[Course Name] 00:00:00.7200000 Hi, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. Today's seminar is titled Ethics Potluck Topics for Litigation Attorneys. We're going to talk about various ethical topics here that touch the rules of professional conduct. No concentration necessarily in one area, but just kind of a little spattering across the board of three, usually of the most common areas, where we see malpractice claims, where we see disciplinary complaints, and a little bit of how you can protect yourself from those claims. A little bit about myself. 00:00:33.0720000 My name is Carrie Sheehan. I just started a new position this week, Council of Taft Law Firm here in Indianapolis, Indiana. In that role, I do ethics and compliance work with clients on terms, conditions, engagement letters, and anything that touches the firm in an ethical capacity or its lawyers. So you can say that I work with the rules of professional conduct 24 hours a day, seven days a week. And I do in my job. 00:01:01.5360000 In addition to that, I'm an adjunct professor over over at The Robert H. McKinney School of Law, which is part of Indiana University, where I teach professional responsibilities. The rules that we were talking about here today is not only what I teach, but also what I practice. So if you have any questions regarding anything you hear today or anything outside of the box, you can always drop those in the chat as well. If I see them while I am talking, then we will discuss them right then and there. 00:01:29.0940000 If not, then I will get to those questions at the end of the seminar. With that, let's get started here on our first potluck topic, which is just civility because it is always good to remind ourselves to be ethical. Now, you may think it's common sense to do the right thing, or it's common sense to have morals and standards and uphold your conduct to the highest ethical values. But if you think about the people that you oppose in litigation, or you think about the people that you go against in maybe a contract dispute or in an estate planning matter, or if you're administering a state or in a divorce matter, are those opposing counsels and opposing parties always ethical? Are they always professional? 00:02:18.4200000 And the answer to that is we can probably think of one or more examples in our careers where we run across an uncivil, unprofessional opposing counsel client, or even just someone we work with in the law firm. Incivility and unprofessionalism is rampant within the legal profession because the legal profession not only includes, you know, representing clients in court, but it also includes attending bar events, running and managing a law firm with non attorneys in it, then also too dealing with opposing counsel, dealing with the judiciary, anything that touches the profession is considered that practicing law. And if you're conducting yourself in an uncivilized, unprofessional manner in any of those capacities, then you have committed incivility and unethical conduct. Now, have you been sanctioned for that under the rules of professional Conduct? Probably not. 00:03:17.3100000 It is really hard to have that type of complaint filed unless your conduct is very egregious. But they do get filed, and we are that self Reporting Jurisdiction Rule 8.3. So your clients can turn you in, your opposing counsels can turn you in, the judicial bench you're in front of can turn you in. And so you've really got to watch your conduct. But a conduct and being uncivil is not just being rude. 00:03:44.4600000 It's also knowing what else is included in being uncivil and unprofessional. And with that comes competence. We have to stay competent in anything that touches or concerns our representation of a client. This is not just knowing the black letter law, the textbook definition of things, how to put together a litigation case, how do you know depose a witness? It's not just that. 00:04:11.6800000 Being competent also includes knowing how to conduct yourself in court, knowing how to talk to your clients, knowing how to diligently put together a case, prosecute a case, or defend a case. It also means knowing when you need to associate with another lawyer or when you need to do something to get your skills up to par with what you need to be. Competence can also include how do you manage non lawyers, how do you supervise non lawyers, how do you manage a law practice or law firm, and just being prepared and being thorough in all those endeavors that you undertake. And so again, we sometimes mistake our duty to be competent in just knowing the law and going to law school and checking the box on those cles, which I know some of you are doing here today. But it's so much more than that. 00:05:06.7000000 And a lot of times incivility and unprofessionalism can lead to a breach of Rule 1.3, diligence. In addition to that, it can lead to a breach of other rules, which we'll get to here in a second. But we have to be diligent in our representation of clients. If you read the comments To Rule 1.3, it tells you that diligence includes not procrastinating. How many of you have ever procrastinated on a brief, on a project, calling back a client, calling opposing counsel, or just managing your law practice in general? 00:05:43.7400000 Has anyone ever done that now, I wish I could see all your hands or your faces at this point, but I cannot. And so the answer to that is probably all have. At some point, we've all let that brief, which we owe a response to sit on the corner of our desk for way too long, and then we file a note for extension of time claiming we were too busy to get to it, when in reality we made donating. We have procrastinated on probably calling back clients that we don't really necessarily like to talk to sometimes, which is not good either, because we do have a duty, as we'll see under Rule 1.4, to communicate. But this idea of procrastination and not acting with reasonable diligence is considered unprofessionalism and incivility in some ways, depending on how you handle that. 00:06:32.1100000 In addition, under diligence too, we should not take on more clients than we can handle as litigators. Especially for my plaintiffs litigators out there. You may have a volume practice. A volume practice is great for paying the bills, especially if you have small sum settlements and then occasionally hit it big or maybe you have big windfalls, depending on the practice area you're in. But plaintiff's lawyers usually work on contingency fee, so they need a volume to keep the money coming in and those settlements coming in. 00:07:05.3400000 But with a volume can come lack of diligence, lack of promptness, lack of, you know, just communication sometimes with the client, which can lead to a very grumpy lawyer. If you're managing 500 cases, that's exaggeration, but you kind of know what I mean. You have a very high docket or caseload. You're going to get more short, probably in your language. You're going to get grumpier, you're going to get less communicative with your clients just because you can't afford to be. 00:07:37.7180000 You can't afford to take that time to sit down with each one because you got to keep them moving in and out, in and out. Well, with that can be considered unprofessional, lack of competence and violation of diligence, too. So we have to manage our caseloads as litigators, and we have to look at our attitude and how our caseload affects how we conduct ourselves and how we hold out. Another place where we can see incivility or unprofessionalism is just dealing with the client. I was saying that a little earlier, but under Rule 1.2, it tells us that the client is the boss. 00:08:14.3260000 I repeat that the client is the boss. You did not go to law school to get a law degree to be the boss of the client. Now, that may be a misconception of yours. When you were in law school, you're thinking, well, I went through three years of law school. I sat for this bar exam. 00:08:31.3940000 I sat for maybe multiple bar exams. Who knows? The client did not. But the client is the boss, and we should never forget that rule, because the moment we forget that rule is the moment when usually disagreements come up with the client and the attorney. Because the client necessarily doesn't want to be told what to do. 00:08:52.2180000 They've invited your advice as a counselor, as an advisor, not as a dictator. So you are not the boss. You have to work with the client to get to the objectives or what you're trying to achieve with the representation. This is where our rules 1.4 come in with communication and then obviously working with diligence under 1.3 and knowing these rules under rule 1.1. But working with the client, talking to the client, and knowing that you are not the final say in things is very important to, to keeping the relationship with the client civil and professional. 00:09:33.0540000 Because when we start crossing those boundaries is when we start seeing disciplinary complaints be filed and when we start having issues with our attorney client relationships. So we really need to think of our conduct and what we do and just knowing that the client is the boss. Rule 1.1 is that foundation. Kind of like the next slide was ref. Or excuse me, the previous slide was referencing it. 00:09:56.1180000 Rule 1.12 tells us that the client controls those objectives, what they want to get out of the representation, what they want to achieve via it. And the lawyer consults with the client regarding the means of how to get to those objectives. So we have the objectives which the client sets, and then we have the means of how to get to those objectives, which the lawyer assists in that conduct from there on. Now, at any time, if the client says no to the means or avenues that the lawyer recommends taking, then the answer is no. If you go to a client and say, hey, we've got this great settlement offer in from defendant, you're not going to get any better than this in court. 00:10:39.7200000 You should really take this. If the client says no, the answer is no. The answer is not, well, you're going to take it anyway. I'm going to make you. The answer is no. 00:10:52.5720000 We really have to listen and communicate with our clients and do what they want us to do. Now, we obviously counsel, we recommend we use our expertise, skill and knowledge to try to persuade them to what we think is best for them. But at the end of the day, if they say no, they say no. This is the same thing if you're in a criminal defendant and they don't want to take a plea or you're representing a defense and they don't want to make an offer to settle when you tell them they're probably going to lose at trial. The client is the boss. 00:11:25.3380000 Now, how do you protect yourself if they don't take your advice, Put it down in writing. If they don't take your advice and you think it's the wrong advice and you're afraid that they're going to maybe sue you for malpractice later, claiming you didn't warn them that you know these negative things are going to happen, then you take down what you said. So you write a memo to the client, you write an email to the client or a formal letter that just says, you know, here's what I've advised in this situation, however you've decided not to follow the advice, you'd rather do this, please confirm this and have them confirm it. Then if they come back later and say, you didn't tell me the risk and benefits you didn't tell me, I would get worse at trial than that offer, you have something to prove that you did tell them and that they just didn't take your advice. And that is a great defense to involve practice claim or anything like that. 00:12:19.1480000 So if they're not going to take your advice on the means to get to those objectives, then get it down and writing, confirm it and make sure you have that because your insurance company and your attorney defending you will love you for that. This is just the rule on communication. I know. I've already kind of talked about. We have to communicate with our clients to make sure we stay civil in those communications too, and just consult with them along the way because again, they control the yes or no. 00:12:48.1080000 They control how we proceed forward. They are the boss under that. Rule 1.2. With our communications though, we need to be prompt. If we get, say, a verdict or something in we don't wait months to tell them. 00:13:01.8960000 If we get an adverse ruling in, we don't wait months to tell them. Just know that bad news does not get better with time. Bad news never has got better with time. If you can think about situations for yourself personally where someone has withheld information from you because it was bad news and they just didn't want to hurt you or they didn't want to get in that Argument right then and there. Were you even more mad later when you eventually found out the answer is probably yes, and your client is no different. 00:13:35.3800000 So just owning up to it. If you get an adverse ruling from a court, you know, the clients can be upset. Just brace yourself for it. Find the best way to communicate that information, but do it promptly, do it diligently, and if it is something of an adverse ruling, then have some advice to tell the client saying, yes, we lost here. This is not great for our case. 00:13:56.7580000 However, this is what we're going to do from this point forward. So having that next step plan and coupling that with the bad, with the, you know, the not so happy communication can really go a long way with the client. Because then the client's thinking, okay, my lawyer's not stopping. My lawyers thought about this. My lawyer knows, okay, we lost here. 00:14:17.1100000 That's all right. We're going to try this. You know, we have that plan B in place. And so having that and coupling it with bad news news can sometimes soften the blow of something you need to tell your client. But don't hide the information. 00:14:30.2100000 Don't try to make it sound better than it is sometimes and not tell them the full truth. Just tell them the information. Figure out plan B or C or D, whichever one we're on, because we all know litigation can go sideways sometimes and then move forward in that. Another thing with communication that we have to remember is that we have to gear our communication to the sophistication of our client. This means if you're representing someone who's 20 years old and it doesn't have a high school education, then you need to talk to them like they're 20 years old and don't have a high school education. 00:15:06.6800000 This means you're probably not going to use the words motion and limine. You're probably not going to say prohabiche or, you know, some other Latin term we all learned in law school. You're going to have to take the level of communication down to how they'll understand it. I lecture at the undergraduate level and at the law school. I taught both types of students, and my lectures are different for each type of student. 00:15:31.0700000 And that's because I'm gearing communications towards the learner at the college level. They don't even know we have a state and federal court system half the time. So again, I have to gear the communications down to that level. This is kind of what we have to do with our clients to make sure they understand and make sure they can effectively make those Decisions, because again, rule 1.2, they are the boss. And this is hard. 00:15:55.3400000 In litigation, we all have those clients, especially if you're a plaintiff's attorney who you just don't want to talk to. I've had my fair share, too. I started out my practice as a plaintiff's attorney, and I had a client that would call me almost every day and he would say, is my case settled yet? When is my case going to be over? Well, we were only a week after he hired me. 00:16:21.0680000 So of course we didn't even have the complaint on file. It wasn't the statute of limitations yet. We were still collecting stuff and getting the complaint together. And he didn't know why his case wasn't done yet. And so every day he would call me and he would say that, you know, we're not doing enough, he's firing us, and hang up the phone and yell. 00:16:42.0320000 And finally I just started saying, your files downstairs, come and get it. And then I would start hanging up the phone. Now to the defense of my client at the time, he did have a traumatic brain injury, which was part of it. And unfortunately for me, he never came and got his file, even though I was secretly wishing he would. But we eventually got the case settled. 00:17:02.5440000 But even during that, with that difficult personality of the person I was representing, I still had to make prompt communications if he would call me and hey, call me back. I knew what was going to happen. He was going to ask why it wasn't settled. But I still returned his call within 24 to 36 hours. That was always my rule. 00:17:22.5900000 So having a rule, even with difficult clients, is a good thing. Now, if you can't do a 24 to 36 hour rule yourself, then what you need to do is have your assistant or law clerk or paralegal or someone working for you. If a client calls and you're on trial or out of the office and you can't call them back, they make the touch or they make the communication back to the client. And they don't give anything of substance because we don't want a Rule 5.5 violation of unauthorized practice of law. What they do is they just tell the client, we've received your call. 00:17:56.8260000 Attorney so and so is busy until X date. They'll return your call thereafter, or let me set up an appointment for you with the attorney. And then that way the client knows that you've received the communication, they know that you've acknowledged the communication, and now they have a boundary or a definite time frame of when you're going to get back to them. So now they're not thinking every day, why haven't I heard from my attorney? Why haven't I heard from my attorney? 00:18:22.9140000 They have a set date, time or time frame in which they know they're going to hear from you. Now if you do that, then obviously you need to follow up and call them at that certain date and time or on that appointment. But it is a way to manage those communications, to make the clients feel heard, to make sure you manage them with professionalism. And then two, you're not going to have disgruntled clients. If you have disgruntled clients, you're more avid to be disgruntled yourself and fights and arguments break out. 00:18:53.3820000 But this way you manage it in a way that is good for everyone and helps with your schedule. But we all have those clients that we just don't like and that are difficult to speak with. And I shared kind of a story when I've had, you know, one client, I thus I've just not just had one, I've had several that, you know, were very hard to communicate with or disgruntled. Even being an in house counsel role, I've had several clients and my clients or the attorneys within the firms I work for are disgruntled. And so just dealing with that and keeping civility, kindness and decency is what we have to do now. 00:19:34.1560000 Civility is not, you know, giving in to a client's every demands or wishes or not arguing or not, you know, green all the time. Civility is just, there's a way to conduct yourself professionally and then there's a way to conduct yourself unprofessionally. And we have to choose that professional route by saying things like, you know, I respectfully disagree. Here's why. Instead of yelling, you're, you know, effing wrong and then just going off on a tangent, there's a way to say it that's professional and there's a way to say it that's not professional. 00:20:06.3600000 And so this needs to be employed not just with our opposing counsels and the judiciary, but also with our clients as well. This also helps curb unreasonable client demands too. Because if clients have unreasonable demands, we still need to stay civil and professional in our approach to them and know when to say, enough is enough. We need to say, no, I'm not going to do that, because that steps beyond my rules of professional conduct. No, I'm not going to do that because that is not, you know, something we need to do that is immoral. 00:20:38.1720000 That is Wrong. That's against what I stand for. And that's okay to say no. Now, sometimes you may lose the client, and you have to be okay with that. But would you rather be up for a disciplinary complaint or up for a malpractice claim or sitting beside the client in jail, heaven forbid, for something you did seriously wrong, just because you wanted to please the client and didn't want to argue? 00:21:02.1500000 No, you don't. And you can argue in a way that's great and good and professional, and you can argue in a way that's bad. You have to find that balance. Then you also have to find the balance to say, no, enough is enough. The client's crossing the line, or they're going to make you cross the line and you can terminate that client. 00:21:22.1520000 We can fire clients. We really can. Clients can fire us. We can fire clients. And if you get to that point of incivility, then you need to start thinking about firing the client. 00:21:34.6480000 And as I was saying, civility is not an. Is not an agreement. It's not the absence of criticism. It's not liking every person. It's not even just having good manners. 00:21:45.3680000 Civility is exhibiting good behavior to a community or profession or a code of decency to a civilized society. It's really putting yourself in those shoes to conduct yourself in a very civilized, respectful manner to everyone that is involved. And that is sometimes hard because the rules of professional conduct apply to us 24 hours a day, seven days a week in our personal and professional capacity. And that is kind of hard to really conceptualize because you may say, well, I'm always professional at work. There's that phrase at work. 00:22:22.3440000 The rules apply personally and professionally 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Now, if I pulled your spouses and significant others and I asked them, do they act professionally, do they act civilly 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally? And some of your significant others or spouses may say, yeah, right, you know, and start laughing, or even your friends. So you need to think of your conduct all the time and how you conduct yourself. Because we are held to these high standards as lawyers. 00:22:56.4200000 And it started back when we took the bar exam, when we raised our right hand and took the oath of attorneys and those requirements to even become a lawyer. Most jurisdictions still have those fitness and character interviews that you have to go through when you apply to sit for the bar exam. I know I had to go through that in Indiana, where you had to meet with a lawyer in the local community. They got to question you on Anything. They had your entire application, and then that lawyer had to certify or sign off that they thought you were of good moral character and would exhibit the traits of a good moral lawyer upholding the rules of professional conduct. 00:23:35.2740000 If they didn't sign off on that, you were probably getting called in front of the entire bar Board of Law examiners to see what they thought and if you should be able to sit and pass the bar and become a lawyer in the community. So it's been kind of part of the profession for a long time, and it starts early on at that application phase and moves into our oath of attorneys as well. The oath of attorneys that we take, it says normally within them, when you raise your right hand, that you will abstain from offensive personality or that you will act in a civilized, professional manner. There's going to be some phraseology like that within the oath that you took when you became a lawyer. Each jurisdiction is a little different. 00:24:21.3180000 So you need to look up your specific jurisdiction of what you swore to uphold when you raised your right hand, because most of us forget, we know the normal, zealously defend, uphold the laws and Constitution, all that stuff. But that oath is a lot longer than just those two or three things. And so going back and taking a look at it, and really taking a look at we swore to uphold and seeing that it includes professionalism and civility in that context. So we got to remember those things as well. And yes, there's always been that tension between zealous advocacy and professionalism or civility. 00:25:00.8720000 A lot of people say, how can you do both? How can you be a zealous advocate and act professionally? Well, it's easy. It's just the approach of when to say no to the clients, how to phrase things when you argue. There's a good way to argue, like I said earlier, and a bad way, and just knowing that difference and when not to cross the boundaries. 00:25:21.7700000 And so those boundary lines may look a little blurry to some people, but when you really get down to it, the boundaries should not be that blurry. It should be very clear, very concise what our duties are as lawyers and how we can uphold our civility and professionalism within the legal profession. But if we don't, and we kind of tend towards that zealous advocacy, like we've talked about the rules here, we can violate Rule 1.2, 1.3, 1.4, which is not on your screen. We can do all kinds of things. We don't want to be that hired gun, just advancing the lawyer or Excuse me, the client's objectives all the time. 00:26:03.8680000 We want to stop and actually be the counselor, to be the advocate, to be the person of reason and refusing demands that are unethical and unprofessional, because that's what we do. We should know how to do that. We should be brave enough and confident enough to stand up to the client. Courts and justice systems have also picked up on civility over the years. There is a Sedona conference which is held out in Arizona. 00:26:34.4000000 It started back in the early 2000s. This is where judges signed a proclamation that they wanted to push civility within the courts and in their judicial systems. So they started requiring, and the federal courts did this a lot of them years ago, face to face communications between opposing counsel. They also required opposing counsel to try to work out their own differences, especially in discovery when they had disputes prior to seeking court intervention. So they wanted lawyers to start talking to each other again. 00:27:09.9500000 They wanted lawyers to be civil to each other again. Because if you're all litigators sitting out there, just think to yourself, what is the most contentious part of a litigation? It's discovery. No one likes discovery. People are trying to hide stuff. 00:27:26.5660000 People are trying to say this is privileged when it's not. And a lot of arguments take place in discovery and depositions. And so the justices, we're trying to curb this by saying, hey, we're not mommy and daddy up here. And you running to us with every little fight and miscommunication. You have work yourself out as adults, as civilized, professional litigators. 00:27:51.9700000 And then if you still can't resolve it, then you can come to us. But we want to see you talk and communicate first. And when they did that, it was not just email communication. It had to be a simultaneous type of face to face or telephonic communication where you talked back and forth simultaneously late. Because we all know if you send an email, you can sit on it, never respond or respond, and the tone is wrong, or, you know, you just. 00:28:18.2780000 It's just not good to send emails sometimes. So civility was what the courts were pushing because they found great benefits in it. Some of those benefits are listed here on the screen. And they found that, you know, it helped move cases along faster. And that's the whole goal of the judiciary, to get the cases in and out, out and move them through the process a lot faster. 00:28:41.4500000 Now, obviously too, civility can breach other rules. We've already talked about Rule 8.3, which is our self reporting rule. We do have a duty as lawyers to report Other lawyers who we know have violated the rules. This is a very high standard to meet a knowing standard. So it's not just, well, I assume he violated the rule or I assume she did. 00:29:05.1100000 Xyz. This is a knowing standard. You know, that this person or this lawyer violated a rule of professional conduct. If you meet that knowing standard that absolutely no, then you have a duty under Rule 8.3 to report that lawyer. If you do not report that lawyer, then you are liable for violation of 8.3 yourself for failure to report. 00:29:30.8700000 So we are a self reporting jurisdiction. And so if you are uncivil or unprofessional or breach any of these rules I've just mentioned or any of the rules I haven't mentioned, then you could be reported by your colleagues, clients or anyone. So we also have to watch that. Now the biggest rule where we do get the incivility and unprofessionalism, aside from the ones I've already talked about here today, is Rule 8.4. This rule says that we can be sanctioned or disciplined for anything we do that is prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:30:05.3700000 Defined prejudicial to the administration of justice. It's a very broad term. It's in the rule and that exact language in the Model Rules and in most jurisdictions. And the rule doesn't define what is prejudicial to the administration of justice. The comments give us some guidance. 00:30:23.6660000 We can obviously think of some clear examples, but we can. There's also unclear examples and disciplinary commissions just like to tack it on where they can of anything prejudicial to the administration of justice. We can also get sanctioned too for incivility and unprofessionalism under Rule 8.4g as in girl discrimination and bias. This is where if we discriminate or hold bias or harassment or sexual harassment against another person, we can be sanctioned for it. This is kind of like the Title 7 of the Rules of Professional Conduct. 00:30:58.9860000 So there's protected classes in Rule 8.4g and we cannot discriminate or harass any of those protected classes. It is way broader than Title VII though. Lex Vid has several seminars just on rule 8.4g if you are interested in that. I have given several of them, but it is a very broad bad way to get at unprofessionalism in regards to harassment and discrimination making. The rules have their own sort of Title 7 for lawyers. 00:31:28.7640000 And so that is what that is. Otherwise, some of the rules we talked about here today, 1.2, 1.3 1.4. We also have the truthful and honesty rules. We're not supposed to lie as lawyers to the judiciary, two third parties to opposing counsel. We're supposed to hold ourselves to those high Conduct act and standards. 00:31:47.8360000 Any of these things can be incivility. Any of these violations can be unprofessional. So we do have to look at what we do. And this is just the quote from the Indiana Oath of Attorneys, which I told you earlier, where we will abstain from offensive personality. South Carolina has a similar one to opposing parties and their council. 00:32:10.4360000 I pledge fairness, integrity and civility not only in court, but also in all written and oral communication. So if you're in South Carolina and your pledge and oath, that is what you said, and I challenge you if you're in a different jurisdiction, which a lot of us are in various jurisdictions on this call today, go out and look at your specific state where you raised your right hand and took your oath. There's probably going to be something similar in it. It won't be verbatim as to South Carolina and Indiana, but you're going to see some sort of civility clause or professionalism clause within the oath you took to be an attorney. Knowing how to stand up against opposing counsel or clients with incivility is always a good thing. 00:32:56.8840000 This is kind of some things we should think about, obviously check our own attitudes, any stereotypes, biases, so we don't implicate that rule 8.4g. If you let them get to you, they win. They win. You don't want to bring your behavior down to someone who's being uncivil or unprofessional. You want to bring their behavior up to your conduct of being a professional within the legal world. 00:33:20.5900000 Smile, ignore them. That always kind of makes them more angry. But you know, you can do those things too. Fight up, don't fight down. Have compassion. 00:33:29.5900000 Because sometimes opposing counsel or clients anger and incivility has nothing to do with you. Maybe there's something else going on in their life. Maybe they're just a disgruntled person and need like an aura cleansing or something. But just have compassion for them. Believe in that professionalism, karma, because it does come back around. 00:33:50.5860000 Their reputation of being that uncivil and professionalized lawyer is keeping with them and catching up to them. And a reputation is hard to create and you can ruin it instantaneously. So you really need to look at those things too. Keep the communication open. Talk to opposing counsel, outsmart your opponent, stay ahead, beat them. 00:34:13.8360000 You know, in the legal system in the court where it counts, not with yelling and screaming and being unprofessional. Prepare, prepare, prepare. Keep all communications. Communicate with your clients. You know, play the waiting game, know the rules, follow them and check your own attitude and what you do routinely too, because that's highly important as well. 00:34:33.4360000 Well, just knowing all these things is a good way to get what you want and also to have that good lawyer and professional if opposing counselor, someone is having exhibiting bad behavior. Just some ways to protect yourself. Here on the screen in front of you, we document the bad behavior. An instance, we'll just read a couple of them. For example, if a lawyer does not provide a request to document, after agreeing to do so, write them an email know saying, I've called you five or six times. 00:35:03.8340000 How many times you've called them, you have not had the courtesy to return my call and I still have not received the document that you promised or I still have not received those documents. So you just start making a written record of opposing counsel's conduct. Because then if you have to file a motion for sanctions with the court against that opposing counsel, then you're going to have some evidence to present and you're going to have the concrete date and times. You're going to have the concrete create facts more and not you just trying to recreate them for the court. Another one here you can write memos to the file. 00:35:38.4220000 This is the third one down. This is just a memo to the file so you can refresh your recollection when you go to write that motion for sanctions. It can be as basic as saying, I spoke to attorney X and told him that we would not accept 5:00pm fax notices and that if he doesn't again, I'll ask for sanctions. So you just kind of record in the file a memo to yourself when the conduct happens. So then you remember dates and times when you do write that motion for sanctions. 00:36:05.9800000 Civility is important. Civility is huge. But another topic that gets lawyers a lot, especially in litigation, is confidentiality. Rule 1.6 tells us that a lawyer shall not reveal information unless the client gives informed consent or the disclosure is impliedly authorized. This means that we cannot disclose anything we learn in the course of representing a client without the client's consent confirmed in writing or impliedly authorized by law. 00:36:37.5900000 Now this includes a lot more stuff than just the attorney client privilege communications. The attorney client privilege is a very small subsection of confidentiality. As you can see on your screen in front of you. Attorney client privilege is that little blue circle inside of confidentiality the attorney client privilege, or the communications directly between the attorney and the client, no third parties present, minus a few exceptions to that rule, but normally just the attorney and the client, nothing else. That's attorney client privilege. 00:37:10.3800000 Confidentiality is everything else you learn regarding the course in the course of the representation. This could be your witness statement statements, this could be evidence. This could be an investigator's report, or the medical records or the HIPAA information. This could be anything else that you learned because you were representing that client and all of the information that you learned, that big red circle and the attorney client privilege information is protected under Rule 1.6, and you cannot disclose any without the client's consent confirmed in writing or impliedly authorized under the law. The one biggest misconception of Rule 1.6 is that if it's on the docket or if it's part of a public record, then we as the lawyer can talk about it to whoever we want. 00:38:03.9560000 That is wrong. If you are the lawyer representing the client, even if the information relating to the representation is part of the public record, court docket, newspaper, whatever, you cannot talk about it to a third party without the client's consent confirmed in writing. There is no exception for publicly available information under Rule 1.6B where we get our exceptions. This concept of confidentiality is way broader than that attorney client privilege, and way broader than you can imagine regarding the information you learn in representing someone. Most lawyers, especially litigators, violate this on social media and on their websites because they win a big case in court. 00:38:54.6020000 And what is the first thing they want to do? Take to social media to broadcast that. What is the last thing they want to do? Take to social media to broadcast that. The first thing they want to do is go to the client and say, hey, you just want a big verdict. 00:39:10.5800000 You know, we helped you win it. We would like to use this on our website. We would like to taunt our Successes on our LinkedIn or Facebook. Do you agree and consent to us saying that we won this case for you and what the verdict is? If the client says no, you as the lawyer can't use it in any of those places or tell anyone about it. 00:39:32.9080000 If the client says yes, us, then you can use it within the parameters of the consent. Social media gets lawyers in trouble all the time. I can't tell you how many times I've gone on social media, LinkedIn and see lawyers taking screenshots of, you know, the top caption saying, hey, we're in court today for this case or we just won this case. And the first thing in my mind is not great, congratulations. It's, did you get consent, did you get consent from the client to make this post? 00:40:02.5700000 Because, yes, it's a caption on a public record, but there's no exception for public information. They would have needed the client's consent to make that post. So hopefully they got the client's consent to make that post. And that is confidentiality. And a lot of people, especially in today's day and age with social media and everything, forget just how broad it actually is. 00:40:25.9140000 That big red circle that we saw two slides ago, and we'll even go back to it, that huge red circle and that there is no exception for that public information, social media anywhere. If you can't do it in person, don't do it online. The other time this is really violated is cocktail parties or talking with other colleagues that are not in your law firm or family. Come home and talk about your cases with your family with names and details. That's a violation of Rule 1.6. 00:40:56.7040000 There is no exception for family members. They're not part of the confidentiality. There is no exception for colleagues and other firms at cocktail parties and events. That's not part of the confidentiality. It is all just part has to stay confidential. 00:41:14.4600000 In negotiations, though, there is no duty to disclose affirmative facts to other parties. That is one exception too. So you don't have to give over certain information in those settings. That's one thing a lot of people sometimes comment on, especially in litigation is just, hey, you know, we're in negotiations or we're in this xyz. Do we have to disclose everything to opposing counsel? 00:41:38.4360000 Answers, no, you don't. Now, obviously, don't lie about things, but you don't have to disclose everything. Also too, in negotiations, normally if something is disclosed, it can't be later used against you at trial like the prosecutor or the opposing counsel can't say, well, in negotiations, you said this. And negotiations is a place to find that settlement and to get to, you know, each give a little on each side. So if we were going to have a rule that says you can use all this against you at trial, no one would want to go to settlement. 00:42:07.5640000 So there is that protection there, too. Now, the only times where we can disclose confidences are set forth in Rule 1.6 B, as in boy. And it is a usually a discretionary standard, unless the client is using our services to commit a crime, then you don't have any discretion and you have to disclose the confidences to stop the crime from happening. Because you don't want to be sitting next to your client in jail. You want to be on the other side of the bars helping them get out of jail. 00:42:35.5640000 But otherwise, lawyers may disclose to prevent a fraud that is reasonably certain to occur, or economic injury and or a crime. So if something's crime that's going to be imminent, like you know, a murder or death, you can disclose in those circumstances to stop something substantial imminent, like a crime or fraud, an economic injury or anything like that. But it is a may standard, which means you have discretion as the lawyer if you want to disclose or if you don't want to disclose or what you want to do with at that time. So again, it is a may standard, a discretionary standard in the event, again, we have that may standard, you know, we obviously, you know, to prevent the substantial injury, fraud or harm. But again, like I was saying, we cannot assist in the client's crime or be part of the crime, or they can't use our services in furtherance of a crime. 00:43:33.0340000 So if that is what is going on, then we have a mandatory duty to disclose, meaning no discretion that we shall disclose the confidences to prevent the client from using our services to commit a crime. So those two differences is a good distinction to always remember the may standard and the shall. And if you're ever in a situation trying to figure out if you should disclose or if you have to disclose or you want to disclose. And if you fit under a may standard, Obviously read Rule 1, 6B in your specific jurisdiction. And then I also recommend you reach out to maybe a lawyer in your community that practices professional ethics. 00:44:11.3720000 Or I do know some bar associations have ethics hotlines that you can call. And if you're a member of the bar association, they will give you ethics advice. You give them the scenario they give you, you know, what you should or shouldn't do. And usually those ethics hotlines is an exception to Rule 1.6 as well, because you're seeking legal advice to protect yourself in certain circumstances. And so you can do those with confidentiality and not violating any rules. 00:44:40.0480000 But again, check your local jurisdictions to see if those resources are available with your bar association. Or just know the different lawyers that practice ethics within your legal community at that point. These are just five tips to protecting your attorney client privilege. This is just a graph I, I found online that I thought was kind of cute and gave some good advice. Obviously, when you're talking with a client, keep the discussions with the client and you as the attorney private. 00:45:08.4060000 Again, we don't want those Third parties present to break an attorney client privilege. Do not discuss any details of your case on social media. That's good advice for the client and for the attorney. Tell your client and you not to blog about anything that may involve the case case that you're working on. Do not use your work email to correspond with the attorney. 00:45:32.3480000 This is a tip for your client when you have that client come in for initial consultation. If you're a plaintiff's lawyer, you should advise them that normally work emails are not confidential because normally employers have an apology that if it's on a work email, that they can scan it, view it, and they own the rights to those emails because it's a work email. So you as a lawyer have to remember when you communicate with clients, ask them, do you have a personal email if they start using their work email? Or tell them that they need that personal email because otherwise the employer could see all the communications and it could potentially break the attorney client privilege. And then all those communications could be subject to discovery by opposing counsel. 00:46:18.2980000 So you've got to be very careful with how you correspond with your clients as well, watching that privilege. Another thing to remember too, do not use your work computer either, because again, we all know there's logs, there's metadata, there's different things like that. And your work can log those things and then pull them back up. So again, counsel the clients to use personal devices, personal emails when communicating, and explain to them just why we have to do this due to the attorney client privilege and keeping things confidential, you know, so it doesn't hurt them in discovery or in their case. Another rule, just kind of moving on to a different topic in our potluck series here, Avoiding the unauthorized practice of law, known as upl. 00:47:07.4040000 The unauthorized practice of law is when you practice law without a license. This you think, okay, well, I'm a lawyer, I have a license. Well, lawyers can violate this too. Obviously not applying for the proper pro hoc viche status, practicing in a jurisdiction in which you're not licensed, unless you're comply with the rules of that jurisdiction too. Just also to having your paralegal or legal assistance do stuff that only a lawyer can do, like give legal advice, sign, you know, stuff for court, you know, create an attorney client relationship. 00:47:42.5600000 There are certain things only lawyers can do, and if our assistants under our direct control violate those, we've committed UPL and they've committed uplift. So this is one too, especially in the litigation practice, that sometimes gets overlooked and violated just because we have volume practices and, you know, you're having your assistant do stuff. Maybe your paralegal has been there for 30, 40 years and they're just like, well, the attorney always says this. Well, whatever that is, could be legal advice. And even every single time it needs to come from you, the attorney, not the paralegal. 00:48:18.3240000 So we need to watch out for those things too. That we cannot assist in the unauthorized practice of law and that we cannot do it ourselves. And we've got to watch how we conduct ourselves and our non attorney staff here in front of us. Paralegals must be cautioned to be mindful of this because they can overstep problems. They're so integrated in any client relationship and they've seen it over and over again. 00:48:41.3500000 And sometimes paralegals think they're attorneys or they can give the advice because they've heard you give it it. They have some type of legal education. Not a law education, like a law degree education, but legal education. And so just keeping that mindful and doing that is good. Just watch that blurry line. 00:49:00.1280000 Only a lawyer can give advice, whereas a non lawyer paralegal can recite information. So you could say, hey, tell the client this and they can tell the client that. But if a client comes back with another question which requires more legal advice, then the paralegal probably should not be giving it and the client just needs to have a communication with you. So watch that, watch that, watch that. In some jurisdictions it's also a misdemeanor to give legal advice without a law license. 00:49:28.3540000 So you really don't want to be encouraging that. A lot of areas where this can happen too. And this is something just to train your paralegals and non attorneys on within your law firm advice to clients, friends and family over the holidays. Specifically, this is because if you think about it, they go to these parties too. Their family knows that they work in law firms, their family knows that they work with lawyers. 00:49:53.9000000 And then their family has legal questions. So they say, hey, you're a paralegal. Hey, you're a legal assistant. I have a question. Have you seen this before? 00:50:02.8200000 And then that non attorney assistant of yours gives legal advice. What they should say and how you should train them is to say, yes, my attorney I work for does that. Why don't we make an appointment with him and he can talk to you about this further. I can't give you the legal advice. Do you think they say that or do you think they try to answer the question to help out their friends and family? 00:50:26.1900000 That's the unauthorized practice of law. There's no exception for advice to friends and family. So we really have to think about that also too. If you're having them do too much in the firm, like signing documents in court, going to represent third parties in court, that's all the unauthorized practice of law. Unless you have a license, they cannot run your practice while you're on sabbatical. 00:50:49.9660000 They cannot run your practice while you're on vacation. If you are out as the attorney and you're a sole practitioner, you need to have another attorney step in or give your non attorney assistance the same time off because you don't want them running the practice, giving legal advice, especially when you're not present. That was very rampant during COVID Just because, you know, people weren't in the office as much, they figured out they can learn from remote locations or you know, work from remote locations. And so they just told the paralegals to man down the fort, do this, do that. And then we saw a lot more UPL coming through just from our non attorney assistance that we have in the firm. 00:51:32.7100000 So really something to look at and consider as well. The last topic we had here today, which we don't have time to get through all of it, but I will just introduce it to you just so you know, conflicts of interest is a huge area where we see ethical concerns, especially in litigation. We always need to make sure we need to run conflicts. Just kind of briefly talking about our conflict rules here. Rule 1.7, our current conflicts of interest is a rule you would go to if you have a current client and then you want to be adverse to that current client because it tells us we cannot represent what client directly adverse to another client. 00:52:10.1540000 So if you're going to be reverse adverse to any client of yours, even in an unrelated representation, I repeat that even in an unrelated representation, this rule is invoked and you cannot do it unless you get informed consents confirmed in writing. This rule also applies if you have a material limitation, such as, you know, a client's taking a position and you may be the president of a group against that position. That's a material limitation because it's going to be perceived that you're going to pull your punches. And so that is something we don't want to do either. Now how do we cure these things? 00:52:47.3180000 We get informed consent confirmed in writing, we lay out to the client our conflict of interest, we tell them that we can continue to represent them. You know, we were not going to pull our punches. Basically both affected clients, the one that you're going to be adverse to and the one that you're going to represent adverse to the other client. Sign off, consents come in two. We need one from both affected clients and then you can move forward past that point. 00:53:14.2180000 But that's how we cure a conflict. Screens Chinese walls, the old phrase of them, or screens or anything like that cannot cure a conflict. The only thing that can cure a conflict are consents confirmed in writing. And consents come in two. Now, if you're going to be adverse to a former client or a client you've already closed out, that goes under Rule 1.9. 00:53:36.7460000 It's little different analysis. You can only be adverse to a former client so long as you're not being adverse to them in the same or substantial matter in which you represented them at the time they were active clients. So you have to look at what you did for the former client. And if what you did for the former client is not the same as or subs related to what you're going to be now adverse to them in, then you can go ahead and be adverse to them without seeking consent. That's the difference between Rule 1.7 and 1.9. 00:54:09.9580000 The only time you need a consent in Rule 1.9 is if you're going to be adverse to that former client in the same or substantially related matter in which you represented them when they were an active client. So the consents are more Limited in 1.9. You're not going to have to get as many. You're going to have to get more consents under the rule 1.7 standard current clients and 1.9 is for former clients. So we need watch out for those two things. 00:54:39.4000000 And with that, I hope everyone has a great rest of your afternoon and evening. And if you have any questions, please let me know.