[Course Name] 00:00:02.4000000 Hello everybody, this is Mike Doubless. This is a continuation of our newly launched tax series with LexVid. The topic for this program is called the Streamline procedures. I will give you a little bit of background and without jumping right in because I'm mindful of the fact that you may not know this area as well as teaching tax practitioners. Most of these programs are geared for CPAs and accountants. 00:00:36.8900000 But because so much of this crosses over into the world of compliance, there are a number of legal issues that always get triggered by, you know, by these tax issues. And so just a little bit about how I came to this work. I am not an accountant by any stretch of the imagination. My interest in tax was peaked in my third year of law school when I did an externship with a white collar criminal defense firm in New Jersey. 00:01:13.5100000 I came on board right around the time they were getting ready to try a white collar case. It was a case involving money laundering and it was a high profile case as the defendant was the CEO of a large computer manufacturing and distribution company. The allegations were that he was making use of the black market peso exchange to help drug lords launder the proceeds of dirty money from the drug court cartels. So it was a fascinating. It already had a lot of sex appeal and immediately piqued my interest. 00:02:01.2300000 Because of my interest in white collar crimes as well as money laundering in general, I became involved in researching a lot of the issues for the pre trial motion practice that the senior partners were engaging in. And one of the, one of the motions or one. Yeah, one of the motions was to dismiss the charges related to tax offenses. So as you might imagine, money laundering charges in the federal system are the most severe in terms of punishment. They can lead to punishment for over 10 years. 00:02:46.7300000 And as we all know, in the federal system, the prison sentences are, you know, are 85% or long longer, unlike the state system where the sentences are flat sentences and the individual oftentimes only has to serve, you know, 70% of the sentence or less before they become eligible for parole. But there were also a multitude of tax offenses that got charged in concert with the money laundering offense and, and those charges became the topic of motion practice. One of the charges was a charge for tax evasion. So I was asked to do a lot of the research around the dismissal of that charge. And along the way I became very interested in tax crimes. 00:03:39.8900000 And I stored that away and said to myself, wow, it would be very interesting to combine a criminal tax or criminal defense practice with tax crimes since it's such a niche area that not many attorneys actually parade in that area. So after six or seven years in the public defender's office, I went back to school. I earned my master's in tax law and I realized then that there was so much to the world of tax beyond just tax crimes that I was interested in. And as I, when I graduated and when I went into private practice with my dad, I helped to expand the practice into civil tax controversies and a little known area known as international tax compliance. And that's what I'm going to be talking to you about today. 00:04:33.6100000 International tax compliance usually is centered on a form that is not even an IRS form, believe it or not, but is a creature of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network and the Bank Secrecy Act. It is a form called the Foreign Bank Account Report. It is a little known form, as I said, and not many people are aware of it and have been aware of it since it's, you know, even though it's been on the book since the 70s and it really wasn't enforced by the IRS. The IRS is the enforcement agency for this form. However, again it's not an IRS form, but the agency for which it's a form of is the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. 00:05:27.8900000 The form is dubbed FinCEN Form 114. 00:05:35.0900000 It requires US persons, which is a broad term who have foreign bank accounts with high watermark balances that exceed $10,000 in us at any point in the course of the year to file what's called a foreign Bank Account Report form. Simple enough, right? If you are a green card holder, if you are a US Citizen, it doesn't matter so much where you reside in the world. 00:06:08.4700000 You may not have been on US soil in over 30 years, but if you have maintained your citizenship and not renounced it, or if you are considered to be a U.S. resident, you would trigger the this requirement of having to complete a FinCEN 114 with your 1040 at the end of a tax year. Many however, have not been compliant with the form for a myriad of reasons. Most of which, at least going back to the time when it wasn't enforced, was because they didn't know about the form and, and believe it or not, their accountants didn't know much about the form because it just didn't get much attention pre 2001. But in the aftermath of 911 the form got a lot of attention. 00:07:10.0300000 Why? Well, in the aftermath of 9 11, the terrorist attacks on US soil, the government began to look for ways to to track the illicit flow of terrorist money through our banking system. Because so much of what was learned in the aftermath of 911 was that the terrorist organizations were funneling money through our very own banking system. So you know, they were using, they were using our institutions to get this money to the terrorist organizations. And so the government had to stamp out the ability to use our banking system for illicit means. 00:08:10.5500000 And at the same time they didn't want to shut the whole banking system down because that would shut commerce down and that would result in even more harm to our economy because obviously our economy took a severe turn in the aftermath of 9 11, especially with the stock exchange and things and all of the after effects of the attacks. So what the government did was they looked to the low hanging fruit, meaning what laws and what forms were already on the books that they could start, that they may not have previously been enforcing, that they could begin enforcing to help root out or stamp out those who would use, who were using our banking system for illicit purposes. And they identified the F bar as such a fruit. As just such a fruit. They saw it as a way to, to, to bring those who were in the shadows into the light by having them, by having them disclose, by, by making sure that they disclose their foreign bank accounts to the extent that, that those accounts exceeded at any given time, $10,000. 00:09:39.6200000 Now, as you might imagine, the FBAR was not just designed to capture, if you will, those that were using our banking system for illicit purposes and to funnel money to terrorist organizations. But the government also saw it as an enforcement tool for those who would, who were in the shadows, if you will, about their undisclosed foreign bank accounts. So the government recognized that there were a great deal of individuals who should have been disclosing their foreign bank accounts and who had these foreign bank accounts for legitimate purposes or perhaps because, you know, by legitimate purposes, because perhaps the Swiss banks were offering a higher level of interest than, you know, the traditional brick and mortar accounts in the U.S. such as Wells Fargo and TD Bank. And yes, there might have been an aspect of bank privacy that the, that the U.S. 00:10:51.8600000 person and enjoyed and wanted to remain anonymous under bank secrecy laws by not having to disclose it to Uncle Sam. So the government recognized that there were individuals that were not using the banking system for terrorist purposes and to funnel money to terrorist organizations. But that just as well, but that might just as well have been dodging their FBAR filing requirements by not wanting to disclose their foreign bank accounts that they kept with Swiss banks or with other international bank institutions because they enjoy the anonymous ability of, you know, maintaining those accounts offshore without the government having to know about them. And so we need to know a little something, we need to know a little something more about why those individuals may not have wanted to disclose their foreign bank accounts to Uncle Sam. You might ask, you know, what harm would befall them aside from the fact of anonymity. 00:12:02.2900000 Well, first and foremost, they enjoyed the anonymity, but they also, but those who were not inclined to disclose their foreign bank accounts to Uncle Sam also had another modus operandi for not doing so. And that was that the US Stands alone as one of the only countries left in the world that taxes its U.S. citizens and residents on their worldwide income. And you know, as you can imagine, accounts, bank accounts that generate interest income tax, that interest income, no matter how light it is, needs to be disclosed on the taxpayers. 10:40 and this idea of the US taxing its citizens and residents on their worldwide income means that an account held in an international bank is also fair game for that individual to, to disclose and to pay taxes on the interest generated on the bank account. 00:13:15.7600000 So, you know, going back 30 some odd years, the Swiss bank accounts were oftentimes got a lot of interest, significantly more interest than a U.S. a traditional U.S. bank would offer its clients. And so, you know, the US person not only, you know, wanting to, wanting those bank accounts to remain anonymous and not wanting the government to know about them, also recognize that by disclosing those accounts, they would be responsible and ultimately liable for paying taxes on the interest income generated by those accounts. Now, keep in mind, we're not always, we're not talking about, you know, we're not talking about accounts with principal balances, you know, that are small. 00:14:10.8300000 You know, a lot of people that are parking money overseas had bank accounts that were in the high six figures and in the seven figures. It doesn't mean that that was, you know, that that was across the board. But many who did, you know, bank with Swiss banking institutions had principal, had principal amounts of 6, 7 figures. So, you know, at 11, 12% interest, that's going to be sizable amount of interest income that gets generated. And so to the extent that these individuals knew about an FBAR disclosure form and yet, you know, didn't really and didn't see it as having much teeth to it because there wasn't a lot of enforcement around it pre 2001, they would have just ignored the form. 00:15:02.1400000 And you know, it wasn't always their fault because a lot of times they'd have accountants that, you know, it wasn't on their radar screen either. So you can see that there are a host of reasons why, you know, people pre 2001 and even post 2001 would not like the idea of having to disclose their foreign bank accounts. You have, you know, those that are extremely willful in the sense that they were using the US Banking system to funnel money to terrorist organizations. And so we would be looking then at terrorist organizations of the likes that Osama Bin Laden was involved in. And then, you know, then we move. 00:15:45.3600000 It's like on a scale, right? It's like on a spectrum, if you will. The far extreme being those that would funnel money through our banking system to finance terrorist activities. And then on the other end or mid range of the scale, you have those that were, you know, that didn't want to disclose the foreign bank accounts for fear that they were going to have to pay taxes on the interest income generated by those accounts, which was going to be a sizable amount of tax liability. And then you have those on the other end of the, of the scale altogether that were non willful and just didn't know about this FBAR form. 00:16:31.7700000 So yes, this is, this is where we are right now in post 2001. Of course, the government is looking for the low hanging fruit in terms of finding whatever is already on the books and has been passed by the legislature to start enforcing these laws to stamp out terrorist organizations and those again, that are using our system to finance money to terrorist organizations and at the same time to bring out of the shadows those who have these large bank accounts overseas that are generating so much, so much interest income that can be taxable. Because obviously the government is always looking for ways to replenish the coffers and to make sure that they're capturing all of the taxes that they are entitled to. So for all these reasons, post 2001, the government started to enforce the FBAR with abandonment, with gusto, like it never had before. 00:17:42.9200000 And in that spirit or in that effort, they realized along the way that there was a sizable number of individuals that had not been in compliance with their FBAR reporting obligations. They realized that there were essentially two forms of, of individuals that were not in compliance. Those that were labeled the Al Capones, that were so willful in their failure to disclose their foreign bank accounts and were, how can I put it? They were so willful. They were, they were, yeah, they were, they were, they were basically, you know, goading. 00:18:29.2900000 They were basically, you know, under no circumstances did they want to disclose. Then you had those whose failure to disclose on their FBARs was just completely accidental. Completely. It was completely an Oversight. So the government recognized that it had a number of ways to encourage enforcement. 00:18:53.4800000 There were civil penalties that they could enforce as part of the, part of what are called civil FBAR penalties, which again are monetary penalties that they could use to enforce the filing of an fbar. And at the same time the government had the ability to bring criminal charges for failing to disclose foreign bank accounts on an fbar. So for all these reasons, there was an absolute, an absolute firestorm that developed in the wake of heavy fbar enforcement post 2001 because of those taxpayers that were getting ensnared within the coils of the heavy handed enforcement of the government. These individuals may not have been sneaky, so accidental in having not filed their FBARs. Their failure to file their FBARs might have veered closer towards the willful end of the spectrum. 00:20:03.0600000 And they didn't want to take a chance that if the government found out about them, not only could the government unleash the full panoply of civil f bar penalties and other civil tax penalties such as the accuracy related penalty, the civil tax fraud penalty, interest penalties, etc, etc. They wanted to find a way to get up on this and to, you know, and to get out into the open, if you will, and to disclose before the government caught on to them. And that. And so the government realized that there was a cross section of taxpayers who in a good faith effort wanted to come out of the woodwork and disclose their non compliance on the FBAR front. So they designed what was called an offshore voluntary disclosure program that offered taxpayers who came out of the woodwork and who self disclosed this non compliance with their FBAR the opportunity to get into compliance without a losing the shirt off their back in terms of civil FBAR penalties and b without risking a referral to DOJ for criminal prosecution. 00:21:24.4400000 On the FBAR front, that program was known as the offshore voluntary disclosure program. It was very controversial because there was a heavy, heavy handed penalty that taxpayers had to agree to pay in order for, for their sins to be forgiven. On the FBAR non compliance front and in order for them to be brought up to date with their tax obligations such that they would be given immunity from prosecution. And again, that was known as the officer of voluntary disclosure program. There was an eight year look back period and essentially what the government insisted upon was, was that they would take the highest of those eight years watermark balance of the highest balance of the accounts that the taxpayer had in that eight year look back period and apply a 27.5% penalty that would be called the miscellaneous offshore penalty. 00:22:30.8500000 And that miscellaneous offshore penalty was the penalty that the taxpayer had to pay in lieu of undergoing an examination and having to pay a host of civil FBAR penalties that would have been so far higher than the miscellaneous offshore penalty that the miscellaneous offshore penalty would almost be a joke. However, it wasn't a joke because even though it was disproportionately less than anything that the IRS could have asserted in terms of a willful civil f bar penalty, the fact remained that a lot of these high watermark balances were in the 5 to $10 million range. So you take a high watermark balance of 5, $7 million and you multiply that by 27.5%, that's a pretty hefty penalty. And if you take a taxpayer who, who was in retirement or close to retirement, that could have wiped out their entire life savings. So a lot of taxpayers were strong armed into going into this, into the offshore voluntary disclosure program based out of fear. 00:23:44.1100000 They didn't want to wake up one day and discover that the IRS was examining them for the undisclosed foreign bank accounts because the risk was so great that if the IRS asserted these willful civil FBAR penalties, it would be disproportionately higher than any civil penalty they'd have to play have to pay in the offshore voluntary disclosure program. And they would risk the possibility of a referral to the Department of Justice and criminal prosecution. So, you know, that would keep anybody awake at night fearful of what could happen not only in terms of civil penalties, but also in terms of the loss of their liberty. So that's what caused a lot of people to jump into the offshore voluntary disclosure barrack, if you will. It was like the equivalent of the fox and the predator, the greyhound that hunts the fox. 00:24:53.1500000 The fox was, in this metaphor, was the taxpayer. And to the extent that the greyhound got the scent of the fox while the fox was out hunting and before the fox got to its hole to bury itself or bury itself into the ground, it would be then too late for the fox to take advantage of OVDP or for the fox, you know, literally speaking, to save itself, because the greyhound would be too fast and would get to him before they were able to seek sanctuary in the hole in the den, if you will. And in that case, the fox is squat. Similarly, as the IRS is the greyhound in this metaphor, if the IRS caught assent of the taxpayer and their non disclosure with the FBAR and got caught the scent of it before the taxpayer came out of the woodwork to enter this Voluntary disclosure program. It would then be too late for them to avail themselves of this program. 00:25:57.4100000 While this was all going on, the government was entering into. The government had begun to start compelling disclosure of what they called anonymous aggregates from foreign banks. So the days where there was no information sharing between the US and the Swiss banks basically went the way of the bathwater. The government knowing that, that there were so many taxpayers that would not come out of the woodwork or the shadows to disclose these foreign bank accounts. Despite the incredibly onerous and high FBAR civil penalties, the government began to compel the foreign banks themselves to disclose nameless aggregates, meaning the number of US Account holders that were maintaining accounts with the bank. 00:27:06.8700000 And once the government obtained those nameless aggregates, they were able then to take the next step of uncovering or unsealing the names of those very taxpayers. So no longer was Swiss bank secrecy and other countries bank secrecy laws going to insulate or protect these taxpayers from disclosure to the government, to the US Government. Instead, the banks who themselves, if they did not sign onto these agreements with the US would suffer an incredible backbreaking finds and penalties. They then began to cooperate with the US government, who was essentially strong arming them in many ways to disclose these nameless aggregates. And the government was succeeding. 00:28:04.6100000 Week after week, month after month, there would be press releases on the DOJ's website and all over the Internet on Forbes, especially with press releases adding to the list of banks that had partnered with the US Government to disclose nameless aggregates. And so taxpayers with these foreign accounts were getting nervous. And a lot of times, in the wake of a new press release identifying that particular taxpayer's account as being that particular taxpayer's bank, as entering into one of these agreements with the U.S. the taxpayer would do one of two things. They would rush to their accountant's office to find a way of entering into this OVDP program or B, they would then transfer their assets to another bank that had not yet been ferreted out or not yet signed onto an agreement with the doj. 00:29:09.4300000 So this was going on all over the place and for a period, and it's still going on. But it reached its peak between I would say, 2007 and 2018, 2017, 2018, the IRS recognized that there needed to be a companion program for those taxpayers that were less willful, or what we call non willful, where the failure to disclose their bank accounts was a mere oversight. 00:29:47.5100000 These are those taxpayers who just didn't know about the F bar and essentially might have inherited a foreign bank account from a relative in the old country, or they might have taken advantage of, of the higher interest rates that Swiss banks and other international banks offered them. And there's nothing that makes that illegal. Of course, a person can do that, but they might not have known about their tax obligation, about their tax reporting obligation. And perhaps the high watermark balance on those accounts was not more than 50,000 or 60,000 at any given point and during the tax year. So the IRS realized that they needed to create a companion program for non willful taxpayers, and they did just that in creating the streamlined procedures. 00:30:46.4200000 The streamlined procedures are designed specifically for those taxpayers who are non willful. And this whole issue of willfulness gets put on a, gets put on a spectrum like we were talking about earlier, where we look at the, at the extreme poles and the extreme poles on a willfulness, a willfulness timeline or a willfulness, a willfulness. I just described it right now. A willfulness, a willfulness. Yeah, Willfulness timeline is willful on the far end, non willful on the, on the opposite end. 00:31:28.7200000 The those two extremes of this timeline are easy to determine based on certain factors. It's the gray areas which fall in the middle or in the 2/3 area or in the first 1/3 area that are difficult to make calls on. And that's when tax attorneys are needed because accountants don't do this type of work. And so they'll have their client, they'll refer their client to a tax attorney that specializes in this and the tax attorney will do a risk assessment to let the client know where the non compliance, you know, what part of that light spectrum the non compliance falls on based on these variables of the high watermark balance of the account. What year are we in right now? 00:32:26.4900000 Are we in 2020? Where there's been so many press releases surrounding the FBAR that any individual that claims not to know about FBAR reporting is essentially not being truthful. Because even my brother and sister who don't practice this area help have at some point come upon a press release from DOJ about banks having to turn over nameless aggregates and a Forbes article or a Forbes article about the FBAR filing form. And they themselves don't have an international, an account with an international bank. So, you know, we have to basically look at all of the factors and, and do a risk assessment. 00:33:15.1500000 And based on that risk assessment, we would give the client an opinion on which program the streamline or offshore voluntary disclosure was best to come into compliance with their FBAR reporting obligations. The offshore voluntary disclosure program has been retired. It no longer exists, but the streamlined procedures do, and that's what this program is focused on now. There have been a couple different versions of the streamlined program. Back on June 18, 2014, the IRS overhauled the Offshore Voluntary Disclosure program, which was still in existence then, and expanded and modified the streamlined filing procedures in order to accommodate a broader group of US taxpayers. 00:34:06.4200000 These changes amount to the IRS's latest effort to promote tax compliance and to crack down on offshore tax evasion, which has been an agency priority for years. Experts predict that these programs will ease the financial and legal pain for almost 6 million expatriate Americans who live and work abroad, many of whom are utterly naive about FBAR reporting. These are some of the major changes to the streamlined procedures. First, they expanded eligibility to a wider population of U.S. taxpayers, namely those residing in the U.S. 00:34:41.6600000 second, they eliminated the $1,500 tax threshold. And third, they eliminated the risk assessment process associated with the 2012 Streamline Filing Compliance procedures. So a fundamental tenet of streamline is that they relax the penalties that a taxpayer with an overseas account might otherwise face for failing to disclose a foreign account. We talked about that earlier. There's on one hand a civil FBAR penalty scheme and on the other hand there is a criminal FBAR penalty scheme. 00:35:17.3000000 The civil f bar penalty scheme includes financial penalties. However, it can be subdivided into two types of f bar tax penalties. On the one hand there is the non willful civil f bar penalty and then on the other hand there is the willful civil f bar penalty Willfulness. If the Obviously, and I don't want to take anything for granted, so I'm going to be very specific here, a willful f bar penalty is a staggering amount. Essentially it is the higher of $100,000 or 50% of the account balance on the last day of the tax year, whichever is greater. 00:36:14.1800000 So to the extent that the IRS can make a showing by clear and convincing evidence that the taxpayer's non compliance and failure to disclose the foreign bank account was willful, then the IRS would be able to assert a whopping willful civil FBAR penalty, which would be $100,000 the greater of $100,000 or 50% of of the end of year balance. So just to give you some figures to put some meat on the bones here so that you can see how large those penalties can be, if the client, for example, had an end of year balance in their foreign bank account of $500,000, 50% $500,000 would be $250,000 I'm extrapolating or converting, of course, from the foreign currency into the US Currency because when you talk foreign bank account, you're going to be talking about that foreign currency. You're going to be talking about the account in that country's foreign currency. So yen, for example, let's assume that the yen, that the high watermark balance was converted from yen to, to US currency and gave us a $500,000 high watermark balance on December 31st of the tax year. It's an undisclosed foreign bank account. 00:37:50.0500000 To the extent that the taxpayer did not avail themselves of this special, this special program, this special program, then they would be subject, if the IRS could prove willfulness, they could be subject to 50%, a 50% willful civil FBAR penalty, which would be $250,000, multiplying 50% times 500,000, 250,000 is greater than $100,000. So it would be $250,000 for that account. But it gets even worse than that. If the taxpayer had a another account, for example, that was $100,000, the willful FBAR penalty would not be limited to only the $500,000 account. It would also include all other accounts that were not disclosed. 00:38:47.1500000 So they would be aggregated one on top of the other. And like I said, if the individual is close to retirement and this is their retirement savings, it would be wiped out in one fell swoop. That's with this, with the willful civil FBAR penalty. But that is what is risked if the taxpayer doesn't come out of the shadows and take advantage of one of these voluntary disclosure programs, whether it be streamlined or whether it be offshore voluntary disclosure. Now, of course, I mentioned, I preface this all by saying that, that the IRS must prove willfulness by clear and convincing evidence. 00:39:30.9700000 So to the extent that the IRS has undertaken an examination and submitted a deficiency letter with this tax deficiency, but the taxpayer believes that their failure to disclose these foreign bank accounts was not willful, meaning on that, on that spectrum, it fell closer to the non willful poll than it did the willful poll. The taxpayer, of course, could go challenge the deficiency, could challenge that amount, and have, for all intents and purposes, a civil trial in federal court where a jury gets assembled to hear the issue, the narrow issue of whether the taxpayer's non compliance was willful. So we, I just gave you an example of a willful civil FBAR penalty. The other thing that you need to note when it comes to civil FBAR penalties is that the FBAR penalty is just one aspect of the of the spectrum of civil tax penalties that the IRS could unleash on the taxpayer, the IRS also can avail itself of other civil tax penalties. When they assert an FBAR penalty. 00:40:56.9600000 They can avail themselves of something called the accuracy related penalty. They can avail themselves of another penalty called the civil tax fraud penalty, which is a whopping 75% of the understated under reported amount. They can avail themselves of interest. So these penalties get compounded and compounded and compounded. Now, on the other side of civil f bar penalties is what's called the non willful FBAR penalty. 00:41:25 As you can imagine, the non willful FBAR penalty is going to be a little less, a little is not going to be as high as a willful FBAR penalty because after all the, the IRS is recognizing that it's non willful in the sense that the taxpayer hasn't been intentional or deliberate in a sense of Al Capone for failing to disclose their international bank account. It was in that case a mere oversight. And in non willful civil FBAR penalties, the IRS could actually opt to just slap the taxpayer on the wrist by sending them a letter saying, don't do this again. We found out about this undisclosed foreign bank account, don't do it again. However, the IRS also reserves the right to assert penalties, but again, and there are guidelines that the IRS has to adhere to based on the high watermark balance of the accounts that were undisclosed that would drive the penalty for non willful. 00:42:38.4800000 And so you see that there are two forms of civil FBAR penalties. When we get into when the non compliance is so blatantly willful, that's when the IRS is going to unleash all of these enforcement tools. It's going to not only come after the taxpayer on the willful civil FBAR penalty front, but it's also going to make a referral to CI, the criminal investigation arm of the IRS to investigate the taxpayer and recommend criminal charges. Because willfulness in the f bar world could lead to a criminal charge of failure to file an FBAR which carries with it five years in prison, as well as a number of criminal financial penalties on top of willful civil FBAR penalties. So you can see that this is something that, a lot of, that scared a lot of taxpayers and that they wanted to, they wanted to get ahead of, if you will, by coming out of the shadows and, and self disclosing before the IRS caught wind of their foreign bank accounts as a result of having obtained all this information from the foreign banks. 00:44:04.8300000 There are two types of streamlined procedures there's what's called the streamlined domestic offshore procedures, and then there's what's called the streamlined foreign offshore procedures. Don't think that this is anything like real, real, you know, real fancy, if you will. It is merely a way of distinguishing between a US Person who is residing off, residing outside of the US Meaning on foreign soil, versus a US Person who is residing inside the United States on US Soil. And we'll see how that, how that, how that distinction will result in two different types of requirements for a taxpayer to be shepherded through these programs in terms of what is required. So US Taxpayers living abroad or their estates who disclose their foreign accounts and settle their US Tax bills under streamline foreign offshore won't be charged any penalties whatsoever. 00:45:21.2600000 Instead, they will simply owe back taxes and interest. So I state this again, under the streamlined foreign program, U.S. taxpayers who live abroad, meaning outside of the United States on foreign soil, who disclose their foreign accounts and settle their US Tax bills under the streamlined foreign program won't be charged any penalties. Instead, they'll simply owe back taxes and interest. Right about now, you might be asking, did I hear you right? 00:45:52.3500000 There's no miscellaneous offshore penalty under the streamlined foreign offshore procedures? Yes, that is correct. Also eliminated was the requirement that the unpaid tax be fifteen hundred dollars or less a year. That was a low ceiling that most people exceeded. There will now be no limit. 00:46:10.9500000 At the same time, the IRS extended an olive branch to Americans living in the US with undisclosed foreign accounts or their estates who previously were ineligible from participating in streamlined. Those individuals who come forward now will owe back taxes, interest, and a reduced miscellaneous offshore penalty equal to 5% of their undisclosed foreign financial assets. Previously, they would have faced a 27.5% penalty. That was the penalty scheme within the offshore voluntary disclosure program. So keep in mind, the disparity between the penalty in streamlined domestic versus the miscellaneous offshore penalty in the offshore voluntary disclosure program has to do with the fact that in ovdp, that program was designed specifically for those taxpayers whose failure to disclose their foreign bank accounts was willful. 00:47:12.9600000 The Al Capones, if you will. I hate to label individuals like that because I did shepherd a number of clients through the offshore voluntary disclosure program that were, that were, that were, to me, more like grandma and grandpa that, you know, didn't really know about their, you know, FBAR filing requirements. But because of the high watermark balance of their accounts, we didn't want to risk basically putting them through the streamline program for fear that we would be trying to fit a square into a round Hole and shoehorn something that was not going to fit into the streamline program because it's a one shot deal if you make the wrong decision. It's a little like that Indiana Jones movie where you know, they had to pick the right chalice of, you know, from the last supper, and if they picked the wrong one, then they were going to perish. So it's a little like that in the sense that if you try to shoehorn a client that rightfully belongs in the offshore voluntary disclosure program because of the willfulness into the street streamline programs and are subsequently rejected, then it's too late for the taxpayer to jump into the offshore voluntary disclosure program. 00:48:48.1500000 They've made their bed and now they've got to deal with the repercussions, which is that they're now ineligible for any program. But again, the 27.5% penalty recognized the fact that there was more willfulness with the taxpayer who entered the offshore voluntary disclosure program than with the taxpayer who entered streamlined. Streamlined, again, was an oversight, you know, a mere, you know, you know, just, it was completely benign and innocent. The failure to disclose the FBAR and thus the penalty would be substantially less in streamlined than it was in offshore. It would be a mere 5% of the undisclosed foreign financial assets. 00:49:35.0900000 However, as with all programs overseen by the irs, there's always the fine print, the most important of which is a certification by the taxpayer that his or her failure to report all income, pay all taxes, and submit all required information returns was not willful. That again was called the certification. And it wasn't something that you could simply say, I didn't, you know, my failure to do this was a mere oversight. The IRS was looking for a deeper apology, if you will, or a deeper explanation for what happened. So tax attorneys were asked to draft certifications to list all of the the factors that weighed heavily in favor of the taxpayer's conduct being non willful. 00:50:28.2600000 It wasn't enough to just say, I, John taxpayer, merely overlooked my FBAR filing requirement. No, we had to substantiate that conclusory statement with facts like actions speak louder than words. We needed facts to marshal up to show that this was an innocent oversight. What might some of those facts be? Low watermark balance in the bank account, meaning that the account generated such little interest income that it might have resulted in $100 or less of additional tax liability. 00:51:09.5900000 And this is someone who was in compliance with their tax obligations since the time they were they first started to file a 1040. So it is so out of character for someone that has been in compliance for the last 20, 30, 40 years of their life to just to willfully and deliberately not disclose this foreign bank account age is another factor in if they were on in their years and not as savvy in terms of being online and that younger people that the younger generation was, that would lend itself to one of the non compliance being a complete oversight. If the account was inherited from a family member, from a will, and they didn't even know that they were the beneficiary of that will until recently, that would be another factor that inured to the benefit of the taxpayer. You know, factors that might militate in favor of willfulness would be ones where again the high watermark balance in the account was very high, meaning that the interest income generated was significant enough to, to have increased the taxpayer's tax liability. And thus the IRS could make some assumptions that the taxpayer wanted to underreport, didn't want to disclose his foreign bank account for fear that they would have to pay more money in taxes. 00:52:49.3100000 So essentially that's like tax evasion. They're under reporting their gross income by not wanting to do disclose a six figure high watermark balance account. Other factors in the wake of one foreign bank account. In the wake of a press release from DOJ announcing that HSBC bank has entered into an agreement to disclose nameless aggregates to doj. In the wake of that press release, the the taxpayer moves three or four of the accounts that they maintain with HSBC to another foreign bank account and that subsequent foreign bank account has not been named as one of the foreign banks that has entered into a disclosure agreement with the Department of Justice. 00:53:39.3100000 So you see there's so many factors that go into this and so we could not no attorney worth his soul in five minutes, let alone an hour, could be able to give an opinion, make an opinion to the taxpayer that they could rely upon. Instead they had to look at all at the totality of the circumstances. They had to look at so many different variables and then give the client an opinion on whether they felt that this form of disclosure was more reasonable than that form of disclosure. And essentially it would hang and rise and fall on where the needle on the spectrum of willfulness fell. Did it fall closer to the willfulness end? 00:54:35.2200000 Did it fall closer to the non willfulness end? Those are usually easy, easy to deal with or was it vacillating in the middle, in which case it could go either way. And then you need to take into consideration your client's tolerance for risk. So yes, so much goes into all of this. Those taxpayers, again, who could not certify that their conduct was non willful were left with one option, albeit an unpopular one, and that was to apply to the offshore voluntary disclosure program. 00:55:07.4100000 Despite the seemingly taxpayer friendly incentives, the streamlined procedures, both domestic and foreign, had many shortcomings. And here are a few of them. First, they do not provide an ironclad guarantee of immunity from prosecution. So that's really what you always are after. Because even with the Department of Justice's scarce resources and low manpower when it comes to prosecuting tax cases and how selective they are to maximize the deterrent effects of these convictions, this is why DOJ will sink their teeth into a celebrity who has underreported gross income over a grandma who is 75 years old and is under reported $100,000 of gross income. 00:56:00.8200000 The backlash against the IRS for going after an elderly person who was in the twilight period of their life would be so detrimental to them that they wouldn't even want to go there. They would want to deal with that in terms of asserting tax penalties for failing to disclose that underreported gross income sooner than they would want to refer the 75 year old grandma to the Department of Justice. But with scarce resources, DOJ always has to be very strategic about what cases they're going to prosecute. They also take into consideration how likely the conviction is. They don't want a case that could go either way because of course they're going to be spending an inordinate amount of money in prosecuting the case to the extent that the client, that the defendant is not willing to take a plea deal and wants to fight it. 00:57:03.7800000 So they want to review how substantial the likelihood of conviction is. DOJ loves, loves CPAs, accountants, professionals like attorneys who have under reported their gross income. They will, they will certainly throw the book at them because that also sends a very strong message to the rest of the public that these professionals who have a fiduciary responsibility to their clients are not above the law and they will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. So we were always looking for immunity. And yes, there is no ironclad guarantee of immunity in streamlined, let alone in the OVDP program. 00:57:51.2600000 However, it was the rare circumstance that an OVDP case would be referred for prosecution. It's a delicate issue of course, that there isn't an ironclad guarantee because after all, as part of the offshore voluntary disclosure program, even streamlined for that matter, you, you are the ones, you are the receptacle of all of the evidence. The government doesn't have the evidence that they need to prosecute your client. You, however, are providing it. And that puts you in a very delicate situation because you are not a DOJ attorney, you are not an ausa, you are not a member of irs, you're not a revenue agent, you're not in chief counsel's office, you are the attorney representing the taxpayer. 00:58:50.5500000 And so your obligation first and foremost is to protect the rights of your client. So it can become problematic that to hear that there isn't an ironclad guarantee of immunity. However, the officer voluntary disclosure program came very close to saying that it was pretty much immunity by saying that it was substantially unlikely. I think that was the language that they used that a referral would be made to the extent that the taxpayer cooperated to the fullest extent possible. And they would also be subject to, in this offshore voluntary disclosure program to a internal. 00:59:36.9900000 They would be subject to a review. They didn't call it a full scale examination or audit of the type that the taxpayer could be subject to outside of this program. But nonetheless it was a review that mirrored in many ways a full scale examination. Because oftentimes we would receive what were called information document requests for further information. So you would first and foremost have to fill out all of the forms as part of OVDP and submit the information that was required on these forms. 01:00:15.2600000 Most of the information was tailored specifically to the foreign bank accounts. They want foreign bank account statements. They would want, you know, specific information regarding the accounts themselves, how they were set up, etc. Etc. Part and parcel of those. 01:00:34.1500000 Of that, you know, of the bare bones information that the government wanted as part of an offshore voluntary disclosure were additional things. So based on the information that you would forward them initially based on that, you know, the quorum of. Or the. Yeah, based on that small information or not small, it was still substantial. But based on the general information that was required up front, there might be follow up items that the government wanted in doing their review and they would submit those things in a checklist form on what's called an information document request and you would have to comply. 01:01:18.2100000 So yeah, it's a little bit like feeling you're selling your client down the river. But when you have a client whose willfulness, you know, veered closer towards who, you know, on the scale of willfulness, veered closer towards willfulness, you didn't want to take any chances, especially if their tolerance of risk was such that they were having trouble sleeping at night and that this was causing them Psychological. 01:01:43.1000000 This was taking a toll on them psychologically. The question that I get asked most frequently is if there is any risk of audit under the streamline procedures. Returns submitted under either the foreign or domestic offshore procedures are not automatically selected for audit. Instead, they were subject to verification. And through verification, the examining agent could request account statements and other relevant documents to verify the information reported. 01:02:10.7600000 So again, it wasn't called an examination or an audit, it was called a verification. But I dare say that some of those verifications would be as intrusive as an examination. However, this doesn't mean that an examination isn't impossible. This doesn't mean that an examination isn't possible. Sorry. 01:02:31.6400000 On the contrary, such returns could be selected for audit under the existing audit selection process applicable to any US Tax return. A recent Internal Revenue Manual procedural Update so if you're not familiar with pronouncements and different things, different authority, I should say in the world of the irs. So we have the Internal Revenue Code. The Internal Revenue Code is the bible. That's where we go to to find the answers to questions that we have. 01:03:12.9400000 If we cannot find the answer to our question in an internal in the code itself, then we might look to secondary sources. Secondary sources include treasury regulations. They are small little opinions on issues that have surfaced in the course of, you know, in the course of that Internal Revenue Rules, life lifespan. There are also a myriad of other secondary resources. We of course have U.S. 01:03:53.6400000 tax court that hears disputes and authors opinions. 01:04:00.4000000 And just like in article, I think we call them Article 3 courts which are, you know, our basic federal courts and our basic state courts. Just like there are published and unpublished opinions in Tax Court, there are published and unpublished opinions. So we might look to see if the issue that we are researching has been answered or has been reviewed by a court and how they've decided that issue. What other items are secondary sources for us? Well, we can of course go to the instructions for an IRS form and they're pretty detailed, especially around these international reporting forms. 01:04:54.9400000 For example, if you were to look up the instructions that accompany the FBAR. Again, the FBAR is a FinCEN, a Financial Crimes Enforcement Network form. On the FinCEN website you can find a five or six page, if not longer detailed explanations about the finer points relating to the FBAR that are not so obvious. And so we can use that as a resource to follow when we have questions. There are IRM procedural updates. 01:05:34.1800000 These are Internal Revenue Manual procedural updates. The IRS themselves publish these and we can use those for guidance as well. I'm trying to Think of some other secondary sources. I think we covered most of them. There's Tax Notes that is a resource online where you can go to, to help summarize key tax court decisions so you don't have to spend the time reading the opinion itself and interpreting it. 01:06:08.8000000 Instead you can go right to a, right to this website and they have tax professionals that synthesize and summarize these cases into, you know, like a nutshell, a summary that you can review and see if it's worth reading the case itself. So yeah, there are a number of secondary sources in the world of tax. 01:06:34.2500000 This specific procedural update dated August 13, 2014 sheds light on what type of submissions might be right for exam under the streamlined procedures. It says if there are at least five foreign information returns in the taxpayer streamlined submission, those being like for example form 3520-5471-5400-8938. These are all other international reporting forms that I don't get into in this presentation. But if there are at least five of these information returns that are included in the streamlined submission, then the agent must refer the case to the large business and international division of the service. The purpose of such a referral is not so the taxpayer can be entered into anything fun like a drawing for a three day cruise aboard the Disney Magic. 01:07:28.3800000 Instead, it's quite the opposite. It likely means that an examination is on the horizon, one that could lead to the assertion of multiple willful or non willful FBAR penalties. So yeah, I do talk a little bit about some of these other international reporting forms. The accountants need to know about these. Not so much us as the attorneys. 01:07:51.5200000 However, it's good to just have a general understanding of what some of these other international reporting forms are. These are just some of the international reporting forms. I'm not going to go into explicit detail. This form 3520 deals with an annual report to report transactions with foreign trusts and receipt of certain foreign gifts. We have Form 926, that's a return by a US transferor, a property to a foreign corporation. 01:08:19.8200000 This gets very technical. This, you know, whenever you get these, whenever you get corporations, any, any business entity, you're now talking a whole nother universe of, of tax knowledge that you need to acquire because it's not so easy to back your way into these issues without having some background about, about, about entities and entity formation for that matter. Form 3520, A Information Return of Foreign Trust with a U.S. owner, Form 5471 Information Return of U.S. persons with Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations. 01:09:04.4100000 Form 5472 is an information return of a 25% foreign owned U.S. corporation or a foreign corporation engaged in a U.S. trade or business. Form 8865, Return of U.S. persons with respect to Certain Foreign Partnerships. 01:09:20.7100000 Ah, boy. Yeah. Taxpayers who are eligible to use the streamlined procedures and who follow all of the instructions are not subject to some of the other civil penalties that we talked about a little earlier that would normally accompany an audit and a subsequent determination by the examiner that there needs to be an assertion for a civil FBAR penalty. So a civil FBAR penalty is enough alone to be backbreaking. But the IRS can unleash the arsenal of other civil tax penalties from failure to file penalty to failure to pay penalty, to accuracy related penalties, to information return penalties. 01:10:10.6600000 And so yes, all of these penalties are now are, I'm sorry, are not the taxpayer is not subject to, so long as they were eligible to use the streamlined procedures and followed those instructions outside of the streamlined framework, to the extent that the taxpayer gets audited before they avail themselves of this special voluntary disclosure program called streamline, they would then be subject to all of these penalties. So all the penalties are fair game and on the table when the IRS begins an examination of the taxpayer on the FBAR non compliance front. But if the taxpayer gets up ahead of this, you know, meaning they disclose their foreign bank accounts and submit a streamlined submission before the IRS has caught wind of their non of the, of the non of their, you know, of their tax foreign tax obligations, then they don't have to worry about all of these penalties. And so immunity from penalties does come with a few caveats. First, any previously assessed penalties relating to the years that are selected for audit will not be abated. 01:11:41.1000000 Second, to the extent that the IRS determines an additional tax deficiency for a return submitted under these procedures, it can assert additional tax and penalties relating to that additional deficiency. Deficiency is just a fancy word we use in the tax world. It means the difference between what the taxpayer the difference between the amount that the revenue agent believes that the taxpayer should have reported as their tax liability minus the amount that the taxpayer actually self reported on their 1040. So again, the difference between what the IRS believes that the taxpayer owes from that tax year minus the amount that the taxpayer actually reported on their 1040. Finally, the IRS will unleash the full arsenal of penalties if it determines that the original tax non compliance was due to fraud or that the FBAR violation was willful. 01:12:44.5300000 The civil tax fraud penalty is 75% of the under reporting of the amount of gross income that was under report. I'm sorry, yeah. Of the underreported amount. 01:12:58.9300000 Fifth tax returns will be processed, no different than any other return submitted to the irs. Reading between the lines, what the IRS seems to suggest is not to expect confirmation for receipt of the returns. Even more important, unlike ovdp, the streamlined filing process will not culminate in the signing of a closing agreement with the irs, much to the chagrin of the taxpayer. Because a closing agreement was the last and final step in the OVDP process. It was like a real estate closing in many ways, because it was something that we had been working towards. 01:13:38.9500000 And the OVDP process, certification process could go on for two years, if not longer. And so it was like that closing agreement was equivalent of, of like something that the taxpayer had been working so, so hard towards acquiring. And it poured out so much effort to get to. Because needless to say, the tax attorney, you know, can only do so much alone. He or she needs the help of the taxpayer to assemble and retrieve so many of these documents that the IRS is requesting as part of the offshore voluntary disclosure certification process. 01:14:32.0300000 Because the look back period was eight years. So we're not talking about one isolated year. We're talking about eight years of records that, you know, that the taxpayer had to assemble and gather up and send over to the tax attorney and that the tax attorney had to put in some type of organized fashion and send it over to the IRS revenue agent. And usually it was so voluminous that we'd have to save it to a flash drive. It would have to be extremely organized and bookmarked well, otherwise the revenue agent wouldn't know what you were sending them. 01:15:15.7200000 So this was a painful, painful process. And when we would get to a closing agreement, it was like a relief. It was like this was, this was like finally getting a big albatross off of their shoulders. And in many ways, like I said, it was like a real estate closing in the sense of like, okay, now I have been able to turn over a new chapter, get this all behind me, and start afresh with my tax obligations. Because essentially, ovdp, basically with the closing agreement, waved the magic wand and said to the taxpayer, your sins are all forgiven. 01:15:59.0600000 You are now in full compliance with your foreign tax obligations. Go forth and go forth in peace. And, you know, don't do this again. 01:16:14.7400000 Yes, once again, you can't shoehorn something into streamlined that isn't streamlined. You can't take what is otherwise willful non compliance on the FBAR reporting front and somehow disguise it into non willful compliance on the FBAR front. Because if you try to do that and the IRS figures you out, not only does a taxpayer get rejected from streamline, but they can no longer avail themselves of ovdp. It's one and done. The other thing I just wanted to make mention of going back here here for a second is, so, yeah, the point here was to emphasize the importance of the closing agreement and then to speak to how there is no closing agreement in streamlined. 01:17:17.9000000 And so one might think, well, you know, did the IRS accept my submission if there's nothing formal that I get from the agency recognizing and acknowledging that they received my streamlined submission? No, there is nothing formal in writing that, for lack of a better term, might substitute for a closing agreement that the IRS would give a taxpayer who submits an IRS submission. However, if two years have gone by since the taxpayers made the submission and they haven't heard anything, then I don't think they're going to hear anything after that. But, yeah, it's a little unnerving that there isn't anything analogous to a closing agreement or a closing agreement itself that comes with a streamlined submission. 01:18:19.6400000 Yeah. So again, not to beat a dead horse, but you can't sneak into the streamline program through the back door with a client whose conduct veers closer to the willfulness end of the spectrum. Because again, you have to certify non willfulness by way of a certification. And so that certification could come back to bite your client in the butt in many ways. Not only could the streamline submission be denied, but if the statements and the assertions made by the taxpayer in the certification, because it's got to be signed, if the taxpayer rejects them, then the tax. 01:19:11.6800000 Then the IRS could actually bring charges of perjury against your client for lying under oath. Because, yes, it is. Signing the certification is like signing any other tax form, including the 1040. It is. It's like there's a. 01:19:33.3500000 It's called the. I'm trying to think of the name of it right now. But when you sign your tax return, it's called the juratic. You're signing it under penalties of perjury. So you are holding out to the IRS that everything on that tax form is legitimate and that you are not misstating anything, you are not failing to disclose anything, you are not milking something more than what it is, is. 01:20:09.5300000 And all of that, despite the fact that your accountant did all the preparation work and you didn't look over the return. So the defense that the defense of I didn't check what my accountant did is nonsense. It is absolute nonsense. And it's pure ignorance to think that that defense would hold up in the law when in fact that Jurat puts the taxpayer on notice that their signature on that return is enough to make them responsible for everything on that return. The only defense that I could potentially think of is one where someone other than the taxpayer signed the return, meaning the accountant took it upon himself to sign the client's return. 01:21:02.9400000 And I don't know many accountants who would stake their reputation and their careers on doing something like that, or they were forced to sign it under duress. And those two would be very difficult to prove. Similarly, when you sign the certification to certify your non willfulness as part of a streamlined submission, you got to make sure that again, you're not trying to shoehorn something into this that doesn't belong. Because if the facts show just the opposite and the IRS is proof that the representations made by the taxpayer in that certification are false or fraudulent, not only is that streamlined submission going to be denied, but the IRS is, is going to refer the matter to CI for investigation on perjury charges. 01:22:01.6700000 And so what option then remains for someone who's been rejected from streamline? Well, they can do nothing. But they've already, the ammunition has already been provided to the irs. So I'm not so sure that doing nothing would come with, with the IRS just turning a blind eye. They surely are going to take action because they now have the evidence that they need to come back and prosecute the taxpayer or at the very least to assert some heavy handed civil penalties. 01:22:36.3800000 You may, depending on the circumstances, want to amend the 1040 and file delinquent international returns in what is known as a quiet disclosure. That is always an option. You don't always have to go to, you know, one of, go straight to one of the voluntary. Go straight to one of these disclosure programs. You can always exercise this option of amending the 1040 to reflect the additional income that was generated by the foreign bank accounts and that was never disclosed on the 1040. 01:23:17.5900000 You can correct the international returns or there weren't any international returns to begin with because there were no foreign bank accounts disclosed. So you would file what's called delinquent international returns, meaning preparing them for the first time, using an accountant to assist you in that endeavor, and then submit it with what's called a reasonable cause letter, as long as you can find. As long as one of the reasons for your client's failure to disclose these foreign bank accounts is encompassed by one of the legally recognized reasons for failure to disclose, which is found under the reasonable cause. Reasonable. That's found under the reasonable cause rulings in the courts. 01:24:11.1300000 Then you can follow this strategy of doing a quiet disclosure and submit a reasonable cause letter, which is a mea culpa explaining how and why this happened. But again, the reasons that you would have to be asserting would have to be be ones that are recognizable under this reasonable cause under the reasonable cause case law. And you'd have to do some legal research to find what conduct is recognized by the courts as falling under the gambit or within the gambit of reasonable cause. 01:24:53.8600000 Yeah, and you can see here how high stakes of a decision it ultimately becomes when a taxpayer is, you know, is making a decision to go into streamlined. When, you know, the needle could, is in the middle and could go either way. Because again, it's a one shot deal. If the IRS rejects the streamline, they're left with no other option. They can't jump into the offshore voluntary disclosure program bunker. 01:25:24.8800000 At that stage, it's too late. So, you know, you need to also cover yourself as a tax attorney because if the opinion that you give them, you know, tells them how risky going streamline might be, you should, you know, nonetheless, they still want to go streamlined. You want to make sure that they sign an agreement where they acknowledge going forward, all of the risks and how the safer of the two options would be offshore voluntary disclosure. These days, there is no longer an offshore voluntary disclosure program to avail yourself of. So to the extent that the conduct falls closer to the willfulness end of the spectrum, you may not want to even take that risk of submitting a streamlined submission, depending on how far that needle is vacillating towards the extreme polar end of willfulness, you may just want to let bygones be bygones and not wake the. 01:26:31.9700000 Not wake the animal, the animals, which, you know, not wake the bears or whatever that expression is. Not wake the bears, namely not break. Bring attention to something that hasn't been discovered yet. But then again, you have to consider everything in its totality, including the human factors of, you know, what is the client's tolerance to remain in the shadows and take the risk that they might at some point be found out and discovered versus, you know, coming forward. And you know, and knowing when you come forward that you're essentially providing the IRS with all the ammunition that they need to bring a criminal prosecution against your client. 01:27:20.2700000 So there's just so much to consider here. Back when offshore voluntary disclosure was an option, the default for someone who didn't qualify for streamline was to recommend offshore voluntary disclosure. And then you would still have to talk to them about the higher penalty scheme and how it's going to require a lot of endurance to get through since the certification process could go on for two years and there would be a lot of information that they would be responsible for gathering up and turning over to you for you to turn over to them. So, yeah, there were a lot of things to talk about, but with the offshore voluntary disclosure program, you know, there was at least another option. I'm not so sure that there is any such viable option if after the, after doing this assessment of your client's conduct, you find that their conduct falls more towards the end of the willfulness scale of the spectrum than it does a non willfulness scale of the spectrum. 01:28:22.7100000 So it's a hard, hard decision or a hard conversation rather that you have to have with the client. Okay, I think we'll pick up on this topic when we come back in part two. So thanks so much for joining me for today. There's a part two to this. It's coming up fairly soon if you want to catch more of this. 01:28:44.5600000 There's also a multitude of other tax topics that are on so many different issues. So if you're interested in more on civil tax controversies, I do a program on that. If your interest is more in US Tax court, where you might find yourself one day representing a client who is challenging a deficiency, then I have a course on that as well. All of that is coming up and I will, of course do my level best to make it as interesting as possible. But as I'm sure you know by now, the tax is, it's a dry topic and there's a lot of detail and minutiae. 01:29:24.5300000 So it's very difficult if I'm, you know, if I'm doing this to leave out parts because these, these parts, the smallest little thing like anything with the law, can change things radically. And so I am trying to be as picayune in this because I don't want to leave out something that, you know, you might, that, you know, that they could change and alter, you know, things. So it's hard to talk about tax in a very broad and general way. That's really what I'm trying to get at here. But again, thank you so much for joining me here and hope to see you at a future program. 01:30:05.8000000 I wish you the very best.