reason why it's relevant is because there are very specific procedures that the IRS has to follow in order to be in compliance and in order to give the taxpayer their notifications so that they can exercise their due process rights. And yes, there are due process rights associated with the collections process. One thing I want to be very clear about, when we talk about collection due process, we are talking about a situation where the IRS has already made an assessment. What I mean, and when we talk about assessment, it's very important in tax terms that we understand exactly what that tax term means. It gets thrown around a lot, especially by professionals like myself and accountants, and we don't always use it in its right context. 00:01:32.6500000 An assessment means that the amount that the deficiency amount, which is another term of art, the difference between what the IRS is claiming the taxpayer owes minus the amount that the taxpayer self reported. We are assuming that there was a difference. We are assuming that there was a deficiency where the IRS is claiming that the taxpayer underreported gross income or over reported deductions or a combination of the two to arrive at a tax due and owing that is less than the amount that the IRS is insisting they owe. And so the IRS has certain procedures that it must follow in that aspect of the case to allow the taxpayer to exercise their due process rights to challenge the deficiency. And that is fine and dandy. 00:02:39.3300000 And that's a different stage of the tax controversy. On the tax controversy spectrum, where we are now in is at the stage where the notice to the taxpayer has already been given and one of two things has happened. Number one, the taxpayer has simply ignored the notice, or number two, has filed a petition in tax court and gone before a judge to challenge the deficiency, but has lost typically those two scenarios and one other, because there are always those cases where the taxpayer will arguably, you know, not being happy about it, still agree with the IRS examiner that there is a deficiency. And so we're at the stage right now where the train has left the station, so to speak, to challenge this deficiency that the IRS is asserting. Now it's all about collection. 00:03:44.2700000 Why? Because. Because this amount of tax due and owing is a debt of the taxpayers. So it's very important to recognize what stage we are in in this whole process. We are at the stage of this being a debt and the IRS attempting to collect it, essentially the taxpayer has, for whatever reason failed to, to make the payment of this assessment. 00:04:16.0100000 That's the legal term of art of what this debt is called an assessment. They failed to make the payment or to contact the IRS to attempt to arrive at some type of offering compromise where they would compromise, where the IRS might agree to compromise the assessment to a lower amount, or the taxpayer has failed to attempt to apply for an installment agreement whereby the taxpayer agrees that they do in fact owe the total amount, but they are asking for a special grace period within which to pay it so that they have longer than the typical two year time frame that the IRS insists upon the amount being paid. Why two years? Because the statute of limitations on collections is two years. So the smart taxpayer that might want to dodge this assessment would otherwise be able to just lie fallow for two years. 00:05:26.9500000 And then, you know, and then when the IRS comes after them after the two year statute of limitation expired, argue, sorry, you're too late. I'm using the statute of limitations as a defense. The IRS is smart. They know that any taxpayer would be wanting to try something like that. So they begin collection actions at an early stage to offset this strategy that a taxpayer might try to harness in an effort to avoid having to pay the assessment. 00:06:05.1000000 So now we're talking about administrative collection due process. I told you how it mirrors the last time I explained how it mirrors the civil tax controversy, the aspect where there's litigation. And what I mean by that is that IRS has what is called an appeal section of their, of this fortress. They have what's called an appeal section whereby an IRS representative essentially mediates the dispute between the revenue agent and the taxpayer. And that's typically what happens during the tax controversy stage. 00:06:52.8200000 If the taxpayer disputes the amount that the revenue agent is asserting they should have reported in a tax year, they would file a protest to the appeals section of the IRS and an appeals officer would serve as a mediator to mediate that dispute. Similarly, when it comes to collection actions, even though we are past the stage of challenging the underlying deficiency, we, we are still, there is still the same procedure in place for due process, beginning with appeals. So to the extent that the taxpayer feels that there is a legitimate basis for arguing that the IRS ran afoul of the collection due process procedures by perhaps not providing the taxpayer with the type of notice that the taxpayer was otherwise entitled to, or B failing to give the notice to the taxpayer altogether, or C running afoul of the Deadline by not providing notice to the taxpayer within the set time limit. Any one of those, any one of a violation of those requirements would allow the taxpayer to file a protest in the appeals section of the IRS to contest the collection due process issue. Now, before you get excited, and this is why the defense bar is always up in arms, there's not really any teeth in a violation of these collection due process rules. 00:08:51.5490000 So essentially, you could be representing a client who is on all fours with the argument that the IRS ran afoul of their collection due process rights. And theoretically, a judge could even side with, with you and with your client. But the punishment is virtually nothing. It's virtually nothing. It doesn't allow redress in the form of vitiating the assessment or erasing the debt of the taxpayer. 00:09:33.2400000 And that's what I think is a problem. Because if you want the IRS to get the message that they cannot violate collision due process rights of taxpayers, you've got to put teeth in these rules so that there is something at stake and something that they could lose if they run afoul of these. Now, the IRS will argue that these are technical or ministerial violations because their computers are all programmed to turn out these notices in a mechanical way, just like when we learned in evidence about the records collection doctrine. I think one of the examples dealt with, like FedEx on how they just by a matter of routine habit evidence. That's what I'm thinking of as a matter of habit. 00:10:28.5200000 So things are done. And so the IRS makes the argument that it's just. It's a matter of course, there can be no animus attributable to the IRS for failing to serve a notice on a taxpayer within a certain period of time because the computers have been delegated that responsibility. Well, to me, that's wrong. And I know that there's a lot of debate over this, but one would think that if the courts really wanted to put teeth in this, and if the legislature for that matter, and the body making and the body that had been assigned to draft all of these rules and procedures wanted to send a message, there would be something more at stake. 00:11:14.2300000 So let's resume where we left off last time. I want to make sure that I don't get too far ahead of us. Why don't we start here? It's a little bit of overlap, but what matters may be considered at the meeting with the appeals officer. So once again, we are in a dispute regarding collections, and we are in the appeals section of the irs. 00:11:40.8000000 It doesn't mean that this is the sole body that will that a taxpayer is able to have this matter heard by an adverse ruling by an appeals officer would still not would not preclude the taxpayer from taking an appeal to a higher body. And when I talk about a higher body, I'm referring to the US Tax Court. We'll talk about that momentarily. The appeals officer must receive an IRS verification that applicable law and administrative procedures have been met. For example, in cases of tax assessments requiring a predicate notice of deficiency, the appeals officer must verify that the notice had been properly mailed to the taxpayer and that the assessment had been properly made. 00:12:32.4200000 Otherwise, the taxpayer is not on notice in the civil tax controversy stage of an action of a tax controversy action of their rights to appeal or to contest rather the underlying deficiency. Now, the taxpayer may raise any appropriate defense, including spousal defenses, the propriety of IRS collection measures, and alternatives to collection measures. The appeals officer will not, however, consider any issue previously disputed, disposed of in a collection due process hearing or in a prior administrative or judicial proceeding where the taxpayer could have contested liability. So what we're talking about is a situation where the taxpayer, via a collection due process action that was filed in the form of a protest to appeals where the taxpayer is trying to get a second bite at the apple to dispute the the underlying tax deficiency. As I stated at the beginning, the opportunity to have contested the underlying tax deficiency happened at an earlier time and the collection and at the collection due process hearing that is not the appropriate time to retroactively go back in time and say, oh, by the way, I never had the opportunity to challenge the underlying deficiency now. 00:14:05.1000000 So, you know, this is still taken seriously and the appeals officer is going to want to satisfy himself or herself that the taxpayer actually did have an earlier opportunity to challenge the deficiency if the proper notice had not been rendered to the taxpayer back then, then there is a then then the taxpayer will be entitled to to contest the underlying deficiency. But to the extent that the taxpayer had been issued the proper notices but was merely silent and never filed a protest at that stage, they can't now retroactively go back and challenge that deficiency at a collection due process hearing before an appeals officer. 3. Whether the proposed collection action balances the need for for efficient tax collection with a legitimate concern of the taxpayer that collection action not be more intrusive than necessary. Those are always the two competing interests at a collection due process hearing. 00:15:16.2800000 What issues can the taxpayer raise? Any relevant issue relating to the unpaid tax or the proposed levy. Challenges to the appropriateness of the collection action offers of collection alternatives. Now, in order to do so, the taxpayer must have filed all required returns prior to the hearing. Challenges to liability only if the taxpayer had not received a notice of deficiency or had an earlier opportunity to dispute the liability before appeals. 00:15:45.6000000 That dovetails into what I said before about how the appeals officer will nonetheless take seriously a claim made by the taxpayer to they didn't have an earlier opportunity to dispute the liability. The appeals officer will typically look to see if a notice of deficiency had been issued. Why the notice of deficiency? Well, in the case of a civil tax controversy, a notice of deficiency is what's called the taxpayer's ticket to getting into tax court. It's essentially analogous to the defendant in a civil action or a plaintiff in a civil action having jurisdiction to bring an action in that specific court. 00:16:35.1800000 Without that notice of deficiency, the taxpayer cannot file their petition in the US Tax court. So of course, if the notice of deficiency hadn't been issued, then there's no question that the taxpayer would not have had an opportunity to dispute the liability at that stage. When can the taxpayer challenge the underlying tax liability? As to the underlying liability, the taxpayer can only contest it if he or she did not receive the statutory notice of deficiency for such tax liability or did not otherwise have an opportunity to do dispute such tax liability. What might be considered, what might satisfy the last part of that rule otherwise have an opportunity to dispute such tax liability? 00:17:32.9800000 I would argue that a protest to appeals to the appeals officer that was that the taxpayer lost would constitute otherwise have an opportunity to dispute such tax liability. So the notice of deficiency typically comes after an adverse ruling by an appeals officer. And so it doesn't always have to be the absence or the failure of the IRS issuing that notice of deficiency for the taxpayer to argue that they didn't have an earlier opportunity to dispute the liability. Again, to the extent that they had an opportunity to raise it before an appeals officer, they lost and then the statutory notice arrived. Then that still would be grounds for having had an earlier opportunity to challenge it. 00:18:35.2200000 Or take that hypothetical, take that last hypothetical and say the notice of deficiency never arrives subsequent to the adverse ruling by the appeals officer. Nonetheless, the CDP hearing officer would rule that the taxpayer had an earlier opportunity to challenge the underlying deficiency. Second, the notice of deficiency gives the taxpayer the right to contest the underlying right liability in tax court and is thus fatal to a review of the underlying tax liability in a collection due process hearing. The taxpayer will also be considered to have had a previous opportunity to contest if he waives the right to a notice of deficiency on Form 870 or Form 4549. The next issue is may the taxpayer contest the merits of the self reported tax liability in a collection due process hearing? 00:19:28.4000000 The merits of the self reported tax liability in a collection due process hearing and this case holds yes. So let's talk about the facts of this case that led to a favorable ruling for the taxpayer. The taxpayers who were a husband and wife filed their federal income tax reporting, filed their federal income tax reporting rather a substantial tax liability, but did not remit full payment of that liability. The IRS accepted the return as filed and assessed the voluntarily reported tax liability. The IRS did not audit the taxpayer's return or issue a notice of deficiency. 00:20:10.8600000 After collection efforts failed, the IRS issued a notice of intent to levy. That notice of intent to levy usually comes on the heels of the IRS exhausting all other collection efforts. And that's exactly what we have in this fact scenario. So after collection efforts failed, the IRS issued that notice of intent to levy and the taxpayers responded by requesting a collection due process hearing. The appeals officer issued a notice of determination allowing levy actions to proceed. 00:20:43.1000000 Now remember what I told you before that the appeals officer word is not final. There is. The taxpayer always has the right to challenge the appeals officer's determination. And that's exactly what the taxpayers did in this case. They challenged the appeals officer's determination and the amount of the underlying tax liability by going to tax court. 00:21:06.1800000 So essentially, even though tax court is the trial court when you would be disputing the underlying tax deficiency, the tax court turns into appeals court for an adverse ruling of a collection due process claim at the hands of an appeals officer. So that's why we're in it in the US Tax Court for this case. And this was the analysis. The plain language of section 6330 entitles the tax payers to an opportunity to establish that they erred in their self assessment because the IRS had not issued a notice of deficiency, which of course they were not required to do because there was no tax deficiency and the taxpayers did not have an opportunity to dispute their tax liability. This holding advances the policies of these sections and is consistent with congressional intent that the IRS should consider collect the correct amount of tax. 00:22:11.6400000 What can the taxpayer do if liability issues cannot be raised during the collection due process hearing? There's a few options. Number one, determine how the liability came to be. So for example, if the examination division completed an audit and issued a statutory notice of deficiency and the taxpayer failed to petition the US Tax Court, the tax on the notice will be assessed, and once it's assessed, it becomes a debt of the taxpayer. The taxpayer can follow procedures in 3598 to dispute the assessed tax liability, and that would be under the audit reconsideration process. 00:22:52.6800000 If the taxpayer makes such a request and examination does not accept the taxpayer's position, the taxpayer will have the opportunity to request request that the case be forwarded to appeals for consideration of the issues raised during the audit reconsideration process. Second option. A second option is for the taxpayer to submit an offer in compromise based on doubt as to liability. I mentioned this briefly at the beginning. An offer in compromise consists of the taxpayer submitting an application to the IRS asking the IRS to consider a lesser amount in full satisfaction for the assessed amount. 00:23:42.9900000 So, for example, if the amount assessed is $80,000 and the taxpayer is in a precarious financial situation, and it's unlikely that that situation is going to improve anytime soon, the taxpayer may take it upon himself to prepare all of the paperwork required for an offer in compromise submission. One thing you should be aware of is that the offer in compromise, the application process is very detailed. It is analogous to a colonoscopy. The taxpayer will need to literally open up the financial kimono and disclose assets, holdings, property, tangible or real, that they own and that they have owned for a number of years in the past. So there's a look back period that is information that a taxpayer would rather not have to disclose to the irs. 00:24:50.9000000 So a lot of times taxpayers that are gung ho on filing an offering compromise, you know, when they see what's required, it has a blanket shilling effect on them and usually will stop them right in their tracks. Nonetheless, there are those that still pursue it. And one thing that that taxpayer needs to be aware of is that, you know, it's not always granted and it takes a while for it to be reviewed. And while it's being reviewed in good faith, the IRS requests the taxpayer to abide by the very conditions that they have proposed in this offering compromise notwithstanding the fact that it hasn't been determined whether it is acceptable or not yet. 00:25:51.5200000 So in both situations, the taxpayer has no further appeals rights beyond the administrative appeal. And that is if we are pursuing this under the audit reconsideration process. So yes, if the case will be forwarded to examination for consideration, if the examination function doesn't agree with the taxpayer to taxpayers entitled to have the offer considered by appeals. But in both situations, taxpayers no further appeals rights beyond that administrative appeal penalties for abusing collection due Process procedures. Many taxpayers use the collection due process procedures to delay and obstruct the IRS legitimate collection actions. 00:26:36.2600000 Many taxpayers use the process to raise frivolous arguments that they previously asserted during the audit and appeals stages. We have they're labeled tax protesters, and the arguments can go from the absurd to benign absurdity, but usually it's rooted in some type of argument that the government did not have the right to tax American citizens and residents from the very beginning. So these get, you know, closed down very quickly by the by tax court judges. Section 6673 allows the court to penalize the taxpayer up to $25,000 if it appears that the taxpayer has instituted a proceeding primarily for delay or when the taxpayer advances frivolous or groundless positions to discourage taxpayers from requesting collection due process hearings in the first place when they don't have legitimate concerns. 6702 of the tax code imposes a $5,000 penalty on any person who submits a specified frivolous submission. 00:27:55.7700000 A request for a collection due process hearing that includes a specified frivolous submission will be treated as if it were never submitted. What must appeals do after it holds a collection due process or equivalent hearing? If the taxpayer and appeals employee reach an agreement about the case, the taxpayer will be asked to sign an agreement form. Now, in the tax world, as I'm sure you're aware, there's a number for every form. 00:28:26.2900000 Don't think you need to memorize these numbers today. I am still absolutely amazed at accountants who I know that can pull these form numbers up just off the top of their head. They can be the most obscure forms. And because they're in the trenches every day and they're filling these forms forms out for clients, they know them like they know the back of their hand. At the end of the hearing, appeals issues a notice of determination or a decision letter. 00:28:58.6100000 Results of the collection due process hearing appear in that notice of determination. Now, what must the notice of determination contain? It must describe what was considered by the appeals officer in the hearing and confirm that all procedural requirements were met and decide the merits of any issues raised by the taxpayer during the hearing. And by the way, these are very, very informal. This is not something where you would go to Washington or any other IRS branch with the client and then walk into a, a room that looks like a courtroom. 00:29:42.6100000 No, these are done over the phone sometimes, and sometimes they're even done on the papers. Sometimes they're done over over the phone sometimes. I haven't heard of any instances of zoom being used for these, but I haven't had one of them since the pandemic. So it's possible that they might even be using zoom for these appeals hearings, you know, but they're. But the point is they're informal. 00:30:13.7200000 What happens if the taxpayer does not obtain a favorable result in the administrative collection due process hearing? Judicial review of the decision in tax court is available from both post lien and pre levy administrative proceedings. Now, there are time frames and time frames are very strict in the tax world. So unfortunately, what's good for the goose is not good for the gander. Because I just told you up front that these time frames, despite being promulgated by committees that have been convened by the legislature. 00:30:58.5500000 And so, you know, these rules should mean something, you know, but if the IRS violates a notice rule, they are not told that the assessment needs to be vacated. They still can pursue it. There's no teeth in it for the irs. But guess what? The same is not true when a taxpayer misses a deadline to file an appeal of an adverse ruling before an appeals officer. 00:31:26.1600000 So judicial review must be taken within 30 days of the appeals office notice of determination. Although the notice of deficiency gives a taxpayer 90 days to petition the tax court, the notice of determination from an adverse appeals officer's ruling on a collection due process case requires the taxpayer to file a petition requesting review of that collection due process issue in the tax court within 30 days. And guess what? If you wait until the 31st day, it can be even an hour later, you are too late and the client is forever barred for having any further appeal right to dispute that adverse ruling. So guess what? 00:32:24.3200000 Your calendar. And I'll admit it, I am the old. I'm old fashioned. This is a just very basic calendar that I use consistently for all of my tax cases. I am, so I guess you can call nervous and anxious and wrapped tight about missing a deadline that I don't even trust my smartphone. 00:32:52.3900000 I fear that God forbid my smartphone is going to fail me and not turn on or my app is with my calendar entries is somehow going to, you know, get deleted and I'm going to be without all of these deadlines. So out of an abundance of caution, so I don't have to stay up at night worrying about whether I've remembered a deadline. It goes right into the book with a pencil so that, you know, so that I have. So that I have it. It's in black and white. 00:33:30.1000000 I can refer to it. And there's also something about writing it, I think that makes it stick more than if I'm just using my thumb on a smartphone to enter it. So that's how anal you have to be. And I'm sure I don't practice bankruptcy law, but I'm pretty certain that with bankruptcy law, many attorneys probably are old fashioned and retro when it comes to keeping deadlines just as well because of how high stakes it is and how big of, you know, how big of an effect it would have on the client and on you having to get your malpractice carrier involved if you blew one of those deadlines. So there is an exception to the 30 days if the taxpayer only seeks Tax Court review of appeals, denial of relief in connection with an innocent speech spouse claim. 00:34:28.3800000 Now, this is specific only to an innocent spouse claim that's raised at a collection due process hearing. Then the taxpayer has 60 days more than just those 30. So it comes to a total of 90 days from the date of the notice of determination to request Tax Court review Forum issues which court has jurisdiction over a collection due process appeal? The Tax Court has exclusive jurisdiction over the collection due process appeals. Now, I do a whole presentation on Tax Court and I believe I've already completed that. 00:35:06.7090000 So it's in the archives at Lex Vid if you want to go back and listen to it. But essentially, Tax Court is a creature unto itself, to say the least. It is not your typical court. It's not a federal court, federal trial court, by any stretch of the imagination. The judges that are assigned to Tax Court are well versed in tax law. 00:35:42.0300000 They're attorneys, and many of them have in a prior life, spent time at one of the big accounting firms, perhaps before even going to law school, and have practiced accounting, have been accountants themselves, have an accounting background. If not, they most likely have their masters in tax and have worked for a big law firm specializing in tax law. So this isn't going to be a situation where the person has no background in tax law. They do. And for that reason, many litigants prefer to have their case heard in Tax Court than they do in federal court, despite the fact that Tax Court does not allow a jury trial and federal court does so. 00:36:37.8500000 Again, one of the reasons is because of how well versed the judges the Tax Court judges are. But also another big reason why litigants prefer to dispute matters in Tax Court than in federal court is that they don't have to post the amount at issue or the assessment as a bond in order to get access to the court. In federal court, they must. In Tax Court, they do not. So that is another Very decisive reason why litigants go the Tax Court way. 00:37:20.3000000 But here we're talking about an appeal of an adverse ruling from the appeals officer. And we know now the Tax Court has exclusive jurisdiction over those. The provision allowing a grace period to refile after filing in the wrong court was removed. The taxpayer may pursue a collection due process appeal as a small tax case so long as the unpaid tax does not exceed $50,000. The one issue that you need to be aware of, though, is if you were to appeal as a small tax case, I don't think that the litigant or that the taxpayer has the same panoply of appellate rights as they would in a regular tax case. 00:38:12.0600000 So I'm not as confident that they would have the right to appeal an adverse ruling if they pursue it as a small tax case because there is a further layer of appeal beyond just Tax Court. We'll get to that later. I don't want to confuse you right now. Can the taxpayer obtain a dismissal without prejudice? Let's talk about the case from Wagner, because that talks about dismissals without prejudice. 00:38:40.3000000 Taxpayers filed a collection due process petition in the Tax Court, but sought to have the case dismissed without prejudice in order to pursue litigation in the federal court regarding net operating losses that the taxpayer sought to carry back to the year at issue in Tax Court. Note, the Tax Court does not permit voluntary dismissal of a tax deficiency action. So in a going back to earlier to an earlier stage of the tax controversy, the tax controversy affair, when a taxpayer wants to dispute an underlying deficiency and files a petition in the Tax Court, even if the taxpayer has reached an agreement with the attorney from IRS Chief Counsel's office that represents the IRS in Tax Court, they would not. The taxpayer nonetheless would not be able to do a voluntary dismissal of the petition. Once the petition is filed, it's filed. 00:39:48.7900000 The judge would, however, have the power to bless, if you will, the negotiated settlement, which is what it's called between the taxpayer and the IRS chief counsel. And then the case would basically be removed from the docket and it would be considered settled. A settlement in Tax Court is very much like a plea bargain or plea negotiation in superior court or federal court on a criminal matter. So just because the petition gets filed doesn't, of course, mean that there's going to be a bench trial. A very small percentage of cases actually proceed to a bench trial. 00:40:34.7400000 And those that do, there's so much stipulation that the issues are so narrow that the case doesn't need to take time immemorial to try and of course, you're removing a whole layer of jury selection because it's a bench trial and it's not a jury trial. So those cases, even when they do proceed to a bench trial, are usually disposed of within a few hours time. I mean, the more complicated ones, I suppose could go on beyond a day, but it's unusual. 00:41:09.0100000 So the test here is, would the IRS lose any substantial right by the dismissal? So, you know, contrary to what I just told you, right now, when it comes to collection due process cases being appealed to the Tax Court, what we're saying here is that there is. It's a little bit of a different playing field. The taxpayer actually might be able to make a voluntary. 00:41:39.3000000 The taxpayer might be able to make a voluntary dismissal even though the appeal has been filed in the tax Court. And the test here is, would the IRS lose a substantial right by the dismissal? If not, then the taxpayer's motion to dismiss should be granted. In making that determination, the court weighs the equities and does justice between the parties. The court's analysis here is that the statutory period where the taxpayers could refile their lawsuit in tax Court had expired. 00:42:16.1000000 The IRS would not be prejudiced in maintaining the collection action against the taxpayers as if the instant proceeding had never been commenced. It's almost like I view it as being analogous to a defendant looking to withdraw their guilty plea after having entered it. Of course, in most states, as in my state, there's a difference between whether the motion has been made prior to the defendant being sentenced or after the defendant being sentenced. It's a harder standard for the defense to make out a claim that the defendant should get their plea back post sentence than it is pre sentence. But nonetheless, one of the issues on both sides, because it's the same test, it's just a higher standard post sentence than it is pre sentence. 00:43:10.1900000 One of the issues that gets reviewed by the judge at such hearings is whether the state or the judge, the prosecutor, would be prejudiced in any way if the defendant were able to get their plea back. And if you think about it, because these motions could theoretically be brought months, if not a year or longer after the sentence to the extent that the prosecutor, that the witnesses no longer can be found, or perhaps they're deceased. Just think of the hearsay rule. Any one of those reasons would give the state a very strong argument to push back on the defense and to say, hey, Judge, we are significantly prejudiced here because our witnesses are unavailable for whatever reason because of all the time that has elapsed. The case has Basically gone dry. 00:44:08.8200000 So those are, you know, in the tax context, it's going to be a little bit different. But the same concept is at play here. The government cannot be put in a weaker position than they otherwise would be. Judicial review of administrative collection, due process determinations, the standard of review. The code itself offers no guidance. 00:44:28.3100000 Well, that's great. No guidance on the standard of review, but the legislative history does. And this is what's annoying about tax. You know, there are so many, so many secondary authorities that the tax attorney has to review in order to do their due diligence. Sometimes it's as simple as just going to the Internal Revenue Code, but most of the time it's not. 00:45:01.0300000 Sometimes you're looking at treasury regulations which are secondary authority. Sometimes you're looking at the IRS website and looking at the guidelines and the instructions that accompany the reporting forms. Sometimes, I mean, my God, I know that to make things even more outlandish with certain forms that are not actually IRS forms, they may nonetheless be enforced by the irs. I'll give you an example. And that opens up a whole other can of worms because then you've got to go to the agency that promulgated the form and see if they have internal guidelines that govern things before you even start looking to see whether there are secondary guidelines issued by the irs. 00:46:00.7600000 I'll give you a great example. The FBAR is one such form. It's a foreign bank account report. And it gets a lot, it's gotten a lot of interest since 2001 when the government started to enforce it with more gusto and abandon than they ever had prior to 2001 because of 9, 11 and because they were looking to root out terrorist organizations and terrorist financing being funneled through our banking system. So it was a low hanging fruit and the IRS seized upon it. 00:46:35.1800000 Well, the IRS is the enforcement body of the fbar, but guess what? It's not an IRS form. It is promulgated by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. And further, if you were to look on the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network website, there is, I kid you not, not a 65 page instructional form that governs or that describes in explicit detail the different sections of the form to guide tax professionals and taxpayers alike through the incredibly nuanced form. And if you don't refer to that form, you, you are putting yourself and your client at a disservice and at a distinct disadvantage since the IRS can certainly refer to that form to fire back that what you're arguing does have some type of precedent, even though it might not be legal precedent, or it might not be judicial precedent in the form of a court ruling. 00:47:46.9200000 So yeah, when it comes to tax law, you are looking at so many different authorities all the time, and only when you've exhausted the myriad of first and secondary authority, then you are basically issuing a legal opinion to your client where you state the pros and the cons of a position if there is no, no black and white guidance on it. And there are so many areas of tax law that are rife for that right now. One of which is an issue that I have that taxpayers constantly come to me about for guidance. And it is whether these gold stored in vaults in offshore banks, or I'm sorry, gold stored in vaults that were purchased by private gold companies, but where the private gold companies have actually leased space in banks, legitimate banks, offshore banks, whether those holdings needed to be, need to be reported on an fbar. As I sit here today, there is still no guidance on that. 00:49:02.8400000 And so we are left to basically look at the law as it applies to similar scenarios. One of which is these poker accounts where taxpayers who are US Expats or US Nationals park their money in these third party accounts and then use the money from those accounts to gamble. And it's not a problem. And except when the money is parked on these websites that the money's parked in is an offshore company. And then we get into this whole issue of whether the foreign bank account report form has been triggered. 00:49:46.6400000 The IRS of course, will argue with abandon that it is. The taxpayer will argue that it isn't if there is some basis. And so we're looking for any other similar cases that we can marshal to together to argue that the taxpayer is on all four and that there is a legitimate argument to be made here and that there's no legal guidance and it looks more like this. So we apply the duck test all the time. What is beautiful about this, if you're an attorney, is that there is so much opportunity to carve a niche for yourself in the tax world. 00:50:27.1600000 You don't need to be an accountant. You don't need to know the forms upside down, sideways and backwards. You do, however, have to have a little bit of background information and you have to have an appetite for pick and shovel work because that's what this is. There are a lot of tax attorneys that I know that don't want to touch some of these issues with a 10 foot poll because they have to educate themselves and they know how tedious and how pick and shovel this stuff is. But if you have the desire if you have the work ethic, if you have the patience to do it, I guarantee you there's work here. 00:51:09.3300000 The amount of the tax liability will be reviewed on a de novo basis with the taxpayer bearing the usual burden of proof if the validity of the tax liability was properly at issue in the hearing and the determination with regard to the tax liability is part of the appeal. Now, if the validity of the tax liability is not properly part of the appeal, the taxpayer may challenge the determination of the appeals officer for abuse of discretion. The propriety of the collection activity is reviewed under an abuse of discretion standard. What do we mean by abuse of discretion? We're talking arbitrary and capricious action without a sound basis in law. 00:51:55.2700000 In other words, unless the appeals officer had made a legal or factual mistake, the decision will be left untouched. Should judicial review be limited to the administrative record? Well, we can couch this in this way for the issue. When the tax court reviews a notice of determination in a collection due process case, should the tax court limit its review to the administrative record, or may it consider evidence not presented during the collection due process hearing? This is a very important issue. 00:52:33.3000000 If you remember what I said earlier in tax court. It leans heavy towards stipulation on issues, and more so than I've seen in any other forum that I've ever been in before in my life. And so, you know, the tax court judge will read you the riot act if you and your adversary from chief counsel's office haven't abided by the procedures. And there are very stern procedures for this stipulation. Discovery requests have to be made in a very formal way. 00:53:15.9300000 Defense counsel cannot automatically start deposing witnesses without first going to their adversary and requesting, you know, affidavits or depositions. There is. The formalities are very much analogous to federal court, and if you don't follow them to a T, you will be reprimanded. So, you know, I don't mean to be, you know, a jerk about this, but this is just how it is in this forum. 00:53:52.2000000 There's a rule from Robinette 8th Circuit Court of Appeals. Judicial review of the procedural aspects of a collection due process determination is limited to the administrative record. However, if the record does not adequately describe the hearing process or there is a dispute over what happened during the process, the reviewing court is permitted to supplement the administrative record with other evidence outside of the record. So essentially, there is hope. There is hope. 00:54:24.1300000 The facts. In Robinette, the taxpayer entered into an offering compromise that required him to timely file his returns. So an offering compromise could, of course, require the taxpayer to do other things that the taxpayer may not have offered to in the formal offering compromise. And those, of course, would be proffered by the IRS. The taxpayer claimed that his accountant mailed his 98 return and stamped it using a private postage meter. 00:54:57.2400000 However, the IRS never received the return. So the IRS declared the taxpayer in default of the agreement and began levy proceedings. At the collection due process hearing, the taxpayer offered alternative proof that he timely mailed the 98 return, but that the appeals officer rejected it, stating that he would only accept certified mail receipts as proof of mailing. I don't dispute that this exact scenario played out, because when it comes to, you know, the IRS and how big of a mammoth agency they are and how, you know, some revenue agents and IRS personnel are marching to the people beat of their own drum, I could easily see how something like this would have happened. The Tax Court held that the Tax Court may consider evidence presented at trial that was not in the administrative record of the collection due process hearing. 00:55:54.9700000 Although the judge ruled that the new evidence proved unhelpful to the taxpayer's case, he nonetheless allowed the taxpayer to present evidence that he had signed and delivered the returns to the his accountant for mailing. This was not in the administrative record. So, you know, the Tax Court judge split the baby. He allowed the evidence to come in, but essentially like we usually see on appeal in criminal defense cases, you know, we find out, well, it wouldn't have changed the jury's decision, and it would have still been a guilty verdict. So you get a little bit by the concession of the judge ruling that the new evidence is admissible. 00:56:44.1700000 But then at the end of the day, it's decided that it was not helpful to the taxpayer. And so it doesn't change the. The final outcome. The 8th Circuit, they reversed the Tax Court. They found that the administrative record was adequate and that the IRS did not abuse its discretion when it sustained the proposed levy. 00:57:12.4600000 Okay, this is as good as it's going to be as a spot to stop. So there will be probably one more part to this series. Hope you're getting something out of it. I'm trying to make it as relevant as I can to look lawyers, I usually do these for accountants, but there's certainly an opportunity, if you have any interest, to get into this. You don't have to have any formal training in tax. 00:57:37.2300000 It certainly helps to have that foundation. But again, if you have any interest whatsoever, always feel free to reach out to me, and I'm always happy to chat more about it. So look forward to seeing you in a future program, and I wish you the very best. Bye, now.