[Course Name] 00:00:00.8400000 Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's presentation on if you have a brain, you have a bias. I know the title is a little sometimes concerning to some people, but I promise we're going to make this fun. We're going to make this enjoyable for our hour to get our credit for our CLe here today and hopefully learn a few things along the way. My name is Kerry Sheehan. I'm an assistant clinical professor of business, law and ethics at the Kelley School of Business, Indianapolis, Indiana. 00:00:32.1580000 I am also an ethics and conflicts attorney with Scopolitis, Garvin, Light, Hansen and Fury here in Indianapolis, Indiana as well. They practice in transportation, trucking on a national scale, and I do their internal conflicts or internal ethics and work with their general counsel on those different issues that arise. So you can say, I study ethics every day, all day, either in teaching as a professor or practicing law with scopolitis. And so today's seminar on if you have a brain, you have a bias. We are going to explore some of these intersections between unconscious bias, bias that individuals hold, even lawyers, and then two, how maybe it could impact the rules of professional conduct and our practice of law, not just with clients, not just with opposing parties or counsel or the judiciary, but also managing a law firm. 00:01:26.5340000 The day to day, the cocktail parties after work, the in the office type of exposure where we can see unconscious bias sometimes rear its ugly head. So let's get started on today, and we're gonna do here just a little example. We're gonna do a little exercise, so hopefully you're paying attention. But I want to introduce you to my friend Ellen. Ellen is an accomplished chef. 00:01:49.5940000 She loves sports, animals, hanging out with friends. She volunteers at homeless shelters way more time than I have. Her best friend is her sister Kate, and she also loves just playing bingo and hanging out with her family. Can you pick out Ellen? Look at the different images on the screen. 00:02:10.2000000 See if you can find Ellen. Try to remember those facial features from the slide before. Try to remember what the hair looked like with the eyes, the smile, the jawline, different features. Can you find Ellen on the screen kind of looking at those photos? Let's go on. 00:02:28.1520000 Did you think this one was Ellen? How many of you thought that? Well, if this is who you picked, you are wrong. I know a little trick there. You're wrong the first time. 00:02:39.6320000 This one was Ellen. This one was the one. If we go back the slides, that bottom right corner. So if that's the one you picked, that is Ellen. Now, how many of you had trouble finding Ellen? 00:02:52 And it's okay to be honest with yourself. It's okay to say, nope, I messed that up. It would have picked a different one. Had no idea which one she was. No idea anything. 00:03:01.7240000 And that's okay, because a lot of times people miss Ellen, and we're going to talk about why that is. But let's try another example to see if you're kind of picking up here on what we're doing. This is Shelly. Shelly is a mother of four kids, 45 years old. Loves cycling, yoga, f 45 training, all into all the fitness and hiking travels on occasion. 00:03:24.5560000 Best friends with her sister, Cindy. Has a criminal justice degree. How do you like Shelly? Can you find Shelly? Look at all the pictures. 00:03:34.8400000 Look at the different, you know, facial features and eye features and smiles and just how they look in their presence about them. Which one is Shelly? Getting your picks in, getting your picks written down or in your mind, how many of you chose? This one is Shelley. Anyone? 00:03:53.4100000 That is Shelley's daughter. So that is not Shelly. Let's go to the next one and see if we can find another person. This one was Shelly. So if you pick this one as Shelly, then you were correct. 00:04:06.8580000 This one, when we go back to that main screen, is the bottom center. So that one was Shelly there. And so that if you pick that one, you were absolutely correct on that being Shelly. How many of you had trouble finding Shelly? And it's, again, okay, to be honest, you might have had trouble finding her. 00:04:26.0280000 Now, if I would have done this with any other race, any other ethnicity, any other gender, we would have probably had the same results in such a way. We would have had the same results in the fact that normally we pick out people and remember features that are most like ourselves, we actually have a part of the brain, it's called the FFA, the fusifasiforum, that tells us and lights up, like, with neurons igniting when we see things similar to ourselves, and then we remember them more. So maybe if you're a caucasian female, you would have remembered Shelley more. Maybe if you are japanese, you would have had a better chance of remembering Ellen more. Orlando, if you're of that descent or that ethnicity. 00:05:13.4600000 And it's because when we see things most similar to us, it's familiar, because that's what we're used to growing up, seeing people similar to us, seeing people more like us, what our normal surroundings are. So our brain says, yay, happy. Remember them. This is good. Good lighting up those neurons. 00:05:34.1800000 And then we see things and people that are dissimilar to us. That part of our brain doesn't light up, and we're not as apt to pick up the subtle characteristics, the subtle differences, and see those things in that way. And this is not a terrible part of the brain. It's not something that we should have cut out or go into surgery to have removed. It's actually the part of the brain that's that fight or flight response, the hey, lion, run, it's going to eat you, or hey, soft kitty puppy. 00:06:05.3420000 Okay, pick it up and pet it. You know, that fight or flight, that fear, non fear, it's the same part of the brain. The problem is, when it comes to unconscious bias, it's happening when we do it to humans. And that's when we get the bias, that's when we get the stereotypes, that's when we get the discrimination that comes in. And half the time it's unconscious because we don't realize we're doing it. 00:06:29.8420000 We don't realize our brain is tricking us or our brain is telling us to do something that's wrong. We don't realize it. This does have a name. When it comes to identification of races and picking out your own race over others or their features. It's called the other race effect. 00:06:46.1540000 And it's that difficulty distinguishing faces and characteristics of other races that is not your own. And it's a real thing. And it is not saying that someone is racist. It is not saying that someone is all those ugly words that we hear all the time in politics and mediaev. It is part of our brain. 00:07:06.5100000 Now, the key to it is knowing that we have this built into us. Knowing it and recognizing it so that we can work against it, so that we pay more attention maybe to things that are dissimilar to us, where we pay more attention to remember certain things and that we stop ourselves when we're starting to stereotype, put people in classifications or doing those different things that can lead to discrimination, bias, unconscious or intentional. And we've really got to work on that. Like I said, the FFA helps us distinguish those faces familiar from unfamiliar, us versus them. Those are kind of the dirty words in my ethics class, us versus them, because it shows that sometimes we favor people more like ourselves over ones dissimilar to us. 00:07:55.0020000 And so we've really got to step beyond that and bring in the unity, bring in the culture, and remember that this is like any other business or corporation. Running a law firm is like a corporation. So we have to bring that unity, that culture, to our non attorneys and our attorneys. In addition to that, we're going to see that if we discriminate consciously or unconsciously, we can run afoul with the rules of professional conduct, and that's going to affect your license, that's going to affect the practice of law. And for us, that's really going to hit home probably the most as lawyers. 00:08:31.4100000 And so this is kind of where my title comes from today. It was doctor Jennifer Eberhardt, a Stanford professor in psychology. She did the examples that I just did for you, obviously using different people to a group of psychologists in a huge seminar on Stanford's campus. And the title, again was, if you have the brain, you have the bias. There's no way of escaping it because it is built into our brain, into that FFA portion of it. 00:08:58.9960000 And 90% of the time, like I said, it's unintentional. Unconscious stereotypes is just what we've been grown up with, what we've lived with, and what we're used to seeing, and we don't think any different. We don't know what's wrong until someone tells us it's wrong. And so we've really got to stop and think about those things and quit making the snap judgments about characteristics and pay attention to details that normally our brain would kind of shut down and shy away from because it's not lighting up with those neurons again. We've been exposed to this since childhood, through culture, religion, schools. 00:09:36.0780000 If you think about it back, maybe when you were growing up, if I say, who is primarily a grade school teacher, you may think of a female right off the top of your head. If I say, imagine a police officer, you most people would probably think of a male. If I say, think about your receptionist at work, is there a female? I've seen advertisements that says, you know, we are hiring a receptionist. Please make sure she. 00:10:01.4660000 And uses those pronouns or they reference that. It needs to be a female in there. These are things, again, that have been ingrained in us, those unconscious bias, those stereotypes. And I guarantee the person writing the advertisement writing the thing, or, you know, saying it isn't thinking about that, or they just don't know that they've done it, because since it's so unconscious, it's like second nature. So again, it doesn't equate to being racist or being any of those dirty words, but we need to be aware of it and we need to know how it affects us and our law practice. 00:10:34.9700000 So how does it affect attorneys? Most jurisdictions have what is known as rule 8.4 g. Now, not every jurisdiction has this. The model rules just recently adopted it, and I say recently kind of loosely, back in 2018. Before that, some jurisdictions had had their own version on the books, others had not. 00:10:54.7000000 If they did not have it on the books, and some jurisdictions still do not today, they usually go under 8.4 prejudicial to the administration of justice. Because who can define prejudicial to the administration of justice? Not very many people, the rule tries, but there is very broad categories. So even if your does not have 8.4 g specifically, you are going to get caught under 8.4 d, as in dog, prejudicial to the administration of justice. Because when you think about it, unconscious bias, stereotypes, discrimination can be prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:11:33.1220000 So that's why some jurisdictions have chose not to adopt a specific anti discrimination rule of ethics, and others jurisdictions have, because they want to be more clear and really define out what they mean. Most jurisdictions have followed the model rule, if they have adopted it, which states, an attorney shall not engage in conduct that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, or socioeconomic status related to the practice of law. This classification is way broader than title VII. There are more protected classes in the rules of professional conduct. Now, the one thing about this rule, which I have underlined and put in red font in front of you on the screen, is that it is related to the practice of law. 00:12:29.0620000 This is the only rule in our rules of professional conduct that only comes into play when you are practicing law. Every other rule in the rule of professional conduct book or the rules manual themselves applies 24 hours a day, seven days a week. This one does not. It only applies when you are practicing law. Now, the kicker is ABA formal opinion and our comments have told us what practicing law means. 00:12:56.5820000 And practicing law means quite a few things. It can mean running a law firm, dealing with your staff, working with clients, talking to opposing counsel when you're in the courtroom, when you're at that after hours cocktail party, that bar association event in, break in the kitchen. It is huge that practicing law related to the practice of law is not just talking to a client or your representation. It's everything that touches and pertains to the legal practice. So even though they narrow it, they don't really narrow it that much. 00:13:31.1900000 But again, it is in there. And you may think, well, why did they narrow this specific rule? Well, a lot of jurisdictions did not adopt this rule because they thought it infringed too much on attorney's freedom of speech. And so the jurisdictions that did adopted in the model rules put that limiting language in there that it only pertains to the practice of law. Cause they wanted to kind of curb the arguments that you're limiting, you know, personal freedom of speech of lawyers. 00:13:55.8720000 So that was kind of what they did. Does everyone agree with this rule? Absolutely not. Does everyone think that it has its place in time? Probably, but not everyone has adopted it. 00:14:06.4980000 So again, you need to check your specific jurisdiction to see what is there. Otherwise, check out 8.4 d, as in dog prejudicial to the administration of justice. On the screen in front of you. I did put, like I said, the classifications are way broader than title VII. You can see that here, just a side by side comparison of them. 00:14:25.1780000 This is that part of the definition of what discrimination can hold. It can include verbal physical conduct, which manifests into bias or prejudice towards people. It can be harassment, sexual harassment, regular harassment, derogatory, demeaning remarks, sexual physical conduct, or physical conduct in general. It's just a reasonably objectable, excuse me, objectionable standard, very vague, very broad, that can fit into those classifications when it comes to this rule. So it is something there to protect and something there to do that. 00:15:01.9300000 And as I said, since it is narrowed to the practice of law, comment four gives us kind of what that means a little bit. They don't narrow it too much for us, but they say it means representing clients, interacting with witnesses, co workers, court personnel and lawyers, operating or managing a law firm or law practice, participating in bar associations, social events. You can see it's still huge. We haven't really narrowed it down. This is our 24/7 you know, five, six days a week besides sleeping and eating dinner with our family. 00:15:33.0980000 But if a coworker's there or a client, then we're still in there. We haven't narrowed down it very much. So practicing law is very big. Like I said, it was met with some lack of optimism. They didn't think it was going to take on even John Gleeson, the ABA center of Professional Responsibility chair, was quoted as saying it would be mostly accurate to tell you that 8.4 g is dead in the water. 00:15:57.0800000 He didn't think a lot of jurisdictions would adopt it. Not everyone has. The majority have, but it's a slight majority just right over that line. Not the great team majority with only a few outliers. So again, check your specific jurisdiction. 00:16:14.1600000 So where in business law firms, corporate world does, can a lawyer violate 8.4 g? We're going to go over some areas, we can do this. We're going to look outside of just talking with a client or, you know, litigating a case in court. We can violate this in recruitment of new attorneys and staff, screening and hiring new attorneys and staff, work allocation and promotion lawyers and non lawyers, discharging lawyers and non lawyers, interactions with co workers, attendance at work related social events, correspondence with employees and third parties. We can see it in company policies, how they're implemented. 00:16:52.7280000 It may not be blatant on their face, but through implementation we can maybe see it. We also want to work to make sure we have policies to combat these areas and comply with rule 8.4 g. We can also see it in work advice, decisions and choices we make. We're going to go through some of these, especially the recruitment and screening and hiring a little bit, a little more in detail, because I found some nice advertisements. Not all of them are for law firms, but some advertisements where we're going to see how people just don't stop, maybe use their brain, or that FFA is an overdrive. 00:17:28.2110000 They're used to a stereotype or an unconscious bias, and it just comes through in that recruitment ad that is posted in the newspaper, on tv, or wherever you post it for hiring. So recruitment is one of the first big areas. And besides just the posting itself that goes out, someone has to write that. That's normally an HR, a hiring manager, or someone like that. So that is actually their biases or unconscious or conscious coming through. 00:17:57.0200000 And they always need to have those checks and balances. Have someone else review it, have a team review it, don't send it out the door until it's been reviewed. But even in addition to that, those hiring managers that get in the resumes during that recruitment phase have their own biases. And what's the first thing we see on a resume? A name. 00:18:19.4800000 Do certain names have certain ethnic connotations? Absolutely. Can you tell the gender sometimes by a name? Absolutely. Or you think you can. 00:18:31.8800000 And so then when you read the name, when you see that resume, you've already formed a picture of the person in your head, already kind of have a feel like if they give you a good vibe or a bad vibe or no vibe at all, and you've just stereotyped them into a classification without even knowing it, you've already put an image. So if they show up and give the opposite image or different than what's in your head, you're gonna be like, oh, that's not what I was expecting. Well, what were you expecting? You shouldn't have been expecting anything. And so hiring manager them have their own biases, unconscious and conscious as well. 00:19:10.4820000 So we have to start thinking about those things and thinking how do we train them not to? Can we do certain steps to alleviate some of this in that process? One of the things during recruitment is for those resumes is doing blind resumes. This means you hire an outside, independent third party company. Or maybe if you have to do it in house, just ask it to one person. 00:19:33.7400000 That person, when they get the resumes in or as they come in, they're given a number, the name is removed. Why do we remove the name? Because it has those ethnic connotations, gender, different things like that. And it helps us from stop forming an image fully. Then you review the resumes, the hiring manager reviews them with just the number, decides who they want to bring and meet in person. 00:19:56.5900000 Then when they meet them in person, that's when they get to know the name. It's a way to kind of stop some of it. Now obviously, once they meet them and they hear the name and then they can, they start to form those things all over again. But maybe it will stop some of it to where we're throwing resumes aside just because we get the, eh, feeling, because of some stereotype or bias we've held. So you start to see it in recruitment training, thinking outside the box of how to alleviate it from the process. 00:20:24.1000000 Those things are vitally important for it. Now let's look at some job postings. Like I said, I found some job postings that have bias, prejudice, conscious, unconscious stereotypes scattered throughout them. And some of these are funny when you think about it. Some of them are serious. 00:20:41.7300000 All of these we should not do though. So just keep it, think of it that way. We should not do these, but from different perspectives, different viewpoints. So this first one here is for a full service web design company specializing in industrial and commercial clientele. It says at the bottom there, you know, there's going to be different things like knowledge of social media, talent, grammar, spelling, you know, all those different services making blog posts. 00:21:05.2420000 But it says, please note that the person requires filling in the responsibilities of a receptionist, so female candidates are preferred. That's a stereotype. Why can't we have another gender? Why can't someone else do it? Obviously, whoever wrote this ad believes or thought that females should do more the responsibilities of receptionist. 00:21:31.1380000 Now you may think, why that's so archaic, that's so xyz, but I'm going to challenge you and play devil's advocate for just a moment. Think about when you call a company, corporation, or law firm. If you call and say, hi, I'm so and so, and you're met with a really gross, deep sounding voice, are you going to get that warm and fuzzy feeling about the company? Or do you want the other person on the other line to be like, oh, you're so sweet, honey, let me help you out. That type of thing. 00:22:00.5640000 Now, I'm not saying that can't come from any gender, but stereotypically, what people believe is that needs to come from a female and have that soft sounding voice, have those soft sounding way about them to get more people to think, oh, reminds me of my grandma. I want to work here. I want to go here. I want to use their business. And so that is where sometimes you see that. 00:22:21.3800000 Now, the other reason people think that females should be receptionist, just historically, that's how it's been. That is, you know, back in the 1940s, 1950s, what you normally saw, and then even past that. But we've got to start stepping out of those gender roles, those unconscious biases, those stereotypes, and we need to really make sure they're not in our recruitment advertisements for any type of position. This is another one. This one's kind of concerning. 00:22:48.6300000 Whoever applied to this, I want to talk to them. So, document processor, female, not above, 29 and single. I don't know what single has to do with being processing documents and accuracy and numbers and word and excel operations. And I don't know why you have to be 29 or younger either, but all right, accounting assistant, same thing. Female accounting graduate, county graduate. 00:23:13.0360000 I'll give them 21 to 28. Why young? Why are we having some age potential discrimination come through here? Single again, I would not apply teeth on one of those. You may. 00:23:23.4200000 That's your choice. But again, you can see the different types of discrimination, the stereotypes coming through, or just a creepy boss. The other side, we have an executive driver, male, 30 to 35 years old. Again, age, gender. Why can't a female or another gender drive a truck or drive a car or be an executive driver? 00:23:47.8420000 I can wear a suit. I can put on a tie. I can do all those things. And so we have to watch our language in our advertisements, in our postings. This is another one. 00:23:57.5620000 Customer service. Fun young team. I'm young. Some of you may think I'm old. Some of you may think I'm young. 00:24:04.0740000 And I may say, think or say you know, similar things about you. I don't. But why do we need a fun young team? And why is that part of the qualifications? Or why is that even part of the advertisement for the job? 00:24:18.9300000 So watching those adjectives, sometimes age can really come into play. And age discrimination is one not a lot of people think about as much anymore. This is one, actually, that was here in Indianapolis, Indiana. They are hiring a high energy bartender at Soho Bistro lounge, which is a food beverage lounge in Indianapolis. Must have experience. 00:24:42.1520000 And if you don't have experience, you experience. You must be attractive, reliable, thin, and have a great personality. And maybe we can train you. Compensation is competitive, negotiable. There are no mask or vaccine mandates. 00:25:00.3440000 This is an anti woke business. There are four bars, two inside, one on the enclosed deck, one on the outside path. Liking drugs is okay, but no addictions, please. And no using drugs at work. Victimless crimes are okay. 00:25:16.1440000 Uniform is all white or all black. Please cultivate class. Either keep your own tips or tip. Sharing is voluntary. Your choice. 00:25:26.9600000 Think to yourself, and I know this is not the legal industry, but you can maybe see parallels of where we could have some downsides in the legal industry if this was for a job too, maybe for a non attorney. What is wrong with this ad? There are several things wrong with this ad, and there's several alarming things on wrong with it as well. So again, we need to look at what we post. Attractive, reliable, thin, great personality, probably not those in there, some of it not illegal, not discrimination, not, you know, anything against those, but just maybe poor taste too when it comes to it. 00:26:07.8500000 Another one here too. This is for a desktop administrator. If you see the red area there, it said, it's nice being one of the good guys. We have to watch our gender pronouns, especially in society today and in the culture, and just inclusivity and DEI initiatives. Gender pronouns. 00:26:28.0180000 We really need to watch and use more neutral ones when we're posting different types of jobs and advertisements, whether it be legal or non legal, in the legal profession or any profession, we've got to be very careful with our wording and phraseology. This one here too. We are particularly interested in receiving applications from candidates who identify as female. I get maybe what they're trying to go for here with a DeI diversity initiative, potentially. I don't know if that's the case, but this is not the right way to go about that. 00:27:00.4140000 And so we really, again have to watch what we put in our advertisements for jobs, and if it's going to violate rule 8.4 g or any other rule or law, we've got to watch that as well. Assistant to the chairman, this is a big one for a while that you started seeing on social media and tick tock people being all up in arms about instead of saying chairperson, they said chairman or chairwoman. And a lot of people come back playing that devil's advocate, saying, well, you know, it's always been chairman. It's not a gender thing, it's just the name of the position. So that can cut both ways on both arguments. 00:27:37.1760000 But again, this is something I'm flagging just because I've seen it in social media where people have picked up on it and been very offended by it. And so we've got to watch again the pronoun usage and different things in those areas. Here's another one seeking grumpy front developer who thinks they're changing too much. He learned this is, again, this person's calling him out again. Pound hack. 00:28:03.5980000 Diversity, unconscious bias because the pronoun big thing, big thing. We've got to watch. Have HR, have anyone, anything you post, double check. Persons with young children need not apply. Okay. 00:28:19.1900000 Why? I don't know. This could be pregnancy type of discrimination. This could be, you know, gender discrimination. This could be several different things that could come through for having that. 00:28:29.0460000 Now, this is in Dublin, the county Dublin. Again, I search everywhere for things. Store requires no Indians or Asians, please. Must speak English. English can be a qualification sometimes. 00:28:41.2540000 If it is obviously customer facing, they have to understand the language to do the job. But if they don't have to necessarily understand the language to do the job, and it's more labor intensive, then sometimes the speaking requirement and the language is not a valid requirement. It's only being used to weed out certain classes of people and discriminate. So you have to look at the job, the job functions, and what's required, and not now. The story requires no Indians or asian police. 00:29:05.2000000 That's probably going to be discrimination because it is cleaning, cleaning a supermarket at night and morning work. Why can't Indians or Asians clean? I, as a caucasian American, can, so why can't they? So again, you've got to look for those different things when it comes in english teacher part time with a loving, kind hearted personality, teaching experience and caucasian race can never again, ever, ever be a classification for a job. Even if it's customer preference, it does not matter. 00:29:36.3140000 We can never discriminate based on race. You'll violate 8.4 g and other laws probably every single time. Same here. We request no dark skinned indian or african applicants apply for this role. They put, as per client request, trying to assuage their guilt for putting that in there. 00:29:54.0980000 But again, client preference does not make this okay. You can never discriminate based on race, and so you've got to think about those things as well. This one I find. I cannot find necessarily any legal or 8.4 g violations of this one, but I just kind of find it funny, especially from a lawyer standpoint and just, you know, working with different types of employees in different areas. Please do not apply if you oversleep. 00:30:20.0180000 Have no alarm clock, have no car, have court, often, have no babysitter every day. Have to give your friends rides to work later than work actually starts experience flat tires every week. Have to hold on to your cell phone all day or become an expert at your job with no need to learn or take advice after the first day. Must be able to talk and work at the same time. Must be able to remember to come back to work after lunch. 00:30:44.5100000 Should not expect gold stars or purple or, excuse me, should not expect purple ribbons or gold stars for showing up to work on time. How many of you, and I wish I could take a show of hands, but I can't. Want to put this in your next advertisement for any type of staff position or attorney position that you can think of. Some of you may be chuckling to yourself, some of you may think, yeah, I'm going to use it. And some of you may think, yeah, I want to, but I'm not going to raise my hand. 00:31:08.9980000 This is something we've all probably been burned at some time or have different feelings about different areas, and this person voiced it, but when you really get down to it, is there discrimination, unconscious bias, stereotype here? The only thing maybe I could potentially see is about the babysitter saying, no, if you have kids, don't apply. So you can maybe roundabout get it that way too. But again, I don't know. There's just, there's a lot going on there and it could touch on it. 00:31:39.5280000 It could not. But something to consider, too. If you are going to go off or set certain qualifications, make sure you don't have those stereotypes or biases in there. Moving on to just the resume. Like I said, names say a lot. 00:31:52.4680000 If I ask you, which I know you're not going to do today, we're not live or in person, I can't do as many group activities, but if this is something you wanted to train your hiring managers on, this is an exercise. I would recommend you give them a list of names right here. As you can see on the right hand side of your screen, the names have different ethnic soundings. Some are going to sound more being from the caucasian race, some more, the african american race, some more, hispanic, asian, different races, different nationalities. So you have those, you list them out. 00:32:24.0120000 You know, you can do 910, 20, however many you want to do. Then on the other side, you give them jobs. You vary jobs from, you know, low income, middle class, lower class all the way up to, you know, CEO, maybe president of the United States. And then you don't tell them anything else. You just tell them all the people on the right have the same qualifications as everyone else on the right. 00:32:43.2200000 So they're all resumes are identical. The only thing different is their name. Now they've got to take those names and put them in jobs. And you may think, well, that's dumb. How do they know which job to put them in? 00:32:53.2940000 You'd be surprised. A lot of people, and I do this with all my classes that I teach, put Linda Allen, sometimes Betty Jones as the stay at home parent or teacher 90% of the time. A lot of people put Michael Cooley as a doctor. CEO usually goes to Brad Williams, John Smith, about 80, 90% of the time. Why do you think that is? 00:33:20.4100000 Because that's what they're used to seeing. Strong name, maybe caucasian, maybe african american. You see them in that position most often in society. So your brain automatically connects the two. People will use their unconscious bias and stereotypes to do this exercise without even realizing it. 00:33:37.7060000 And then after that, you've had them do it quietly. They compare with other people and you are going to see similarities. And it is shocking to see those similarities. I did see a question come in. Would you recommend putting your birth date on a resume? 00:33:53.0340000 I would not, because then that's going to lead to them knowing your age. If you want them to know your age, then okay. But if they see your 60 and you're applying for a job and they're like, oh, my gosh, we don't want to train that person for them just to leave in five or seven years. That's where it could happen. And that could be something you never know that they did because it's going to be, if it's on your resume, they'll just say, well, we didn't pick you for an interview. 00:34:19.3380000 They're not going to say it's because we saw your birthday or it's because of your age. They're going to use a neutral thing. And so having your birthday on there can hurt you in a lot of ways. Same thing with having your picture on there. For instance, if you have a name that sounds more like one gender and you're another gender and then you have your picture. 00:34:37.7380000 That could throw a mind for a loop or they could stereotype you one way or another. And so a lot of people or young people or, you know, the new generations want to put their picture on their resumes because they think it gives them a leg up. Sometimes it can hurt you. So you, because that's like when we take off that name, we'd have to take off that picture. And if they don't have blind resume testing, then it's another issue. 00:35:00.3980000 The other thing that's coming out here too, I'll just talk about for a little bit, is there is AI resume processing wherever they run their applicant's resume through an AI program, the AI program scans it for certain buzzwords or certain things and then it gives a reading on how qualified that person is to the job description. So if the resume doesn't have those buzzwords, AI doesn't pick it up. If AI doesn't pick it up and the employer only, you know, uses what it picks up, then you're not going to get selected. The other thing too is it's been proven that AI holds bias and prejudice itself because it's only as good as those who program it. So the programmer has bias. 00:35:43.1320000 We all do. If we have a brain, we have a bias, then that software is going to have one. And so then it's going to maybe pick out or flag more caucasian sounding names or, you know, non ethnic sounding names and then the other ones where it's like, is that even a name? You know, the weird spelling, the different things or, you know, just the uniqueness of names and different cultures, it's not going to pick it up and so it's going to filter out that resume. And so you, even if you use those AI filters for resumes, you may see some bias conscious and unconscious in those as well, that we have to, you know, consider, we had another question about graduation dates. 00:36:21.6200000 Again, graduation dates, some people have opted to take them off because again, it could show your age. With graduation dates, though, I have noticed that hiring employers or hiring managers, yes, they see them there. And if they can see a trend, you know, like from college, you went straight into grad school and on up. If they see a gap, they probably know you're older. But again, a lot of people go to college later in life now too. 00:36:44.7660000 So that's not always as definitive as the birthday. Still can be risky, still can be, you know, something you may consider taking off if you're worried about an age discrimination. But again, that's going to be a choice. Not as bad as the birthday, because the birthday is a tall tale sign of how old you are. The graduation dates, yes, it gives a roundabout, but not an exact one. 00:37:07.0720000 And again, we have so many non traditional students anymore where they didn't go straight from high school to college to grad school. And so you can't always trust those dates either to try to determine age in that sense of it. Some other things. Like I said, going back, if you have that brain, you have a bias. We see that in this name thing. 00:37:26.1300000 If you did this exercise with your staff, your company, you would see those coming through. And it may be as simple as they put all females in the teacher role, all females in the receptionist role. Police officer was a male. You're going to see the stereotypical trends that come through. You're going to have outliers, you're not going to have 100%, but again, you're going to see the trends come through. 00:37:48.5460000 And it goes back to that fafa, unconscious bias. If you have a brain, you have a bias. It's ingrained in us since we were kids. Social media reinforces it with its images, its news, its media, TikTok, Instagram, ex, formerly known as Twitter, all of those things reinforce the FFA saying, you're right, you're right. This is scary different. 00:38:11.9960000 I don't want it because they keep showing us them. It keeps showing us these images. And so we've really got to work against it and we've got to think about it statistically. These are just some statistics. Real quick. 00:38:24.9680000 In a canadian study, equally qualified applicants with asian names, broad category, 28% less likely to score an interview in the canadian market than Anglo caucasian sounding names like Greg and Emily. Those types of ones. So you can see it through other countries too. And some other ones too. Here. 00:38:45.3000000 Sweeten did a study in 2007, white sounding names got five more, excuse me, 50% more callbacks than Middle eastern names. United States, northwestern did a study across countries regarding discrimination and hiring. No country ever discriminated more against white individuals. We always discriminated more against our minority classes. 83%. 00:39:08.1320000 France was the highest. Germany was the lowest. We were right in the middle at 33%. Discrimination. That figure shocked me. 00:39:14.9560000 I was like, oh my gosh, we're not higher than that, but we're not the highest country discriminating and employment practices and hiring practices. We're kind of smack dab in the middle, which is kind of interesting for that. Boston, Chicago have done different types of seminars or different types of things regarding this and so you can see those in there as well, that there is discrimination in those practices and that, you know, people with more caucasian sounding names get less callbacks or, excuse me, more callbacks than people with, you know, african american or minority sounding names. So you really have to look at those employment discrimination practices and those different things when it comes to that. Some other things just to consider here, too. 00:40:08.2680000 The top ten companies that have been held to be the most diverse companies. This is a 2020 statistic. Marriott International, Hilton, Eli Lillian Company, ADP, Accenture, Comcast, NBC Universal, Abbott, TIAA, Toyota Motor. These have been named the biggest companies with the most diversity in a 2020 statistic. Now, obviously that changes from year to year and we're going to see different companies come in and off that list. 00:40:38.8880000 But again, these were the ones from 2020. We can also see discrimination and bias unconscious, conscious in our screening and hiring practices. Require high school diploma. Sometimes that can be discrimination in and of itself, because if you think about it, if you have a job where you have to move bricks from here to here, why do I need a high school diploma? But sometimes people require them. 00:41:04.4320000 Or if you need someone just to answer the phones and say, hi, how can I route your call? Do you need a high school diploma to do that? That could be the job of a receptionist. Or if you have someone working in your mail room or filing room, do they need a high school diploma? Do you need to give them an aptitude test? 00:41:21.0960000 Do you need to do those different things? If you're putting these qualifications on those types of positions where it's not really a qualification of the job, it could be because you're unconsciously or consciously trying to discriminate out or weed out certain groups of people. So you've got to look at to your screening and hiring processes when it comes to, you know, what you're doing and what you're requiring for different areas. Another exercise which I do recommend doing, if you're going to do any training internally in your firm, or if you work for a business as an in house counsel, this is one to that leads into the discussion where we can have discrimination in promotions or discrimination in job allocations or in work allocations. So I would challenge you again. 00:42:10.2520000 We're not going to do it fully here today, but you can, if you want, list five to ten people you trust, your inner circle, the ones that you would take your diary, open it up and let them read it. You're going to tell them your deepest, darkest things, let them into your personal space, have them over, maybe give them a key to your house. Five to ten people, not your family. That's the kicker. Not your family. 00:42:32.1440000 Now, if you can't give five to ten, because I can't. I can only give probably two or three. That's okay, too. Just give those two or three. But it has to be friends, coworkers, classmates, not your family. 00:42:44 Now, for each of those people you put on that list, start to identify their gender, race, ethnicity, age, sexual orientation, education, disability status. Do they have a disability or nothing? Those identifying immutable characteristics, start to list those down. Once you list those out, ask yourself, are those the same characteristics as you have? Are they all caucasian? 00:43:10.6780000 Are they all female, male? Another gender? Do they all have around the same age? All have the same sexual orientation? Do it for this inner circle. 00:43:22.1020000 Now, you may think, why are we doing this? I'll tell you here in just a second. But once you get that, too, now go to the next circle. This is the ones where you're going to be comfy on your front yard. This middle ring, level two. 00:43:33.4640000 You're going to say, come over for a barbecue. Come over with a group of friends for dinner. I'll meet you at a restaurant. They're not in your diary. You're not giving them key. 00:43:41.8800000 You're not letting them into your bedroom or your secret spaces. But they're more than an acquaintance. But they're not the best. Now list out those characteristics again for that group of people. Gender, race, age, sexual orientation, education, those immutable characteristics. 00:44:01.4000000 Are they the same and similar to you, or did it get a little broader? Did it get a little more diverse? Go out to your next level comfort zone. Hi, how are you doing that acquaintance level? List out the five to ten people. 00:44:14.2000000 I guarantee we can list out five to ten people in that category and probably level two, too. Then list out again their gender, race, age. You get the picture. Now, are they most similar to you or not? Do we have a little more diversity? 00:44:29.7560000 Do we have a little bigger ring? And you probably do. Now, the problem with this is those friends, coworkers, because these aren't our family members. These are friends, coworkers, classmates. And if they're coworkers or if there's someone you are supervising that is in that inner circle or in that middle circle, you are more likely to put more time and attention into them because you want to. 00:44:53.9740000 You want to foster that relationship. You want to move that person forward and see them do great things. You may even see yourself in them if they're in that level one. And when they do good. You feel that pride, that beaming like you've done something great, and so you put more time and energy into them over everyone else you're supposed to be supervising and mentoring over anyone else in the company or firm. 00:45:18.2400000 You've just created a bias towards them, unconscious. You've just created almost a favoritism or nepotism towards them, probably unconscious. But when it comes time to that promotion, to getting the recommendations to move into partnership path or to move up in a position, and that person is the person up for it and you have a say, or you're the deciding person, or you're on that partner management committee, who are you going to vote for? The acquaintance level three that did just as hard as work or the inner circle trust level one coworker who's just like you? I'll let you answer that for yourself because the answers could go either way. 00:46:03.2700000 But when you think about that, you can see if everyone chose the inner circle, that person and those characteristics of our inner circle are usually most like us. About 90% of the time when I pull my students that they're just like the person that's writing it, you start to see discrimination and promotion and work allocation. Because if you are over those people, you're managing them, then that's who you're going to promote, that's who you want to foster the relationship with, that's who you want to see. Move ahead and that's where you're going to get it. And so this is unconscious. 00:46:38.0020000 Affinity biases biases managers are more likely to spend more time informing and contributing to teammates that they feel more in the inner circle or even the level two, not the level three. The less affinity they have to someone that level three, they're not going to put much into them. They don't care if they stay or go, they're an acquaintance. They'll say, oh, I used to work with them. They were so nice. 00:46:59.0700000 I talked to them in the lunchroom once and then not give it a second thought. So you're going to see it throughout there too. Again, unconscious, if any president, then you're going to promote those, support them other you will not. We can also see unconscious bias and discrimination through discharge as well. Layoff policies rely on seniority status that can be a type of discrimination. 00:47:22.4300000 Managers are less likely to discharge individuals that are in those level one, level two categories that affinity with them. So you've got to watch out for that as well if there's not a seniority. Because if a manager like, say, you were for a managing partner and you had to cut some fat or, you know, cut some associates or that, because again, maybe it's a recession, maybe it's something else. Who are you going to cut? Your level one closest friends that you form bonds with in the office or your level three acquaintances. 00:47:51.6820000 Both are great. Both have the same qualifications. Which one's going? Probably the level three. So you've got to look at those areas as well too. 00:48:00.2100000 So interactions with coworkers, and this is another category where we can see it too. So we're going to see not just in the hiring process, promotion, demotion, discharge. We can see it through other interactions too with coworkers where bias, unconscious, conscious can come through. So we're going to look at some case examples. These are real life lawyers that have gone wrong, some terribly wrong. 00:48:23.3500000 First one, this would have been under 8.4 g. This is a sexual discrimination harassment type of lawsuit that would come through or, you know, obviously not lawsuit, but professional rules of conduct violation. This is an attorney that engaged in sexual behavior with current client has created a hostile work environment. Actually hired the person to submitted to the unwanted advances he eventually got turned in for. Sexual harassment, sexual behavior prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:48:55.0460000 8.4 g violation. So many things wrong with this. 1.8, you know, no sex with a client. All of those things can come through, but this would also trigger that 8.4 g in the workplace as well. This one too sought sexual favors from clients for discounted fees to clients and various sexual acts. 00:49:14.5600000 Sexual harassment 8.4 g. Eight 4d prejudicial to the administration of justice. And then you could also have, again, no sex with clients. And so those are ones that you need to look at there as well. Moving on to the next one. 00:49:30.4640000 This is Mister Abran. He represented, excuse Abrams. He represented a married couple that had a contract lawsuit against a former builder. He formed a very negative opinion about the judge, told his clients about the opinion. He felt the judge was bullied as a child due to the judge's perceived sexual orientation. 00:49:49.4300000 He stated that in emails to his clients how, you know, the judge probably got beat up as a kid, that, you know, derogatory slurs towards him. And the clients fired the lawyer. I mean, the lawyer was saying this to the clients about the judge presiding over their case. Fire the clients, fired the lawyer, reported him to the disciplinary commission, rightfully so. In 2028.4 g, violation 8.4 d, prejudicial administration of justice. 00:50:16.8500000 This is bias discrimination. We do not do this. And so we need to remember those things as well. This is one which is kind of alarming too, because if you remember 8.4 g, says while practicing law. So this attorney called back. 00:50:33.9920000 A telemarketer picked up the phone, a telemarketer card claiming to be her husband's attorney. She just put herself into the definition of practicing law. While on the phone with the telemarketer, she asked the representative he was gay or sweet because she thought he had a male sounding. That thought the male sounding had a feminine sounding voice when he was really male. She got turned in for that conduct, public reprimand in Indiana. 00:50:57.9600000 This is another one, too. We had an attorney who just decided to go off in an email one day, secretary, assistant of opposing counsel, emailed over trying to set up a meeting between the two attorneys. The opposing counsel's response was to the secretary's request just to schedule a meeting. I know you must do your boss's bidding at his, but I'm here to tell you that I am neither you or his. And then he said a very derogatory word. 00:51:25.6320000 You do not tell me what to do. You ask if you ever act like this again. It's the last time I give any thought to your existence. Do we understand each other? This was a 30 day suspension without automatic reinstatement. 00:51:37.3160000 There is bias, there is prejudice here. There is prejudicial to the administration of justice, all the things there. Indiana has had 8.4 g on the books for quite some time, and this is probably what it came across. So another example of what not to do. Moving on to a different one. 00:52:00.1340000 This is actually one you can google. This is a more recent one. This was in a deposition. Defense counsel decided it was okay to bend over and twerk in front of opposing counsel, which means bending over, putting your hands on the ground, and shaking your butt up and down. And as he was doing this, he said the unfortunate phrase of do you want to blank me? 00:52:21.1580000 And, you know, made derogatory comments about the opposing counsel's ponytail, haircuts, those different things. This was described as lavacious gyrating of the lower, fleshy extremities in a court brief, which was very probably chat GPT language at that point. I'm just going to say that whoever came up with that phrase filed sanctions. Monetary defense counsel. Unfortunately, when responding to the brief about the sanctions, put, let's put this in the rearview mirror. 00:52:52.1020000 Put this behind us. Probably the wrong language when the claim is bending over and shaking your rear end at your opposing counsel. Judge issued no sanctions on the case. Thought the attorney had suffered enough because the national attention attorney was terminated from the case. Texas does not have 8.4 g on the books. 00:53:09.9740000 It does have prejudicial to the administration of justice, though. 8.044, which is what would be under this. This is another one too. Deposition. Depositions team to bring out the worst in people. 00:53:23.4300000 This was opposing counsel got so frustrated with opposing counsel across the table from her that she stopped the deposition. She grabbed the table in front of her, stuck her head underneath it. Opposing counsel goes, what are you doing? Her response was, I'm checking. I'm looking to see if there's anything between your legs. 00:53:45 Not the appropriate response for deposition, not the appropriate conduct for deposition. She later apologized for her conduct and said that she lost her composure due to the chronically and persistently condescending behavior of opposing counsel. This could be an 8.4 g violation if Connecticut have it, but if not prejudicial to the administration of justice. 8.4. We see cases here too, and I know we are winding down on our last five minutes on top on race. 00:54:15.1360000 This is one where we someone was referred to in court as the black guy, the black man. The man's race was irrelevant to the case. It was just meant to be racial or condescending. Public reprimanded in Indiana in 2005. We never bring up race, ethnicity, anything like that unless it's pertinent to the case. 00:54:32.9680000 We need to remember that in our conduct and what we do. This is one too, regarding citizenship and immigration. In a child support case, there was repeated disparaging references that the mother was not a us citizen and that was receiving services at no charge. The fact, again, was irrelevant in just a dig or, you know, having that stereotype or trying to breed that stereotype to the court to win more favor. Public reprimand again in Indiana, I would just say Indiana, let's do better. 00:55:04.6800000 So this is another case here too. You can see on your screen we have references like, stupid idiot little girl, be quiet, little girl. We bring in religion in the last one. Attorneys were sanctioned in each of these. Some suspension, some reprimands. 00:55:19.1120000 Again, we've got to watch that bias, the stereotypes that conduct when it comes to it, where we mainly see it, profanity and emails, mouthing off to their attorneys. You think to yourself, I'm just joking around. Who could ever take me seriously? You never know how someone perceives something and it's not based on your intention. It's based on the perception of the person hearing it. 00:55:41.9500000 And it may not be the person directly across from you you're talking to, but someone else in the room that overhears it and perceives it in that negative fashion. And it is never, ever funny when it is exhibit a in an HR complaint, in a lawsuit, or at your disciplinary commission proceeding. If it is going to. If you want it blown up on a poster board as exhibit a and you're going to be proud of it, then by golly, do it. If you're not going to be proud of it as exhibit a on a poster board, I wouldn't be doing so. 00:56:11.7560000 Those are the things we need to think about. There was a case too, which is the last thing we'll talk about here, where racism required a new trial. This is because the defendant proved that his counsel was racist towards him based on derogatory comments, based on racial innuendos that the attorney made to his client during and after the trial. And it led the judge to believe that the trial was so prejudiced and that it was ineffective assistance of counsel because he didn't feel the counsel was truly advocating for the client because he held such bias and stereotype against him. And so it got a murder trial basically reversed and it had to be all done again because of ineffective a census of counsel. 00:56:56.5720000 So if you let it breed or bleed that much into your practice, it can have detrimental effects like that on cases, on clients. Freedom, non freedom. Think about the victim. If this person really was guilty, what that just did to it all. Because if your bias and stereotype went unchecked or was so unconscious that you didn't know that, if you have a brain, you have a bias. 00:57:21.4700000 So we've got to constantly think about these things. Always train your staff, get your own education. Take those exercises I've stated here today and use them at the forefront of your mind. So I thank you for attending and please let me know if you have any questions and hopefully you have a great rest of your day.