[Course Name] 00:00:03.0400000 Hello everybody. Welcome to Alphabet Soup for offers in Compromise. I'm Mike DeBliss. I've been lecturing now in the tax series with Lexvid for a little while and this is a brand new topic in the tax series. We've been working our way through some interesting areas from civil tax work to civil tax controversies, I should say, to international tax compliance. 00:00:33.5800000 And alas, we arrived today at offers in compromise. So why don't we jump right in? This is a little bit about me. 00:00:45.1000000 So taxpayers who have few assets and little prospect of generating sufficient income to pay a tax liability in full may be allowed to strike a settlement for less than the full amount due to settle their case. In a nutshell, that's what an offering compromise is. It's where the taxpayer comes forward and basically makes a proposal to the IRS for a smaller amount than the amount that they owe in full settlement for the tax liability. The IRS acceptance of an offer in compromise conclusively settles the liability absent fraud or mistake. So where does the authority come from for an offer in compromise? 00:01:37.3900000 It comes from the Internal revenue code, section 7122. That section gives the Secretary of Treasury the authority to compromise any tax debt owed to the government. If the government accepts the offering compromise, the taxpayer pays less than the full amount due to settle their case. What's the policy goal behind it? Well, it is to achieve collection of what is potentially collectible at the earliest possible time and at the least cost to the government, while providing taxpayers with a fresh start toward future voluntary compliance. 00:02:13.1900000 So you can see now, you know, that the interest that are weighed, it is basically a way, what it offers taxpayers is the opportunity to, to get up to date with their tax obligations and to put them on a path for a fresh start toward voluntary compliance. That's our tax system. We have a voluntary compliance system where we do our taxes and we submit them to the government every year. Of course, you know, they can be examined, our returns can be examined, and the IRS can perhaps disagree with the amount that we have disclosed as gross income and the amount of tax liability that we have. But for all intents and purposes, this is just a very straightforward way of the taxpayer working towards a fresh start. 00:03:11.0600000 And at the same time, it's basically one where it gives the government the opportunity to collect some something at an early time as opposed to letting this drag on for years and years and years where they're trying to get blood from a stone so the interests for both sides are satisfied. In this way, the IRS will compromise tax liability on three Grounds. The first is doubt as to liability. The second is doubt as to collectability. And the third is to promote effective tax administration. 00:03:51.7100000 We will explore each one of these. The IRS allows taxpayers three different payment options. A cash lump sum offer usually payable within 90 days. A short term periodic payment offer payable over a two year period and third, a deferred periodic payment offer payable over the number of years remaining in the statute of limitations on collection. 00:04:18.0500000 So a taxpayer would request an offer in compromise by submitting a standardized form. That form is known as Form 656. Form 656 is to request relief based on doubt as to collectability or effective tax administration. And Form 656L is to request relief based on doubt as to liability. So let's take a look at 656 first. 00:04:49.2700000 The doubt as to collectability means exactly that, that there that it is unlikely that the taxpayer is going to be able to pay the total amount of tax due to something that's going on in their life at the present moment. They might be out of work, they might be unemployed, they might, might, they might have, you know, there just could be a myriad of reasons that are affecting the taxpayers financial well being and that are the impetus for them to request this offer in compromise. There's a processing fee. Taxpayers must submit a $150 processing fee for offers based on data to collectability and effective tax administration. This fee does not apply to offerors based on doubt as to liability. 00:05:50.5700000 This fee is mandatory if the taxpayer earns 24,000 or more and is single. However, it can be waived in the case of low income taxpayers, those with income at or below 250% of the poverty rate. The processing fee is not refundable even if the IRS declares that the offer request is incomplete or, or incorrect and cannot be processed. The user fee may be refunded if one the IRS accepts the offer based on effective tax administration or two the IRS accepts the offer because of doubt as to collectability and collection of an amount greater than that offered would create an economic hardship for the taxpayer. So you can see here that there is some leeway in terms of the taxpayer getting that fee refunded to them, that $150 processing fee refunded to them. 00:06:51.4300000 Now down payments. Most taxpayers must submit a down payment before the IRS will process their application. It's almost like, you know, putting up collateral, you know, in advance. It's a good faith, it's not just a good faith gesture. It's required. 00:07:09.9500000 But essentially this down payment must accompany the application itself. This advance payment is generally not refundable even if the IRS rejects the taxpayer's offer request. For lump sum offers, the taxpayer must remit 20% of the amount of the lump sum offer. So, you know, there can be a lump sum offer or there can be, as we discussed at the very beginning, an offer that spans over the course of up to two years and where monthly payments might be made towards paying it. But when we are in the territory of lump sum offers, for example, where the taxpayer wants to pay $10,000 in complete satisfaction for the $15,000 of tax liability that they owe the IRS, they would have to put down 20% of that $10,000, which would be $2,000 when they submit the offering compromise application. 00:08:17.7000000 For periodic payment offers, the taxpayer must remit the amount of the first proposed installment and comply with their own proposed payment schedule while the offer is being considered. So if it is a periodic payment offer, then it's one where the taxpayer must submit the first proposed installment. So let's say, for example, that it calls that the taxpayer is proposing quarterly payments in the amount of $2,000 for two years. And that is what they are, that's what they are applying for. They would then have to commit, they would then have to submit $2,000, the first proposed installment, along with the offer and compromise application. 00:09:15.0500000 And then while the offer and compromise application is being reviewed, they must follow the terms of their proposed payment schedule. So if the second quarter comes, meaning the end of six months time now, or I'm sorry, it would be the end of three months time, that would be the next quarter because when they first submit the application, they are submitting the $2,000 with that application, say three months later. There still has not been an answer from the IRS as to whether the offering compromise has been accepted. Notwithstanding the fact that there has been no response yet from the IRS as to whether they're accepting it or not, the taxpayer must pay $2,000 at the end of the first three months because of the proposed installment plan that they have made for every three months or quarterly to pay $2,000. And similarly, if six months have passed and the IRS has not gotten back to the taxpayer on a decision as to whether the offer in compromise is accepted, the taxpayer would have to pay another $2,000. 00:10:34.3700000 The taxpayer must adhere to the proposed installment plan that they're making while the offer is being considered. The IRS waives the down payment requirement for low income taxpayers and for offerors based on doubt as to liability. The IRS will process an offer in compromise only if the taxpayer 1, remits the required payments, 2, completes the application in full, 3, has filed all required returns and paid the necessary estimated taxes, and fourth, is not in bankruptcy. So those are the threshold conditions, remitting the required payments according to the proposed plan that the taxpayer has made. Second, completing the application in full. 00:11:25.8690000 And it is a comprehensive application. It's not just, you know. A couple questions. It does probe very deep into private issues regarding the taxpayer's finances that many a taxpayer may not necessarily want the IRS to know about. So if a potential client comes to you asking you for assistance in an offering compromise, what I would recommend is to download this form onto your computer, print it out, and review with them what would be required in the disclosure so that they know up front the type of information that the IRS is going to request. 00:12:09.7600000 It will include, of course, disclosure of all bank accounts, both domestic and foreign. It'll include information as to balances in those bank accounts. There might be a requirement for bank statements as well. For the last year or two, the taxpayer will have to disclose all of their assets, both real assets and both real, as far as property goes and land goes and then other assets as far as material items go. So the taxpayer isn't going to be able to just give lip service to wanting to do an offering compromise. 00:12:55.0100000 They're going to have to disclose information, like I said, that is quite private and confidential and information that many a taxpayer may not want the IRS to know about. Third, they must have filed all required returns and paid the necessary estimated taxes. And fourth, they must not be in bankruptcy. Fourth, I'm sorry. Next, if the IRS returns an offer to the taxpayer stating that it cannot be processed, can the taxpayer appeal the decision? 00:13:27.3200000 No. 00:13:30.2800000 What happens when the IRS accepts an offering compromise? The settlement will not be reopened unless the taxpayer has falsified information, concealed assets, or there was a mutual mistake of fact. The taxpayer must agree to fully comply with all filing payment requirements for five years from the date the IRS accepts the offer. If the taxpayer fails to carry out his obligations under the agreement, the IRS can terminate the agreement and collect the originally determined liability. This is important and must be emphasized to the client that just because there's been a settlement reach with the IRS doesn't mean that if the taxpayer breaches their end of the agreement that the IRS cannot terminate the agreement and collect the originally determined liability. 00:14:30.1900000 So, you know, you need to make that crystal clear to them. It's almost like probation. I do a lot of criminal defense work. I always tell the client that probation may not end this case forever. If they come back on a violation, and if the judge determines that they have violated the terms of their probation and has terminated them from the program, in that case, the judge can resentence them to anything that they could have been sentenced to originally. 00:15:05.1600000 So you have to take a look at the underlying charge that the defendant pledged pled to. If it's a third degree offense, in my state, that's punishable by up to five years in prison. So if probation were to be terminated and the judge resentenced the client, he could potentially, or she could potentially resentence the client to anything within that third degree range from, you know, from 364, you know, nearly a year in jail all the way up to five years in prison. 00:15:39.6400000 What happens if the IRS intends to reject the taxpayer's offering compromise? It sets into play the following chain of events. First, an independent review of any proposed rejection must take place. The IRS may not arbitrarily reject an offer in compromise until this independent administrative review has occurred. Second, if the IRS rejects the offer, the IRS must inform the taxpayer. 00:16:06.2500000 They can't leave the taxpayer hanging. If an offer in compromise is rejected by either the examination or the collection function, after an independent administrative review, the taxpayer will receive an explanation of all available appeal rights. Third, the taxpayer has the right to appeal the rejection to the IRS Appeals Division. The IRS Appeals Division is like a mediation department. It's not an appellate court. 00:16:36.5600000 It's very important to understand that IRS Appeals again is labeled an independent arm of the irs. It's a bit of an oxymoron because the individuals who man the IRS Appeals office or the IRS Appeals Division are employees of the IRS themselves. They are called appeals officers. However, based on the 1998 Restructuring act that Congress put into law, they recognized the need for a neutral department, if you will, and the IRS that can review disputes between the taxpayer and the examiner in the hope that potentially the appeals officer would be able to resolve the dispute in a way that was satisfactory to both the taxpayer and the IRS, such that the taxpayer would not have to file a protest or file, I'm sorry, a petition to go to Tax Court court. So it was designed as a mechanism to reduce the volume of cases that were being filed in Tax Court. 00:18:01.0500000 Taxpayers, naturally, are lukewarm to having their case reviewed by an appeals officer because, of course, they feel that they are biased since they are an employee of the irs. I don't disagree. However, I do let them know what Congress attempted to do to make appeals as neutral as humanly possible. They set up a lot of mechanisms such that the appeals officer cannot have ex parte conversations with the, the examining, with the examiner that did the audit. So the two sides that you have in a contest for a tax deficiency are the irs, the IRS examining agent, the individual who undertook the actual examination of the returns, and then the taxpayer. 00:19:04.6400000 On the other hand, to the extent that the examiner determines that the taxpayer underreported gross income or over reported deductions such that they owe more tax, then the agent, then the revenue agent would submit to the taxpayer a deficiency letter or a deficiency notice. The deficiency notice basically says to the taxpayer, I've reviewed your returns. I've conducted a thorough audit. And based on that audit, I believe that you should have reported X when you only reported Y. And the difference between X and Y is the deficiency amount. 00:19:53.8400000 That is the amount that you owe us. The irs, to the extent that the taxpayer disagrees, this is one of their rights. They can appeal to the IRS Appeals division. They can also pursue an appeal. They can also pursue the case in the, they can also have the case reviewed by an appeals officer in the appeals division. 00:20:18.0500000 And if they lose or if they're dissatisfied with the appeal officer's decision, they have the right to file a petition and, and to go to tax court. And if they lose in tax court, theoretically they could even go one step higher to the court of appeals that covers the circuit where the taxpayer resided at the time they filed the petition in tax court. But the deficiency notice is the ticket to the taxpayer getting into tax court. And these days, the IRS is insisting on, on the taxpayer proceeding first by having their case by having their case reviewed by an appeals officer. And then if they're dissatisfied with the decision by the appeals officer, then they can go to the US Tax Court by filing a petition and having the dispute reviewed by a judge who is an expert in the field of tax law. 00:21:25.7000000 That's one of the benefits of the tax court judges. They all are not only lawyers, but they also have a very diverse background in tax, as many have either worked for the IRS, they've been CPAs in a prior lifetime, and, or they, you know, LLMs. So, you know, this is all, this is kind of the procedure of how these things work. But when it comes to the offers in compromise, the taxpayer does have a right to appeal the rejection, and it would be to the IRS Appeals division. However, as with most appeals in the civil tax world, there are deadlines to those deadlines have teeth in them. 00:22:15.1200000 If you do not meet the deadline, then it becomes too late to exercise your appeal rights. You forfeit that right never to be able to get it back again. So the taxpayer would have 30 days from the date of a rejection letter of their offering compromise to request an appeal. May IRS Chief counsel weigh in and provide an opinion of on whether to accept or reject a taxpayer's offer in compromise? An opinion of IRS counsel is in fact required in all cases where the unpaid tax, including interest, penalties and additions, is 50 grand or more. 00:22:55 I want to stress that the tax deficiency itself may not be 50,000. It may, you know, it may be 40,000. But when you aggregate or add on the interest, the penalties and the additions that might make the watermark that might cause the 50,000 watermark to be eclipsed. And in that case, the IRS Chief Counsel's office would be required to issue an opinion. An IRS Chief Counsel's review consists of legal and policy review. 00:23:37.6300000 The IRS Chief Counsel's review is not of veto power, although few revenue officers would settle in the face of a negative chief counsel review. What are Collateral Agreements? The IRS may condition acceptance of an offering compromise on the taxpayer's execution of a collateral agreement to pay the IRS a certain percentage of his or her future income over a specified number of years. So what might that look practically? Well, if a taxpayer has the potential to significantly increase his income over a relatively short period of time, the IRS may require the taxpayer to pay over a certain percentage of future income in excess of a negotiated amount. 00:24:21.0600000 So, for example, because these offering compromise applications are so detailed with respect to the information that they require the taxpayer to disclose, the taxpayer may find themselves in a situation where they are a beneficiary of a will, where the where a relative has left them a significant amount of money and following probate, they stand to inherit, I don't know, 20, $30,000. And that would be part of the disclosure in the offering compromise application. And that would be a situation where the IRS perhaps insists upon a collateral agreement for the taxpayer to pay them a certain percentage of that future income from that inheritance over a specified number of years. 00:25:27.9000000 Suppose that the taxpayer is a lawyer who has accepted a personal injury case on a contingency fee. If the case resolves within a certain number of years, such as five, the IRS might insist that it get 25% or 50% of any amount in excess of $100,000. So you can see how intrusive the offer and compromise applications are, because this is the type of information if it was an attorney that was Seeking the offer in compromise. This is the type of information that is a contingency fee agreements with clients that would have to be disclosed on the application, and that would allow the IRS to perhaps insist upon a collateral agreement whereby, if the case resolves within a certain number of years, that The IRS get 25% or 50% of any amount greater than 100,000. However, the IRS doesn't like these agreements because they have to monitor them five years into the future. 00:26:37.2900000 They'd rather see the file get closed and get closed like yesterday rather than have to have it linger and stay open and indefinitely, well, not indefinitely, but, you know, over a prolonged period of time, in this case five years. The IRS may withhold a refund from the taxpayer in the year that a collateral agreement is executed. So that's a way that they can ensure that they get the future money that was agreed upon in the collateral agreement by withholding a refund in the year, of course, that the collateral agreement was executed. Offers based on doubt as to collectability, these are the most often accepted by irs. They exist when the taxpayer cannot pay the full amount of tax liability owed within the remainder of the statute of limitations on collection. 00:27:35.9400000 So those for some of you, you might not be familiar familiar with how the statute of limitations works in the tax world, but just like there's a statute of limitations that exists in filing a personal injury claim, it's two years in the state that I reside in. There are statute of limitations on collection that you know as well as on assessing liability that the IRS must adhere to. And to the extent that the statute of limitations has lapsed, meaning it has ended, and the IRS has not made an assessment of an amount that it believes the taxpayer owes, it then becomes too late for the IRS to to make that assessment. So the statute of limitations is a very strong defense for taxpayers. 00:28:45.5200000 Oftentimes when it comes to these offers in compromise, the taxpayer will assert in the offering compromise application that they simply don't have the amount of money needed to pay the tax liability within the remainder of the statute of limitations on collection. And so that gives them a little bit of leverage to negotiate with the IRS for a lesser amount in complete satisfaction of the original amount that they had to pay. The other thing that comes into play sometimes with the statute of limitations is that there are times when the IRS may insist upon the taxpayer agreeing to extend the statute of limitations if there is a concern on the part of the IRS that they will not get even the negotiated, the lower negotiated amount within that period of time. So the taxpayer agrees that the tax is owed but doesn't believe that he can fully pay the balance due. This type of offer is initially considered by the collection function and requires payment of the $150 filing fee. 00:30:06.8300000 In evaluating offers based on data to collectability, the IRS conducts an examination of the taxpayer's assets, liabilities and earnings potential. What standard does the IRS use to determine whether an offer based on doubt is to collectibility should be accepted? The standard is does the amount reflect reasonable collection potential? So what is the definition of reasonable collection potential? The offer amount must exceed be over the sum of one, the taxpayer's net equity and second, the taxpayer's future income determined over a four or five year period, depending upon the terms of the offer. 00:30:50.1700000 So I oftentimes find, because I'm not an accountant and I'm not very strong with numbers, that a hypothetical is helpful to help us wrap our heads around the calculation of this reasonable collection potential number. So let's say that the taxpayer owes 80,000 and the reasonable collection potential is 30,000, but the taxpayer only offers 20,000. The taxpayer will have to increase his offer up to $30,000. An accountant would be helpful here to calculate reasonable collection potential because whenever it comes to calculating a taxpayer's net equity as well as future future income determined over a period of time, that is a very, very tedious, a very tedious task and one that definitely requires the, you know, the expertise of an accountant. 00:31:58.8100000 Calculating the taxpayer's equity in assets. This includes cash amounts in checking and investment accounts, cash value of any life insurance policies, and accounts receivable. Accounts receivable, of course, mean amounts that you have already. It basically means work that you've already done, but that you have not yet been paid for. And those basically get lumped in to the equity in assets, you know, and can very well inflate this number to a number far greater than what you what might exist. 00:32:40.2700000 As far as cash on hand goes, I know many a client that you know, has disproportionately higher accounts receivable than they do liquid cash in their bank accounts. And yet those accounts receivable will be factored into to determine their equity in assets and could certainly cause that figure to go up to the stratosphere. And how fair is it that that number be included when it's unlikely that all accounts receivable will be paid? 00:33:18.8300000 The realizable value of a taxpayer's other real and personal property is its quick sale value. The quick sale value is 80% of the current fair market value of the assets calculating the taxpayer's future income. When determining whether an offer should be accepted based on data as to collectability, the IRS may also consider a taxpayer's earnings potential and the likelihood of any increase in future income. So the basic idea here is that the IRS looks at both income and expenses. Those are, you know, very black and white for income. 00:33:52.9100000 It projects into the future what it expects the taxpayer to be earning based on his present situation and what it expects him to be doing in the future. For expenses. The IRS projects into the future what it expects the taxpayer's expenses to be. So actually, I'm going to go back on what I just said before. It's not as black and white. 00:34:15.8700000 There is a lot of, of assumptions that are made that go into this because we're talking about expectations. And as we all know, expectations are not always met. 00:34:31.4000000 That's of course, the bane of, you know, being human expecting, you know, certain outcome and not getting it. And this could not be any more true than in a situation where, you know, the taxpayer is working and you were looking into the future to determine, you know, based on their present situation, what we can expect them to be, you know, doing in the future. Well, you know, that's all good and well, but how do we know that there isn't going to be a downturn in the economy in the future? And how do we know that there aren't going to be a round of layoffs in the industry that the taxpayer works in? How do we know that the market isn't going to crash? 00:35:14.0500000 How do we, you know, all of these things are assumed to be, are assumed into the future to be okay. 00:35:23.8900000 And it's assumed that there aren't going to be any wrinkles or any obstacles or, you know, that, that stand in the way of the taxpayer of their earnings in the future and the trajectory that they're on. To determine a taxpayer's future income, the IRS uses information from his or her collection information statement. That would be Form 433 in combination with estimated national and local living costs. And those are referred to as collection financial standards. These standards are disregarded if the resulting amount would leave the taxpayer unable to provide for basic living expenses. 00:36:10.9600000 The simple formula here is that a taxpayer's future income equals taxpayers monthly income minus allowable expenses. What are allowable expenses? These are, you know, ones you would probably imagine, you know, just off the top of your head. Food and clothing. They are based on a national standard. 00:36:33.4900000 Out of pocket health care expenses. They're based on a national standard. Housing and Utilities. These are based on standard living costs in the state and county where the taxpayer lives. And finally, transportation. 00:36:45.9700000 This consists of ownership and operating costs associated with a car. Ownership costs are based on a national standard. Operating costs are based on local standards. Offers based on Doubt as to Liability so we've been talking up until now about doubt as to collectability. But how about doubt as to liability? 00:37:07.0300000 This is where the taxpayer disagrees that he owes the tax that the IRS is asserting. So essentially the taxpayer is disputing the underlying deficiency, the difference between what the taxpayer the difference between what the IRS believes the taxpayer owes versus the amount that they voluntarily disclosed on their return. Keep in mind, we have a voluntary compliance tax system. The irs, the taxing authority here in the United States, does not do our taxes and tell us you owe X, Y and z. We do our taxes ourselves and we voluntarily and then we voluntarily submit them to the irs. 00:38:02.2700000 And if we get examined and the IRS disagrees and feels that we owe more based on having underreported our gross income or overstating our deductions, then again they would send us a deficiency notice telling us the amount for which we owe. And it is this, it is now, it is this that we're talking about. When it comes to doubt as to liability, it is where the taxpayer is saying, sorry, irs, I don't agree with you that I under reported my gross income and that I owe more taxes. Generally, the examination function of the IRS considers this type of offer and the taxpayer is not required to pay a filing fee. Exceptions are offers submitted to compromise a trust fund recovery penalty which is considered by the collection function. 00:38:57.3600000 That's another presentation in and of itself. Given that the taxpayer has other avenues available to negotiate with the IRS over the extent of his tax liability. Compromise on the basis of doubt as to liability are rare. So, yeah, what I said earlier applies here. The fact that the taxpayer has a myriad of ways that they can challenge the deficiency amount means that these offers based on doubt as to liability are very rare. 00:39:34.1600000 That the tax that the IRS is going to grant them. And as I said earlier, to the extent that the taxpayer disagrees with the amount of with the amount of extra tax that the IRS is asserting, the taxpayer can challenge that deficiency by filing a protest and going before an appeals officer. And even if they lose, it's not over. They can then wait for the deficiency notice to arrive and file a petition to go to US Tax Court and then challenge the underlying tax deficiency in US Tax Court before a judge who would be the trier of fact. As well, the judge, there's no juries in tax court. 00:40:22.2300000 The judge would make the decision. And, and if the taxpayer lost or was dissatisfied, maybe because the judge split the baby, then the taxpayer reserves the right to appeal to the circuit court for the circuit in which he lived at the time he filed the petition in US Tax court. So if the taxpayer filed his petition in New Jersey to go to US Tax court and loses in the tax court, then the taxpayer would be able to appeal that adverse tax court decision in a third Circuit court of appeals because the third Circuit Court of appeals encompasses New Jersey, where the taxpayer lived at the time he filed the petition to go to tax court. 00:41:12.6300000 So, for example, again, through the requirement for a notice of deficiency, taxpayers may contest liability in tax court. Taxpayers may also contest liability in a refund or in a collection suit. And by the way, the taxpayer does not have to put in escrow the deficiency amount in order to get access to the US tax court. So if there's a difference of, say, $30,000 between the amount that the IRS believes the taxpayer to owe after conducting the audit and, you know, and the taxpayer, you know, voluntarily disclosed $30,000, and so there's, you know, that difference, the taxpayer doesn't have to put the difference up as collateral or in an escrow account in order to get access into tax court. However, if the tax, if the taxpayer wanted to go to federal court and avail himself of a jury to hear this dispute over the underlying tax deficiency, then it would be incumbent upon the taxpayer to post the deficiency amount in escrow as collateral. 00:42:32.8600000 And that would be held until there is a decision in the case. 00:42:40.6600000 Once the liability is judicially contested. The IRS will not consider offers in compromise based upon doubt as to liability. So, for example, it's like you can't take two bites at the apple. If the taxpayer has litigated the underlying deficiency amount in tax court and has lost and not availed themselves of any of an appeal, but let the period, the 90 day period in which to file the appeal to the circuit court, you know, come and go without filing an appeal. They can't turn around and be like, okay, I'm going to file an offer in compromise based upon doubt as to liability. 00:43:19.6300000 No, they've already had their option to challenge the underlying deficiency and they've lost administratively. Taxpayers also have procedural rights, including invoking appeals office consideration to contest liability. Nevertheless, some taxpayers have not had an effective review of their liability for the assessed taxes. They may not owe the taxes in that case, they can use offering compromises to contest their liability for the underlying taxes. So to the extent that the taxpayer hasn't had an earlier opportunity to exercise their due process right to challenge the underlying tax deficiency, and if there is a good reason for why not, that they were asleep at the switch and that they, you know, were that they missed the, you know, the period in which to file their petition, you know, for no good reason, you know, as long as there is a reason that they can advance for, you know, for not having had an earlier opportunity and to effectively have a, you know, have their liability, have that deficiency reviewed, then this might be an avenue for them to contest the underlying liability. 00:44:45.2100000 The offer based on status Liability. Taxpayers applying for an offer in compromise based on data to liability Must file form 656L. This form does not require taxpayers to submit a collection financial statement, which is good news for the taxpayer. In these combination offers, the liability issues will be considered first by either the examination or collection functions of the irs, depending on the type of tax. Why? 00:45:13.6900000 Well, to the extent that the taxpayer is not liable for the tax, there's no reason for a complete investigation of the taxpayer's financial situation because if the taxpayer prevails on not being liable for the tax, then they owe no tax. So we don't need to put the cart before the horse and do a, you know, do the proverbial do the proverbial root canal of them to uncover what assets they have that can go towards paying the tax debt if they have no debt to pay at all. And that's why the protocol would be for the examination to go first and to determine whether the taxpayer is liable for the tax before we go into, you know, doing the root canal and looking into their financial situations to see if they can pay something that we don't even know whether they have a responsibility to pay yet. If the revenue agent determines if the taxpayer is liable for the tax, the case will be forwarded to the collection function. That makes sense. 00:46:29.9900000 Right? If the revenue agent determines that the taxpayer is liable, then they will have an amount that they have to pay. And in that case, the natural progression is for the case to be forwarded to the collection function to consider whether the tax liability is collectible. 00:46:49.5300000 And now we move on to offers based on effective tax administration. I just want to check on time. Okay, we're doing good on time. 00:47:10.5800000 Super. So now that we've covered doubt as to liability and doubt as to collectability, let's talk about offers based on effective tax administration. Even if the taxpayer has assets and income that allow him to pay the amount of tax liability owed. The IRS may still accept an offer in compromise so long as it promotes effective tax administration. In other words, on paper the taxpayer can fully pay the liability he has or she has the financial wherewithal to do so. 00:47:43.6600000 But circumstances exist. That's the operative term. Circumstances exist that with the acceptance of the offer, the public would be competent that the tax laws were administered fairly and equitably. That's the catchphrase there. On paper, the taxpayer can fully pay the liability, but circumstances exist that with the acceptance of the offer, the public would be confident that the tax laws were administered fairly and equitably. 00:48:14.7500000 So the issue becomes one of will accepting this offer promote effective tax administration? Compromising the tax liability could promote effective tax administration for any one of the following. First, collection of the entire liability would cause the taxpayer economic hardship or two, compelling public policy or equity considerations provide a sufficient basis for compromising the liability. Once again, collection of the entire liability would cause the taxpayer economic hardship or two, compelling public policy or equity considerations provide an adequate basis for compromising the liability. Let's look at the first one where collection of the entire liability would cause a taxpayer economic hardship. 00:49:04.6300000 Economic hardship in this context exists if the taxpayer faces a long term illness, medical condition or disability and it is foreseeable that his or her financial resources will be exhausted as a result. You know, we don't have to think long and hard about this. A terminal illness such as cancer, where, you know, the taxpayer has, you know, basically has been basically been given a death sentence and you know, and an estimate as to how long they might live, that would definitely qualify as an economic hardship. It could also be a disability, you know, from an accident that has changed this person's life forever and has led to them being unable to provide for themselves. So you can see it's going to be a drastic, drastic event that triggers one of economic hardship. 00:50:18.5500000 However, it can also cover cases where the sale or liquidation of assets to pay a tax bill would prevent the taxpayer from meeting basic living expenses. To the extent that the taxpayer could sell, you know, their home and be able to pay the tax bill, but that in doing so, you know, they would not be able to, you know, would not be able to find a home to, and a roof to put over their, the heads of their kids and their family, I would see that as an example where an economic hardship would, would be triggered. However, however, however, if the family home, when it comes to family home, the IRS is, you know, they might attach liens on the on the family home. But through experience, I found that the IRS will not resort to the nuclear option of foreclosing on that lien, you know, despite how egregious the circumstances are in terms of how much the taxpayer owes if it's the primary home and if there are, if the taxpayer has a family that, you know, would disproportionately be impacted by the foreclosure of the home. So, yeah, all of these circumstances are looked at. 00:51:47.0200000 You can see here that this is done on a case by case, basically basis. But if the taxpayer is living the high life and has a nice home in the suburbs and has a second home in the Hamptons, you better believe that the IRS is not going to view that second home as if, as it did in the first example I gave you, where the taxpayer has only one home and that's the primary residence, you know, and there's a young family that is that the taxpayer is providing for and that, you know, is living under that roof. So, you know, you have to just, you have to look at this on a case by case basis. Second, compelling public policy or equity considerations provide a sufficient basis for compromising the liability. Compromise would be justified only where collection of the full liability would undermine public confidence that the tax laws are being administered in a fair and equitable manner. 00:52:56.6500000 No effective tax administration offer would be accepted if it would undermine taxpayer compliance. The IRS will not accept an effective tax administration offer if it determines that the taxpayer also qualifies for a an offer based on data to collectability. So before we can go to effective tax administration, the IRS is going to see if the offering compromise first qualifies as an offer based on data to collectability. However, if payment of the liability would still cause the taxpayer economic hardship, the IRS may treat the offer as one based on doubt as to collectability with special circumstances. The same factors that the IRS takes into account when processing an effective tax administration offer would be taken into account in a special circumstances offer. 00:53:48.9800000 What effect does an offer in compromise have on collection activities? Well, once the taxpayer submits an offer in compromise, the IRS is prohibited from levying against the taxpayer's property or while it processes the offer. All right, I will say that once again, taxpayer submits an offer in compromise While the IRS is processing the offer. Reviewing the application, the IRS cannot resort to the nuclear option of levying against the taxpayer's property. At the same time, collection action is postponed for 30 days following rejection of the taxpayer's offer and during any appeal of that rejection. 00:54:36.5900000 So here are the two Circumstances that would play out with this second scenario, IRS rejects the offer in compromise, taxpayer receives the letter, the rejection notice, taxpayer takes no further action. Collection action on the part of the IRS would be postponed for 30 days following rejection of the taxpayer's offer. However, on the 31st day, keeping in mind that the taxpayer in this scenario has not appealed the rejection or taken any further action, on the 31st day where the taxpayer does nothing, the IRS would be able to commence collection action, but not until again the expiration of 30 days following rejection of the offer. However, let's say, for example, that the taxpayer decides to appeal the rejection and within the 30 day period files an appeal. Well, on the 31st, 32nd and subsequent days, while the appeal is paid pending, the IRS cannot take any collection action. 00:55:51.0400000 So essentially, the filing of an appeal of the rejection of the offering compromise will extend the period within which the IRS cannot commence collection action. It will further the postponement of collection action until such time as the appeal has been decided. 00:56:20.3600000 However, much to the chagrin of taxpayers, the statute of limitations for collection is told during any period in which the IRS is prohibited from enforcing collection. So in dealing with statute of limitations, I always like to look at running versus told. And from the perspective of who it benefits. Whenever we say that the statute of limitations continues to run, that inures to the benefit of the taxpayer because it means that the clock keeps ticking away. Tick, tick, tick, tick, tick, tock, tick tock, tick tock, tick tock. 00:57:00.9800000 And that always is to the benefit of the taxpayer, because keeping in mind that the IRS has a limited time within which they must collect the amount that is owed, and that is the statute of limitations for collection. So to the extent that the clock keeps ticking, that goes against the IRS and that goes in favor of of the taxpayer. However, when we look at told, told means stopped. So who's going to make out or be the beneficiary of a told statute of limitations? The irs, of course, because the IRS only has a limited period of time within which to collect. 00:57:50.6600000 Also they have a limited period of time within which to assess. So that's why we have statute of limitations for assessment and then we have statute of limitations for collectability. But again, you know, the statute of limitations is a definite period of time, not an indefinite period of time. So to the extent that the statute of limitations is frozen and stopped, then that inures to the benefit of the irs. Because the IRS doesn't have the clock ticking in the background. 00:58:21.0900000 Tick, tock, tick, tock, tick, tock. Instead, it's getting prolonged and prolonged and prolonged because the tolling time could itself be the entire period of statute of limitations. And when the tolling period ends from that moment on the balance of what time was left on the statute of limitations would then commence. So if there was a year left on the statute of limitations at the time it was tolled and it's told the statute of limitations is told for a year while the appeal is undertaken, and it's not until a year later that the appeal has been decided adversely against the taxpayer. Well, guess what? 00:58:59.7800000 There's a whole other year that the IRS has within which to collect the liability. Because for a whole year it was the session of limitations was told it was not running against the irs. So this is why it's important to recognize what happens with respect to the statute of limitations on the one hand. And then with respect to levying and collection action on the other hand, you know, that tends to be a little bit more favorable towards the taxpayer than the statute of limitations for collection goes, you know, vis a vis the taxpayer. If an accepted offer is payable in installments, the taxpayer may be asked to extend the statute of limitations on assessment for the period the offer remains in force during the taxable year in which the offer is accepted. 00:59:51.7800000 The IRS will also retain any refund to which the taxpayer would otherwise be entitled and apply that refund against the taxpayer's outstanding tax liability. 01:00:04.5800000 IRC Internal Revenue Code 7122 gives the taxpayers the right to appeal the rejection of an offering contract compromise to the Office of Appeals. Again, that's the mediation arm of the irs. This represents the second largest collection related program in appeals. When to request an appeal. An appeal must be made within 30 days from the date of a rejection letter. 01:00:29.3500000 The Appeals Division has no authority to consider an offering compromise appeal submitted after the 30 day period expires. So if you blow that period and you knew about it well in advance, then that's an issue where your malpractice carrier is going to get involved. So you might as well let them know in advance because that would be on you if you blew that period. Since the taxpayer is barred if the appeal isn't filed within that 30 day period from appealing the rejection of their offering contract compromise. What does appeals consider? 01:01:07.7900000 Appeals considers the same administrative guidelines and requirements that collections relies on. However, the appeals process offers an opportunity for a fresh look at the computation of reasonable collection. Potential appeals will use their settlement authority and offers filed based on doubt as to liability. Appeals also considers offers in compromise that are submitted as a collection alternative. In collection due process hearings. 01:01:33.0600000 If a taxpayer's financial situation is complex or asset values must be verified, appeals must ask compliance to conduct an evaluation and send them a report. Based on this investigation, the appeals employee would determine whether an offer is acceptable as submitted, whether the offer amount needs to be raised, or whether it must be rejected. Whether the appeals decision is final and is based on the source of the offer of consideration. In an equivalent hearing, the appeals decision would be final. In a collection due process hearing, the taxpayer whose offer has been rejected as a collection alternative has the opportunity for judicial review based on an abuse of discretion standard. 01:02:15.5500000 We're at the end. Oops. I'm sorry about that. That wraps up today's presentation and I know we're over time. I'm sorry, I wanted to just in the spirit of being complete so that you got the whole kit and caboodle, I went a little over. 01:02:32.4000000 Hope you got something out of this. My gosh, there is so much opportunity to carve a niche for yourself in this area of civil tax controversies. And that's why I'm doing this class, because I think that a lot of attorneys, attorneys have this idea that if they don't have a tax background, this is an area that's off limits. But it really isn't. You know, to be fully candid with you, I myself went back to school to get my LLM in tax because areas that I wanted to practice were very arcane and I had no accounting background. 01:03:09.3600000 However, there are a lot of areas in civil tax controversies that you can begin to understand through these presentations once you get a grasp on the language and the terms that are used. And like I said, you know, if you develop relationships with accountants, they become referral sources very quickly for you. And you can grow and build a formidable tax practice in a very short period of time by being someone that is there and trusted and that they can refer their clients to when an issue comes up that goes well beyond the scope of their knowledge. And trust me when I say a lot of issues surface like that. And I myself find myself reviewing and having to do research on areas that I didn't know about. 01:04:02.8000000 And that, of course, gives me the opportunity to learn new areas of. Of civil tax controversy. So it's a very fascinating field. And you do get to court. Doesn't happen with the same frequency as personal injury or criminal, of course, but you do eventually get to court and you get to see when that happens, how things work in this US Tax court, which in and of itself is fascinating. 01:04:31.0700000 So thank you so much again for your participation, and bye now.