[Course Name] 00:00:01.3600000 Hi everybody. Welcome to Alphabet Soup for Installment Agreements. This is a one hour presentation and I'm going to delve into this topic of installment agreements. A little bit about me. I am Mike Tablis, for those of you who have seen some of the lectures I've been presenting on topics specific to two areas, those being litigation and the other being tax law. 00:00:31.1900000 And I usually get comments such as, wow, that's like two radically different areas and how did you get into them? So I'll just give you a quick rundown. Basically, my beginnings, if you will, were in the office of the public defender. When I got out of law school, I knew I wanted to be a trial attorney like my dad, who litigated hundreds of cases and was a fierce advocate for the disenfranchised. At the same time, in my last year of law school, I did an externship for a white collar criminal defense firm in New Jersey that was representing a client who was charged with money laundering. 00:01:16.4800000 He was the CEO of a large computer distribution company that was selling computers in Colombia, in South America, and who had been wrapped up in the black market peso exchange. I came on board right when the defense. Right when the firm was preparing motion practice. And I was asked to draft a motion to do two things to reduce or to basically to circumscribe or to, you know, to bring in a lot of the. Not to bring in, I'm sorry, it's been a long last two days. 00:02:05.7600000 It was basically a motion to a motion to prevent the government from introducing the testimony that they wanted to introduce through their expert witness. So that was motion number one. And motion number two happened to be a motion related to the tax crimes that the defendant had been charged with. Amongst other things, he was charged with tax crimes. And I knew very little, if anything about tax evasion. 00:02:38.5400000 I knew very little if anything about failure to file a return. And so I delved into the Internal Revenue Code and I learned a lot about tax crimes. And with that knowledge, I was able to put together a motion to dismiss. And those two motions were argued amongst the other motions that we had. And that piqued my interest in tax law. 00:03:03.9000000 I realized that I wanted to come back to that area later on. But I also realized that it was a minefield without a background in tax because I had no formal background in accounting. And, you know, I realized that it was going to require going back to school some years later and getting my LLM in tax law, which I did. So what I've done today basically is married my two interests of litigation with tax practice. And not only do I specialize in criminal tax defense, but I also am really fell into this by accident. 00:03:44.6300000 But I have a niche practice in the area of international tax compliance, helping US Expats to come into compliance with their US Tax obligations. I also specialize in civil tax controversies. So these presentations in the tax series are born out of my experience in, you know, nearly 10 years doing tax practice. And I do very much hope that you find this information helpful because you might want to, well, find yourself in a position where you know somebody, specifically an accountant or an enrolled agent, who wants to refer a client to you for a consultation on any one of these matters. I Covered Offers and Compromise About a week and a half ago this topic is on installment agreements, which might be considered the sister program to an offering compromise. 00:04:41.5700000 So what is an installment agreement? It's an option for taxpayers who cannot pay their entire tax bills by the due date. It allows taxpayers to pay the amount, too, over a period of time. So the difference primarily between an offering compromise and an installment agreement is that in an offering compromise, the taxpayer is making an offer to pay a lesser sum of money than what is otherwise due in full satisfaction for the amount that the IRS is asserting the taxpayer owes. So, for example, if the IRS is asserting a $50,000 deficiency, and we should be very specific in what these terms mean, a deficiency is very simply the difference between the amount that the IRS asserts the taxpayer owes after conducting an examination minus the amount that the taxpayer self disclosed on that year's returns. 00:05:48.2700000 So if the IRS is alleging that there was $100,000 of unreported gross income and the taxpayer has alleged or the taxpayer has declared $50,000 of gross income on the return, there's a deficit of $50,000 of undeclared gross income that is going to translate into a tax deficiency, an amount that's due and owing above and beyond that which the taxpayer declared on their return. That is the simple definition of what a deficiency is. And what we're saying here is that if the IRS deems that that $50,000 of unreported gross income translates into, say, a $10,000 tax deficiency, and the taxpayer doesn't have $10,000 to pay, but instead has $5,000 to pay in full satisfaction and has good reasons for why he doesn't have the full $10,000, then through an offering compromise, the taxpayer may be able to pay the $5,000 in full satisfaction, meaning that the IRS will forgive the difference of $5,000, that is between 10,000, the amount that they believe is due and owing, minus 5,000, the amount that the taxpayer has available to pay. An installment agreement, on the other hand, basically says, hey, you, the taxpayer owe the government $10,000 on that, unreported, on an unreported $50,000 of gross income. And by submitting this installment agreement, we are not letting you off the hook for the complete amount of $50,000, but instead we are going to allow you to set up a payment plan with us. 00:07:54.6400000 And over the course of these next few years, if you will, you're going to make in good faith a monthly installment payment towards the, the, towards the tax deficiency. And so that's the difference again between an installment agreement and an offering compromise. In an offering compromise, there is no, there is a, there is the taxpayer making an offer for a lesser amount to satisfy a tax debt. And if the IRS accepts it, then they are forgiving, in essence, a certain percentage of the taxpayer's tax bill. And so the offer is in full satisfaction for the tax bill. 00:08:40.5600000 Whereas in the installment agreement, there is no dispute about the underlying tax deficiency. If it's 10,000, it's $10,000. It's just that the taxpayer is submitting a special installment agreement in the hopes that it will be accepted so that they will have more time to pay this instead of having to do it in one lump sum. And if they, if the taxpayer doesn't pursue an installment agreement and just simply sits on their hands and does nothing, then the irs, of course, can begin collection actions. Because once an assessment has been made against the taxpayer, all that's left is for the tax, is for the IRS to collect what is due and owing to them. 00:09:27.5600000 So to thwart that from happening, the taxpayer will attempt to submit an installment agreement. Now, once a taxpayer is granted an installment agreement, the agreement remains in effect as long as the taxpayer meets the terms of the agreement. If the taxpayer stops making the required payments, he'll be notified that the installment agreement will be terminated. There are times when collections may reject a taxpayer's request. So I want to make something very clear at the outset here. 00:10:02.9100000 Just because a taxpayer has made an installment agreement doesn't mean that the IRS has an obligation to accept it. The IRS may reject the installment agreement for any one of a myriad of reasons. One being, of course, that the IRS believes that the taxpayer is liquid enough to make the payment in one lump sum, or perhaps has enough assets, whether it be real property or tangible property, to sell or to leverage against in order to pay the tax deficiency. Now. So, yes, there are times when collections may reject a taxpayer's request for an installment agreement if they believe that it does not reflect the taxpayer's ability to pay his or her tax liability. 00:11:00.2500000 Although revenue officers are instructed to request immediate payment of an outstanding liability, it'll be obvious to the IRS when a taxpayer is unable to comply with such a request. Why? Well, it's not as simple as the taxpayer sending a letter to the IRS saying, dear irs, I request an installment agreement. If that were the case, then everybody would be doing that. There are forms, standardized forms, that the taxpayer has to fill out, which require the taxpayer to make disclosures about their financial assets that many a taxpayer wouldn't want the IRS to know about. 00:11:40.5600000 So is it intrusive? Absolutely. Is it. Can it be as painful as a colonoscopy? Well, depending on how you look at these four forms, it is a wealth of information that the taxpayer is obligated to disclose to the irs. 00:11:57.1700000 And so, you know, a lot of taxpayers are deterred from doing an installment agreement for the very reason that this information, you know, they rather not disclose to the IRS because it's kind of like opening up the kimono, if you will, and letting them look under the, under the hood of all of their holdings. And, you know, and when that happens, of course, the IRS can point to different holdings and assets and, you know, say, well, how about this? How about that? And, oh, you know, we didn't really know about that, you know, in your, in last year's tax return. That's interesting. 00:12:37.6400000 So these are, these are way. This is how tax controversies actually begin and how they mutate into referrals to criminal investigations. It's always the taxpayer who has the information that, when disclosed to the irs, can and does get used against them. It's almost equivalent to you giving the IRS the ammunition they need to, to pursue a litigation or to make a referral to CI. And so you want to be very careful here and have these discussions with your clients up front. 00:13:24.3900000 Although revenue officers are instructed to request immediate payment of an outstanding liability, it'll be obvious to the IRS again, when a taxpayer is unable to comply with these requests. Deferred payments. As an alternative to enforced collection action, the IRS may be willing to defer payment. The revenue officer can grant an extension of time to pay for up to 120 days without supervisor approval if the taxpayer needs additional time to assess funds. So this might be the path of least resistance, because with a deferred payment, you don't need to formally submit an installment agreement, you get the 120 additional days and maybe, just maybe, it'll do it. 00:14:10.7000000 Those 120 days. It'll allow the taxpayer the time he or she needs to come into a settlement perhaps or to sell property that needs to be liquidated in order for the taxpayer to pay the debt, the tax debt. Formal installment agreement. These are meant for taxpayers who have serious liquidity problems. Payments under a formal installment agreement ordinarily include an interest charge computed on the unpaid balance. 00:14:40.3800000 As we all know, interest can and sometimes is more onerous than penalties than civil tax penalties themselves. So always be mindful of the fact that there are going to be interest charges there that accrue what happens if the IRS rejects a proposed installment agreement? So one thing I can say from my years of practicing tax practice is that there's good and there's bad when it comes to the taxpayers ability to exercise due process. When the IRS turns them down and rejects a proposed installment agreement of the likes here. And even when the taxpayer is audited and the IRS believes that the taxpayer under reported gross income and that the taxpayer has a higher amount of tax that they should have self reported in that year's returns, it doesn't mean that the taxpayer is stuck with having to pay that additional tax. 00:15:54.6800000 The taxpayer has due process to challenge that tax deficiency. How might the taxpayer do that? In the example I just gave where there's an audit that leads to the IRS revenue agent asserting and a higher amount of tax? Well, the taxpayer would submit what's called a protest and a protest would be lodged in the appeals division of the irs. There is an appeals division of the IRS which is not a court. 00:16:27.2200000 It is similar to a mediation department or it is similar to like a workers. No, I wouldn't go that far. No, it's like a mediator, what they call it IRS appeals. The IRS appeals officer is the arbiter of the dispute between the IRS who's represented by the IRS by the IRS revenue agent on the one hand and second the taxpayer on the other hand. The appeals officer will basically review the dispute. 00:17:04.9700000 Once the taxpayer has filed their protest, which is basically documenting the disagreement, the disagreement that he or she has with this, with the audit and with the assertion that he owes more than what he has self disclosed on the return. And then the appeals officer makes a decision. They are the umpire. If the taxpayer is dissatisfied with the appeals officer's ruling and they are, very frequently they will be able to file a petition in the US Tax court. So now we have two levels of due Process, if you will. 00:17:46.9400000 The first level being to the appeals officer and then the second level being to the US Tax court, which is an article, I believe they call it Article three court. I always get my Article one versus Article three confused. A traditional federal court basically is not the same as tax court. Tax court is basically what you know. I don't want to say that it's like a workers comp court, but in terms of how the judges, the judges are. 00:18:26.1900000 It is more like a workers comp court. The judges are the arbiters of the dispute. They hear all of the cases and they make, they're the triers of fact. They make decisions and make rulings. And those rulings sometimes get published, sometimes they are unpublished. 00:18:46.3700000 That is the next step for due process. If the taxpayer is still dissatisfied after the appeals officer rules against them, and if the, if the tax court judge rules against the taxpayer, the taxpayer can still appeal from there to a higher court. And that would be the circuit court of appeals for which the taxpayer resided at the time they filed their petition to the US Tax Court. So if the taxpayer resided in Roseland, good old Roseland, New Jersey at the time they filed the petition to get into tax court and the tax court judge ruled against them, then they would appeal to the third Circuit Court of Appeals because that's the circuit that embodies or encompasses the state of New Jersey where the taxpayer lived at the time they filed the petition. So we have all these rules going on. 00:19:42.3900000 But my point in all of this is that the taxpayer always has due process. However, where things can go south fast is when the taxpayer does not act within the time that they are allotted to file this protest, to file this petition. And these timelines are very strict so that if the taxpayer runs afoul of filing a protest by even one day, by even one hour, then they will be barred from being able to challenge the deficiency in this example before the IRS appeals officer. However, so there's different timelines. It's 30 days from the date that they get what's called. 00:20:36.4400000 They get a revenue agent's letter, that's what they call it, that announces a deficiency. And essentially they have 30 days from the date that is labeled on that letter to file a protest to the appeals office. If they lose that, then they will get what's called a notice of deficiency. And then the notice of deficiency is a 90 day letter. It is basically their ticket to get into tax court. 00:21:06.0800000 Upon receiving that 90 day letter or notice of deficiency, they will then have 90 days from the date listed on that letter to file a petition in the US Tax Court. And that's how it progresses. Essentially, there's tactics involved. Some taxpayers refuse to go through IRS appeals because they feel that IRS appeals officers are biased in favor of the irs and for good reason, because they're paid by the IRS and they're employed of the irs. So notwithstanding, you know, the tools or not withstanding Congress's efforts to try to make IRS appeals as neutral as humanly possible. 00:21:46.8700000 They are human. They're only human. And so a lot of taxpayers prefer to just bypass appeals altogether and have the matter heard in US Tax Corp. Another thing to consider is that the deficiency amount does not have to be put in escrow or what you might call. Yeah, it doesn't have to be put up as leverage in order to get access to tax court. 00:22:12.0800000 So it is the type of forum that is very friendly, tax friendly to the taxpayer. Because in federal court, if the taxpayer wants to dispute heard there, they would have to put the deficiency amount up as collateral in the federal court before they would be able to go that route. And so there are strategies for why a taxpayer would want to go one route over another. They would want to go to federal court. If they would want a jury to preside over the civil tax controversy in the tax court direction, it is a tax court judge who would hear the proceeding, the benefit. 00:22:51.7400000 And you know, there's all sorts of pros and cons, but with a tax court judge, they usually have backgrounds in accounting and they usually have their master's in tax law. So you're getting someone who is proficient in the tax code and who might have, even in a prior life, have been an accountant. So these are all things on the side. But circling all the way back now to what exists as far as due process concerns is concerned. If the IRS rejects a proposed installment agreement, the taxpayer has 30 days in which to file an administrative appeal with the IRS Appeals Division. 00:23:26.6300000 Taxpayers can appeal the rejection of a proposed installment agreement as part of a collection due process hearing as well. Levy action. And this is very, very important because we're going to be. You need to distinguish two things in your mind whenever we're in the tax. In the realm of tax, there's going to be two critical, critical, time sensitive issues that you as a tax attorney must be so in tune to. 00:23:55.7600000 The first is levy action or collection action. And the second is the statute of limitations. All right, let's first address levy action. Levy action, of course, is the taxpayer's worst nightmare. It is when the IRS resorts to basically coming out and taking, seizing the property. 00:24:22.3100000 And it could be a bank account, it could be a car. It could be, in the most extreme cases, a lien on real property, including the primary home, Although it is, it would take a lot for the IRS to foreclose on a lien of a primary home. But then again, there are taxpayers with secondary homes, vacation homes that the IRS will not think twice about foreclosing on if the deficiency amount is substantial. And if they've been knocking on the taxpayer's door for quite some time and the taxpayer has just been completely lost in the sauce and has completely been completely dug their head in the sand and not given the matter any attention whatsoever. So, yes, levy action and collection action is a very important issue. 00:25:20.5600000 And so we want to pay attention to is it suspended or can it continue notwithstanding the filing of an installment, the application of an installment agreement? And so let's just deal with levy action for a second. Levy action is suspended by law if a rejected or terminated installment agreement is appealed within 30 days of notification of rejection. So there's a few things going on, and I might have skipped this. I usually spell this out more specifically, when the taxpayer files an installment agreement, a period of weeks, if not months, is going to go by while the IRS is reviewing it. 00:26:06.2600000 And during that time, levy action is suspended. So it's not something where the taxpayer has to risk that the IRS will begin levy action after he or she has submitted their installment agreement. It is suspended during the time that the IRS is, is reviewing the installment agreement. All right, so that we get that squared away, this slide is dealing with a scenario where the, where the installment agreement has been rejected by the IRS and the taxpayer appeals the rejection within the allowable time frame of 30 days. If such conditions happen, then the levy action will be continued to be suspended. 00:27:02.9000000 All right, so again, what would happen is that during the time that the installment agreement is being reviewed, levy action is suspended. Even after an installment agreement is rejected, the levy action could continue to be suspended so long as the taxpayer appeals the, the rejection of the installment agreement within 30 days of the rejection letter. All right, A lot. I realize that, that, that, that is a lot. But we want to be very clear on this. 00:27:38.7700000 And these timelines, again, are very strict. If you miss the timeline, I'm not talking about just days. I'm talking about hours. One minute will be enough to bar the taxpayer from, you know, from enjoying any type of right to challenge or contest a rejected agreement. So we want to be very, very careful. 00:28:04.7900000 Now, I talked about something else that you as a tax attorney have to be super, super focused on. That is the statute of limitations. In the tax world, these two things levy actions and whether they are suspended or ongoing. And number two, the statute of limitations are huge. There is in the tax world two primary statutes of limitation. 00:28:33.1200000 There is, number one, the statute of limitations on assessment, and number two, there is a statute of limitations on collection. So assessment is a very fine term of art in tax parlance. It means that the IRS has conducted an examination and has determined that a deficiency exists, meaning that the taxpayer owes more than what they self reported on that year's return. However, it goes even another step forward. It says that the assessment says that the taxpayer has gone through all the collection due process rights that they had available to them by literally having gone to court or by not having done anything. 00:29:30.6400000 And then the statute of limitations has passed and now this deficiency amount has become a full fledged debt of the taxpayer. In other words, it's too late for the taxpayer to dispute the underlying tax liability anymore. That train has left the station and this amount is a debt of the taxpayer, meaning all that's left is for the taxpayer to collect. The what is for the irs, I'm sorry, to collect what is rightfully theirs. That is what assessment means. 00:30:09.2000000 So we have two things going on. We have the statute of limitations on making an assessment, which is the last step before collections, and then we have the statute of limitations on collections itself. For the statute of limitations on assessment, there is a period in which the IRS has from the time the tax return from the, from the, from the tax return due date in which to trigger, in which to begin an audit of the taxpayer's return. And typically that period of time, and I don't want to get it wrong because I always, I always get, I always get, look back periods in my voluntary disclosure world, confused with statute limitations periods for assessments. But it's typically four, sometimes six years. 00:31:08.7900000 And so that period of time is critical in the tax world because if you think about it, if the IRS tries to go back more than that period of statute of limitations to begin an audit, then they can't do that. And that is a non starter. And that would be the first way that a tax practitioner pushes back, pushes the IRS back from the possibility of making an assessment against a taxpayer by not being able to do the examination in the first place. So that is what the statute of limitations on the assessment is. We need now to know these terms of art. 00:31:56.4800000 What does it mean then for a statute of limitations to Be told versus run. So if you think about it from this perspective, if the statute of limitations is running, who does it benefit? If a statute of limitations is running, it benefits the taxpayer. Why? Because time is going against the IRS within which to begin an examination if that clock keeps ticking. 00:32:25.6700000 Ticking, ticking, ticking. What we call statute of limitations. Running, running, running, running is favorable and inures to the benefit of the taxpayer because the IRS is losing time within which to galvanize their examination division together to undertake an audit, which will almost always result in a deficiency of the taxpayer. On the other hand, tolling. Tolling means stopped. 00:32:53.7300000 Who would you think the tolling of a statute of limitations would favor in the tax world? And it's not a trick question. It's either the IRS on the one hand or the taxpayer on the other. The tolling of a statute would inure to the benefit of the irs. Why? 00:33:11.9700000 Because it's now taking what is otherwise a definite fixed period of time and prolonging it. Because the clock now is not ticking. It's frozen. It is frozen in time. And so we say tolling. 00:33:29.7000000 So knowing whether tolling is friendly towards one side versus the other is very helpful in keeping these terms fresh in your mind so that you're not. You're not laboring over, oh, I forgot, you know this. I've memorized it this way. Is it that way or not? I was never taught it that way. 00:33:50.3700000 And I struggled with these concepts in my first year of my LLM program to no end. So I only. I say that not to re. Not to try to. Not to try to, you know, not to. 00:34:06.9700000 Not to try to be deprecating or anything, but to set down some key concepts, because everything is building in tax. Everything is building. And to have a solid foundation of these concepts is going to be so helpful to understanding the more complicated concepts that do come up in this world of installment agreements. So now we have knowledge of these two core concepts. We can talk about the statute of limitations on assessment, and now we can talk about the statute of limitations on collection. 00:34:39.2090000 All that means now is that there's been an assessment. Correct? And all that's left for the irs, once again, when there's been an assessment, is for the IRS to undertake collection of the amount that is a debt of the taxpayers. And guess what? The irs, even though they have the assessment, it's like a bird in the hand. 00:35:04.9100000 They still have a statute of limitations within which to collect that amount of money. And that's why we have this installment agreement program, because the IRS knows very well, that astute taxpayers might, let's say, turn a blind eye to this liability and in the hopes that the statute of limitations on collections will continue to run and run and run and run like the dog Lassie all the way down the field and as if it never even happened. And who would that inure? To the benefit of the taxpayer, of course, because now the IRS is left holding the bag. And if it happens once or twice, of course, you know, it wouldn't be so earth shattering. 00:35:56.2850000 But. But can you imagine if every taxpayer who owed the IRS a debt used the statute of limitations on collection as a sword and offensively to just sit back and let that period lapse without making any payment, and then once it does lapse, walk away and say, ha, got you. The IRS knows this very well. So this is why we have an installment agreement program. And this is why you know that the irs. 00:36:32.8300000 The IRS knows these things in advance. And in order to combat this type of conduct that every taxpayer might try to take advantage of, The IRS has all of this ammunition in their coffer, if you will, or in their, oh, God, I'm just thinking right now, in their bow and arrow case, whatever, to combat this. Levy action is one, and then we have statute of limitations on the other. So levy action again, we talked about this. I don't want to beat this with a. 00:37:09.7700000 Like a dead horse. Let's talk about the application process for installment agreements. Taxpayers must submit form 9466. That is an installment agreement request. You can Google it. 00:37:22.0400000 It comes right up. You can complete it online. The IRS is authorized to collect a small fee for entering the agreement and for modifying it. If the IRS accepts the installment agreement, it'll charge the taxpayer processing fee $105 for a basic agreement and $45 for restructuring an existing agreement. These prices have probably gone up due to inflation. 00:37:45.8700000 When I prepared this presentation last, it's been. It was a while back for accountants, so I apologize if those figures are off. Installment agreements need not provide for the full amount of the accrued taxes, penalties, and interest. In that sense, they bear some of the attributes of offers in compromise. During the period that installment agreement request is pending, the IRS may not levy on the taxpayer's property. 00:38:11.6400000 And that gives the taxpayer some peace of mind, knowing that the IRS can't do anything underhanded and take advantage of a situation where the taxpayer has in good faith made an application for an installment agreement. The IRS cannot do anything underhanded like try to levy on the taxpayer's property during that time Period. Automatic acceptance, statutory or guaranteed agreements. There are certain agreements that if they meet a certain requisite or certain threshold, will automatically be accepted. There are, I guess you would call it. 00:38:55.1300000 I'm trying to think right now. 00:39:00.1700000 Yeah, there's metrics. Yeah, that's what I'm thinking about, metrics. There's metrics that when applied and that meet certain thresholds that are instituted by the IRS will automatically be accepted. There are streamlined agreements and there's the Fresh Start program. So let's talk about statutory or guaranteed agreements. 00:39:21.0800000 In limited circumstances, the code requires the IRS to accept an individual taxpayer's installment agreement request for statutory agreements. No. Collection information statement needs to be completed. Collection information statement is what I was talking about earlier. That is very, very, very intrusive and it digs very deep. 00:39:43.1900000 They want to know everything when it comes to the taxpayers. Holdings and ownership, interest in tax ownership, interest in bank accounts, IRAs, retirement. Oh my gosh, it just goes on and on and on and on. And a lot of taxpayers just don't have the stomach to fill something like that out and, you know, much less turn it over to the IRS to be used as ammunition to, you know, quite frankly dispute the terms of the installment agreement. So they're basically taking the information that you're giving them and using it again against you. 00:40:26.1600000 Now let's talk about those circumstances where acceptance is guaranteed. The IRS must accept the agreement. If these conditions are satisfied, the unpaid amount is less than $10,000, exclusive of interest and penalties. Oh, and let's go back to something else. And this took me like two years to really understand as a non accountant, but which of course, all accountants in the program understood, you know, better than the professors themselves. 00:41:00.8700000 When we talk about, when we talk about unreported or undisclosed gross income. Well, there's two ways, right, that the IRS can assert a tax deficiency, and that is by a taxpayer underreporting gross income or over reporting deductions. We don't see it as commonly with overstating of deductions. The IRS much prefers to dig their teeth into the big whales that underreport gross income. But the point that I want to make here, and we're getting into numbers a little bit, I referenced this a little earlier. 00:41:46.6500000 Just when we talk about an under reported amount of gross income, it might be, you know, 20, 30, 40, 50, whatever, that has to be translated, that's one amount, but it's got to be translated into what? Tax attributable or associated with that amount. What is the tax unreported tax associated now with that amount. But we do look in terms of under reported amounts when it comes to IRS policies as to what types of cases get referred to CI for criminal investigations. And I'll give you a very simple reason for that. 00:42:31.7000000 Good tax attorneys, when they are, when they are given a case involving a client that has been referred to CI by the IRS Examinations Division for under reported gross income, rule number one is you're going to get a forensic accountant involved. Why? We want to work down the under reported gross income amount to a level that may preclude the case from, from getting the referral to CI or if it's made, if the referral is made to CI, from escalating beyond CI to the criminal Investigation Division of DOJ where it could be prosecuted. So they hire a forensic accountant to look for any and all deductions that the taxpayer could have taken but didn't take on the their return. And guess what? 00:43:29.8600000 There will always be a myriad of additional deductions that the taxpayer did not avail themselves of. And this is all done to get down that key number that is going to sway the case from civil to criminal. But suffice to say, most of the time we're dealing with the underreported gross income number because the government knows that the good criminal tax attorneys are going to work the corresponding tax liability down from extrapolating from that underreported gross income amount. So it's the under reported gross income amount that the IRS focuses on the most in making decisions as to referrals to CI, for example. So when I talk about underreported gross income, it's not the same as the unreported tax liability. 00:44:31.6400000 That's all I'm trying to say. That's the point I'm trying to make here. If I talk about $10,000 of underreported gross income, that's not the tax that the IRS is asserting the taxpayer owes. It is taking that underreported gross income and extrapolating it into what the tax due and owing is. And a lot of times that depends on, you know, the deductions, all of the additional deductions that the taxpayer might have been entitled to that he didn't take and that the forensic accountant is going to uncover for us in the course of discovery. 00:45:11.9400000 So here we're talking about conditions in which the IRS must accept the agreement. First, the unpaid amount is less than $10,000 exclusive, exclusive of interest and penalties. Second, within the last five years, the taxpayer has filed all required income returns and paid Any tax shown on those returns. So we're checking the list off. It's a laundry list. 00:45:34.7900000 It's a grocery list. We're checking it off. Third, the taxpayer agrees to pay the outstanding liability in full within three years. So three years is a cap. Four, the taxpayer agrees to comply with the tax laws and the agreement while the agreement is in effect. 00:45:53.7800000 Streamlined agreements and the Fresh Start program. The IRS also has a streamlined applications process that results in automatic acceptance. The Fresh Start program provides more taxpayers with the opportunity to use streamlined installment agreements to catch up on back taxes. Its purpose is to help individuals and businesses pay back taxes and more easily and with less burden. So long as the taxpayer meets his obligations under the agreement, the IRS will not file liens or take other collection action. 00:46:24.8800000 Effective March of 2012, the threshold for using an installment agreement without having to submit a financial statement, which again, is very intrusive to the IRS, which was raised, it was raised from 25,000 to $50,000. So that's very, you know, that's newest. To the benefit of the taxpayer. Taxpayers who owe up to $50,000 in back taxes may now enter into a streamlined agreement with the IRS that stretches the payment out over a series of months or years. The maximum term for streamlined installment agreements has also been raised. 00:47:02.9900000 So instead of 36 months, it's been raised. Oh, I'm sorry. Instead of 60 month max, it's been raised to 72 months, which is another favorable advancement for the taxpayer. Taxpayers seeking installment agreements exceeding 50 grand must still supply the IRS with a collection information statement. Taxpayers may also pay down. 00:47:24.8000000 Oh, this is what's really cool. So if you have a taxpayer, for example, that owes, say, $60,000, but doesn't want to pay or doesn't want to fill out this ugly collection information statement that is going to disclose more things than what they want the IRS to know. Well, the taxpayer can pay $10,000 and lower the amount down to 50. And by lowering that amount down to 50, they now have the benefit of not having to fill out the collection information statement. And so that's a strategy that you can talk to them about if they have the $10,000 in cash and they are adamantly against the collection information statement. 00:48:19.3200000 That's one way to circumvent having to fill out the collection information statement. Pay $10,000, get that 60 down to 50, and now you can submit your installment agreement without a collection information statement. In order to qualify for the new expanded streamline installment agreement, taxpayers must agree to monthly direct debit payments, conditional acceptance under A conditional acceptance. The taxpayer's ability to enter into an installment agreement is largely within the discretion of the irs. The IRS will only approve such an agreement if one, the taxpayer is compliant with filing and payment obligations for the current year. 00:49:01.3800000 Two, the taxpayer is truly unable to make an immediate payment in full. Taxpayers must furnish a financial statement, form 433A. Everything has a number in the IRS world. Don't get so fixated with it. A lot like, here's the thing, accountants are so good with the numbers of the form, they'll spit them out like that. 00:49:24.8400000 And to me, that's a lot like us in law school. Having memorized the case names, it's helpful, but it's not critical for me, I could never remember the case name, and so I would really rely on the holding and the facts to jog my memory. And so you don't have to get so fixated with the actual form numbers. I suppose accountants, for good reason, know these numbers because they're on the front lines all the time filling these forms out. Taxpayers must furnish a financial statement describing their assets and liabilities, bank accounts, employment information, and future income prospects, which is very speculative. 00:50:06.0800000 That's why I don't like these forms at all. The IRS will review Form 433A to determine whether the taxpayer's assets prepared provide a readily available source for payment. In doing so, the IRS will determine the taxpayer's equity and assets and his or her ability to use these assets as collateral to borrow from third parties in order to pay the liability. Second, whether the taxpayer has any big ticket items, airplanes, yachts, that could be sold to satisfy the liability. And third, the taxpayer's cash flow based on monthly income expense information. 00:50:43.2500000 A good, an interesting fact. There was a case, I remember reading when I was in my LLM program about lawyers who owed mounts to the irs. And there was, I believe in this case, a personal injury attorney who was, who was attempting to avail himself, I believe, of an offering compromise, not an installment agreement. So he was attempting to make an offer to the IRS for much less than what the assessment was, in full satisfaction of that assessment. And so the irs, as a means of looking into what they call future income prospects, they asked the attorney for all information relating to contingency fee agreements on his personal injury cases. 00:51:46.8400000 I mean, my God. And yes, the attorney actually provided that information and the offering compromise was accepted. However, the terms of the offering compromise request required a percentage of, of settlements of a certain number of these cases that were over a certain amount. My God. Like I, I, I mean it must have been a lot more than, you know, a small amount of money that the attorney was trying to compromise. 00:52:18.9800000 But my lord, I mean, I just, I just, I, I can't wrap my head around that. I can't imagine why the attorney would have gone to the lengths of doing an offering compromise and disclosing such information, much less agreeing to percentages of future cases, future income from these cases that we all know. You know, it's just, it's so speculative. You know, you might one day think that, you know, you've got a settlement in hand for X number of dollars only to learn that, you know, two weeks later it's going to be half that amount or that the client has rejected it and now we're starting from ground zero. So I wouldn't want anything, any amounts owed or any agreement with the IRS to be tied to contingency agreements that are so speculative that, you know, we can't count on them. 00:53:18.0300000 So be very careful with that because that one case really stood in my mind. If the taxpayer's assets don't provide a readily available source for payment, in other words, the taxpayer has no equity in the assets or they are not readily disposable. The IRS will collect the tax through payments based on the taxpayer's disposable income. A taxpayer's disposable income is based on information in the collection information statement. 433A. 00:53:44.9300000 When evaluating the amount to be paid, the the revenue officer must make an objective economic judgment as to how much the IRS can collect without jeopardizing the taxpayer's ability to support his family, pay current taxes and earn income from which to pay future installments. So this is why this, you know, overly broad collection information statement is required. Because how you, we need to know, the IRS needs to know, know who they're dealing with. Are they dealing with a 52 year old CEO of a telecommunications company who is single, without any kids, no dependents, and you know, is earning half a million dollars a year versus a mid level executive in an advertising agency that's earning $180,000 a year with three kids under the age of 18, one of which is a minor, and a wife who doesn't work and you know, a family, a close family member who has cancer. So all of these things, you know, it becomes a very specific examination into the taxpayer. 00:55:03.5600000 And like I said, these are personal matters. Doesn't mean though that these installment agreements don't get accepted with frequency. They do, they oftentimes do, but it does mean that the taxpayer becomes an open book of sorts. The idea is to give the taxpayer a minimum fair living amount, subtract that amount from income and require him to pay the balance in installments. In allowing living expenses, the revenue officer will generally be constrained by national and local state standards for reasonable amounts of living expenses. 00:55:38.0700000 Food, housing, entertainment. Although special circumstances such as medical needs may cause the IRS to deviate from these standards, if the revenue officer approves an installment agreement, the officer will generally insist on an immediate payment of part of the outstanding liability, followed by equally monthly payments. So they are going to want something upfront. If the taxpayer can show an urgent need for assets and net cash flow, the IRS may allow him to keep all or some of it. The taxpayer must convince the IRS in the alternative. 00:56:14.2900000 One of two things. One, it would be inequitable to grab the asset now, or two, the IRS will be better off if the taxpayer is allowed to retain more of the assets or cash flow than the national standards indicate. 00:56:29.9400000 If the installment payments are to continue for more than 12 months, the IRS may insist that the taxpayer provide follow up financial information. Because after all, things change over time. What if that mid level executive in the advertising company that I just talked about who was earning $180,000 a year? What if he got a raise? Or what if he was elevated to top level management and is now raking in $250,000 a year? 00:57:02.1100000 Guess what? The IRS has a right to know that. And so that's why the IRS may insist that this information be updated on a regular basis. And based on those updates, the IRS can use them to modify or terminate the installment agreement in the event that there's a significant change in the taxpayer's financial condition. The IRS can modify or terminate the agreement if the taxpayer 1 provides inaccurate or incomplete information with the request, 2 accrues additional tax liabilities, or 3 fails to make scheduled installment payments, partial payment installment agreements. 00:57:45.9700000 These can be used to reduce or settle a taxpayer's final liability. However, it does not have the finality associated with an offer in compromise. Instead, it's merely an agreement that allows the taxpayer to pay part of the liability over time. All right, so now we're going to talk about two things. First, effective installment agreement on collection activity and the statute of limitations. 00:58:12.2900000 So when we talk about collection activity, we're automatically in the territory of the statute of limitations. The statute of limitations for collection is suspended during the period that the proposed installment agreement is pending with the IRS like we talked about before. Second, if the IRS rejects the proposed Installment agreement. The statute of limitations period for collection remains suspended for 30 days following the rejection. Why is the statute of limitations on collection suspended for 30 days following the rejection? 00:58:53.0800000 Because, as we talked about earlier, the taxpayer has a due process right to appeal the rejection within 30 days of the rejection. Essentially, the IRS would issue the taxpayer a notice. And it's always the date on the notice that will hold the, that will hold water or will be the date within which you extrapolate the 30 days. It's not the date the taxpayer receives the notice. This happens so much. 00:59:27.2300000 It happens a lot. And I feel bad for taxpayers because naturally people go on vacation, people come back sometimes two weeks later to find these ugly tax notices in their mailbox. And, you know, the tax notice, you know, they might not think anything, anything of it, wait another week, and now it's three weeks. And they might fully intend in good faith to appeal the denial of the installment agreement. But they may, you know, the urgency, you know, it just might have just completely been an innocent overlooking of the timeline. 01:00:08.6500000 And so when the letter finally gets opened, it might be the 29th day, and it might be too late for the taxpayer to file the appeal within the 30 days of the date stamped on the rejection letter. But think about it then, from the IRS perspective. The IRS doesn't want to have to get into disputes with every taxpayer who's been on vacation for that period of time and gets back on the 31st day claiming that they didn't open it up. And then, of course, there are going to be people that take advantage and make up the fact that they didn't see the notice until the 31st day. That's why the, the stamp, the timestamp on the rejection letter is the official date that is used for extrapolation of the 30 days again. 01:01:05.1500000 And that's why the statute of limitations on collection is suspended for 30 days following the rejection. Let's say that the taxpayer defaults on an installment agreement and the IRS terminates it. Then the statute of limitations for collection is told for 30 days following termination. Because why shouldn't the IRS be able to undertake the full panoply of collection actions if the taxpayer has defaulted on the installment agreement? In other words, why can't the IRS levy, why can't they, you know, foreclose on a lien? 01:01:50.4300000 Why can't they garnish wages from the taxpayers, you know, the taxpayers, you know, salary, etc. Etc. If the taxpayer appeals the rejection or termination, once again, the statute of limitations period is suspended while an appeal is pending. That is, by the way, across the board, not just with offers installment agreements, but also when the taxpayer has received an adverse ruling in tax court or by an appeals officer in the irs. Whenever the taxpayer takes up an appeal to a higher level, the statute of limitations on collection activity is always suspended during the course of the appeal. 01:02:42.2200000 It's simply not fair, not fair at all to think that the IRS would be able to collect on an assessment when a higher court is ruling whether a lower court had properly decided in the IRS's favor. So, you know, just think of it. Who you know, is it fair? All these questions going on in your mind is going to make this a hell of a lot easier than trying to memorize it. Trust me, I've done it the hard way, memorizing it. 01:03:21.7300000 And inevitably because of so much crossover in other areas. I mean, we haven't even talked about innocent spouse. My God. I mean, the rules there are enough to just make your head go around and spin around in circles. But if you actually know the policy reasons and you have an idea of who benefits, who gets hurt, who has the advantage here, who stands to be disadvantaged, those will help you to understand these rules and to pull them up quickly. 01:03:59.3200000 No substitute, of course, for, you know, verifying as you will, these things. The IRS is prohibited from levying on the taxpayer's property during any period that an installment agreement is pending or in effect. The 30 day period after the IRS rejects the installment agreement request, the 30 day period following termination of the agreement and the appeal of a termination or rejection. So all I did was I just put you, you know, I listed the handy dandy list of those of those circumstances whereby the IRS is prohibited from levying. All right, I think we have and we are over time. 01:04:42.3700000 I'm so sorry. Went a little over time. I apologize. Thank you all for joining me today. Once again, sorry to go over time. 01:04:50.2100000 So long.