[Course Name] 00:00:01.8400000 Hi, everybody. Welcome back to part three of this series. This is Mike Doubless. So we're going to continue where I left off last time. I think where we left off was with a video of Ian McKellen. 00:00:20.4000000 And there is something I do want to share with you at the top of today. I'm always inspired by different things that I see about public speakers that have dabbled a little bit in this world of acting and have shared their thoughts and what they have learned through these experiences. And so much of this presentation is focused specifically on how to bring your authentic self to this work. That's really what I'm focusing on in. I would say the lion's share of these presentations are centered around that theme because it is an area, I think, that doesn't get enough attention in traditional trial advocacy and storytelling for lawyers classes. 00:01:16.3900000 And it's a question that comes up time and time again. You know, we know the mechanics, we know the tools, we know how the how tos, if you will, how to construct, you know, our opening, how to construct a closing. But then there's this element of delivery that can become challenging. How do we take these words that we have spent so much time shaping, you know, on our feet and in the hours and hours of brainstorming, how can we take these words and lift them off of the page to make it as gripping for the jury as the words themselves are? How can we do justice to these words that we have, as I said, that we have molded and worked on through the course of weeks of preparation. 00:02:13.6200000 And so I don't like to speak about it as something that's elusive, because it isn't. It really is something as simple as standing up in front of a jury and really tapping into that part of ourself that our family and friends love so much. Those parts of ourselves that are a little quirky, those parts of ourselves that are, you know, charming and seductive. And so, you know, getting. Getting into that state of ease, if you will. 00:02:46.8000000 I would call it an ease state. And it's not easy. It can be quite challenging. But I do want to share with you some reflections of a public speake who went on a journey of his own where he dabbled a little bit into the creative arts, specifically by attending a method acting class at the renowned Lee Strasberg Acting Institute in New York. And he had some thoughts here that I thought were very, very telling of what you can gain in terms of self improvement and in terms of unwrapping, if you will, the box of your potential. 00:03:32.1600000 He says, because what makes a good speaker stand out is not the technical knowledge, but the performance on stage. The most important things are energy, emotion and authenticity. He says what distinguishes a good keynote speaker from a purely technical expert is not the technical competence. It's the performance on stage that also gives you goosebumps during the talk. Because he takes his job as a speaker very seriously. 00:04:02.5700000 He went to New York together with a colleague of his to the renowned Lee Strasberg Acting Institute to learn method acting for speakers. He talks a little bit about some of the musings and some of what he learned. But then he gets. He got to the core of what he learned. In the course of our training, we spent hours on imagination. 00:04:31.4800000 We imagined the coffee cup from home, smelled the coffee and touched the broken parts. We remembered sad, outrageous and funny scenes in our lives. Because the method actor always plays himself. He brings the feelings from his experience into the present in order to be able to reproduce them authentically. That is the whole art, and yet it is anything but easy. 00:04:54.1300000 And the art of the good speaker lies precisely in this. It's not about stuffing his listeners with knowledge that they can also read up on, but about letting them participate in their own emotions. I've used the metaphor before of if it was only about a one sided assault by the actors to the audience, and if there was no nuance in and feeling and emotion in the play, well, then all we would really need to do when the audience arrived at the theater is simply give them the scripts that the actors themselves were given during the, during the rehearsal and let them read it on their own and let them have an internal experience by letting their imagination do all the work. But we go to the theater for so much more than that. We go to the theater to see these words be lived by the actors on stage. 00:05:57.6500000 That's why many people who are big Shakespeare fans are drawn to different adaptations of Hamlet performed by different, different, different groups. They, they may have gone to see 30 or 40 different adaptations of the very same play. Why? Because one actor's portrayal of the protagonist is going to be radically different than another actor's portrayal of the protagonist. Despite the fact that the words are the same and they don't vary or fluctuate from performance to performance. 00:06:33.3100000 It's what that actor is bring and actors are bringing to the stage. Their personality, their intellect, their imaginations are different. We are unique after all. And so we are going to see different portrayals of that same actor from performance to performance. 00:06:57.3700000 He also goes on to talk a little bit about improvisation, breathing and voice. He talks about how during the course of the program, we also improvised individually and as a group, which was especially fun. We spoke to fill the whole room, and of course, we sang. The whole thing was rounded off with tai chi for speakers. This is the art of pushing one's excitement into the ground and if necessary, getting missing energy from above and controlling one's breath. 00:07:28.7700000 And then he concludes by saying that the training was overwhelmingly worthwhile and it was fun, too. He says that he's still in touch with many of the classmates that he worked with during the course of the four days of training. So, again, just some thoughts that I share with you a little bit about this speaker's experience. So what I'm really doing is again, attempting to cover turf that is not traditionally talked about in these other classes. You know, I can always talk about the bread and butter tools that you see in these traditional storytelling and public speaking for lawyers classes. 00:08:17.7400000 But I'm trying to take this a step further. And I feel that so much of my experience has been influenced by the creative arts and by the years of conservatory training and the years of actual performance that I've had. And then I marry that, of course, with my trial experience to try to unlock for you some of the roadblocks that I myself have experienced that I think many other lawyers experience as well. But because they are so vulnerable, they don't get talked about very much. We tend to push those parts down, and this is territory that I think we do need to go into if we are going to be the advocate that we need to be for our clients in their darkest hours. 00:09:07.4000000 So word stress, again, I'm picking up from where I left off last time. We want to be careful not to overstress words. I think that sometimes it's always good to look at the. Look at the fringe, look at the poles, if you will, or the extremes of where we can go and what potential harm befalls us if we are at those fringe ends or at those extreme poles, if you will. One of the extreme poles is overstressing words. 00:09:46.9300000 I've experienced this firsthand, and I've experienced it firsthand with heightened text of Shakespeare. And I've learned a valuable lesson, and that is that when you don't know 100% of what you're saying, one of the defaults that I fall into is that I will overstress too many words almost to make. Almost to project to the audience that I know what I'm saying, even though I don't. So if I haven't done My homework in advance to know what it is I'm saying. I will often default into overstressing words to make it sound as if I know exactly what I'm saying. 00:10:28.5100000 And that is a dangerous place to be, because what happens when you overstress every single word? Not only is it annoying and uneasy for the ear, but when you overstress every single word, nothing becomes emphasized anymore. The audience doesn't know what words take on significance, nor can they understand the full thought, because you're focusing and hammering every syllable of every single word that the complete thought gets lost. So we want to be very careful. The beauty is there's not much work we need to do with. 00:11:13.9800000 With legalese or with contemporary storytelling, because it comes off of the tongue very easily and naturally and intuitively and innately, we know what words to stress. I am not putting conscious attention right now on what words to stress in speaking during this presentation. It's coming out organically, and there's an innate innateness inside that's already causing certain words to be stressed and other words not to be stressed. But we do have a little bit of a blueprint that will help us sometimes, because I always find myself, every so often defaulting into overstressing words when I am in closing argument because I'm so preoccupied with wanting to make sure that the jury understands every single point, that I will sometimes go into that overstressing of words. And I've got to be very careful, because, as you can tell, when I was giving you an example, it's not easy for the ear to. 00:12:24.0500000 How can I put it? It's not easy for the ear to hear overstress after overstress, after overstress. It's just enormous. It's painful. It's like nails going down on a chalkboard. 00:12:36.3700000 So we want to be very careful there. So what are some rules? Pronouns don't need to be overstressed. You, yours, his, hims. Those come off of the lips so easily that we actually just abbreviate them by, for example, saying yours or using its. 00:12:57.5500000 Or that's. We don't have to spell it out, you know, as we would if we were writing it out. So that's one way the jury, again, won't be able to hear meaning, because the clarity of a thought is swamped by too much stress. The very important words in a thought will have full weight. I like to refer to those as the operative words. 00:13:18.5300000 Those tend to be your verbs and occasionally adjectives, colorful adjectives sometimes will fall within that area. And there also will be opportunities for nouns, people, places, and things to be emphasized in verse speaking. The way that Shakespeare wrote and the way that I find we speak a lot when it comes to closing arguments, because we're talking in a. We're talking very heavily in rhetoric. And when we get into rhetoric, I can't help but find comparisons between rhetoric and between the verse or iambic pentameter that Shakespeare wrote in. 00:14:00.0300000 So the good writer does this with the iambic stress. It's almost like a very special hidden key, if you will, that's there within Shakespeare's words. There's no stage directions, of course, in Shakespeare's plays, but the words themselves. The way it has been written innately contains the clues that the actor needs. And the way he wrote in the Siambic pentameter provides for this understanding of light stress followed by strong stress. 00:14:34.4100000 And so we have this rhythm of ba bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum, or dee dum dum dee dum. It's the beating of the heart. And so we know that when we start a new fresh line, the first syllable is always going to be a soft syllable followed by a strong syllable. And the strong syllable is what tends to get the stress. We don't need to get into that much nuance when we are talking in contemporary speech today. 00:15:03.7300000 But it's worth noting, a full stress on a word will include a fuller speaking of the word. An unstressed word will be neutralized. So I like to play with different lines so that you can get a sense of what this looks like in contem. My friend is coming to supper. If the meaning you want to convey is my friend is coming to supper as opposed to your friend, then my would be fully weighted. 00:15:30.0300000 The other words in the sentence move towards being more neutral. If supper, on the other hand, is weighted, the meaning shifts to supper. So it would sound like this, my friend is coming to supper. We can see that when you stress supper, my friend is coming to supper, it almost provides a contrast to breakfast or to lunch. So when we stress supper, we are automatically precluding or automatically comparing the fact that it's not lunch or tea. 00:16:03.7000000 We do this stressing naturally. But if there's a problem with stress, you might check the words you really need that you might check to make sure that the words you really need have the weight, while the others are moving more towards neutrality. 00:16:19.4500000 As a word of stress, we move into and out of that word with inflections. Again, a natural movement in the voice connected to meaning. So with a partner, you Might take a sentence and say it first as clearly and neutrally as possible. Then change its meaning through stress and inflection. Speak it again with a different meaning, stress and inflection. 00:16:39.9400000 See if your partner can distinguish the different meanings. Um, yeah. I'd like to share with you a little bit of this. I believe it's an opening statement. This is Denzel Washington playing the attorney who is representing Tom Hanks in Philadelphia. 00:16:59.6200000 This is going back some time, but there's a lot that I like that he does in this opening statement. So I'm gonna play it in the movies. There's not gonna be any last minute surprise witnesses. Nobody's gonna break down on the stand with a tearful confession. You're gonna be presented simple fact. 00:17:38.6800000 Andrew Beckett was fired. You'll hear two explanations for why he was fired. Ours and theirs. It is up to you to sift through layer upon layer of truth. Until you determine for yourselves which version sounds the most true. 00:17:55.6400000 There's certain points that I must prove to you. Point number one. Andrew Beckett was. 00:18:02.3700000 Is a brilliant lawyer. Great lawyer. Point number two. Andrew Beckett, afflicted with a debilitating disease, made the understandable, the personal, the legal choice to keep the fact of his illness to himself. Point number three, his employers discovered his illness. 00:18:22.2900000 And, ladies and gentlemen, the illness I'm referring to is aids. Point number four. Therefore, they panicked. 00:18:33.4400000 And in their panic, they did what most of us would like to do with aids, which is just get it and everybody who has it as far away from the rest of us as possible. 00:18:45.3600000 Now, the behavior of Andrew Beckett's employees may seem reasonable to you. Does to me. After all, AIDS is a deadly, incurable disease. But no matter how you come to Judge Charles Wheeler and his partners in ethical, moral and inhuman terms, the fact of the matter is, when they fired Andrew Beckett because he had aids, they broke the law. 00:19:15.9600000 Fact. 00:19:20.4400000 I just want to stop and just point a couple of things out that he's done here. He's using principles of rhetoric in the beginning by doing point one, point two, point three. There's a concept in storytelling in general that says trilogies, or threes are remembered with more frequency than fours, if you will, or even twos or ones. Believe it or not, the mind is able to grasp onto threes. And so what Denzel Washington does here is by enumerating things, is 1, 2, 3. 00:19:59.1300000 It's easy and clear for the jury to understand. He also does something that I think is so powerful in the courtroom. And there is what I might call a movie too. That will help to actually solidify this concept. Essentially, what he does is he takes his opponent's or his adversary's argument and he confronts it. 00:20:30.4700000 He brings it into his own argument and addresses it front on, instead of A, ignoring it, or B, waiting for his adversary to ambush him or to unleash that argument for the first time. This is so utterly powerful in a courtroom when you can already anticipate and predict where your adversary is going to come from, what their arguments are, and take those arguments and in some fashion neutralize them or turn them upside down where they can be favorable to your side. And so what Denzel Washington did here is he mentions how the employer's conduct might appear to have been reasonable in light of the fact that AIDS is a deadly virus. But then he has his comeback. And so this principle, in order to help you to remember it and remember it well, you can go back in time to this movie where that Eminem store starred in. 00:21:41.8000000 Eminem was a rapper. I think he's still rapping these days. And there are some in the movie, essentially what Eminem was doing is he would take all of his faults and all of his negativities and deal with them in his opening rap speech. And essentially what that does is it takes the wind out of the sails when his adversary would get up to rap against him. So you're. 00:22:13.6200000 You're basically neutering, if you will, your adversary by taking them up, by taking their arguments up and dealing with them head on. And if you want to take this to the next level now, after you do that, you may then, in an effort to bring them onto your turf and to force them into your territory, you might then say to the jury, demand that the prosecutor, or demand that the defense attorney answer this. This is where the beef is. Demand that they address this. And of course, he will have done your. 00:22:52.9400000 Your preparation in advance in a way that you will have boxed your adversary in to that one issue where the only escape, where there is no escape from that narrow issue, except one where your adversary would have to concede a point that would be strong or at least neutral to your case. So these are all concept of what we call rhetoric. And so this is where I want to go later in the presentation. I want to address rhetoric because there are some very strong principles here that we're using already, but that we don't even know where they come from and what their history is and how many and how much more there is in the world of rhetoric to use as a persuasive tool. In the courtroom. 00:23:40.8600000 Long thoughts. The reason I sprinkle in talk on long thoughts is because in closing argument, especially when we're taking the facts and we are applying them to the rule, we are speaking in long thoughts. And despite the fact that we might try to really veer on the side of shorter phrases and sentences, when we begin that analysis in closing arguments, it's hard not to talk in long thoughts. So the idea then becomes, if we need to talk in long thoughts to make the point, how can we do so in a way that the jury is following us? And the way I look at a thought is in a very. 00:24:35.0500000 In a very literal sense, in a visual sense. I look at a thought as a map. And you know how when you looked at those. At those maps from like, those cartoons going back to the 80s or the 90s, like Scooby Doo. I know I'm dating myself right now, but. 00:24:51.9900000 But you would see, like, the treasure at one far point in the map, and you would see the starting point as like, a red dot on the other part of the map. And then you would see, like, the twists and the turns and the river and the tunnels that the person would have to get to to get to the treasure. That, to me, is the map of a thought. And isn't that true about how when we're talking in long thoughts, how we would get up and recite when we were asked question in contracts, or how we would answer questions or make arguments when we were in moot court or when we were arguing something in mock trial back in law school, and that we still do today, when we are even just in an informal setting with colleagues or with a client that we're doing a consultation for. This is how we're moving about. 00:25:49.4900000 We're taking things that we're hearing for the first time and we're taking those set of facts and we're applying. Applying them to the law as we know them. And we're also intuiting as well all of the wealth of experience that we've built up over the years also has a say in how we analyze this new set of facts. So we've got so much going on, and so we've got to work our way through this map and through the tunnel and through the desert and swim through the water and up the mountain. And while we're doing this, we need to be able to carry the audience, whether that be the client that we're doing the consultation for or whether that be the jury. 00:26:35.1100000 And that is harder. That's easier said than done. Isn't it? Because as we're figuring something out, we need to make sure that we need to make sure when we ourselves don't know the end point, we still need to make sure that we find our way through this maze and that we don't lose the jury and that they're with us as well through the twists and turns. And that's a thought. 00:27:00.5400000 As we express a thought, that's exactly what we're doing. And we do that in everyday life, even when we're just communicating casually with friends and with family, we're moving our way through a thought. And because we've been, because we're lawyers and we've gone through law school and we've been practicing law for so many years, we do it better than anybody else in the business, in my opinion. I've never seen anybody else, aside from lawyers that I know and I've seen in action, be able to navigate through long, contrived and thick and dense thoughts in a way that makes it clear for the jury to understand. But every so often, we get trapped. 00:27:42.4000000 And I find for myself, I get trapped when I'm on my feet and I've got the eyes and the gazes of 12 jurors, 14 jurors, probably with two alternates, and the whole gallery on me. I'm always better and. And clearer when there's less eyes on me and there's less pressure. But when I have the pressure of the courtroom on me, oh, boy, it's, you know, that stress and that tension is compounding these complicated thoughts and making it that much difficult to navigate through. So I think many members of an audience sit and listen most of the time without understanding a speech or even a whole play, because. 00:28:24.8400000 Because the actor or the speaker have not understood the thought themselves, the length of the thought or their thoughts connection, or one thought's connection to another. This same. This is true of jurors as well. Many of us no longer express ourselves in the kind of long, complex passages that we find in plays or hear in closing arguments. Make no mistake about it, closing argument is just that. 00:28:51.9900000 It is a complex, long passage, and it is heightened language. No matter how much we try to talk in shortened phrases, we're still inevitably going to have a long thought that is going to either either grab the jury and, you know, bring them to the edge of their seats or confuse them and not. And befuddle them and not know for them not to know what's coming next. So we want to connect our ideas and thoughts together. And that does not get Nearly as much attention as it deserves in secondary schools throughout the country. 00:29:33.7200000 One thought must lead to the next. There must be this logical progression. You yourself must know where you're leading the jury to. Can you imagine if you were the one, if you were the tour guide for a safari and you've got all these tourists that are trusting their lives to you to get them through the safari and to help get them the most magnetic pictures that are going to grace their mantles when they get home? Can you imagine if you yourself as a tour guide, don't know where the endpoint is? 00:30:11.6800000 If you don't know where the danger spots are, if you don't know where the safe harbors are, forget about it. And that's a metaphor for public speakers as well. If you don't know where you're going with the thought, then the jury is going to be three, four, five times as lost. So this is why I use the metaphor that you need to know 140%. You need to be 140% certain where you're going and where you're steering the jury in order for them to have 90% or even 80% recognition of what's going on, to be able to follow along again, one thought must lead to the next. 00:30:54.6500000 There must be this logical progression. Thoughts and structured communication must not hover in space like disconnected fragments. I find that inevitably you'll have to park a thought in space and have it hover. But then you come back to that thought and you have to do it seamlessly so that this thought that initially that you've put out here isn't hovering in space too long, that the jury forgets about it and doesn't hover so long that the jury forgets its significance. So you need to be able to come back to that first thought that's hovering. 00:31:31.6300000 And maybe that first thought that's hovering is the jury, is the law, is, is the jury instruction. And maybe the subsequent thought is the facts that you have that you're now marshaling together. And now maybe the third thought is taking those facts and now basically applying it to the law so that the jury can have an aha moment. Oh, now I see what's going on. And be able to follow everything in a circular pattern all the way back to that initial thought that was parked out there and that is hovering out there, which in my example was the law itself. 00:32:19.6000000 Okay, yeah. And so we piece those together. We piece it together to form a coherent whole. 00:32:26.6400000 Here's some helpful tips. First, rely on a full stop or period I know that sometimes it can feel as if we are in a hurry and we're rushing, but I think that it's imperative to let things breathe and to use a pause so that when you do, it gives the jury some time for things to catch up. It's almost like if I'm thinking about it, how can I. How can I think about it? It's like there's a great. 00:32:59.4400000 There's a great metaphor I have. I had in my mind that I was thinking about. It's like when you're. It's like when you're running, this is. This isn't going to be as clear as I'd like, but it's like you're running and you've got. 00:33:17.1600000 Yeah, this isn't the best metaphor. It's like. Like you're running and then you come to a stop and you have to wait for whatever you were. Whatever was. Was whatever you were pulling behind you to kind of catch up to you. 00:33:33.4200000 Maybe the example would be, oh, I have a puppy. This is a good example. I'm walking the puppy, and every so often she likes to run. And so I like to run as well. I'll start running, and I usually get ahead of her as I'm running. 00:33:47.6600000 And then I can tell when she's getting a little bit tired and she's starting to slow down. Then I start tired, I start to slow down to allow her to catch up to me. And so there's about, like, a little bit of a space, the gap that has to be filled from the time I stopped to the time she now comes, comes up to where I'm standing in space. And so that's a little bit about what we can. Or how we can view pauses thing. 00:34:17.9600000 It's like the jury is the puppy, and they're like, running to keep up with you. They're running to keep up with you. Running to keep up with you. And it's nice to be able to stop and then to give them some time just to catch up to where you are so that they're not always trying to always, always, always running, running, running after you, but giving them the time to catch up and then to get to you and then start again. You might start the anatomy. 00:34:45.3200000 The metaphor would be, okay, the dog is now, you know, healing, and she looks like she's ready to run again. So I'm going to go out and start running. And then that would be the next thought that begins. Yeah, you can use periods, full stop for a period question or exclamation mark. To indicate the end of a thought. 00:35:03.8800000 The other thing is, you see, you can see this a lot in speeches. Good, good speakers, when they ask a question, it's not rhetorical, it's a question that they really are asking the audience for an answer to. And this is hard to do sometimes because today, especially as lawyers, when we ask like for cross examination, for example, we ask leading questions, it's very difficult and I'll put myself up there as a lawyer who finds this extremely challenging. So I'm not going to ridicule or criticize other attorneys because I myself struggle with this immensely. It's very difficult to ask an open ended question of a jury without it sounding like a leading question or a rhetorical question, meaning there's no inflection at the end on the last syllable or two to really give the reign to the audience to answer it for their, on their own. 00:36:17.1300000 So for example, you know, how can you say this is, or how could that be fair? You know, that might be something that you, that you ask the jury, how can that be fair? And so you can see that how can that be fair? There needs to be a voice inflection on the last syllable affair in order to really empower the jury to ask that, to answer that question of their own accord. If I say it like, how can that be fair? 00:36:48.4200000 How can that be fair? There's no impetus on the part of the jury to answer that question on their own. You're stating it as if it's a leading question. So to me, not only does it require voice inflection, but there's vulnerability to really asking a question that you want the other person to answer and that you don't want to give the answer to by the way of how you're stating the question. So there's vulnerability in that. 00:37:19.5000000 And so I think that subconsciously that's what makes it difficult for me personally to really ask the question of a jury. It's almost like, you know, giving them the power as well to make discoveries, which I talk a lot about. 00:37:35.7100000 I like to give them, I like to tell them what I want to tell them. I don't like to leave anything open ended or to give them the autonomy to have to make the discovery themselves. However, that runs counter to how we, or how humans like to be able to like to be involved in the decision making or, or like to feel empowerment when they are being spoken to. So for example, if you tell the audience what you want them to do, and you can see this in speeches by politicians that say you Must do this. You shall do this. 00:38:18.3200000 I don't know about you, but when I'm sitting there, I'm like, oh yeah, the, the wall goes down. And I'm like, oh yeah, you're telling me I have to do this? No, sorry, I don't want to be told. You know, and we're all rebels, you know, I, I was a public defender, you know, right out of law school. And to say that there was a part of me that was a little irreverent and, you know, a little rebellious would be a complete understatement. 00:38:45.6300000 I don't like to be told by somebody what to do. And public speakers have learned this as well of audiences. And they talk about how you want to let an audience come to the recognition or the acknowledgement of something on their own. And you want them, of course, to make, to come to the decision that you want them to come to, but you want to empower them to do it on their own. And the way we do that is something that we learned on cross examination when we were cross examining adverse witnesses. 00:39:26.9100000 You can hardly stand up and get a witness to agree to something that might, that is true by stating it in a conclusory term. So, for example, you were wearing a red shirt on the night of the incident. If you say that to a witness that is a state's witness, they're going to find a way to quarrel with you. No matter how red that shirt really was, they might say no. And then they might add the caveat that it was a light red, pinkish type shirt and not a red shirt. 00:40:04.1500000 So we stay away from, from conclusory language that is automatically like a neon sign going to trigger the witness to fight with you. Instead, we find ways in that will that help build fact by fact by fact? The example I love to use here is the example of an underpass that is pitch black at the time of the mugging of the victim. Instead of saying to the victim, the underpass that you were in was pitch black, instead you approached it from a different angle. When you were, when you were walking under that Underpass, it was 8 o' clock at night. 00:40:52.4900000 Correct? It was 8 o' clock at night when you walked under that underpass. There were no light in the underpass when you were walking. Correct. 00:41:03.8100000 There were no dims, there was no dimming light or no irradiant light that was coming from anywhere nearby. You didn't have a flashlight on you. So the conclusion, you see how we're narrowing and narrowing and narrowing so that the jury will be able to reach the inescapable conclusion on their own, of their own accord, that it was black, that it was pitch black under the underpass. And this would go work within the theory and theme of the case of mistaken identification, that it was impossible for the victim to be able to tell who the actor or to be able to identify the actor in conditions where it was pitch black at 8 o' clock at night under an underpass. 00:41:58.9600000 Okay. Commas, colons, semicolons do not indicate the end of a thought, but they're turns. That's how I love to look at commas, colons, and semicolons. If a period is a complete stop, right? Commas, colons, semicolons are turns, pauses, or different pulses in the thought before it is finished. 00:42:19.8700000 You can map out a phrase by walking it out, just like on the treasure map that I was talking you. Talking to you about. You just basically look at the periods and the punctuation that's already there in the written text that you yourself wrote, and use that and experiment a little bit. See what would happen if you came to a complete stop as you're walking in your family room to map out the thought. And then see what happens if you make a turn, like a left turn when you come upon a comma or a colon or a semicolon. 00:42:55.5100000 See what happens if instead of making a left turn at a colon, you make a right turn at the colon. See what happens if there's a little pulse in your body, if you maybe skip a little bit at another at a semicolon when you get it into your body physically. Oh, my God. That thought is going to be so crystal clear that when you stand up and you plant yourself two feet in front of the jury, the jury is going to hear that thought in a physical way, not just in an auditory way, but in a physical way. Why? 00:43:29.8700000 Because that thought has been mapped into your body. And it's like how everything, all of our experiences in our life are, like, tattooed on our body. And it's that type of innateness that comes from actually mapping out, walking out a thought and physicalizing the punctuation so that you will be able to speak this thought in such a clear way that the jury is going to be right there with you. A thought is physical and is expressed as one completed movement, like a dance step. Even if you are standing still, something inside you is moving, is actively taking you a step further. 00:44:12.7000000 There's always something that's moving inside your body. And, you know, at a very primal level. Your, your, your insides, your heart is, is beating. Ba boom, ba boom, ba boom. Your digestive system is always working. 00:44:26.7800000 There is always movement going on on the inside. Forget about the outside. I mean, there's so much going on on the inside, outside as well. But there is always movement. Even though you're not physically walking and using the type of physicalization that you might have been using to map it out on your own. 00:44:45.6300000 In your preparation to complete the movement, you might have many flutters, diversions, or tempos. Once completed, it stops. And that again, is how you would see this translation into the real thing. When you stand up and do it for the. Do it, you know, standing still with your feet planted into the, into the floor, and you speak it. 00:45:08.7500000 Instead of the physicalization, there's going to be tempo changes, there's going to be, there's going to be variation and nuances and, you know, different, different, different audible and sound levels that go to your voice. All of that will be taken on from the physicalization of the thought. 00:45:30.4400000 Think of each thought as a journey from A to B to C. How do they connect to one another? And you'll be able to tighten the thoughts together and make them, and constantly refine them and make them cleaner and make them more one, you know, one after the other so that they're easier to follow. For example, if I want to leave the room, I move to do that. But of course I have to stop off and pick up my bag, then return as I nearly reach the door for my coat. 00:45:59.9700000 The journey might metaphorically be in a car from point A to point B. In order to get to point B, I have to turn corners, stop at lights, change gears. All these turns, stops, gear changes, will be reflected in the other punctuation such as commas and colons. 00:46:16.8200000 All right, exploding misconceptions about speaking long thoughts. 00:46:23.7800000 You don't have to do a whole thought on one breath. I think that that's safe to say we're breaking down thoughts into small pieces and we're getting it into our body, as I said, through this, through actually physicalizing the thought in the privacy of our own home, we can delay thought and still breathe. Delay and still breathe. You don't have to suspend the breath. You can continue breathing as your, as your thought, as your wheels are turning. 00:46:57.9900000 The breath will invariably come on those turns, those stops, those diversions. Sometimes it's useful to play with speaking a thought on one breath. This can make clear the thought, thoughts, journey and enable us to recognize the wholeness of an idea. But some Long thoughts would be impossible to speak on a single breath. Resist the temptation to rush a long thought for obvious reasons. 00:47:20.5300000 These thoughts have so many ideas that are inherent in them that if we're rushing through them, it's going to be hard for the jury to see how they connect. You can stop and pause, but carry on working with an idea. We do this all the time. Halfway through a thought, we pause, probably accompanied by holding the breath, then continue on my journey along a road. I can stop, admire the view, then walk on to my destination. 00:47:49.1900000 If you don't understand the length of a thought, try speaking it at speed. The speed will propel you through the thought and will often give you clarity. But speaking quickly is not needed or all the time and is only a superficial solution. It's harder to hold a long thought slowly, though, for fear that we might forget it if we don't get it out quickly. But it is possible. 00:48:10.2300000 What is essential is that you complete the journey and that you are filled by the language. You must not stop thinking and working a thought until the thought ends. It's like you've got, you know, it's like you've got a gasoline in the tank. That gasoline has to get you through. Your, your energy has to get you through the end of the thought. 00:48:31.8400000 We don't want the thought dying out at the end. In fact, you see this happen a lot, even with the best public speakers. Their, their voice trails at the end of the thought. But as a public speaker, we want the, the end of a thought to be the most powerful. It's almost as if the trajectory of the thought will start here and will go up diagonally. 00:49:00.0100000 It'll go up diagonally from this point up. We don't want it to start here and to fade down like this because a jury won't get that it was important if you start letting the voice trail off at the end. So we want to always end at, at a high note with the breath there. So if we need to take in some catch breaths in order to sustain and give us enough fuel to get through the thought, we do just that. 00:49:31.6500000 Again, you must not stop thinking and working a thought until the thought ends. The intellectual vigor required to communicate thoughts implied in ambiguous legal arguments to a jury is tough. It's demanding and, and it's physical. For this reason, trial attorneys need to bring the same work ethic and dedication to their craft as professional athletes do to theirs. Some metaphors that I like to use are I dig a hole in the garden, working and digging until I get the Whole root of the weed out. 00:49:59.4200000 I pile the bricks one on top of the other until a wall is built. The same work, excavating and building is required for sustaining a thought. Take a long thought from your own opening or closing and examine how many changes of direction occur in it. Perhaps the thought is one uninterrupted arc, or maybe it takes many swerves and corners. Visualize the thought as a map that takes you to a hidden treasure in a secret forest. 00:50:25.8500000 Recognizing one continuous energy of thought or many changes in directions within a thought provides important acting clues. So here's what's so fascinating about this, and I'll harken back to Shakespeare just briefly. I'm not going to get off on a tangent, I promise you, but if you take a look at some of the. One of the opening speeches in Hamlet, it is the. Oh, that this too too solid flesh would melt, thaw, and resolve itself into a dew. 00:50:55.7700000 This happens. This is spoken by Hamlet. And it's on the heels of his mother marrying his uncle. For those who don't know the plot, Hamlet has got an enormous amount of rage going on inside him. His father, the king, died just a few months earlier under very suspicious circumstances. 00:51:22.1000000 Nobody knows how this man, who was a warlord and who was as healthy as can be, would just die. And so. And then the uncle who Hamlet abhors, has basically shacked up with his mom, who he was very close to. And his mom was basically like the only true friend. And yes, I hate to have to go there, but the relationship was a very much the type of relationship that, you know, was like, you know, Freudian in a sense, if you know where I'm going. 00:51:58.3100000 But yes, so, you know, Hamlet, who was so close to his mom in that way, you know, now the uncle steps in and marries the mother. So he's got all this rage going on. And Shakespeare, who, to me knew human nature better than any author that has ever written, he was able to memorialize that into this hallmark speech by the way he connected his thoughts. The thoughts were basically disconnected and in the middle of the speech and chaotic and tempestuous. And so even though there wasn't a recording of one of his actors from that very day reciting the speech, scores and scores of actors from generations after generation after generation were clued into the tempestuous rage that Hamlet was experiencing in the speech. 00:53:01.3100000 By the way, the words were written by Shakespeare because his stage directions were in the text themselves. They were the subtext of the way, of the words gave the meaning, the way they were written. Actually was on the surface, the. Not the subtext, the surface text, if you will, described what this emotional Mount Everest that was brewing inside of Hamlet. And so you can even get this sense from your own speech, whether you are embroiled with rage and you're tapping into injustice at this point in your speech by way of. 00:53:46.5500000 Of how quickly the turns become in your own speech that you've written, in your own text that you've written. And maybe, just maybe, it will take you physicalizing it and walking around to see the commas to realize, oh, boy, here's what I'm getting at. Now. This part is really where I'm getting at. I am now expressing the injustice in all of this, and it's right there. 00:54:15.3700000 It's in my own pen. It's in my own written word that is right there now that I can feel it in my body. I want to even bring it out more now. And this is going to be a point. And you'll be able to highlight now by way of the clues that you already have with the punctuation and with the substance of the words themselves. 00:54:35.5700000 All of those are going to come together in a big melting pot. And for the big moment in your mind that, oh, yes, this is a big moment. This is where I am all fired up, and this is where the gates are opening up. And I'm now able to, you know, I'm now able to zealously argue the injustice and to let the jury know how it's hitting me and how it's impacting me. And if I can bring that. 00:55:04.8700000 That to light in how I express it, the jury won't be able to help but tell and experience it on a visceral level of their own from, you know, from. From picking it up on me. So all of this gives you clues and gives you, you know, more. More, if you will, fodder for developing the argument. Yeah. 00:55:30.2700000 Again, more chaotic and more tempestuous the more terms it's going to have. If the thought flows effortlessly, you're probably more liberated in your thinking at that moment in time. Now, look at the thought in the context of the whole speech. Maybe the whole speech is one thought, but find a speech with several thoughts. You might be amazed to discover that many large speeches just consist of three or four separate thoughts. 00:55:53.6300000 Shakespeare's long Soliloquies and his sonnets often work that way. Speak the speech aware of the journey laid out in each thought. Begin to notice that each subsequent thought is connected to the previous one. Each thought completes part of the whole and moves you towards a conclusion. You always have to be moving it forward, always moving it forward. 00:56:15.3000000 The movement is not only active, but like building bricks or boxes on top of one another that open or close into and onto other boxes. It creates an edifice which is the storm. This process governs most good plays and opening statements. Good writers like Shakespeare do something even more enthralling. As the thoughts move towards the resolve or conclusion, the focus zeroes in on a more concentrated issue and pulls you right onto the target. 00:56:45.5100000 Suddenly, in a manner of speaking, the wide angle landscape that began the play has isolated in close up of a bird sitting on a branch. And maybe that represents something that is a metaphor for what's going on in the case. Jerry Spence had this beautiful, beautiful metaphor because, as you know, when we do criminal work, you know, we have to be very careful about what we say to the jury. Regarding. 00:57:22.5500000 Regarding what we. Yeah, regarding, you know, what the potential outcome could be to the defendant if they're convicted. You can't go in front of a jury, even if this is valid, and tell the jury, don't convict, John, because if you do, he's going to go to prison. No, it's objectionable. In fact, that will probably cause for the jury, for there to be a mistrial. 00:57:49.3600000 But what you can do is something that Jerry Spence so beautifully does in this image and this metaphor of a bird. He talks about a bird, and he talks about. Before he gets to the bird, he talks about how this. This man, I think. I'm not sure who. 00:58:09.6800000 I'm not sure if it's a young man or an old man. I think it might be an old man. I don't know. But in any event, the man goes up to another person and his hands are like, in this position where they're covered in an effort, like to show that there's something inside the palm of his hands. And he basically says to the other person, there's something. 00:58:38.1300000 There's something in my hand, and I want to give it to you. You know, and the metaphor is that it turns out to be a bird. And basically it goes something like, you know, when he gives the bird to this other person, you know, he says to. He says to that other person, you know, do you want to quash the bird or do you want to let it go free? And the other person, you know, says, I want to let it go free. 00:59:06.9200000 And then that bird symbolizes the defendant in the case. It's more artfully and craftily shaped, but it's something of that nature. Using the Metaphor of the bird for the freedom of the defendant. 00:59:26.3200000 As soon as you understand the movement. Okay, again, as soon as you understand the movement and direction of the thought. And only will learning it become easier. The technique. Text, that is. 00:59:35.2200000 But you'll be learning the text thought by thought and appreciating the connections. That makes it a lot easier to memorize. And if you're just memorizing something sterile that doesn't have any continuity or connection, it also, again, makes it easier to memorize. The other creative exploration you can make when examining a text thought by thought is the varying lengths of each thought. Longer thoughts reflect a character whose intellectual juices are flowing along with emotional ones. 01:00:02.5700000 This should come as no surprise to U.S. attorneys. If the thoughts are suddenly short, it is a clue that the intellectual and emotional gears are grinding to a halt or suffocating the character. Ask yourself if the character is flowing with long thoughts or is constipated with the shorter ones. Maybe he or she speaks a mixture of sudden movements forward followed by stops and shudders. 01:00:25.6900000 When you interrupt yourself, there's usually a lot of emotion in it. I'm trying to think of that part of the speech that I referenced before in Hamlet. 01:00:39.7100000 He interrupts himself because there's so much emotion going on. So when you've got a lot of emotion inside you, you're stopping, you're starting. Your thoughts are not long and thought out. They're characterized by sudden stops, quick starts, quick turns, things like that. This is just the pattern, the physicalization of the thought process. 01:01:05.9200000 When the juices are going and we're really full of life and we're really passionate about something, and there's just so much that's coming to us at one time that we're getting ourselves all lathered up. This is what happens a lot in oral arguments when you're arguing something passionately to the judge and, you know, you feel that you're. That you might be losing and that you're, you know, the judge, you know, is interjecting and is, you know, throwing, you know, hard questions at you. And the way it seems is that the wind is blowing in the opposite direction because those are all the cues you're getting from the judge. So you're getting, you know, you're getting a little agitated. 01:01:44.8700000 You're getting a little hot under the collar. Your thoughts aren't as, you know, complete and as well thought and as manicured as they would if you were in a less stressful situation with less on the line. You see, you see, you get my idea. Here's an example from Paul Newman's closing argument. In the verdict, we become weak. 01:02:13.4800000 We doubt ourselves, we doubt our beliefs, we doubt our institutions, and we doubt the law. But today, you are the law. 01:02:33.4800000 You are the law. 01:02:40.3700000 Not some book, not the lawyers, not a marble statue or the trappings of the court. 01:02:55.7300000 See, those are just symbols of our desire to be just. 01:03:08.4600000 They are. They are, in fact, a prayer, a fervent and a frightened prayer. 01:03:23.8200000 In my religion, they say, act as if you had faith. 01:03:32.7100000 Faith will be given to you. 01:03:38.1500000 If. 01:03:44.0700000 If we are to have faith in justice, we need only to believe in ourselves and act with justice. 01:03:59.5200000 See, I believe there is justice in our hearts. 01:04:16.0800000 There's a lot there. 01:04:21.5700000 You're seeing him pause, take the time he needs to think. There's so much power in the thought and thinking. It's a very vulnerable state to be in where you are taking your time and just speaking very simple to the jury. I think that that's something that I myself overlooked the first few times. How simple, simple the message was, and yet how powerful it was. 01:04:54.3600000 I think I'll leave it at that. For that, for that clip. 01:05:01.2400000 All right. We've talked about, you know, walking out the thought. I don't want to belabor this much more. When you physically walked and spoke in the speech, then you stand still and speak to it. I want to emphasize something standing still. 01:05:18.4400000 And I myself have, you know, had a lot of feedback on this, and I've learned the hard way that pacing in the courtroom is very dangerous. Why? Because I've had feedback from jurors that it's distracting. And it wasn't until I really got into the art that I realized what was happening with a speaker, public speaker, who was pacing. It really did take away or detract from the words and from the thoughts that they were communicating. 01:05:56.3900000 So as public speakers, one of the most important things that we're taught is to stand still and to plant ourselves in one place. Now, that doesn't mean that you're not allowed to move. You sure are. And in fact, it would not be natural to grow roots, if you will, into one spot for the whole opening or closing. In fact, I think it would really confine you to and make you feel as if you're in a straitjacket. 01:06:32.4800000 What I. What I've been taught and what I think is very powerful is to use movement to help highlight and accentuate parts of your speech. So instead of just meandering about, or instead of just pacing around the courtroom with no intention, instead you bring purpose to what you're saying when you choose deliberately to move at certain junctures, instead of just moving aimlessly around and arbitrarily around because of, you know, let's face it, nerves. So when we. When we coordinate, if you will, or marry our bodies and the movements of our body with the words that we speak, we be. 01:07:23.6100000 We are more in unison, and we. And our message is more impactful for the jury. So, for example, if I am coming up to something that is so vitally important that I want the jury to understand and I want this to dominate their discussion in the jury room, there are a few different things that I can do. What I might do might be very different than what another attorney does. It's all going to be unique to you as the lawyer. 01:07:53.3900000 And that's what I love about this, because there's so much art here. You have the opportunity to explore and to find what. What works for you. You're not hampered in any way by another person's vision of how they want you to do it. But, for example, one style in that example, to emphasize an important point might be to do what Paul Newman did, where Paul Newman lowers his voice a little bit and he slows down his pace, and he really speaks to the jury as if he's. 01:08:28.7000000 As if he's speaking to each one individually. Could you catch that? That his speech didn't really sound like a speech, did it? It felt as if he was talking to you directly. What we call that in the theater world is acting from what we call second circle, or speaking from second circle. 01:08:51.4200000 So speaking from first circle is when you have an orator that's on stage and that is speaking in a very general way to the audience, in a way as if they themselves know there are hundreds of people out there, and they've got to make their points. However, when you have someone like Paul Newman who leans in a little bit, lowers her voice, and makes eye contact with as many jurors as he can and talks to them as if he's having a conversation, we then get to see what's called second circle. And second circle is what is so compellingly powerful for public speakers. These are the speakers where you go to see them speak and you are blown away, and you feel as if, despite the fact you were one of 300, that they were speaking directly to you. They have found an intimacy with each. 01:09:55.7800000 They've established an intimacy with each individual member of the audience. And make no mistake about it, they're not talking. They're not talking in a Very broad way. Okay. Their attention is not diffused across the whole auditorium. 01:10:13.3300000 It's very direct. They've now gone into what we call direct space where they are literally making eye contact with as many individuals as they possibly can. They're lowering their voice a bit. They're pausing to allow the audience to keep up with them. And they are. 01:10:34.7700000 They're vulnerable. They're vulnerable in that moment without doing anything more. By taking their time and by allowing their thoughts to be on full display for everybody to see. It's a very vulnerable state to be in. And you could tell how when you slow down, emotion just naturally starts to bubble up inside. 01:10:58.1200000 We saw that in Paul Newman. You began to see the emotion and how connected he was to these words. They no longer were being spoken in a way they were never originally, but they are not spoken in an empty, hollow way. It's easy to do that. It's easy to be removed from the words that we're speaking, you know, and as if to say, I want you to do, jury what I myself cannot do, and that's care for my client. 01:11:25.9700000 But when you slow down a little bit and you really let. And you really feel the words that you're speaking, you are going to have some type of response. And nobody is saying that. You have to have this response. You have to have that response. 01:11:40.1200000 It's whatever organically is coming to you. But to actually experience. To have an experience with these words today, we often don't do that. We often, you know, we just. We speak phrases that have such heavy meaning as if they're nothing anymore. 01:11:55.5600000 You know, like, you know, I'll kill you or, yeah, right, go jump off of a bridge. You know, we say that and, you know, we just say it as if it's casual, like, you know, oh, look, we'll have a beer later. You know, that's as if we're saying something with that much gravity. But, my gosh, if you had to slow down and really speak those words, obviously we have puns and we talk in, you know, fun, you know, language. You know, buddy language, one another. 01:12:18.3900000 But, my gosh, if you were to really slow those words down and experience and just whatever's coming up in that moment, let that come out, you would bring a little bit of what we just saw on display with Newman. But there's other ways to do it as well. If that's not in your personality or that's not in your wheelhouse, there are loads of attorneys that will use a different style to emphasize something very important. And, yes, they might stand their ground as if they are a lion defending their territory and be very bold and be very assertive about, about this. And in that moment, that might be what it calls for and that might be what, you know, that might be to. 01:13:02.0100000 That might be the way they can best describe or the subtext of how they're feeling. And, you know, the righteousness of their cause can come out. So you see how this is. So it is so what we might call. Oh God, it is just. 01:13:23.3900000 It's subjective. It's going to be what works for you and what you yourself are comfortable with. What's your style, if you will? But I always challenge attorneys that find one way to be easier than the other to experiment with going in the opposite direction. Just to feel in preparation what it might be or feel like to try something contrary to what their go to is all the time. 01:13:48.9100000 And you might discover something that you never knew was there before. So you always do need an outside eye. I always, when I'm prepping, I always have outside eyes. I love the feedback. I love to get as much feedback from as many different people as possible. 01:14:04.0100000 Over the years, I've gotten better at it. In the beginning, it is frightening because, you know, you're. You're hearing person A say this person B might disagree with person A and say. And think that what you did was just spectacular. So you have to learn to take this with a grain of salt. 01:14:18.9800000 And if you can, it's not easy. But if you can record yourself and videotape just smidgens of your opening and closing and after, and with the benefit of having all of that feedback from non lawyers too, I might add, non lawyers, if you can, then you will have a lot of fodder. You'll have a lot of things that you can objectively start looking at to help share your opening and closing. You may find that you are not even worried about your breath and that the range of your voice is most likely responding to the changes of the text. That's when you're working on all cylinders. 01:14:57.3700000 Most heightened texts, not unlike legal arguments, have two key components. The language moves you forward. We're advancing the story. It's active. We are in. 01:15:06.6500000 We're using active verbs. We're not using the oh gosh from French. I'm thinking past participle and you know, and all of these. We're not using the past. 01:15:20.3400000 The past was or were. We're always staying active. And in the present, you don't dally and inspect your words, but use them to shift Events, transitions, or changes in text are great opportunities for movement. So if you're one that likes to move around in the courtroom, I'm not saying that again, that you have to be growing those roots in one spot. You can, at the time your speech gets to a transition, you can then transition and move to a different spot in the courtroom. 01:15:55.4200000 And guess what that's going to highlight for the jury? That there's a transition. So not only will your words convey that there's a transition or a change, your movement to another part of the courtroom, of the well, of the courtroom, will also. Will also serve as a reminder or as a note to the jury that you're going to another topic. 01:16:20.5900000 Other. Like, mostly with one word. We like to transition. But if, when, conversely, in less heightened, more casual language like we use today, we make turns with several words. You know what I mean? 01:16:32.0700000 Perhaps I might. I wonder if in legalese, we don't do that. We change on a dime using one word. Like, but if, when, conversely, this language difference should be transformed into your movement, you should be clearly turning on every word that turns. Many regular word turns result in a physically gentle curve. 01:16:50.1500000 Heightened text has us turning clearly, cleanly and quickly. Lock this motion into your body, and it'll surface in the voice when you speak. Speak. What you physicalize will show up in your voice through practicing on your own before the actual. Before the actual trial. 01:17:07.4300000 Of course, I've discussed the potential that incomplete thoughts have on losing a jury. However, I haven't really discussed interrupted thoughts, although I did earlier. So I'll just tackle this very, very superficially. Shakespeare knew about this. He knew that when the character has lost his or her train of thought during a speech, it's usually for a reason. 01:17:33.5600000 It's not there just for the sake of being there. They were experiencing a heightened level of emotion, from rage to despair, to loss to love. The thoughts go all over the place. It's like. 01:17:46.1600000 How can I put it? It's like sparks going off here and there. There. It's like fireworks, you know? Oh, a new firework. 01:17:52.4300000 Oh, something else. I call this, like, the puppy. The puppy thing. My puppy these days is just. She sees all of these bright, shiny objects. 01:18:02.0300000 A new, bright shining object. Oh, a stick is over here. Oh, my ball is over here. Oh, my food is over here. Oh, another dog is there. 01:18:09.1100000 Oh, another human being. These are sparks that come to us. And this is exactly how our brain is, because it's. There are electrical transmissions that are lighting up different parts of our head. And so we need to make sure that we know what type of energy we're putting out there and how it's landing for the jury. 01:18:29.1000000 I talked about the Hamlet speech already. You see that there's a break in the iambic pentameter in the middle of the speech where he is so full of rage that he can't let it, he can't hold it anymore. It's just coming out, you know. So an example again in the legal realm is this sense of injustice. Now it's just pure injustice. 01:18:51.3500000 I've been playing with the facts. Now it's just pure raw emotion. This is wrong. This is wrong. This should not be. 01:18:59.9900000 This man is entitled to a recovery in this case. His life will never be the same again. In 10 seconds, his life has been turned upside down. He has gone from preparing to run the New York City Marathon to not being able to get up and get out of bed and walk on his own anymore. Now he is confined to a bed. 01:19:20.3900000 He'll never walk again. He is, you know, he is. He is, you know, he has a wet nurse who is waiting on him hand and foot. He can't bathe himself, he can't shower. He has gone from being a completely independent, self sufficient 28 year old person to being completely dependent on as many people as possible to get him through just a day. 01:19:47.3800000 How can you possibly, how can you possibly argue that there is no liability? You know, these are the arguments. You see, that sense of justice is going to come out. So yes, yeah, we're going to do the job of taking the facts, applying them to the law, doing the analysis. But then there will be times in the speech where, whoa, it just comes out. 01:20:10.5500000 It comes out, this isn't right. This isn't right. And sometimes, just sometimes, that's a good prompt for getting into your speech and how you want to start crafting the speech. Start with this isn't right. And then what follows afterwards? 01:20:26.4600000 Words. Trust me when I tell you that those four or five arguments that come afterwards will somehow find their way fit in your speech in some way, shape or form. Because interrupted thoughts are innately human. And we always strive for conversational reality when we're in the courtroom. I endorse their use when the moment calls for it. 01:20:47.9000000 For example, a juror nods their head or smiles and you are affected by it, that you have to pause and smile back and then you can pick back up where you left off. Owning your words. This is all about connecting your own words to the voice and more importantly, to the breath. When an actor owns a Word. There is no clutter in the voice or speech process. 01:21:10.8700000 The word is spoken cleanly and efficiently. It is there. The audience hears the word clearly in the most profound yet, yet simply way. The word is free but informed by the actors unique experience of it. So everything that we say, okay, is going to be informed by our history, by our upbringing, by the experiences, by what has shaped us into the person who we are today. 01:21:36 So, for example, a word for me like love, you know, if that is a part of the theme of my case, and love or friendship or something innately human that comes up, that word is going to have a unique meaning to me that will be very different than any other attorney who stands up to deliver that same speech with the same text. It's a place of enormous simplicity. But underneath that simplicity is a world of experience. Many writers and directors will ask an actor who is confused about words in a speech to just say the words, which I take to mean just know and own the word enough so that you can trust and experiment without denying it makes sense. Either bellowed or muttered, the words invariably get lost and have no real weight. 01:22:26.7200000 A lot of this work is chicken and egg. The voice and breath have to be free in order to own the word. Yet you have to own a word before the voice and speech are completely free. Much of the technical work actors get is to shortcut the process of owning a word. If the rehearsal period is long enough, good actors will get there on their own. 01:22:46.9400000 The reason why actors spend so much time on this is because actors are not writing what they are acting. Unless of course, they were the playwright as well as acting in the play. Instead they. There's a playwright who's separate than the actor, and then the actors are coming to perform the piece. And so these words are not their own. 01:23:08.5500000 They have to yet be able to take the words of a third person, the playwright, make them their own, so that they spring out of them in a way that's spontaneous and organically and so that the audience will believe that those are truly, truly the actor's words. And that's very hard, especially with Shakespeare, because we don't talk very. We don't talk like that anymore. So when I'm talking about, oh, that this too too solid flesh, oh, that this too too solid flesh would melt, thaw, and resolve itself into a dew. That's not a common phrase that I would utter today in, you know, in. 01:23:46.2800000 In a conversation with a friend. So I really need to do a lot of soul searching to find out where those words live inside of me because I don't want to divorce myself from the text. I don't want to say to myself that it's got to be spoken in the way that I've heard 15 other actors say it. In fact, that's the worst thing that I can imagine. I want it to be unique and true to who I am. 01:24:11.4100000 And I want it to be uttered so that it's coming. It's coming out of me freely and not in a way that sounds as if I'm reading it from, you know, from a book. All right? Because if it were going to come out that way, then there's no sense for the. For the audience to even see the play. 01:24:27.5000000 They can just be given the script when they walk into the theater. We can raise the lights up, and we can give them two hours to read it on their own. Their imagination will actually do more wonders than anything that I can do if I'm just speaking it as if. As if I'm reading it. 01:24:47.1100000 Yeah. Ownership of words. Knowing the text. The good news is that you are the writer of your opening and your closings. And so the words that you choose will invariably be words that you yourself use very frequently. 01:25:01.6700000 I found that there are certain words that I come back to over and over and over again. There are certain expressions that I like to rely upon, upon that helps me to put my individual stamp of authenticity on it without even knowing it. You know, I'll use example. I'll use expressions that, you know, people will. That some of my friends, you know, will chide me about, you know, and have done so over the years, you know, but they're true to who I am, and they're the ideas that come up when I'm in a creative state of mind. 01:25:33.9500000 When the words begin to grow roots in the heart and soul, in a sense, they have to be relearned. You develop this deep ownership that that's what starts to happen. 01:25:46.0100000 It's not at all uncommon to forget words as they span the chasm from intellectual enlightenment to sensual, emotional, and spiritual knowledge. For this reason, I try not to get frustrated when I forget a line. As a matter of fact, forgetting a line when you are rehearsing like you're opening or closing, it should not. You should not be raised yourself. When you forget a line, it's probably because there is something. 01:26:10.2600000 It's probably because you're experiencing something. And when you experience something, the brain tends to get so absorbed in the feeling of it that the analytical part of the brain gets a little bit lazy, if you will. And is unable to keep the thought up in the air. And so you'll drop it. And it's not a bad thing. 01:26:34.5700000 I used to really admonish myself and really beat myself up when I forget a line during my preparation phase. But I realized that there was something that was happening. I was experiencing that I thought an idea in a different way than I had experienced it before when I had rehearsed it standing up. And so now what if the way I just expressed it now what about that way I just expressed it? Now can I see the difference between how it was expressed now and before? 01:27:03.3200000 And was there something that I did this past time that made it ever more powerful within me? And so it might then have even a deeper impact on the jury, how it came out before. At the end of the day, we don't take a predetermined way of saying the tactics into the courtroom. We want to be open to the shifts and changes that we get from the jury because we're always responding off of them and taking what they give us into what we say. And they in turn will be responding through nonverbal language, but nonetheless through non verbal language from what we are saying and from what the sense and the experience they get from the way we speak. 01:27:49.8100000 Speak our words. And that includes not just a spoken word, of course, but also our own body language and our gestures. Yeah. So, yeah, there's a lot of emotion. And you might have heard the expression it was spoken by a famous poet. 01:28:06.2900000 People may not remember the words that you actually said, but they will never forget the feeling that they took from actually hearing those words. So that we can really take that to heart. This was a phrase, this was a little bit of Ian McKellen. I think I played at the last time, so I don't want to necessarily go back to that. Oh, and we are. 01:28:31.0700000 Oh my gosh, time just absolutely flies. We're ready at 2:30. Let me just see if there's something I want to cover. 01:28:40.9100000 All right. There was the pause. 01:28:44.9700000 Yeah. I want to just talk very briefly about chapter method organization. I didn't talk about that through this series, but I do want to draw your attention to what we call the chapter method. The chapter method is basically just an organizational method. You can call it whatever you want, but what we really look at is, is taking ideas and grouping them so that we know what point any given idea is going towards. 01:29:18.5000000 It's almost like in a visual sense, you have the idea and then you have a sub idea that goes underneath that main point. And this is a critical way for preparing for cross examination. When you know what point it is that you're driving towards, you'll know what individual facts that you need to get the witness to agree to in order to be able to argue that point in closing. Because as I cautioned you about earlier in the presentation, if you come out by attempting to ask an adversarial witness a conclusory statement of, you know, you know, you didn't see the actor who robbed you, okay, they're going to disagree with that. So you need to look at the individual parts of that conclusory statement. 01:30:15.3100000 You want to be able to argue that conclusory statement at closing. And guess what? You can and will, even without getting the witness or having the witness stipulate or acquiesce to that conclusory statement. How will you do that? You'll be able to do that by the building blocks, building it fact by fact by fact. 01:30:35.2400000 What are the individual parts that I need in order for the jury or in order for me to make this argument? And once those individual facts are in place, they form the foundation that I'm going to stand on so that when I get up in closing arguments, I might not have gotten the witness, I might not have asked that direct conclusory question of the witness, but I have all the facts and all the evidence from the mouth of that witness to make that kind of argument. There can be no objection in closing that can prevent me from making that conclusory statement because I have all of the essentials, the foundation, if you will, for that conclusory statement. And so I think that's how we'll end here. Yeah, there's just so much, so much to talk about here, but I don't want to take up anyone any more time than I already have. 01:31:32.9900000 Super. Thank you all so much for joining me today, and I hope to see you in a future program. There are a bunch of programs that I'm partnering up with LexVid to do in different areas as well. I also practice in as a tax attorney, and so I'm bringing a little bit of tax law to LexVid. And I'm excited about that programming because I've done a lot of it for CPAs and accountants, and this has actually forced me to specifically tailor it for an audience of lawyers because it's an area that's rife for lawyers to get involved in because they're. 01:32:10.3700000 There are not enough tax lawyers around, I find, to handle the myriad of issues that oftentimes come up with CPAs for at least consultations that CPAs might need some advice on for proceeding with problematic cases. So look out for that and look out for a few more of the programs in the litigation series. So once again, thank you so much for joining me and can't wait to see you again next time. Take care. Bye now.