[Course Name] 00:00:01.6000000 Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's presentation. Today's presentation is on ethics for government law attorneys. So we are going to talk sometimes more specifically just about government attorneys and being in the government and how we look at different scenarios, such as conflicts in relation to government attorneys, because sometimes it's a little different or there can be some nuanced things when it comes to government attorneys outside of private practice attorneys. So. So that's kind of what our focus and concentration is going to be here today. 00:00:34.8400000 But we will also talk about the rules of professional conduct in general as well, and just how they relate to the practice of law, whether that be a government attorney, a regular outside attorney, or anything in between, and just how it affects us in general. A little bit about myself, too, before we get fully started here. My name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant general counsel at Taft, Stentinius and Hollister law firm and in Indianapolis, Indiana. In that role, I practice ethics professional rules of conduct every single day, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. 00:01:10.5300000 And that's because I help with internal compliance with the rules of professional conduct questions from all of our attorneys across all Taft offices. They can come to myself or our general counsel with any of their ethical questions or concerns. And then if the firm gets sued or there's any malpractice, we help coordinate with outside counsel. We respond to subpoenas to the firm. We do all the internal ethics, governance, compliance, and anything that affects Taft. 00:01:40.5700000 So as I was saying, we're going to talk about the ethics of government lawyers. And with any question, whether it be for government lawyers or for your private practice attorneys, one of the main things that always comes up when you're talking about almost any rule of professional conduct is who is the client. And that is because knowing who the client is triggers who you owe our duties of loyalty to, who we owe our duties of freedom of conflicts of interest to, who we owe our duties of confidentiality to, and who we directly report to, who we work with and who we take direction from. And to answer any of those things that I just mentioned, we have to know, who is the client. Now, in private practice, sometimes it's a little more obvious who is the client. 00:02:31.1000000 For instance, if an individual comes to me and says, I want you to represent me in a divorce, okay, say the client's name is Joe Smith. I say, okay, Joe Smith. Write the engagement letter saying, you know, Joe Smith, I'm going to represent you regarding your divorce from Jane Smith. Here are the terms and conditions. Signed, sealed, delivered. 00:02:52.2600000 We know who the client is. It's Joe Smith. Now take that more into a corporate setting, too. When you're in private practice. We're still talking about private practice here. 00:03:03.5200000 Say Google comes to me and says, I want you to represent Google, the corporation. I say, great. I do that same type of engagement letter in private practice saying, google, you are my client. Here's the legal work I'm going to be doing for you. Here's our terms and conditions. 00:03:20.7500000 Signed, sealed, delivered. Now, sometimes in those corporate settings, they can get a little more complicated. And we're not going to get fully into the weeds of those complications at this moment, but just kind of a brief overview. If Google said, okay, represent me, Google and all of my affiliates and subsidiaries, then we're getting a little more complicated. There's going to be those questions of who are the affiliates, who are the subsidiaries? 00:03:46.7900000 What if they change? Are you going to notify us? I need the list. We got to run it through conflicts. And it goes on and on, but still pretty straightforward in that private practice context. 00:03:59.1700000 Now let's switch over to government practice. When you are in house or with a government or with an organization, who is the client? Is your client? Say the State of Minnesota is your client. The AG is your client. 00:04:17.7300000 You know, the Department of Justice or whatever, Department of AG or whatever it is you're the attorney for, who is your client Is your client, the town, the city, the people of that city is your client. You know, one individual victim, who is the client? Have you ever stopped as a government lawyer and thought about that question, who exactly is the client? Now, with a local government, it can be, you know, you're acting through the voters, the government board, the elected officials, employees. These are what are known as kind of the authorized constituents of that local government. 00:04:59.2400000 Now, it's usually the heads of the local government, which will be the ones you'll directly interface with, who probably the confidentiality will attach, who the duties of loyalty will attach not to the individuals, but to what they represent, the local government. You have to do what's best for, say, that city, that state, that town, that department. You're not thinking of what is best for this individual board member. What is best for this individual elected official? That's not the question, that's not the analysis. 00:05:33.3500000 Your client is the overarching entity. And while Rule 1.13 doesn't specifically say, you know, when you represent a government, this is your client, you, it does tend to go that way in the comments and the different literature that comes after it tells us it's used in this context too, that an organization's attorney represents the organization acting through its constituents. So you got to think of the word organization as government, as city, as town. So if you are a town lawyer, estate attorney, or you represent a governmental body or entity, that entity itself is is your client. And then you correspond through those constituents, those elected officials, that hierarchy, board, and report to them and take direction from them. 00:06:23.5700000 But at any time, as we'll see as we go through the presentation today, if their advice is contrary to the best interest of that government, that state, that town, that city, that organization, you have to do what's best for the entity, not those individual constituents, governing board voters. Now the problem really comes into play here is that we become friends with these people. We become friends with the voters, the members of the governing board, the elected officials, employees, they come over for dinner, they may be coming over for the holidays, your kids may go to school together. And so then you get this affinity, this loyalty towards them. But then one day those individuals come to you or one of them does and sits down in your office and says, hey, you know, we've had worked long together years, our kids are in school. 00:07:16.7200000 This has been great. By the way. I'm going to start embezzling money, by the way. I'm going to do this thing which may not be the best interest of the government or may not be the best interest of the town, but I'm going to do it anyway because it benefits me. You as the lawyer have to look that person in the eye and say you can't do that. 00:07:39.4300000 Otherwise you as a lawyer, and we'll see this coming on later too, with our reporting obligations, have to try to stop them, counsel them to stop or take it up and out those up John Miranda CORPORATE WARNINGS so those friendships start to cloud the question who is the client? When you represent a government body or when you represent a government agency, or when you just are in house at a company or corporation, it goes across the board because the rules really treat sometimes government entities the same as organizations. And so the same rules apply. We just have to look at them in the context of whatever scenario that you are in. So again, Here is comment 5 to Rule 1.13 really honing in on that point of how the rules kind of treat and classify government lawyers as, you know, kind of similar to the in house lawyers of corporations. 00:08:36.3000000 A local government attorney's ethical obligation flow toward the local government's governing board because that's the highest authority that can act on behalf of the organization. So we really look for that governing board, we look for those constituents, we look for that primary decision maker within the government and that's who we take direction from. But again, if their direction is going to adversely affect the government entity, the state, the town, the city, the corporation, whatever it may be, then we have to. And we'll see, we have slides for it. Don't worry. 00:09:11.7400000 We'll have to make those up, John. Reporting up and out obligations and because our duties of loyalty are owed to the entity itself, the governing body itself, not to those individuals, not to those golf buddies that, you know, we've become so familiar with over the years in working with them. Like I said, those difficulties really do come into play. The difficulties with the client relationship, the close relationships we develop, the places of interest over personal. We have a lot, a lot probably of heads of corporations, heads of government entities and bodies that are thinking more how does this affect me personally? 00:09:54.4500000 How can I profit myself? And then if we're that lawyer for that entity, that state, that government, we're thinking of how does this affect the governing body as a whole, not that one person's individual interest. And so then our interests start to conflict with who we have to report to you over here and what's best for the entity over here. And that's really what makes it difficult because we're all human, we would prefer probably to have that connection and keep that friendship than have to report them up and out or have to do something that's going to adversely affect that individual who's now our friend. So we really have to stop and think all the time who is our client. 00:10:40.8700000 And sometimes those individuals, the ones that, you know, we talk with daily and who help, you know, be that correspondence, that governing board, that body, look at us as their personal attorneys too, if we're a government lawyer and that's not the case. And we always have to keep that relationship very clear, very succinct, because if they tell you something and they think you're their personal lawyer and you're really the lawyer for the entity, then your duty of confidence, this is not owed directly to them, especially if what they're telling you is adverse than entity. You have an overarching duty to the client to make sure that client, that entity is protected. So always making sure we define those relationships, making sure we keep those clear boundaries, even as hard as it is with the friendships that will develop if you're a government lawyer or in house lawyer, and knowing when the privilege attaches, when it doesn't, and how you're going to navigate those waters. Now to the question is if you represent a governmental body and you talk to say a lay employee or a non attorney employer or someone not on the governing board, on the town council or whatever it may be, are those communications confidential and privileged? 00:11:55.6400000 Well, it may depend on the scenario. Obviously you'd have to let them know that you're not that non attorney's attorney. You know, you're not there to represent them. Your duties are owed to the overarching organization or entity. But can those be privileged? 00:12:12.6100000 Some jurisdictions say no, that it's just the privilege only attaches when you're talking to those decision makers where, you know, we owe, that we work through as the government lawyers or as the corporation corporate lawyers. And some jurisdictions say yes. And then some say depends on the scenario. So you really need to look at your specific jurisdiction. Most tend towards the first scenario I said, where those lower conversations are not necessarily privileged unless there's something you can get to attach or there's a certain scenario that can come about the privilege. 00:12:47.1600000 And the confidentiality only comes really when discussing matters with the decision making board, the C suite, that upper level. But again, you're not their individual attorney. You are the attorney for the corporation and that needs to be kept separate or the governing body. It's sometimes a very hard distinction to make, but it's one that government lawyers have to make all the time. And luckily here's kind of, you know, just the breakdown of what we were just talking about with that privilege and that confidentiality attaching. 00:13:20.4800000 Under federal law, the attorney client privilege for organizations extends beyond the control group, meaning it can cover employees authorized to act on behalf of the organization in connection with the matter being discussed under state law, usually the same applies and is recognized either by statute within that state or supreme court rule. So again, you need to check your local jurisdiction because each jurisdiction can differ from on where the confidentiality and privilege is going to attach. Is it just that control group at the top, that CEO or that, you know, mayor or whoever it is, that governing board and body, or does it extend to cover other employees that are not in that suic suite, that are not in that control group up at the top or not on that board? Does it extend throughout the government, organization, entity or body? That is going to be a very important thing to understand in your specific jurisdiction, wherever you're located. 00:14:25.1800000 So you know where that confidentiality attaches, so you know the parameters of it. And no two of you can claim privilege. What if someone on the other side or, you know, you're the organization, government body gets sued and you're in a discovery dispute, well, they ask for all these documents, all these communication, all these emails. Can you claim privilege on them? Can you say these are protected confidential communications? 00:14:52 Well, it's going to come down to who are you speaking with? What was it regarding? Are they part of this control group? Or are now we outside of the control group, meaning, you know, the lower level employees? And is this jurisdiction authorizing that privilege to extend down? 00:15:11.5900000 If it's not, then those documents or those communications may be discoverable from the other side. So we really need to understand who is protected under the client privilege, who is protected under confidentiality, and then make sure we know that and communicate that going into conversations. And I mean that by saying, you know, what if the governing board or the entity says to you, hey, I need you to go talk to these five, you know, lay employees, you know, about this case. Well, if those communications aren't going to remain privileged, then you need to let them know that because, you know, you may need to put certain protections around it or, you know, do something different to get the information. So understanding where communications are privileged, where they're not, where they're confidential, understanding who is that control group, who do you report to, who do you take your direction from, is important. 00:16:07.6900000 And that all flows from that first question of today. Who is the client? The government body, the entity, the organization that is your client, not the individuals within it? Yes, those are who you communicate with, but that does not automatically transform them into your client. Just another slide regarding that attorney client privilege, how it extends to all communications between attorney and client rendered. 00:16:35.9600000 But we still got to know who is that client? Who is that, you know, control group, who is that into that body that we can claim that privilege under? And then also flows to the second bullet point here on your screen. You know who has the right to waive it? Can that employee that extends to wave it, does it have to come from that upper management, that C suite control group, can it be impliedly waived through communications in the presence of third parties? 00:17:06.3300000 Absolutely. On that last one, the harder question is who can waive it? Because the client holds the key to any confidentiality. The client holds the key to waiver of confidentiality. But when you represent a government body or an organization or a corporation, who is the person that holds that key? 00:17:30.1000000 Is it more than one person who has the final say? Can one override another? And what does that look like? And it may be different for every governmental entity or organization in which you may be a part of or an attorney for throughout your life. If it is governed by a board, the board holds the key. 00:17:50.9000000 If the board's rule says some, you know, it has to be a majority vote, then maybe it has to be a majority vote to waive it. If someone has that final decision making power, maybe that waiver can come from them. You have to look at, you know, who holds the decision making authority within your client, which is the organization, and that who is who holds the key to waiver privilege and confidentiality. And so you can't just go to any Joe Schmo within the governmental entity or corporation and say, hey, I need you to wave this sign here and then claim, well, everyone is confidential. Well, yes, but not everyone's a decision maker. 00:18:33.8300000 And so that key is held with the client to waive confidentiality. That key can only be used by the client if the client is an entity, governmental or otherwise, then we have to go to who we take the direction from the C suite, the governing board, and look to what type of vote we need, who gets to make that final decision. Maybe it's a discussion. It may be different with every entity, but we have to treat it as that is the client who holds the key to it. One of the other issues too, aside from confidentiality, that comes up especially with government lawyers, and we may not think about it too much in the government as we do as much in private practice, the conflicts of interest. 00:19:23.3500000 Most local governments have a few attorneys who just provide legal advice to all departments and employees, but they still can have conflicts of interest. And there are still limitations on what they can and can't do. And especially if they're representing multiple agencies within that government. Because we all know government is not just necessarily one entity, but say, for instance, the state of Indiana, there's different sub entities of the state. There's the Department of Education, maybe there's the Department of, you know, Wildlife. 00:19:59.1400000 There may be something else, you know, down the line. There's tons of departments. They're all escaping me right now, of course, because I'm talking. But again, there's the state or there's the local government and then there's these departments. You can even think of that in the big context of federal government too. 00:20:15.5200000 You have the federal government and then, you know, we have all these sub governments, departments that are arms and wings of the political subdivision of the governmental entity. And so if you have one lawyer who is representing or giving advice to all those departments or wings of the state or the federal government, you could potentially have a conflict of interest depending on if the interests are all aligned or what is happening. But that government lawyer, that one lawyer giving advice to all these entities subdivisions has to keep in mind too. Who is the client? Is the client the big state federal government? 00:21:02.2600000 Is the client, the political subdivision or you know, the department? Because sometimes these interests over here with the department or the subdivision may differ from big state interest or big federal interest over here. So if we have one lawyer trying to advise both, we could have a conflict of interest. And so even government lawyers have to keep in mind those current conflicts of interest under Rule 1.7 and that there are limitations on representing multiple agencies and entities. Now, just going back to the foundation here, before we get into this a little bit deeper, Rule 1.7 is on the screen in front of you. 00:21:45.3600000 It states that a lawyer shall not represent a client if the representation of one client is adversely directly adverse to that of another client or there is a significant risk that the representation will be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client, a former client or a third party or a personal interest of the lawyer. Breaking this down, that first part of the rule of or 1.7, we can't be directly adverse to another client. So if we have government lawyer for State of Indiana and for Department of Agriculture in Indiana and now Department of Ag is conflicting with something the state's doing and wants to basically go head to head with the state, even though it's an arm of the state government lawyer can't do that. We're directly adverse. Same thing if you were in private practice. 00:22:42.5200000 If you represent Google and Yahoo, you can't be adverse to Yahoo on behalf of Google or vice versa without consents confirmed in writing. That's what cures a conflict, is those consents confirmed in writing. So we can't have that direct diversity whether you're in private practice or in government practice. The other part here, which may come more into play with government lawyers, is maybe that second part of the rule that the representation be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client. So say the lawyer is representing State of Indiana and the lawyer for all the departments and subdivisions. 00:23:18.9300000 But State of Indiana has told this lawyer certain things that it wants to accomplish which could affect the departments and not be necessarily in their ideal best interest. And so now when lawyers trying to represent these entities, he's trying to convince them to go along with State even though they don't want to. And so he's not really zealously defending them. So we could have a material limitation too, when it comes to one lawyer representing big government entity and subdivisions or different sections of big government that can be in state, federal, or any type of political subdivision across the board. So we still have to think of the conflicts rules. 00:24:03.3100000 We still have to think of how do they affect the representation. Even with government lawyers, it's not always just private practice where conflicts come up. Conflicts can also come up for government lawyers and the different contexts and roles that government lawyers play when they are representing the government entities. So here, despite a concurrent conflict of interest, a lawyer still may undertake the representation. If we believe that we can do it competently and diligently, that representation is not illegal. 00:24:35.1300000 It's not. We're not adverse in a litigation and we get those consents confirmed in writing. The obtain the written consent. And that is really the key to if the government lawyer wants to do both subdivision and big, they need to make sure these things are met, that they can do both competently, diligently. It's not illegal, it's not a litigation. 00:24:56.3100000 They're not going to be arguing at this table, then walk over to this table and make the other arguments. And the key, the big kicker, that's the only thing that can resolve a consent fully and ethically, is getting the consents confirmed in writing from both affected clients. Which means in the government context, State of Indiana, decision maker C suite there has to sign a consent waiver written, disclosing the potential risk involved of one government lawyer representing both state and subdivision, and then political subdivision or department down here has to sign a reciprocal waiver, just like big state or big federal up here, allowing that one lawyer to represent both. If there's going to be that potential interest, potential material limitation on what the lawyer can and can't do. If either one does not sign government lawyer, you're confined to one side or the other or you're out completely. 00:25:58.0800000 So we do have to watch those conflicts, even in the government attorney context and representing government entities and subdivisions because they are still present. It's a misconception to think that conflicts don't exist if you're a government lawyer, because they do. It's just a little different scenario. It's a little different, maybe analysis. And it may be a little harder to wrap your mind around that this is a conflict under Rule 1.7. 00:26:28.3500000 But we have to remember conflicts can exist anywhere, almost with any representation. And we need to make sure we're thinking about those things as government lawyers. One of the other things which I alluded to Kind of at the beginning of the seminar is our duty to report whistleblowing or, you know, duty to report, which is known as whistleblowing. Let me rephrase that a little differently. And there's always this balance too, because whistleblowing, as we all probably know, is when an inside person in an organization, whether it be an attorney, a non attorney, an employee or just a board member or someone within the organization, see something or hear something that's going to adversely affect the organization or that is illegal conduct and then that person reports it. 00:27:18.9000000 Whistleblowing is usually outside the organization to say the feds, to say local government or excuse me, local law enforcement to further investigate the corruption, the fraud or whatever is happening inside some of famous whistleblowers over time. Obviously there's the Enron whistleblower. I think her name was Sharon, Sharon Williams, I think. Don't quote me on that. I'm going off memory. 00:27:45.1300000 There's also been others through different scandals of companies and corporations throughout time, even during the pandemic. So they're not just, you know, from the early 2000s, there was a whistleblower within Facebook whistleblower there. She was not an attorney. She reported out that Facebook was using algorithms to produce hate and il and illegal actions of its viewers, like to entice its viewers to repeat hate or do something illegal based on hate mentality and hate thoughts. And so that whistleblower came out. 00:28:21.1300000 It, I think it was 2020 to 2021 when that whistleblower came out. Sharon Watkins was the whistler from Enron, just came to me, sorry. And so what we have to remember, it's someone inside that sees something, hear something, knows something that's illegal or, you know, going to harm their organization and they report it out. Now, a lot of times within these organizations there is a duty for lawyers, if we're going to be that whistleblower to report up and then report out the upjohn. Warnings Up, John is just the name of the case. 00:28:59.9200000 If you're not familiar with it, if you googled up John Warnings or put it into, say LexisNexis or Westlaw, you're going to come back with a case that is, you know, the foundation of it. And what it basically means is going back to that first example where we're friends with that, you know, mayor, that CEO, whoever it is, the governmental entity or someone sitting on that governmental board and they're sitting in your office and they sit there and tell you because they're going to embezzle money or they have this Ponzi scheme they're going to set up and they think it's going to work but you're like that's illegal. And they're like no it's not. And you know there's something that they're going to do. Or maybe you didn't find out about it directly through a conversation, but see documents, you see offshore accounts or the county looks off or different things. 00:29:49.6300000 However you find out about the conduct, that's illegal, that's fraud, that is something going to harm the organization. The UpJohn tells us one that technically that information is confidential because you learned it in the course and scope of your employment. The course and scope, the representation of the government entity or the corporation. But the exception to that is the reporting exception. That Upjohn warning. 00:30:14.3900000 We start reporting up meaning we take it to our board, we take it to those decision makers, we say hey, this is what we found. This is illegal. Change your ways, make this stop, do something about it. You know, we're counseling our client first, saying yes, I know this is confidential, I'm coming to you, you can't use my services, you cannot continue this fraud, you know, this illegal conduct or it's going to hurt the entity. If that upper agent or that upper reporting does nothing or does not solve the issue and it continues, you go up again. 00:30:51.7300000 If there's nowhere else to go up, you can go out meaning to the federal government, to the state government, to the authorities, whoever it is, to you know, report up and out. You go up the chain to the head decision makers of whatever conduct you found and if they do nothing or it doesn't stop or it's not, you know, going to resolve it, you can then choose to go out. That whistleblower going out. There are whistleblower protections and if you are an employee of the government because you're in house with the government, or you're an employee of the corporation because you're an in house cor corporate attorney or an in house attorney, you still get the protections that any regular employee would get for whistleblowing. It doesn't make a difference that you're the lawyer for that entity or that organization. 00:31:40.5500000 Now the thing though with whistleblowing and making sure we go up and out is that it doesn't allow us to reveal all of our clients confidences, all the entities confidences. What it allows us to do is to report enough to help stop or resolve whatever fraud, illegal conduct or harmful thing that is occurring. You don't just open necessarily everything you know and learned in confidence for the representation. It is only enough to make the disclosure. And that's one of the exceptions is stopping illegal conduct or fraud or financial, you know, stuff from happening that's imminent and very harmful. 00:32:22.5600000 If you read Rule 1.6 B, as in boy, you will see those exceptions there to this general rule of confidentiality. So we are allowed to report up and out when we see that illegal, harmful conduct or actions that are being taken. And this is just an example too, just to remind everyone of how broad our duties of confidentiality are. It is not just those attorney client privilege things where we're talking directly with those constituents, that C suite or those people that are protected under the veil of privilege. It's also protects anything we learn within the course and scope of our representation, which is that big red circle around attorney client privilege. 00:33:06.9900000 Now that big red circle, especially if you're a government attorney or an in house attorney, can include your entire job, everything you do at work, everything that hits your desk, you have to keep it confidential. As the attorney for that entity, that corporation, that governmental body. That is a very high task. And a lot of lawyers tend to forget that. They think it's only those communications, those attorney client privilege communications that are protected. 00:33:35.6100000 But it's not. It's anything that touches and concerns your representation of the client. So again, that first question of the day, who is your client? We now know. We have to know that for conf, for conflicts of interest, we have to know it for confidentiality, we have to know it for whistleblowing, because again, we're protecting that client, that entity, that government body, that political subdivision, that corporation, whatever it is, that is our client and that is who we have to protect. 00:34:08.8300000 And that too is going to define what fits within this big, big red circle of confidentiality and what fits within that inner blue circle of attorney client privilege. But they are two different things. The attorney client privilege or the communications directly between us and the stakeholders, whether it be the control group and employees, trickle down or just a control group. And then confidentiality is anything we learn in the course and scope of our representation of that government entity or that body, which includes our entire job normally. So we really have to think about that confidentiality and knowing that if we whistleblower report up and out, we only disclose enough information to basically stop the legal conduct or the bad conduct from happening, or for someone to take action. 00:34:58.6690000 We don't necessarily open our entire book of confidences to whoever reporting up and out too, but just enough to make whatever is going wrong wrong. And this is that Rule 1.6 B summarized because it really is delineated out in a lot of the rules, the local rules. And I do encourage you to check your local rules of professional conduct to see how your rules read. Because while we have the model rules, some jurisdictions have tweaked them slightly, changed them a little bit. So we need to make sure they're all complying, but just Lawyers may disclose to prevent a fraud that is reasonably certain to result in substantial economic injury and in furtherance of which the client has used or is using the lawyer services. 00:35:43.3100000 If you are in house in government or company corporation, if the company incorporation, someone inside of it is committing fraud, then obviously they're using your services because you're probably, you know, there to protect the organization. They may have run questions by you, maybe you advise them how to do it without knowing it and it could substantially result in economic injury that we have to try to stop or that we should try to stop. This is a May standard. You see that in the first line there. It's not a mandatory standard, but unless you want to be complicit in the crime or crimes, if that's what's occurring, or get charged as well, like the Enron attorneys did, I would recommend that May became a shall. 00:36:29.4500000 If you find illegal conduct or fraud or you know, embezzlement or anything like that, do not become a participant. Once you have knowledge, try to stop it. Report up and out. If you become complicit or you just look the other way or you actively help participate, you're going to be sitting in jail next to those control group clients or control groups that you report to for your client and not on the other side under the whistleblower protections. So again, think about those things. 00:37:03.8200000 But we do have a duty of confidentiality. But one of those exceptions is that we can whistleblow or report up and out if certain qualifications are met. And that is to prevent that fraud, that is that prevent that substantial injury. Because we cannot, we cannot insist, assist in our clients fraud or illegal conduct. Otherwise we are just as guilty as them and we deserve to be in jail right next to them. 00:37:33.1600000 And it was a wise professor of mine, I think, pretty wise. That said, you know, if anyone's going to jail at the end of the day, let it be your client, not you. Protect yourself first. Follow your ethical obligations, whether you're in house or private counsel. If anyone's going to jail, let it be the client, not you. 00:37:52.3500000 At the end of the day, this too just simplified down that Rule 1.13 is really going to be a lot of your home base when it comes to, you know, questions about organizations representing organizations, being a government lawyers representing entities, it is just really where it comes there. And this just says if a lawyer for an organization knows that that officer employee is filing the law or legal obligations to the organization, the lawyer must heightens it to that mandatory standard, report it to the higher authority. So reporting up and out, if you comply with your ethical duties and obligations, you can minimize damage to yourself into the organization that highest authority fails to act, then you may reveal to outside. So you take it up, you take it out, you take it up, you take it out. If you are complicit, if you look the other way, you're going to be in jail needing your own attorney. 00:38:48.3700000 So really think about that. And one of the hardest questions, especially when you're in house or with a government entity like in in house, meaning inside the government as well, when do you report? When do you decide to go up? When do you take that action? Is. 00:39:05.0600000 And the question to ask is, is the constituent, is the person who's doing the conduct that's harming the organization or could harm the organization or entity engaged in it, or intends to act, or refuses to act in a manner that's compliant with ethical obligations and does not avoid the lawyer services or the violation is impedable in the organization and likely to result in injury. So if you're deciding do I know enough to report or was that you know, CEO that came in the office or that mayor that came in your office and sat down just bluffing? Were they just blowing off steam? You have to sit down and think, okay, are they engaged in it? If the answer is no, do they intend to engage in it? 00:39:48.9900000 Like are they telling me their plans that are going to probably come true, or are they refusing to act in a manner related to the representation which is know, consistent with ethical obligations and they're doing the opposite. And so you've got to really go through and if you meet any of those things, then you probably may need to report up and out. Some other factors to consider in making that decision include the seriousness of the violation, the consequences, the responsibility in the organization to motivate people involved, policy concerns. There's always policies upon policies normally and anything else to help decide, do you meet that knowing standard to report up and out? Do you meet that standard to where if you don't report up and out, you're going to be sitting in jail next to that constituent that's doing their fraud or illegal conduct. 00:40:40.7700000 You really need to think about it. And this is just some other considerations too, because, and I put so much emphasis on this in so many slides. There's more slides. There's more slides on this, trust me, is because lawyers, especially in house government or in house corporate lawyers, do not like to report up and out. They will do everything they can not to do it if it does arise. 00:41:04.9700000 They don't like to be that whistleblower. They don't want to rock the boat. They don't want to make their friends mad or hurt their friends. So they try to rehabilitate inside. They try to say, well, I counsel them to do better. 00:41:19.6500000 They didn't. And then it bites them in the end sometimes. And it's those connections, those friendships. We really have to look out for those things because again, we're human. We want the friendships. 00:41:31.6100000 We want the golf buddy, the CEO, the dinner date, the kids playing in school together, because they may blame you, the lawyer personally, if you report up and out, even though you're just following your ethical obligations. And so, but we have to be very careful with what we do there. So you can ask the constituent, these are maybe some alternatives passed to you before you report up and out to compromise, mediate the situation, change its ways, you know, try to keep going to those higher authorities, try to minimize, you know, stuff, not minimize the situation, but minimize the harms and then hopefully counsel them to correct it before you go outside. But you always need to proceed in those best interests necessary or the best as necessary for the best interest of the governmental entity or organization or corporation. You have to keep your client, the organization, the governmental body, first and foremost, and do what's best for it. 00:42:28.9600000 And it is always that interplay with how much information, if you do decide to go up and out, how much you disclose. We can disclose obviously, when it's reasonably certain to result in that harm. We cannot reveal certain stuff, you know, that doesn't fall within those exceptions. So like I said, if you are going to report up and out, it is not a open. Your entire just divulge everything like verbal garbage coming out. 00:42:56.7800000 It is very calculated, it is very concise. It is only disclosing the confidential information necessary for them to rectify the situation or for this situation to hopefully have enough to get the people doing wrong hurting the organization. You are protecting your government body, you are protecting your organization. So we have to remember that, and we also have to remember too that a lawyer's duties are not always limited to current clients, but can be extended to those former clients and that a lawyer's duties extend beyond a lawyer moving from government practice to private practice. So this means even if you come out of government and go to private practice, you're still going to get hit with confidentiality obligations for what you did in the government, for obligations to not reveal it. 00:43:48.7700000 Because now that government's your former client and you may be faced with a situation where just leaving the government entity instead of following up John, reporting up and out is not enough. But again, we have to look at each situation separately and individually. But if you do leave the the government entity or organization, they do become that former client and you owe them all the same duties and protections of any other former client if you're in private practice or government practice. So if you leave, obviously you can't now represent someone adverse to the government that you're working for in something in which you were substantially participated and have knowledge of. There is a foundation. 00:44:34.2400000 It's under Rule 1.11, which is on our next slide, changed it. So if you were going to leave that governmental organization and go to private practice, conflicts of interest would be governed under Rule 1.11. And it says that a attorney shall not otherwise represent a client in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially as a public official or employee unless the appropriate government agency gives informed written consent to the representation. So we saw conflicts of interest earlier in the presentation today about, you know, representing maybe big government entity, political subdivision or department. Now we have a scenario where government lawyer is leaving government practice and going to private company. 00:45:25.5900000 In that scenario, rule 1.11 comes into play. Now, the problem with this scenario is, and I'm in private practice and I've seen it several times in, you know, the law firms I've worked in, government lawyer joins private practice. They rely or think, okay, new law firm's going to tell me when this rule is in vogue. So I know how can that be as the law firm or say, in my position, assistant general counsel of the firm, how do I know what you government lawyer, now private practice lawyer, participated in personally and substantially when you were government lawyer? I won't know that. 00:46:04.0600000 There is nothing I can put in our conflict system. There is nothing I can put a trigger red flag in to let every other attorney in the firm know what those cases and what those matters are for you. Only you, former government lawyer, knows that. So the obligation falls on you, former government lawyer, now private practice lawyer, to know when these situations arrive, to stop, to step back, to get your consents to solve it or not work on those matters. So just because you leave government practice to private practice doesn't mean you don't have a former client. 00:46:44.2100000 You still do. It's that government and anything you participated in personally or substantially, you are conflicted out of now doing in private practice. And only you government lawyer can make that call or know when that comes up. Now I will tell you too, if you step in it or do something in violation of this rule, big government entity over here who knows you were former government lawyer is probably going to call you on it and say you have a conflict. And then you're going to have to explain why you didn't follow this rule. 00:47:15.4800000 You could be disqualified. It could harm the client in the private practice. And so again, we really have to think just because you're in government and go to private doesn't mean you're free from conflicts. You still have conflicts. And so we always have to think in that context and that anywhere we do, whether in private practice or government practice, there are conflicts of interest. 00:47:37.8100000 And one last thing here before I know we have about nine minutes left social media and postings. Government lawyers and just anyone in house. It is kind of and even private practice. We all need to use good hygiene just because you represent a governmental entity. And yes, we all have freedom of speech and we know that still doesn't mean we can't violate the rules of professional conduct is what we say and do online. 00:48:06.1300000 So the good rule of thumb to always follow is if you could not or should not do it in person, do not do it online. Do not try to have ex parte communications. Do not disclose confidential information. Government. If you're still a government attorney or you know your private practice clients, always watch out for those. 00:48:25.7300000 Rule 1.6. We also have duties of candor. We can't lie. We have to be truthful in our communications. Prosecutors have to be truthful. 00:48:34.0100000 That extends to social media and online, personally and professionally. Because the rules of professional conduct apply to every lawyer 24 hours a day, seven days a week in our personal and professional capacities. So we need to think about those things. We also need to think before we tweet. We don't want to like ruin our reputation or you know, get disbarred for 120 characters. 00:49:03.8900000 Think before you tweet. Think two before you post anything politically charged or potentially offensive. You're not funny, just offensive. If it's something that is in bad taste, you may think it's funny personally. But think about today's Culture, Think about the public out there. 00:49:22.0500000 Do you want to have that outcry? Do not lie or mislead. Don't take selfies in the courthouse or with evidence. I'll show you a picture of that in just a second. And always remember that the rules apply to us 24 hours a day, seven days a week. 00:49:35.8300000 And I am going to skip ahead a few slides, so bear with me here because I know we're winding down on time, but I'm going to go into this no selfies in the courthouse and kind of show you what that looks like. So we're going through. So this is the. That's not the example I want. So this is the example I want. 00:49:54.6300000 Let's see. 00:49:58 Nope, that's not the one. Sorry. Like I said, bear with me. We'll get to it. This is the one I want to show you. 00:50:04.2800000 This is about the selfies with evidence and in the courthouse. So we have here Julie Jones, the L. Young assistant district attorney in Alany County, Pennsylvania, thought it would be humorous to pose with a Pittsburgh police officer, each of them holding a large gun with evidence in a case that the two worked on together. The police officer posted the photo to Facebook with the caption, you should take the police. So prosecutor district attorney didn't put this on Facebook. 00:50:30.4700000 Police officer did, but tagged district attorney with social media. Anything you are tagged in, anything you give thumbs up to, like, dislike, smiley face, heart, retweet, repost now becomes yours as if you were the original poster. So because Ms. Julie Jones did not untag herself from from this post that the police officer posted, she adopted it as her own as if she was the original poster of the content. Which means that if that content that this police officer posted and tagged her in violates the rules of professional conduct or violates her employee rules as being a prosecutor, she is now in trouble. 00:51:15.4600000 Even though she's not the technically the original poster, she left the tag on. She liked it, she retweeted it, she did any of those things. It is now her content as if she's original poster and can be disciplined for it if it violates the rules or the personnel issues. Here the district attorney's office called Jul Julie's behavior contrary to office protocol and the handling of evidence and her appearance with the photo was now a personnel matter because she was posted with a police officer holding something from evidence. I'll let you be the judge for yourself. 00:51:48.0400000 What do you think we have here? Police officer with the prosecutor Julie Jones. You should take the plate. Do you think this is against the rules of professional conduct. Do you think this is against personnel issues and policies of prosecutors? 00:52:05.3600000 Well, her employer thought it was and she was fired for the one post of 58 minutes or however long it was up. It doesn't matter. This is when it was just screenshotted. 00:52:18.3600000 We have a violation. So we have to watch what we do on social media. It goes back to. And I'll go back to that slide again. We have to use that good digital hygiene. 00:52:28.0400000 We should not. If we can't do it in person, do not do it online. It's not funny. It may have been funny to them, but now she's probably lost her job. Is it funny now? 00:52:37.8000000 You may have thought, oh, this is hilarious. You know, everyone's going to love this. Really? Are they? Let's think before we post. 00:52:43.9400000 You still have your freedom of speech, but the rules of professional conduct and your personnel guides are still there to. One has the right to fire you, one has the right to disbar you, but you still have your freedom of speech. So we need to watch our conduct online. We need to make sure we do the right things. And thank you for joining me for government lawyers and ethics.