[Course Name] 00:00:01.2000000 Hello, everyone. My name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant General counsel of Taft, Centennius and Hollister in Indianapolis, Indiana is where I am located. In this position. I do a lot of internal ethics compliance and different things that just come my way. 00:00:17.1200000 It can be very random, like reviewing internal contracts, reviewing client terms and conditions, helping with engagement letters, clearing conflicts of interest. It can be also to dealing with personnel issues internally and externally, you know, personnel and client interactions. So a lot of things come into my role that touches the rules of professional conduct. So I work with them every day, all day. And one of the biggest of those areas is what we are going to talk about here today. 00:00:45.2100000 And what a lot of people forget is included in civility or, excuse me, is included in the rules of professional conduct and ethics, which is our attorney. Civility and misconduct conduct. This is something that people just think, oh, it's good to be nice to people, oh, you should be professional. But they don't really realize that it's part of our ethical rules to have a professional demeanor to maintain civility in your actions, your words and your conduct with your clients, with your colleagues, with third parties, with the judiciary, with whoever you may encounter. It is required, is required through various rules and it's required through the different oaths that we take to even become an attorney. 00:01:30.2000000 So that oath of attorneys that we take when we become lawyers, that is somewhere where you will see civility and professionalism embedded into those words that we're saying. We're raising our right hand, we're upholding certain things, and we just need to make sure that we uphold those standards. And those are some things that, that we're going to go through here today. Now, one of the biggest questions to you about civility and professionalism is what is it? What does it mean to have professionalism? 00:02:01.1100000 What does it mean to have civility? And there's a lot of misconceptions around these two words as well. It is not an agreement. It is not the absence of criticism. It's not that we have to like everyone because obviously we are not all going to like our colleagues, our, our co workers, you know, our clients are, you know, our post and counsel. 00:02:22.4200000 We're just not going to like them. Our personalities are not going to mesh. But that doesn't mean we're not being professional. That doesn't mean we're not being civil. It's just, you know, a part of it. 00:02:33.3000000 But is not the end all, be all professionalism. Civility too. The misconception is that you just have to have good manners and then you're professional. That's not true either. If you think about it. 00:02:44.7000000 You can say please and thank you. And behind that, please and thank you can be the most sarcastic, underhanded comment. But you said it in a nice way and you had good manners. So just because you have good manners doesn't make you professional and doesn't make you civil either. What professionalism and civility really include is just the confidence and skill and having the decency to uphold, to hold yourself to a higher standard of what a civilized society should look like. 00:03:14.2500000 And like I said, this is not meaning you have to agree with everyone. You can disagree and you can argue, but it's the way you do it. You can say please and thank you and be have the greatest manners ever, but again, it's the way you do it. Are you being sarcastic in it? Are you being underhanded in it? 00:03:31.8000000 Are you saying it the wrong way? I don't know if any of you have ever been in an argument, maybe with your significant other, your partner, your spouse, friends or family, or whoever it is, and the argument is more based on the lines of it's not what you said, it's how you said it. And that kind of gets to what professionalism and civility is. Sometimes it's not what we do or what we say, but it's how we set it and the meaning behind it. And are we really upholding the ideals of what we believe a civilized, decent society should look like? 00:04:06.2600000 There's also those ways when we argue in court. Think of when you're against an opposing counsel. Maybe they're throwing jabs, maybe they're putting sarcastic comments, or maybe they're taking low blow punches instead of just sticking to the facts and sticking to the argument. Then you get up and you stick to the facts, you stick to the argument. You don't raise your voice, you don't flail your hands, you don't put on the theatrical drama like opposing council did. 00:04:31.4900000 And so which one's more civil and which one's more professional? Again, it may not necessarily be the message. It could be the undertone, it could be the jokes included in there. It could be maybe theatrics like, you know, your body language included that make it unprofessional or make it uncivil. And so we really just have to look at a case by case basis of what the conduct is and how the attorneys went awry with it. 00:04:58.8000000 And we will get to some examples later today in the seminar as well. But let's go through some other things. First, the first thing I do want to remind you of, when I said, you know, civility and professionalism is not just, you know, something that we strive for. It's embedded in our rules, it's embedded in our oath, it's embedded in the leg in general. And it actually starts with our application process when we wanted to become lawyers. 00:05:26.6600000 Most jurisdictions require their attorneys to go through what is called a character and fitness interview. You may remember yours, you may have blocked it out as being an unpleasant time and experience, but a lot of us, if not all of us, went through this character and fitness interview in order to even sit for the bar examination or to become a lawyer as part of our application process. Now, in this character and fitness interview, sometimes you get paired with a local practitioner. They have your entire bar application. They can ask you about anything in their past history, anything criminal history that they want, and they have to pass you basically vouching that they believe that you will uphold the rules of professional conduct, be a civil professional lawyer, and maintain that integrity and that each jurisdiction and each bar of lawyers really wants to maintain. 00:06:17.3400000 So it starts there with the application process. It's also embedded in our. In the oath before we become attorneys. Like I said here in Indiana, and this is bullet point four, that first section on the screen in front of you in the oath here in Indiana, in between agreeing to uphold the Constitution and zealously defending our clients, Indiana attorneys agree to abstain from offensive personality. That's all it says, abstain from offensive personality. 00:06:47.2800000 Now, this can have various meanings and undertones and different things, but what it comes down to is that professionalism and civility that you know, the profession and the jurisdiction wants to envision. Now, the catch to this is, is when we say these things in our oath, and Indiana is not the only one, I encourage you to go out and read your specific jurisdictions Oath of Attorneys. We are agreeing to these things and upholding these standards and ideals 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally and professionally. If you read the preamble to the rules and you read the preamble to the administrative rules where the oath is located, it says that the oath applies and that the rules of professional conduct apply to lawyers 24 hours a day, seven days a week in our personal and professional capacities. Now, you may think, oh, that's not a big deal. 00:07:42.7600000 I do that anyway. Do you want me to pull your spouse, your significant other, your partner, your friends, your family, your colleagues, your co workers to ask them if you've upheld Civility and professionalism and Those core values 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally and professionally, I guarantee you there's not many people, if any at all, that have. There's always an off moment we have. We're not always on, we're not always thinking clearly. We're not always, you know, calm and cool headed. 00:08:15.3400000 Sometimes we get emotionally charged or just life hits us the wrong way. And so it's a very, very high standard to meet and it's in the rules. Because lawyers, since we are the guardians of justice, we're, you know, officers of the court where the community's access to those things. We should hold ourselves to this higher standard. We should hold ourselves and out into our communities that, you know, we strive for these ideals, we strive for those oaths we took and for those different things that we took and wanted to fulfill in our jobs. 00:08:50.3290000 The judges and judiciary have also really caught on to civility and professionalism over the years. In 2002, there's what's known as the Sedona Conference and it was a think tank of judicial officers and judges and some lawyers too, of really how to combat and confront the incivility that was facing the legal profession, especially in discovery E discovery in particular at the time. And this is because if any of you are litigators out there, you probably know that discovery is one of the worst phases of a litigation. It blooms the most contention, it has the most fist fights, it has the most arguments. It's something about having to turn over your evidence or your client's evidence to the opposing party that just gets people's blood boiling. 00:09:41.9300000 No one wants to give over that smoking gun document. No one wants to, you know, give over that thing that could, you know, work against them now, even though when they did it, they didn't think you'd be exhibit A in a litigation. And so then we have fights, we try to claim privilege, we try to claim confidentiality. It just goes all up and then we just not giving over anything, or we're giving over one thing, but burying it at the bottom of the stack of documents and then making it fine print or who knows, whatever else it is there. Or we say yes, you can have everything, but it's 50,000 boxes and going to cost you 10,000 plus dollars to get it. 00:10:21.5500000 And so we have this contention and we will see some examples of how this contention really comes to a head here today in the seminar as well. And so judges really wanted to start combating this. So at the Sedona Conference, they Started thinking of kind of cooperation proclamations. Some judges that I've heard across the country make the attorneys that appear in their courtroom sign a civility agreement before they can litigate in front of that judge. The civility agreement says that, you know, they'll talk to opposing counsel face to face, try to work out their own problems, you know, bring civility and professionalism into the courtroom, those types of things. 00:11:01.2300000 This is also where in discovery space phases, especially in federal court, you can't file that motion for sanctions or motion to compel or those things until you've tried to work it out face to face with your opposing counsel. Face to face does not mean email communication. Face to face means simultaneous back and forth communication without the delay or lapse of time. So it can be a telephone call, it can be a zoom call, it can be talking in person. It just can't be those emails or snail mails going back and forth or similar types of communication. 00:11:37.0900000 And this is because, as we all know, it's a lot easier to be mean. It's a lot easier to be unprofessional and uncivil. And in an email or in a communication that when you send it over, you know there's going to be a delayed. Lots of time, you kind of, I don't know if you've ever done it. You kind of hit that sin button or that enter button. 00:11:55.7200000 You're like, oh, maybe I should have done that. But done now. Done now. Just have to wait. Just have to wait. 00:12:00.6800000 And then you're just waiting. You're waiting. Did they respond yet? Did they respond yet? And then all of a sudden you get the response back that says thanks. 00:12:07.8000000 And you're like, was it not as mean as I thought it was? Like, then your mind just starts playing tricks on you. So the judges really wanted to get away from that and said, you know, you have to talk face to face. And when people talk face to face, they're not as ready or apt to be rude, to be uncivil, to be unprofessional. They're more collaborative, they're more, okay, you know, I don't have to press every extreme because, you know, if you say it to someone's face, it may sound very, very ridiculous. 00:12:37.5300000 And then that person's going to tell you it sounds ridiculous and you're going to get an argument. And. And a lot of people don't like to argue in, you know, simultaneous communication time. They can argue in an email because they can sit there and think about it. They can go out and Chat GPT if they can go ask their colleague how they respond in the meanest, most inappropriate way. 00:12:56.4900000 But to think on your feet is a little different. So that's why those face to face communications were really starting to be imposed and became part of the rules in many jurisdictions, state and federal, to help with that contentiousness of discovery. Also, state court jurisdictions are also embracing the civility. In 2005, the Illinois Supreme Court established the Commission on Professionalism under Supreme Court Rule 799C, known as 2 civility. They actually still have their own website called To Civility. 00:13:30.5500000 You can go out and search for it on the Illinois State Association's website. It does promote civility and inclusion. They also in Illinois or they used to try to get into the law schools early to promote civility of, you know, up and coming lawyers, to let them know what the profession's going to expect of them when they enter into being that lawyer, when they take that oath of attorneys, especially in Illinois, and how civility and cooperation is going to really play into that as well. So where does this come into play besides, you know, theoretically, with these proclamations and this oath and all these things? Does it come into play when we're just in the office, you know, talking to co workers? 00:14:12.9800000 Does it come into play when we're just in the courtroom? Does it come into play when we're interacting with clients? When do we have to be civil and when do we have to be professional? And the answer should be crystal clear by now. We have to be civil and professional 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally and professionally, because it is in our oath, it is in our rules, and we'll get to some specific rules here in a second. 00:14:38.5000000 But it is there and we have to uphold those ideals and those standards. But just so you can have some information, just kind of really think through certain scenarios where civility may go down a little bit or it may be harder to be professional. One of those areas is dealing with clients. That attorney client relationship. Sometimes we just have very uncooperative clients or clients we do just not mesh with very well. 00:15:07.5500000 But we should always exercise independent judgment and treat them with civility and professionalism and not have our conduct governed by or influenced by the conduct of the client. If the client has ill will, deceit, or wants you to press every advantage or do something that's unethical or brings the worst out in you when you are litigating their case and when you're working on their case, then maybe they shouldn't be a client of yours, maybe you should, you know, push that aside and say, nope, not going to be a client of mine today. So we do have to look at those scenarios there as well. Lawyers should also make sure that, you know, any benefits or anything that's good for the client are conveyed, any negatives are conveyed to, to the client. We also don't want to overstate what we can get done for the client. 00:15:59.6200000 We really need to curb a client's expectations. A lot of incivility and unprofessionalism and anger and arguments with the client come from when the client's thinking they're getting a million dollars. The lawyer knows that the medical bills are only worth 5,000, if that. So then you add maybe pain and suffering, a little extra on top to make them go away. Maybe the claims were 10,000 total. 00:16:23.4700000 But either way the lawyer is responsible, you are responsible for managing those clients expectations and doing it in a civilized manner. And it doesn't mean just letting the client think and wish for that boat or that a million dollars, but making sure they understand that yes, while maybe you got a million dollars for their friend who used your services, their circumstances were different. And really sitting down and outlining with them in a calm, cool, collected manner of why the million dollars is not realistic in their case. Now if it is, obviously sit down and outline that. If it's not, sit down, outline that. 00:17:00.7000000 Because we don't want to over promise and we don't want to overstate results because then that can lead to incivility and unprofessionalism. We also too want to make sure that client's ill will towards any adversary, witness or anything they want us to do is not done out of the client's anger and just for retribution or retaliation against someone, you know, using the process in a vindictive manner. We don't want them to use our services to fulfill their retaliation, basically. And you don't want to use your services to commit any fraud or any crimes because then you're going to be sitting in jail next to your client instead of trying to get them out of jail on the other side of the bars. We also don't want to use our services to embarrass, harass, intimidate, improperly burden or oppress our adversary. 00:17:50.7300000 And we want to make sure that we use the proper professional tactics and not the underhanded tactics. Sometimes, I mean you've all you probably met lawyers and you're like, they're a sneaky lawyer, they're unethical, they do xyz just to rack up cost or, you know, all those things. And that can be considered unprofessionalism in many contexts. I used to know one lawyer who was routinely late to depositions and depositions that that lawyer scheduled and called themselves. And so one day I asked, I go, why are you always late? 00:18:25.7900000 Like, you know the deposition schedules. You always show up 15 to 30 minutes late. And it wasn't about any particular case. It was just a random conversation I was having with the person, you know, outside of any case contacts, just saw a social event. And the lawyer goes, because I like to put pressure and make the other side antsy. 00:18:46.8500000 So he intentionally showed up late to every single deposition he scheduled to make the other side angry, antsy and more on edge and frustrated. Because he said, normally when they're already flustered, when I start, the deposition goes more in my favor and they mess up. And so is that professional? Is that uncivil? Is that conduct that, you know, that we shouldn't do as a lawyer? 00:19:16.4000000 Because if you think about it, you're being late. Promptness, you know, that can go into good manners, which doesn't always equate to professionalism, but the intentions behind it is that an unfair tactic? Is that something? And it cut both ways. There's probably some people on this call that think that's not unprofessional, it's just strategic. 00:19:34.3500000 And then other people on the call may think that is an a hole move, and that is unprofessional and that is uncivil. And, you know, we shouldn't use those tactics in litigation or in cases. So again, we have to look at each case scenario on a case by case basis to see do we reach that unprofessional or uncivil level. The second biggest area where we see unprofessionalism and incivility is in our courtrooms, either talking rudely to disrespectful to opposing counsel and parties, or even to the judiciary. Also, too, the worst, I think, ever is if you are disrespectful, uncivil or unprofessional to the court staff, the bailiffs, the clerks, they can hurt you or they can help you, they can make or break you. 00:20:21.3800000 And if you're an old school lawyer, which I know some of us are more seasoned than others, but when I started practicing law in the early 2000s, we still had hand filing where you had to go to court, you had a runner. Law firms employed runners at the time. And a runner is kind of what it sounds like every filing that needed to be filed at the courthouse that day, you put in a basket. The runner collected those. The runner took those over to the specific courts where they needed file, had to go up to the clerk, get the stamp copies. 00:20:52.0600000 You know, you had to have so many copies, you couldn't just, you know, e file it anymore. You, you had to have like four copies. One for opposing counsel, one to take back to you, one for the judge, you know, one for the file. You had so many copies, get each one file stamped, you know, signed and accepted that it's been filed. And then the runner would bring those documents back. 00:21:11.6800000 Now, the thing was, the courthouse closed at 4:30. Those clerks, if you walk in there at 4:30 with 10 documents to file, do you think they're going to be happy with you? Do you think they're gonna help you out? Absolutely not. They are gonna be mad at you. 00:21:27.4200000 They're gonna tag you. They're gonna be like, oh, my gosh, close the doors. Hi. Turn off the lights. You know, we know that person's coming. 00:21:32.8600000 They're always late. So they can hurt you or they can help you. Now, even without the filing in person anymore, paper filing in almost every single jurisdiction, I can't think of one off the top of my head that does the stamp filing. Unless you choose to do it, they are still vitally important because they do talk with the judge. They do probably tell the judge how you interact with them, or it's around, you know, the courtroom gossip or whatever. 00:21:58.9500000 So you want to be courteous. You want to use formal mannerisms and all hearings, depositions, and interactions with the court staff. And you need to think about those things. Some things that could be considered professional in those mannerisms, addressing people by their proper names. What do they want to be called? 00:22:15.7900000 Miss, Mrs. Mr. You know, or if they just want their first name or last name, think about those things. Also, just the court decorum. I don't know what's happened to decorum. 00:22:26.1100000 I don't know if they're not teaching it in law school anymore or if lawyers coming out just aren't being mentored like they should be. But in court, we say, your honor, we say, you know, thank you, your honor. You know, I respectfully disagree, your honor. There's those phraseologies instead of saying you're wrong, you're this, you know, that forcefulness with it. So those things can also lead into professional asking permission to approach the bench in court, asking, you know, being courteous in how you ask for things. 00:22:54.2100000 Those are all Things that go into professionalism and civility. Some other things too to think about in the courtroom are your hand gestures, your facial expressions. You may think, since you're a lawyer, you have an automatic poker face. But it is kind of entertaining to sit in a courtroom and watch the councils that are arguing and see some of their faces go like this. When they don't like an argument or when someone says something, they're like, what? 00:23:18.4700000 And you see those, those twitches, those mannerisms, those, even though they're not audible, have comments and can lead to unprofessional incivility as well. So we need to watch our body language and our gestures and our expressions too, because that can also have a dire effect on everything. Also to watch your objections, you know, how you conduct yourself, how you argue in court. Don't name call. If someone's race is not part of the case, don't bring it up. 00:23:48.7600000 And we will see examples like that too. Or if someone's nationality is not part of the case, don't bring it up. It's quite that simple. We've got to think of those things that just make us human beings and how we want society to view us as a civilized profession. A lot of lawyers, when they get in trouble for incivility or for unprofessionalism, either by their clients or in court, they all hide behind the I'm just zealously advocating for my client. 00:24:17.3000000 So since this was such an overused word and not even used correctly, necessarily because zealously advocate does have some definition to it, but it is still very broad. So a lot of jurisdictions started taking out the word zealous from the oath. A lot of oath of attorneys no longer say that they will zealously defend their clients. It just says they'll defend their clients or they'll, you know, put another adjective in there, another, you know, get us the source out, do something. And they still make thesaurus. 00:24:48.6700000 Hopefully they do. But something there to, to replace that word zealous. Because again, it was being overused and a lot of attorneys were trying to hide behind it, which was not the intention of it. It was not there for you just to say, well, anything I do is professional because I'm zealously defending that client. No, we don't want to zealously defend in that, you know, over the top, crossing the line manner to where we're sitting in jail next to them. 00:25:16.1300000 We want to professionally defend them. We want to be civil when we defend them, not zealously defend. And you can see the Inflection in my voice to kind of show you the difference when it comes to that. Some other things, just for civility and unprofessionalism, just some other manners and things. These are war stories that have happened to me personally or to friends or my mentors when I've been in court with them or heard stories from them. 00:25:43 One was, I was with my mentor as very young attorney, probably only a couple years out of law school. And I remember going into court with her, and the judge was on the bench, and we were. She was arguing a motion, and all of a sudden the judge goes, honey, I already have that case. He called my mentor a lawyer in his courtroom, honey, in front of the entire court. She looks straight back at that judge and goes, honey, how about you get it? 00:26:08.3500000 And the judge didn't say another word. So even those little things like that, that can go to gender, can go to discrimination, can go to harassment, sexual harassment, or any of those things can also be considered uncivil and unprofessional. Did my mentor turn him in for being uncivil, professional? No. And a lot of cases are never turned in. 00:26:29.1100000 It's just, you know, more the severe ones that we start to hear about. But that's an example of INC or unprofessionalism that can be in the courtroom because it can include things based on gender, race, religion, sexual orientation, sex harassment, any of those areas. And sex discrimination, another one, too. I walked into a courtroom, and this is more on the lines of, you know, kind of sexual harassment almost would be. I walked into a courtroom in a small, rural county. 00:26:58.5700000 Here in Indiana, we have some very rural counties still have just the old courthouses where you walk in. There's four doors, you walk in. It's the rotunda type. You know, you look up, you see all the. The stories, beautiful courthouses. 00:27:10.6300000 And I walk into the courtroom. This is one I'm not regularly in. So I'm not part of the local bar. Everyone knows I'm from Indianapolis because I'm the stranger, you know, in the court type of court place. And attorney walks up to me, an older gentleman, and he puts his arm around me and he says, honey, are you lost? 00:27:26.8700000 Can I help you? It was actually ended up being my opposing counsel for the hearing, which made it even more. More fun to win that case. Another case, too, where I walked into a deposition as an attorney. I was a younger attorney than two, and the opposing counsel was already in the room. 00:27:43.4500000 No one else was in the room posting. Counsel looked up as I walked in. The door and I had my briefcase, you know, I'm in a suit, all, you know, decked out into, you know, the professional attire for attorneys and the opposing counsel who is sitting at the table, again, only one in the room, he looks up at me and he goes, oh, are you the court reporter? Your seats down there. These things happen. 00:28:03.2300000 Those are all considered unprofessional, uncivil, even though they are more of the tone of a sexual harassment or a discriminatory act or something like that. Those things too fall into that category. And we'll see here under the rules where they really do fall into that, that sexual discrimination and sexual harassment. One of the rules of professional conduct that always comes into play when we have incivility or unprofessionalism is rule 8.4 D, as in dog. Now, I do want you to go out and check your specific jurisdiction because some jurisdictions are numbered a little differently and some are reworded a little differently. 00:28:41.2800000 But you will find this in Rule 8.4. It is called the prejudicial to the administration of justice rule, or that's what I call it. I also call it the kitchen sink rule because it can be almost anything. It states that it is professional misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice. Now the key to this is what is prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:29:05.4400000 You would think the comments would blatantly define this for us, but they do not. They give some open ended examples, they give some, you know, like delay of proceedings. They don't even use really the word incivility or unprofessionalism. But those, all those things can be prejudicial to administration of justice. Anything that casts that bad light on the justice system, the lawyers, the judiciary, very broad, kitchen sink. 00:29:31.2700000 If they're going to get you for anything, they can tack this on to almost any violation under the Rules of Professional Conduct. Whether this is tacked on or done independently, it is there, haunting lawyers in a lot of jurisdictions and you will see it used quite a bit. Another rule that most jurisdiction have, but not all. This is one rule in the Rules of Professional Conduct and the model rules that some jurisdictions have refused to adopt. Some jurisdictions have refused to adopt this rule because they feel like it constrains a lawyer's freedom of speech, personal speech, too much. 00:30:11.7600000 And in response to that, when the model rules adopted it in 2018, they put in the limitation you see in red on your screen that this rule only applies when we are practicing Law. It is the only rule in the Rules of Professional Conduct that solely applies when we're practicing law. It does not apply personally. This is the one exception to that statement I've been making this entire seminar that the rules apply to us 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally and professionally, except for this rule, if your jurisdiction has it. This rule is what I call the Title 9 of the Rules of Professional Conduct. 00:30:51.7300000 It says that a lawyer shall not engage in conduct that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, age, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status or socioeconomic status, and conduct related to the practice of law. Law. Now, we've got to break this down. You can see all the various protected classes there that we have. You can see, you know, everything that's in those rules. 00:31:22.6100000 If we compare this to Title seven, because, remember, I said it's like the Title seven of the Rules of Professional Conduct. You can see how many more protected classes there are and how broader this is. And the jurisdictions that have adopted this rule, some of them have even added more categories of protected classes. Some have lessened it down to be more keen with the Title seven. But you do need to read, because there are protected classes, and each jurisdiction is different on whether you have the rule. 00:31:53.4700000 If you do have the rule, what protected classes are included, and then two, what's included in it. Like, let's define what's going to be, you know, harassment, discrimination on these protected classes. Now, discrimination is defined as the harmful verbal or physical conduct that manifests bias or prejudice towards others. And harassment is conduct that is aggressively invasive, pressuring or intimidating, and includes sexual harassment and derogatory or demeaning verbal and physical conduct. So you can see there where those examples were stories I was giving of someone putting their arm around me, saying honey to my mentor, asking me if I'm the court reporter. 00:32:37.0900000 Those different things could be perceived as harassment, could be conceived as, you know, physical or conduct, physical or verbal, that leads into sexual harassment or types of discrimination in different ways. And so, again, it's very broad. And the limitation on this, if we go back to that slide related to the practice of law, a deposition, a courtroom, and all those things are related to the practice of law. And comment 4 gives us other areas which would include related to the practice of law within this specific rule. The first is obviously representing clients, interacting with witnesses, co workers, court personnel, lawyers and others while engaged in the practice of law, operating or managing a law firm, participating in bar association business or social activities in connection with the practice of law. 00:33:30.4800000 So this is huge, this is massive, especially that last category there, because that's the one you're going out to lunch with co workers, you're going to drinks, you're going to a bar association event, maybe you plan a firm outing to that baseball game or that hockey game. It's not just interacting with clients and interacting with opposing counsel and witnesses and judges and other lawyers. It's also staff, parties, staff, you know, interactions, managing that law firm events and social things and outings. All of that is included in the practice of law and in all of those areas, as a lawyer, if you have this rule in your jurisdiction, you cannot discriminate or harass on the basis of the protected classes and what's all included in those. And so very big rule, very huge when it comes to making sure that we maintain that professionalism and we maintain that civility and that we guard against bias, discrimination, harassment and all those things. 00:34:33.1290000 Because you can see between 8.4D and 8.4G, whichever your jurisdiction has, or they may have both, you're going to get hit with an ethical violation for being unprofessional or uncivil. Even though when 8.4G came out, it was met with so much hesitation. And like I said, a lot of jurisdictions still have not adopted it, even though the model Rules did. Even then John Gleason, the then chair of the ABA Center Professional Responsibility, said that it would be most accurate to tell you that 8.4g is dead in the water. He didn't think jurisdictions were going to pick up on it or that jurisdictions were going to take off with it or do those things, but they did. 00:35:15.4700000 The majority of jurisdictions have picked it up. And so if you really look at, and your, your group is one of those jurisdictions where they have picked it up, how do you guard against it now? How do you train your staff, how do you train your non attorneys on this rule? How do you tell them you can't discriminate, harass on the basis of these things? And they say, okay, I know I, I don't discriminate, I don't harass, I don't hold bias. 00:35:40.0800000 I don't just, you know, all those things. But when I was teaching ethics to the business school, the Kelly School of Business, one of the classes I taught was discrimination and bias and just, you know, complying with Title vii, complying with, you know, the different regulations in different areas of business. And someone said to me, well, I don't hold any biases and My response to that always is, if you have a brain, you have a bias. And that is the truth. It has been studied in psychological tests and psychological experiments and different centers and by researchers and writers and professors across the country. 00:36:18.4900000 If you have a brain, you have a bias, even if it's an unconscious bias. And unconscious means we're not aware of it. And it's okay to have a bias, it's okay to do that because it means you're human is all it means. But learning your unconscious biases, trying to draw them out so you can work against them and correct them or, you know, not let them take over your decision making process is the key to it. And so one of the examples I want to do here is that first I want to introduce you to Ellen. 00:36:50.7900000 You can look at her picture there. This is my friend Ellen. She's an accomplished chef. She loves sports, animals, hanging out with friends, volunteers at homeless shelters, her best friends. Her sister Kate loves playing bingo with her family. 00:37:03.2000000 Can you pick out Ellen? Which one is Ellen? Now you may think, okay, this was mean. They all have similar hair tones. They all have similar, you know, features. 00:37:13.6800000 Which one's Ellen? I'm gonna ask in. And it's okay if you get the wrong answer. It's okay to feel uncomfortable during this exercise, and it's okay to not even verbally announce your answer in the chat feature of, you know, the seminar here today, all of those things are perfectly acceptable. But which one in your mind do you think is Ellen? 00:37:34.5800000 If you pick that bottom center, you are wrong. I like to give one false positive first, just to kind of get people a little antsy thinking they're right. It was actually that bottom left corner. So if we go back, we see Ellen, bottom right corner there in the white shirt, long hair. That is Ellen. 00:37:52.0200000 So did you have trouble finding Ellen? And it's okay to be honest. And it boils down to if you had the same maybe hair color, the same ethnicity, the same skin tone, the same, you know, gender as Ellen, you may have been more apt to catch on to her features and would be able to distinguish them better in the lineup, even with the quick change. Our brain has a part of it called the FFA which is in the lower back part of our brain. The things that are more like us, things that are similar to us, like similar facial features, similar hair color, similar eye color, similar skin tone, similar bone structure, we're more attracted to. 00:38:29.4400000 And we pick up on those details because our mind subconsciously says they're like you. It's good and neurons are firing. If the person or features are different than us, our brain says it's a little scary. It's not like you. I don't know about that. 00:38:42.7600000 I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. You know, it's like freaking out in our brain and then they start to glaze over it and we don't pick out the features and we don't pick out the details and we start to act differently because it's not like us. And that's what your brain was doing here. 00:38:57.5900000 If you picked out Ellen, you may have been more like her in some sense of those characteristics. Or maybe it was something regarding, you know, what I said she was involved in. And if you didn't pick her out, maybe you're less like Ellen. And that's okay. It's okay to be honest either way. 00:39:12.3300000 Another example here. Now this one, obviously you're going to catch on and never. You were probably studying the picture intently going, oh my gosh, who is this? Who is this? This is my friend Shelly. 00:39:22.4900000 Shelly is the mother of four kids, 45 years old, loves fitness activities, hiking, travels, every occasion she gets. Her best friend is her sister Cindy. She has a criminal. She has a degree in criminal justice. Very well rounded person. 00:39:36.1700000 Let's see, can you pick out Shelly? They're all blonde, they're all beautiful. They all have kind of same eye color, similar features here and there. Which one is Shelly? Take a minute to look a few seconds here. 00:39:50.1600000 Don't want to dwell too long on it. Now let's look here. If you picked out her, she was top center. If we go back and look there, top center again, the one false positive, you were wrong, that is not Shelly. But I know Shelly would be elated if you picked her because it looks like a younger version of her. 00:40:07.4000000 In my mind mind, the one that was Shelly was that bottom center. Again, if you had trouble picking out Shelly, it's okay to be honest. The chances are if you got Shelly, there's a better chance that you are a Caucasian female or you realize what I was doing at that point either way. And if you got Ellen, there's a higher chance that you were Japanese or had similar characteristics as Ellen. It's known as the other Reese effect. 00:40:33.6300000 And it's an unconscious bias. If you have a brain, you have a bias that all of us hold. Because we are human. We have difficulty distinguishing faces and characteristics of other races other than our own. And it's not just about environment and exposure. 00:40:49.7600000 It truly is the way Our brains are wired. It's what neurons start firing. It's what, you know, lights us up if you're similar to us. It's what you know, stops firing and says run away. That's a tire. 00:41:02.0800000 That's different. It's an animal. That's the same as that fight or flight response. It's just bad when used to fight or flight against other human beings, causing discrimination, harassment, bias, incivility and unprofessionalism. But if you have a brain, you have a bias. 00:41:19.4990000 And it was kind of like a TED talk Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt gave that was published or televised, I guess you could say, on YouTube and those different channels. As a Stanford professor of psychology that did this experiment with other psychologists who all failed it too. Or those unconscious biases started coming out and it is that lower part of our brain right there, the little red like peanut shaped things that really are the part that are causing these, known as that ffa helps us distinguish faces, differentiate familiar, unfamiliar, friend, foe, us versus them. Those neurons tune up and get excited or they come down if it's not like us and there's nothing we can do about it besides learn about it. 00:42:04.8000000 Being able to recognize that doing the hard work, putting in the uncomfortable exercises and time and making sure that we fight against all human tendencies of not categorizing people, not being unprofessional in this sense of discrimination and sexual harassment and bias and stereotypes and all those things that we let it stop with us and that we educate the people we work with. We educate our non lawyers or other lawyers who are responsible. Because under rules 5.1 and 5.3, we have the responsibility to train our lawyers and to train our non legal assistants in everything. And so we have to always do that and account for it. Now there's other areas too where bias can show up in, you know, practicing law. 00:42:50.5200000 There's recruitment, obviously this can be. We'll do an extra little exercise that you can do with your staff and your other attorneys on this to recruitment, screen and hiring. When you get recruitment is the job posting screen and hiring is when you get those resumes. And we've all probably done it. I hate to say it, but you may say I've never done that. 00:43:09.1400000 But if you really think about it, have you ever read a name on the top of a resume and are in your mind got a mental picture of them, whether it's right or wrong, You've already stereotyped them into a mental picture whether they have dark hair, light hair, brown eyes, fat, skinny, look like someone friend that you have that had their similar name, you've already done something. So it can happen there in the screening and hiring. It can also happen in work allocation, promotion. We have a tendency to promote those that are most like us, that we're friends with our coworkers and then not invest as much time and or not feel like we need to promote because we just don't like them. People who are dislike us. 00:43:43.7900000 And so again you can see it there too. Instead of having an affair across the board, discharge interactions with coworkers, just how we interact. I worked at a law firm once and I don't even know what it was. I was brand new, first year out of law school, went into a law firm. There was two other females in there at the time and the rest males. 00:44:00.2600000 It was a small firm, only about 12 attorneys total and my office was in between the two other females. I was right smack dab in the middle of them in the hallway. They would literally one would get up out of their office, go past my office, stand in the doorway of the other office, which was right by my office doorway and ask each other to go to lunch and do things together and never once asked me. Interaction with co workers and just how you do stuff and maybe it's because they didn't like me, I have no idea. Or maybe it was because of something else, I have no idea. 00:44:31.5800000 But again those different things too can lead to those. Attendance at work related social events, correspondence with employees, third parties. We need to watch what we say, tones of emails, different things like that. We should have company policies addressing civility, addressing professionalism and especially addressing the subsections of discrimination and harassment as well. And then also to just making decisions and choices in our law firm, this is one of the training exercises you can take back to your firm. 00:45:01.2500000 This is one where you're going to draw out those biases in recruitment and when in recruitment and screening. Everyone on the right, the names have the exact same resume and you have to put them in a job on the left you may say, well I don't know, I don't see their qualifications are equally qualified for every single job. Identical resumes, only the names are different. If you do this and your employees are open and honest about it or your other lawyers, you're going to see trends. Every time I've done this with a class or with a big group of cle more in person, you see John Smith, you see more as a CEO or you know those high powered positions, President of the United States. 00:45:37.5300000 You see Like Linda Allen and maybe Betty Jones as the teacher or the stay at home parent. And I've asked before, especially with those two, why they put them in those roles or even like the receptionist roles, another common one for Linda and Betty. Usually they rotate between those three and don't go outside of that. I've heard that, well, Linda and Betty are old sounding names and receptionists are old ladies. I've heard that before. 00:46:03.2400000 So people really do, when they do get down to it and say they're all equally qualified, here's the jobs, just like the resumes you get in, everyone's equally qualified. But then the people in their mind saying, well, I knew Karen, Karen's are mean, I don't want to work with her. And they don't even know Karen. We've never even met Karen, Karen's not even coming and interviewed yet. And so we start to see those biases come out and it goes back to that brain and that exercise. 00:46:28.1200000 You can even go back to as you're giving the exercise at your firm. We are trained to see people in certain professions. We're trained to see more females as a receptionist, more stay at home parents, as the female teachers, especially grade school age, as females, professors like in college, more males. It just depends on the profession and what it looks like. And we're showing these images over and over and over again and that FFA is getting used to it. 00:46:52.9800000 And that's what's familiar, that's what's lighting it up. Not, you know, the other way around for the promotions and work allocation. This is one to make your managers also think too. I would have them list out five to ten people they trust. But it can not be family, it can only be friends, co workers, classmates. 00:47:11.0800000 And when I say trust, I mean like ride or die. You're sitting in jail next to each other, you're telling each other your deepest darkest secrets, letting them into your, you know, master bathroom. Even though it's the nastiest thing ever. Those people, and I can only think of one or two, which is fine if your co workers can. And then once they have that person in mind, have them write down the name of the person. 00:47:32.3800000 And then once they write down the names of those people, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 10. But again, no family members. Then have them write down the characteristics, gender, race, age, sexual orientation, education, disability or whatever list you want to put together. Then ask them, do you see a trend? Are those two ride or dies and their characteristics the same as your characteristics are similar. 00:47:56.3000000 And 90% of the time I do this. 90% of the people those ride or dies have the same race, have the same gender, have the same characteristics. It's not until we start branching this out into what I call the middle ring and the outer ring. Middle ring is you'll invite them over to barbecue, they can use the guest bathroom. You're not going to let them in your diary, you're not going to let them in that nasty master bathroom back there, but you're going to let them in your life in some way. 00:48:27.2400000 That circle gets a little more diverse. And then the outer ring or those acquaintances we say hi to, we're like, oh, I know Joe, I sat by him in class. Those rings. And the point of this is, is we didn't list any family members, only co workers, friends. Now if you think about that and that every human being does that and you build these relationships of ride or die, middle ring, outer ring in the work environment. 00:48:49.8400000 And if you are a supervisor over any of those people, who are you going to promote first? Who are you going to give the best job assignments to? Who are you going to want to take out to lunch with clients? It's going to be the ride or die first. And so then you. 00:49:03.6000000 And if those were most like you in characteristics, you can start to see where subconsciously it comes into play. And so again, we have to be very, very careful. We have about seven minutes left here. So I'm just going to quickly go through some of these examples very quickly. Just different scenarios. 00:49:23.0900000 This one was a sexual harassment environment. Quid pro quo. Again, violation two year suspension in 2019. You can look at the case there, the citations on the screen in front of you. Another one here. 00:49:36.4900000 This was another. Sexual harassment discounted legal fees for sex acts. Now, yes, there is violations rule 1.8, no sex with client and both of these two. But just think of the civility, the 8.4g, 8.4d that could be tacked on as well. This one was a one year suspended sentence in 2010 in New Jersey. 00:49:55.3500000 This one we had an attorney who didn't like the judge presiding over his client's case and the attorney decided to tell his clients he didn't like the judge presiding over their case in emails. Remember that Exhibit A I talked about a little earlier. If you're going to do something against the rules of ethics, do not put it in writing. Do not. That's common sense. 00:50:14.5200000 Let's come on. Do not put in writing because that's going to be zhibit A at your disciplinary hearing. Exhibit A at any malpractice suit, which is what happened here to Mr. Abrams. He was talking about the judge using derogatory slurs, talking about the judge's sexual orientation, calling him a wussy, saying he'd been bullied as a child because he was more feminine. 00:50:31.5200000 All different kinds of bias, prejudice coming out in writing to his clients whose case was pending in front of this judge. They fired him, turned him into the disciplinary commission. Three years to three months suspension in Colorado in 2020. Be careful of our conduct. This one, Stacey L. 00:50:47.8400000 Kelly, her husband, she pretended to be her husband's attorney. So she's putting herself in that practice of law realm now, Indiana. And I will tell you, because you can look at the date there on the bottom, 2010. Indiana has had Rule 8.4g on its books long before the model rules adopted it. And so Kelly put herself in the practicing law realm by claiming to be her husband's attorney. 00:51:10.6600000 When she called back a telemarketer, she told the telemarketer he sounded gay or sweet because he had a feminine sounding voice. Protected classes, professionalism, civility, public reprimand here in Indiana. This is when I said, watch out for those emails. This was lawyer McCarthy in response to opposing counsel, secretary or legal assistant saying, hey, my attorney wants to schedule a meeting with you. Can you send me over some dates and times so we can mutually find a mutually available time? 00:51:37.8900000 Sweet little email, you know. Mr. McCarthy sent a response saying, I know you must do your boss's bidding at his direction, but I am here to tell you that I am neither you or his. Said a very derogatory word. You do not tell me what to do. 00:51:49.8500000 You ask. If you ever like this again, it'll be the last time I ever give any thought to your existence and your boss will have to talk to me. Do we understand each other? That was a bad day for Mr. McCarthy that cost him his law license. 00:52:02.2100000 30 day suspension without automatic reinstatement, which means he has to fill in an application and reapply and the bar can deny him at that point. And they have denied him since that incident. This is one. If you just Google twerking lawyer right now, this was a year or two ago, will come up during a mediation that throws a discovery. One of the counsel, plaintiff's counsel, excuse me, lead defense counsel, decided to bend over, shake his butt up and down that gyrating action of called twerking in front of opposing counsel while uttering profanities about opposing counsel's sexual orientation, which you can see there in the first paragraph. 00:52:39.5100000 Paragraph on the screen, the action was described as a lavacious gyrating of the lower fleshly extremity. Plaintiff filed for sanctions. Defense counsel's response to the sanctions motions was let's just put this in the rearview mirror. Probably didn't want to say rear view when we had a butt shaking incident but you know, council's use of words is their choice. Judge said no sanctions. 00:53:01.1100000 The attorney suffer enough because it has national attention. You can google twerking lawyer and find this guy. Texas does not have 8.4g. It's one of the jurisdictions that refused to adopt it. But they do have 8.044 prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:53:16.7300000 This is another discovery one. This is one where opposing counsel was frustrated with the opposite side, grabbed the table, ducked her head underneath. Opposing counsel goes, what are you doing? She goes, looking to see if there's anything between your legs. She realized it was not her finest moment because she was chronically and persistently exposed to condescending behavior. 00:53:36.2400000 Violation of 8.4g, probably 8.4d and maybe a sanctions motion thrown in there too. Again, discovery can get us every time. This is just one of those examples where we don't use someone's race unless it's related to the case. This was someone used the black guy, the black man, which was irrelevant to the issues at hand. Public reprimand. 00:53:56.5600000 This was where we used u. S. Citizenship or non citizenship when it was not related to the case. Public reprimand. Indiana is a breeding ground for incivility. 00:54:06.0500000 Can you tell various conduct here. Attorneys faced. We don't need to say stupid idiot. Go back to puerto Rico. We got a two year rep. 00:54:13.6900000 Two year probation and public reprimand for that. In florida. I don't have to talk to you, little lady. Tell that mouse to go pipe down. Be quiet, little girl. 00:54:22.6100000 Go away, little girl. That was actually another public reprimand and probation. I think in New York there's just go get your foul odious body on the other side. Don't use those sheeny hebrew tricks with me. Let's not bring religion into it. 00:54:37.0700000 There was some other violations there and he got suspended from the practice of law for that comment. So again, watch those emails. Watch mouthing off. It's not a joke. It's going to be exhibit a. 00:54:48.4300000 There is a case where a defense, or excuse me, a criminal defendant proved his attorney was biased against him based on race and got his murder conviction overturned for it. So again, we have to be very careful, put in those firm policies, have initiatives, have training, because the only way we can combat incivility and unprofessionalism is one to be honest about it and know that if we have a brain, we have a bias and it's okay and to talk about it. And yes, social unrest can play into how firms and how attorneys really address this. I thank everyone for attending, and please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you.