[Course Name] 00:00:01 Hello everyone, and welcome to today's presentation of attorney advertising. But today is attorney advertising. We're going to talk about the good, the bad, and some people's mess ups on some attorney advertisements that I found over the years and some other examples throughout the seminar here today. We may laugh a little bit, we may maybe not pay attention if you're sitting there on your own Zoom call, but we are going to try to have some fun with attorney advertising and ethics. And so let's kind of get started here just a little bit about myself. 00:00:33.3580000 I'm an assistant clinical professor of business law and ethics at IU Kelley School of Business. I teach commercial law and business ethics as well as professional responsibility over at the Robert H. McKinney School of Law. And I've also taught torts before, so you can say I've taught quite a few different subjects. And one of those concentrations as obvious is the ethics. 00:00:56.3200000 In addition to that, I am also an assistant. Excuse me, I'm also an attorney with Scopolito's, Garvin, Light, Hanson and fury here in Indianapolis, Indiana, where I practice conflicts and ethics law for the law firm as an in house counsel. So again, ethics is my everyday, all day teaching and practicing. And so if you have any questions regarding attorney advertising or ethics, just in general, my contact information is below and I'd be happy to assist you with any questions you may have. So let's get started here today. 00:01:30.1620000 Let's look at some statistics. Now, you may think to yourself too about your specific law firm or law firms in your locality and where you're located. But about 81% of lawyers use social media, and I guarantee that percentage keeps going up year to year. And from time to time. About 77% of respondents reported that their firms maintain a social media presence too. 00:01:54.5300000 So it's not just the lawyers, but firms are now gaining a social media presence, whether that be through online, just advertising on Facebook or LinkedIn, all the way to TikToks and different Instagram accounts. For some law firms too, really getting into that social media buzz and craze and reaching those younger generations and reaching the people who are fully on social networking and social media. 93% of attorneys ages 40 to 49 also have that personal presence, which is kind of a good odd statistic about 93, because you would think more, it's normally the lower generation or the younger generation, but it is also the older generations that are still having that personal presence on social media. About 90% of attorneys 40 and under have that social media presence too. So that's even a lower statistic there as well. 00:02:51.3700000 So need to make sure we look at that. And then two, we have 90% of lawyers have LinkedIn profiles. Now think to yourself, do you have a LinkedIn profile? And what does that look like? Do you advertise your law firm on it? 00:03:07.6180000 Do you not advertise your law firm on it? Is it just a personal type of law firm account? What is it that you have for your LinkedIn? And then 40% of lawyers have a Facebook profile, 26% have about Twitter accounts. And there's not a tick tock statistic in here. 00:03:26.9760000 But I can tell you that probably about 40, 30% to 40% of lawyers have tick tock accounts and other social media accounts for their law firms and for their practice. So social media is kind of the new way to advertise and should be part of your marketing plan. If you're going to have a modern business plan, it really does need to include online advertising and social media. It is no longer just print ads, it's no longer just billboards or those commercials after the 06:00 news. It is Instagram, it is YouTube, it is Facebook, it is LinkedIn, it is all of those areas is where you're really going to attract and have the most traction when it comes to attorney advertising. 00:04:14.0400000 I can't tell you the last time I ordered a paper newspaper, everything's online, or even a magazine subscription, or the back of the yellow pages or the white pages, you know, the phone book, we don't have those anymore. So now the advertising and how we advertise has to shift. But we always have to remember, too, that the rules of professional conduct are still the same. There's not a lot of tweaks in them in regarding attorney advertising. So we need to take them and make them adaptable to the social media and the online presence that we now have to have when we're advertising for our legal services, which can be a challenge. 00:04:52.7200000 It can be a challenge, especially to older generations, because they think it's not advertising. This is my personal page. While your personal page can be transformed pretty quickly into attorney advertising, if you're listing wins and losses, if you're advertising your law firm to get people to come to your practice, whether it be, hey, come see me or hire me, or just listen to the name, if it's for that pecuniary gain, which we'll see in the rules, it can be attorney advertising, even if it's on a personal profile or a personal social media page. So we really have to watch what we're posting and the content we're posting. Because if it is deemed attorney advertising, guess what? 00:05:36.6180000 All the attorney advertising rules apply to it. This means you have to keep it for a certain period of time. You have to do certain disclosures and make sure it holds certain content in certain jurisdictions. All of those things will apply. Now, your mind may be going crazy if you don't like social media or use it. 00:05:56.4520000 And you can hire marketing managers and advertising managers to help manage your online presence for your firm and yourself as an attorney. Now, obviously this would need to have a budget or you need to designate someone in the office for it that you already have in the office. But again, you can have that online presence as well. So just make sure you kind of look at these things in a business management role when you are doing your business and marketing plan. And let's get into some of the different rules and some of the aspects. 00:06:29.7260000 Just have attorney advertising. Some of the rules that we really need to consider when we're doing attorney advertising, there's actually quite a few of them, but the first one is rule 1.1 competence. Rule 1.1 requires competent representation by attorneys to their clients. It means keeping abreast with the changes in the law and practice, including the benefits and burdens and risk of technology. This can also mean I advertising. 00:06:58.1600000 We've got to stay competent and how online presence and technology can affect us in all the rules of professional conduct, because advertising is part of our practice. If you read the comments, particularly comment six to rule 1.1, it does talk about technology specifically. Now, does it say social media and list out advertising? No, nothing by name, but that's what it's getting at. These rules are written broadly, so they can include almost anything, and that's what competence is. 00:07:32.4460000 So if you think, I don't need to learn this, I'm going to retire in two to three years or five years, you do need to learn it. It's relevant to the practice and you're still practicing. So competence and knowing the Internet lingo, knowing how this affects your practice and your marketing and your clients too, even when it comes to, you know, discovery purposes, whole nother seminar on that, you start to understand this different lingo and what it means. So advertising and social media, some states have even modified their rules, especially rule 1.1. That comment fix, or even into the advertising rules specifically, which encompass 7.1 to 7.47.5, is usually naming a law firm, which can be advertising too, if trade names are allowed. 00:08:17.8480000 But that's where you're going to span the big crux of the advertising rules within those, and some states have modified them to, say, electronic communications and just not technology. Or they've included specific acceptable forms of advertisements and social media. So you always need to check your local specific jurisdictional rules of professional conduct and not just rely on the main model rules, because the model rules, while they're there as a model, some jurisdictions have adopted them in whole, some have changed them in part, some have completely disregarded them. So always check your local rules. For instance, in Indiana, rule 7.2. 00:09:02.5700000 Since I am located in Indiana, that's why I've chose this one as your example here today for this. The term advertising as used in the rules here in Indiana refers to any manner of public communication intended or expected to promote the purchase or use of professional services of a law, law firm or employee of either involving the practice of law or related services. This is very broad. Any manner of public communication. This can be online, this can be via text message, this can be via vocal verbal engagement, this can be via social media networking platform. 00:09:42.8280000 Maybe it can be a billboard or a magazine, or still those yellow pages. It can be anything. And so advertising includes everything. And a lot of jurisdictions have included and adopted similar language like this to Indiana, but some have not. So again, check your local rules. 00:10:01.5680000 Never just rely on the model rules. Whatever jurisdiction you're in, you need to check it and make sure that it applies. So let's start with some of our specific advertising rules that can affect the practice and can affect what we do as attorneys when it comes to advertising. The first one is rule 7.1, and I'm going to use the model rules from here on out, unless it specifically says otherwise on the screen. But model rule 7.1 is communications regarding our services, and this is the one that really gets people and the one that disciplinary commissions can really catch you on. 00:10:39.2740000 It states that a lawyer shall not, shall not make a false or misleading communication about the lawyer or the lawyer services. Now, false or misleading? Misleading is the one that really trips up some attorneys because of phraseology or words being used. You could use the phrase and say, well, that's not misleading to a lawyer, but that's not really the standard. Is it misleading to the general public? 00:11:07.3340000 Is it misleading to lay persons? Is it misleading to those who you are attending to target with the advertisement? And if that is the case, then it's misleading. A communication the rule goes on to state is false or misleading if it contains a material misrepresentation of fact or law or omits a fact necessary to make the statement considered as a whole not materially misleading. So you can't omit facts. 00:11:36.8620000 You can't tell a white lie. How many of you have ever, and I'm not saying you do this now as a lawyer, but just think back maybe to your teenage years or when you were a kid or what your kids do to you if you're in that phase of life, too. And have they ever just glazed over the truth, saying, well, I didn't lie to you, but I didn't give you the full details. That's kind of that misleading, omitting a fact necessary to make the statement as a whole truthful. And you can't go to a disciplinary and defend saying, well, I didn't lie, I just didn't tell the whole truth. 00:12:09.3520000 You're probably going to get hit with a violation, maybe not if you can argue it pretty well, but I probably almost guarantee you're probably going to get hit with something if that's the case and you're up in front of the disciplinary commission. So you need to look at the statements you make to make sure they're not false or misleading and that it is transparent and communicated to laypersons in the general public. That is your audience, not other lawyers who know the legal lingo, not other professionals in certain industries, but the lay person standard of what is false or misleading. I would recommend, too, if you have the resources in your firm before any marketing or for any advertisement goes out, don't just let one person have the reins on it, but have someone else double check it. Maybe it's an associate, maybe it's a lawyer. 00:13:00.0720000 Maybe you have an ethics counsel or general counsel that can review marketing materials before they get released so that they can think about these rules since they deal with them maybe daily, and make sure they're applied appropriately to all your marketing and advertising communications. I know a lot of big law firms have that in them. That is part of what I do too, for law firms as well, is to make sure that marketing materials are not violating the rules of professional conduct. I've done that in the past at firms I've worked for, and so it is something to consider if you do a lot of marketing. Moving on to material 7.2, information regarding our legal services. 00:13:42.2300000 This means that we can communicate information regarding our services through any form of immediate and just how we are going to go about doing that. The second part of the rule says a lawyer shall not compensate, give, or promise anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer services, except in certain circumstances. This is talking about those referral services. You know, someone refers someone to you or you refer someone to someone else, that is really what this gets at. So you've got to look at, especially when it comes to the marketing and advertising piece, that the pay is reasonable for the cost of the advertisement or the communications pays usually charged for this type of thing. 00:14:28.4080000 If you're using a third party referral service, you need to make sure it complies with this portion of the rule as well. Then, two, you just have to make sure that the client knows if it's a referral type of situation or if you're getting any profit from it. And so that reciprocal referral agreement, you know, make sure it's not exclusive. The client is informed of its existence and the nature of the agreement. So if you and another lawyer or you and a third party have like a referral network going on, or you say, you refer to me, I refer to you. 00:14:58.7340000 We compensate XYZ, let the client know, and so then they know that you're referring them to this other person and you get an incentive. So then they can decide if they really want to use that person or if they want to go somewhere else where you don't have that relationship, or they feel like maybe that's not the best for them. So giving that client that choice, making sure they're informed up front, is what you need to do. And that goes to communication, honesty with our clients, doing the best for our clients and just making sure they're protected and we're not using them as a means to our own end to get those referral fees in and doing something unethical in the process. You also, according to this rule, section C cannot state or imply that you are certified as a specialist in a particular field of law. 00:15:47.8560000 And a specialist holds a special meaning, if you think about it. We always say, we practice law. We're practitioners. That means it's an evolving thing. Now, you may be 30, 40, maybe even more years in than that in your practice, but it's still a practice. 00:16:03.6560000 And it's a practice because the law is ever changing. There is new law every year. Things change. Cases get overturned, new statutes and regulations come out. So it is a continual practice. 00:16:16.7480000 We are never that expert, necessarily. We may be well versed, or this is our niche, or this is different things. But you cannot label yourself as a specialist unless you are certified by an organization that has authority and is approved to make such certification, and it has been deemed so by the ABA and the jurisdiction which are located that certified organization, if you use the term specialist needs to be marked or clearly identified in the communication. If you're going to list yourself as a specialist. I know a lot of here in Indiana, family law attorneys can be listed as specialist. 00:16:58.9780000 They can take a specialist certification course, get the accreditation, get the specialist title, and then they just have to put that certifying organization on their marketing materials in their email, you know, at the signature block, and they can hold as a specialist. And family law, some jurisdictions may not have that designation. Most do, from what I'm aware. But again, if you're going to hold out as an expert or specialist, you need to make sure you have a certification behind it. List that on there. 00:17:28.3390000 Otherwise, we're practitioners. We practice, we evolve. We always learn something new. You may say, I haven't learned anything new in years. You're still a practitioner. 00:17:37.2350000 Maybe you need to branch out into a new area, do something a little different. The law is ever changing. You can find something new. We also too have to this part d of this rule. Any communication made under this rule must include at least the name and contact information of what's least one lawyer or law firm that is responsible for its content. 00:17:59.4300000 So a lawyer or law firm's name has to be listed on it, meaning maybe it's your partner's name. Okay, that's fine. Put their email address, put their phone number, put a contact information, put in a physical address if that's more appropriate. It doesn't have to be your name. It's just someone in the law firm that's responsible for the content. 00:18:19.9420000 And this is because, too, if the content is against the rules or if the content is in violation, then we know who's responsible for it and they can come after you with a disciplinary commission or, you know, seek you down to make you change the information. But again, any communication needs to have those markings on it to be a valid communication. So when it boils down to kind of from the comments, and this is just a summary, so you can see it here on the screen in front of you, the name and office address or contact information of at least one lawyer in the firm for the contents. And then the part of the rule we haven't mentioned yet is we need to keep a copy or recording of all of our communications and advertisements for six years after dissemination according to the model rules. Now, again, check your local jurisdiction. 00:19:08.0800000 This could be different jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but if you are going to hold an attorney advertising, you need to keep a copy of it. And that's because obviously if there's an issue with it, there's some recording, there's some marking for it, there's something we can go back to and figure out what was said or what was published at that time. And this is really, this part of this rule really gets you with social media and your personal social media, facebook pages or web pages. And even if it's personal, if you start posting, wins your law firm name, saying, hey, you know, I work here, hire me. Or, you know, anything for that pecuniary gain or, or getting something in for pecuniary gain. 00:19:48.9180000 It's now advertising. Now we have to have the lawyer's name on it, who's responsible for the content, and keep it for six years. How many of you keep those things, you post those comments on your social media for six years? That's attorney advertising. How many of you screenshotted it and saved it and filed it away? 00:20:09.8860000 How many of you have done that with your personal LinkedIn for attorney advertising? You need to think about these things, of what you're transforming and how you're going to kind of take those snapshots in time in case something comes up. Now, have I seen anyone violated for this? For their social media accounts? Necessarily? 00:20:28.1460000 No, but it doesn't mean it can't happen. So you've got to know that these rules do apply. And as social media becomes more and more common, even though it's already hugely common, you may see some more opinions and stuff coming out regarding it. Rule 7.2 comments further go on to state that these, I'm not going to go through them all. There's an entire list here are acceptable categories for you to put in an advertisement, meaning these are things that are commonly seen in lawyer advertisements. 00:20:59.3180000 These are things that have been said, okay, that you're not going to get in trouble for or step over any bounds like, you know, holding out as an expert without that certification. So if you want a very robust advertisement, whether it be through a law firm website or a posting or a billboard, these are things you could consider, you know, posting in there. You can obviously post your name, contact information, where you went to school, how you accept payment arrangements, office information, membership, you know, anything truthful and honest. The things we can't post, which we'll see in some of our examples coming up here, is we can't do things like comparison. We can't say we're the best at something because that's not verifiable. 00:21:43.2460000 If you look at this list, almost everything on here, or everything on here is verifiable by a document or by something, a position you hold, like there's something that can be verified to make it truthful. It's the things we can't verify that tend to fall in that misleading category and that are going to get us in trouble if we put them in our attorney advertising. So we need to make sure we can verify what we put, go through the list, make sure you have what you need on it, and go from there, going on into the next attorney advertising rules before we get to our fun examples for today, rule 7.3 no solicitation lawyers shall not by in person or real time electronic contact solicit professional employment from a prospective client when a significant motive is for the lawyer's pecuniary gain, unless the person contacted is another lawyer because they think we can hold our own, has a family, close personal or prior professional relationship with the lawyer. And so if they fit into those two categories, you can directly solicit them. If they don't fit into those two categories, you shall not directly solicit them by in person or real time, meaning instant messenger. 00:23:03.7100000 That's real time telephone call. Those things are real time. What's not real time is sending out those mailings, you know, after a car accident report comes down or something like that. So you got to know that we cannot solicit in real time unless it's another lawyer because we obviously should be keen to the tactics of other lawyers, not beefe or influenced by them, or a family member close personal relationship with them or a prior professional relationship with the person, meaning a current client or a past client or someone that's used your services before. In addition to that, too, a lawyer shall not solicit professional employment from a prospective client by in person or written, recorded audio, video, or electronic communication, including the Internet. 00:23:47.9500000 So it goes on to state where we cannot put that solicitation, particularly in the context of those electronic communications, including the Internet. So really think about those things and think, have I ever solicited in this fashion? Have I ever reached out through Instagram or instant messenger? That could be a simultaneous real time electronic communication. So you need to make sure you watch this, because online, if you cannot do it in person, don't do it online. 00:24:19.4800000 So if you can't talk to someone in person about something, then you can't facetime them, you can't message them online. Just because you're behind a computer screen does not make it better. Does not make it work, right. You need to look at those different things and how it's going to come about. Rule 7.3 is a very long rule. 00:24:39.4160000 It is continued here on the screen just for your reference. Again, I use the Indiana one in this because the model one is a little different, but some jurisdictions have specific provisions about dissemination to prospective clients and fines and fees and different things you have to pay for dissemination of advertising materials. I wanted to show in this one that in Indiana, a copy of all communications have to be filed with our Supreme Court disciplinary commission prior to dissemination. So for doing those mailings or for doing those, you know, auto communications, we got to send them out. A filing fee of $50 to has to be paid, and then we have to keep it and give a list of intended recipients and different things like that. 00:25:23.1900000 And if it's changed or altered, we have to update it. So check your 7.3. If you're going to do targeted mailings, say, after police reports come out or accident reports, and you're going to send them that letter. That's not real time. A letter is not real time. 00:25:37.6300000 That's fine, but make sure that you follow any compliance with any rules in your jurisdiction. And again, here in Indiana, I wanted just to show you we have certain things we have to do when we make those mailings as well. This is just a chart if you were confused or forgot from law school what the differences are between solicitations. So written solicitations, targeted mailings are allowed. Usually you have to have the labeling, pay the fees, keep them on file. 00:26:05.7020000 Those things follow rule 7.3. Some jurisdictions, though, do prohibit them, except for certain instances. So again, check your local rules. Telephone solicitations are considered the face to face, similar to simultaneous. So we want to make sure that we're not doing those prerecorded. 00:26:25.9680000 Telephone solicitation is regulated as advertising, too. Generally allowed, though. But it's prerecorded so they don't look at it as real time if it's just a recording. Some jurisdictions may differ on that, so make sure you check your local jurisdiction. Internet solicitation using an Internet chat room to solicit is generally prohibited because it is direct and occurs in real time. 00:26:49.0200000 Again, you got to watch that real time. Those are prohibited. Tweets considered solicitation TikTok solicitation and direct messaging can be considered solicitation. Real time email solicitation is generally allowed. It's looked at more like the mailing, not with a direct simultaneous communication. 00:27:06.1500000 But again, you need to follow rule 7.3. You may need to label it, you may need to turn it in you may need to pay a fee, keep it for so long. You just need to see what category your advertising is in and where it falls, if it's allowed or if it's not allowed. And so again, this is just kind of a good chart. Depending what types of solicitation or advertising you're used, you can come back here and reference this and check, you know, where you're going to fall and if it's allowed not or what has to happen. 00:27:36.3200000 Rule 7.4, again, I use the Indiana one here just because it's a little more specific. I know most jurisdictions are a little more specific to communication of fields of practice and specialization. Indiana deleted most of the model rules. So again, a lot of jurisdictions have. But here we have a lawyer may communicate the fact that a lawyer does or does not practice in a particular field. 00:27:59.6860000 A lawyer admitted to engage in patent practice can use a destination and morality practice. Again, you can't certify as a specialist. So 7.4 has changed in a lot of jurisdictions over the years. Not many necessarily follow that model rule still. So look at yours and see just about those fields of practice specialization, and it really bounces off that 7.2 into a more specialized rule. 00:28:25.8880000 And so your jurisdiction may not have 7.4 at all if it didn't bounce off to 7.2, but some do. So I wanted to make you aware of that. This is just the last part of the rule, too. Again, check your local jurisdiction on it. 7.5 is another controversial one, depending on what jurisdiction you're in. 00:28:46 7.5 is regarding firm names. Some firms say, so long as it's not misleading, then it's okay and that's it. That's all 7.5 is. Model rule kind of follows that. So long as it's not misleading, then you can use a trade name. 00:29:01.0040000 Other jurisdictions say that you can't use a trade name. So this one, a lawyer shall not use a firm name, letterhead, or professional designation that violates rule 7.1. That's that false or misleading. A trade name may be used by a lawyer in private practice if it does not imply connection with the government agency or with a public or charitable legal services organization, and therefore not an otherwise in violation of rule 7.1. That's a little more detailed than some. 00:29:29.5700000 That's more the Indiana standard. Some just say it can't be false or misleading or violate 7.1, period. Some say you can't use trade names at all. So depending on what you want your law firm name to be, depending on if you're going to implicate this rule now, you may say, okay, what is a trade name? Well, a trade name is something other than your last name or the names of the lawyers in the firm or more that traditional sense we see in law firm names. 00:29:55.6260000 It can be names like immigration law practice. That's a trade name. It's saying, we practice immigration law, we're a law firm. Period. Now, that would have to be judged. 00:30:06.2580000 Is that false or misleading? Does it show a connection with a government agency or with a public or charitable legal service? If the answer to either of those questions is yes, then we can't use it. Normally, immigration law firm is not going to spark those things that they know. It's false or misleading. 00:30:24.8680000 But if we put in front of it, say again, Indiana immigration law firm. That implies a connection with the government. That implies a connection that may be a charitable or public organization. That would be misleading and in violation of rule 7.5 just by putting that word Indiana on the front of it. We've now hit on this and are probably in violation. 00:30:49.0100000 Say, for instance, you live in Springfield, Illinois. You can't say Springfield legal clinic. That implies a connection with a charitable organization or the government or the state. If you're not those things, then you cannot use it as false or misleading. So you've got to look at what you're using if it shows that connection. 00:31:08.1060000 If it doesn't, then you should be okay. A lot of trade names really come into, like the family law practice, the immigration practice, different practices like that is where you're going to see more trade names than in other types of areas. But again, you've got to show the connection or the non connection, and then how it otherwise violates rule 7.1 at that point. And again, I don't know what your law firm name is. You may be thinking to yourself, oh, my goodness, we need to change it. 00:31:39.2480000 You may be thinking to yourself, well, I want to get my name off of there. Let's just use a trade name. I didn't know we could check your local jurisdiction. Check. What is there to know if you can, if you have any lawyers holding a public office, their name shall not be in the name of the law firm. 00:31:55.2200000 So say someone went to a public office or a judgeship shall not be used in the name of the law firm or in communications on its behalf during any substantial period in which the lawyer is not actively or regularly practicing at the firm. So if they take a leave of absence or they're retired now to be a judge, we want to get their name off the law firm. But a member of a part time legislative body, such as the generally symbol city, county council, or school board, we can leave their name on the firm. That's more of a part time role. They're not taking that substantial period off. 00:32:27.8300000 We just don't want to show that we have an undue influence with that person on there or that we have some connections that could help clients that are really not there. So that is why we cannot have those public officials, those public things stay within the law firm name, you know, while they are not practicing with us. Again, to a lot of lawyers, just use their last names. But you can use that trade name. Watch out for if you have people going into political office, update it. 00:32:58.5520000 You may have to change it a time or two, but something to think about now, in all these rules, we did not see anything that said that our advertisements had to be dignified, that they had to be professional, that they had to uphold some other ethical standard beyond just compliance with the rules. Now, just think about this. Should advertising for lawyers be dignified? And when I say dignified, I mean within bounds of certain decency, like not use sexual connotations, like not do certain things. If you think about that, Indiana used to include a dignity requirement and then omitted it. 00:33:36.8960000 Aba does recommend one be put into rules of professional conduct. Again, it's not in every jurisdiction. And you may think, what could be undignified about an advertisement? Well, I'll tell you a little story. This was actually quite a long time ago. 00:33:51.5980000 I've been teaching this case for several years. So early 2000, there was an attorney in New York, this is out of New York, and she had a practice of real estate. She was a real estate lawyer. Like closing deals, closing loans, closing real estate. Well, she posed in lingerie with her foot, one leg propped up on a stack of books. 00:34:12.1720000 And her advertising tagline was, any day, anytime, I will close your loan, just contact me. And she's in lingerie and a seductive pose with legal books around her. Is that dignified? Probably not. That's what we're getting at, is should advertising be dignified or not, or should we just trust attorneys to use their common sense? 00:34:34.4000000 Now, this attorney, which was funny about this story, was she did get a lot of clients, supposedly from this. And the male attorneys in her field or her area were kind of jealous that, you know, she could pose like this. So one of the other male attorneys that was also in real estate decided to do an advertisement where he was taking a shower, who was a very good looking gentleman, you know, six packs the whole thing and he peeps his head out, you know, half naked and says, we'll close your loan anytime. So again, fighting fire with fire. But are we violating any dignified requirements, or do we even need dignified requirements? 00:35:11.3900000 Or should we have them with social media, especially TikTok and Instagram and different things where you can make those real time videos and people, you know, dressing differently, people not acting as professional all the time, should we put back in dignified? And what draws the line of what is or is not? Who's going to be the deciding factor? You may look at your jurisdictional rules to see if you have this in the comments or within the rule itself or advertisements within your local community. Can you think of some off the top of your head that are not dignified? 00:35:46.1480000 And that is something to kind of think about. But it also, too, goes to what reputation do you want to have as a lawyer and put out there about yourself? Some tips for making some good advertisements use natural language. Be authentic to your practice area and your personality, but watch and make sure you don't violate the rules. At the same time, do not end videos. 00:36:07.7580000 If you're doing videos with contact me to learn more sometimes because that kind of implies you may be giving legal advice where we shouldn't yet and maybe create an unwanted training client relationship. Plus, you can just put something else, contact me and then just leave it there instead. Or here on the screen it says instead, reach out for any questions. The former implies more unsolicited marketing. So it's just, again, the phraseology we use. 00:36:34.2060000 The goal is to get the audience to trust you. Sometimes to trust lawyers, we have to be a little personable. You got to tell maybe a personal story here and there. You've got to have a little pizzazz or personality. You can't just go on there and be stoic and very monotone as you talk. 00:36:49.0460000 You got to get the audience to trust you. And if you're talking to laypersons in the general public, sometimes our advertisements have to be what they want within the bounds of our rules. So making that balance is key. Incorporate those personal tidbits. Like I said, humanize yourself. 00:37:06.4300000 Lawyers are human. We have a sense of humor. We have a personality. We're fun people. Let's let the world see that in our advertisements. 00:37:13.3100000 Within the rules, though, if you create an account on an app, your first video or feature main hub, make it memorable. Try not to be boring. Try to have fun, entertaining content but ethical content at the same time and there is a balance between the two, but it can be done. Some forms you could look at for your platforms where you're going to manage and advertise. There's blog postings. 00:37:36.9280000 You can label them advertising material. Think of a blog posting just like a print ad in a magazine. So make sure you follow all those same rules and requirements. Lawyer listings too. Information. 00:37:48.4800000 Just make sure the information is not false or misleading. Practice areas practice groups don't give direct guidance don't give unsolicited don't give legal advice unsolicited legal advice or create an unwanted attorney client relationship. YouTube can be great. YouTube's like the next television commercials. All the advertising rules apply. 00:38:08.7840000 YouTube is like television. You can have a YouTube channel. You can give legal, new, updated legal advertisements every week or every day and have a YouTube channel for it. You can host informational sessions, teaching lectures, different things. You just got to watch that line between giving advice and not giving advice and creating those unwanted attorney client relationships. 00:38:30.7980000 But you can advertise there and make sure you do those things. Some other places where we can advertise on the Internet are our TikTok, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat. The list goes on and on. But try to really keep personal, personal and professional. Professional when you start to blend your account, then everything may fall under attorney advertising and you may have a problem if you're not following all the rules to a t. 00:38:56.6000000 You also need to make sure everything you post is truthful and not misleading. And it's the image you want to put out there, whether it be on your personal page or on your professional page you need to watch. And it is your responsibility to comply with the rules. It is your responsibility to delete stuff or take stuff off that's not compliant with the rules of professional conduct. And the thing about this too is if someone tags you in a post and this is just social media hygiene for you, it is your responsibility to make sure whatever you're tagged in complies with the rules. 00:39:29.5280000 If it doesn't comply with the professional rules, then you could be held responsible for it, even though you're not the original poster. So anything you like, anything you give a thumbs up to, smiley face or tagged in, if it's not compliant with the rules of professional conduct, you could be held responsible for its content, even though you're not the original poster. Keep that in mind. Those are some of our newer platforms where we can see advertising. Some of the older traditional ones, obviously newspapers, print media, billboards, buses, television advertisements. 00:40:04.1680000 I was never a big bus person. I never want to see my face on the side of a bus. Some people love, to each their own. But those are still all there available to for you as well. Again, those landmines to consider. 00:40:16.6060000 We've gone over a lot of them, so we won't belabor these points. But just so you can go back to those rules, watch out for those false or misleading communications. Do not hide behind screen names or anonymous posts. We need to be truthful. We need to be honest. 00:40:29.7660000 We need to do all those things upfront. No solicitation. Go back to rule 7.3 or the chart, and watch out for trade names. More recent jurisdictions have changed it. If you're in Indiana, you probably love this seminar, but there's an advisory opinion there too. 00:40:45.5180000 When it comes to Indiana, use control features on social media when they're available to you, such as disclaimers. If it's a personal, professional site, the content, you can throw a disclaimer. There's the about me section. There's other sections on different platforms where you could just drop in a disclaimer that this is not attorney advertising or, you know, I'm not creating an unintended attorney client relationship here. Some ideas of some of those places to put those are here on the screen. 00:41:13.9180000 If you're using Facebook and Persona or statement of ownership, you can put the disclaimer there. If you're losing LinkedIn about me section, you can include it there. Twitter it was actually the New York State bar that suggested you put this on all your tweets. It's short. This tweet contains attorney advertising. 00:41:31.7120000 Prior results do not guarantee similar outcome. And you would need to put that at the end of each Twitter thing or tweet that you were using. And that is from the New York State Bar Association's ethical guidelines for social media from 2017. So again, check your jurisdiction to see if they have any guidance on where these disclaimers should be set or what you should do to make sure that you are compliant with the rules. I did give you guys some slides just to look at regarding control features. 00:42:01.6280000 Obviously, we don't want people posting or putting stuff on our account that are going to violate the rules. So you use and utilize the control features as well to make sure control what you share. Block people, restrict connections, you know, hide endorsements and LinkedIn. That's probably the best thing. You may think, well, why the endorsements? 00:42:19.4800000 If someone endorses you for litigation and you're a contract attorney, that's false or misleading. And if your LinkedIn has your accounts and those things. That's an advertisement that's now falsely misleading and in violation of the rules. And so if your mother or sibling or significant others go on there and just endorse you for every legal word that they can find, that's false or misleading. What if they don't know about the quality of your services? 00:42:43.0400000 They're just endorsing you because you're their friend, but they've never used you. They don't know what you're good at. They don't know what you're not. So that endorsement feature on LinkedIn and those features where other people can give us those accolades or those endorsements just by the click of a button can have advertising implications. So it is best just to disable that in your control feature or to hide it and not allow the endorsements. 00:43:07.7820000 I've never heard one lawyer say that they lost or gained a client due to their endorsements. Like, that's just, I've never heard that said before. So again, just watch what you do. But LinkedIn, that endorsement feature, is a big one. Facebook, again, control what you can see on your posting and profile. 00:43:24.8160000 Sorry, the little Facebook thing got moved there. Only allow access to your post to certain people if you want to restrict it. But remember, whatever you put online is not always confidential. Anything you put online is just think it's going to be public. Someone can screenshot it, save it, retweet it, repost it, snapchat it, I don't know whatever else you can do to it. 00:43:45.7820000 Anything you put online is never private. So use those function controls. Use those features as well. Twitter, unfollow people who you don't want to be associated with, filter notifications, block mute report, protect your tweets, photo tagging, all those things. Just make sure you use the controls, these different social media platforms, because that is going to be imperative to make sure you comply with the rules of professional conduct. 00:44:15.6000000 Some other things to consider, too. Instagram, there's parental controls, but you can use them for yourself to watch out for fake accounts. Do not make fake accounts or hide behind fake pseudo names. Could be false or misleading. So use those parental controls, those features, disable those things. 00:44:32.9120000 And don't think, hey, I'll make a false account. No one knows it's me. A little IP address follows you around, just saying. And we can always find out who it is, or someone can. So just make sure you watch those fake accounts and make sure you know what you're doing in those. 00:44:48.9520000 So let's give some examples here. We have about 14 minutes left, 1314 minutes left in the seminars. We'll go through some examples here together. So scenario number one. A lawyer posted on her personal page, another great victory today in court. 00:45:03.5100000 My client is delighted. Who wants to be next? And won a million dollar verdict? Tell your friends and check out my website. Personal page. 00:45:12.9180000 But she posted this. Has she transformed her page into advertising? Probably yes. Is this good advertising? Probably no. 00:45:22.7500000 She's almost guaranteeing results. She's trying to say, hey, I can do this for you. You could be the next one. We're violating several advertising rules here. One of those things we can't do is guarantee results. 00:45:34.4460000 We can't say, you know, we got a million here, we'll get a million for you. Because every case is different. And the other thing here that no one really thinks about sometimes is rule 1.6. Did she even ask her client if she could post about their case? Because we cannot post about anything without our clients permission confirmed in writing. 00:45:54.3580000 And so before you post about a win, before you post about anything, even if it's part of the public docket, you need your client's permission confirmed in writing. Rule 1.6 tells us that there is no exception for public information. There's no exception for public records. There's no exception for stuff listed on the docket or a jury verdict. You need your client's consent. 00:46:16.2880000 So this would be in violation of probably advertising rules. In addition, probably rule 1.6 if she did not obtain that consent before posting it. So we can see several ethical violations really fanning through here in the just this one post. Example number two, a lawyer got all excited about winning a case against the parents of a disabled child and took to Twitter to gloat about it. The tweets read a great win last week, which sent some parents into a storm. 00:46:44.4440000 Tweets were from the founding partner who served as the firm's managing director. This is actually a real case. Are there ethical implications here? We have rural 1.6 implications. Again, we have potentially those advertising implications, different things that could come to play. 00:47:02.7260000 I will tell you, in this case, they did get hit with the malpractice suit for violation of rule 1.6 and they got fired by the client for future work and that the attorney got disciplined within the firm. So just know getting that consent 1.6 is going to come about. And I posted that here just as a reminder. We cannot reveal information relating to a client's representation unless the client gives informed consent. Includes public docket information. 00:47:30.5760000 There's no exceptions. There's nothing publicly known unless you're under former client, and that is very few and far between and very limited. So we need to get that client's consent confirmed in writing before we post about wins on our website site number three a lawyer just moved to a small town and hung his own shingle. Solo, I should say solo instead of soul. Sorry about that. 00:47:53.5740000 Practitioner in a new small town posted on his personal LinkedIn and Facebook pages big city experience small town service I just moved to this wonderful small town. Let me help you with your legal needs. You'll be getting big city experience. I am experienced in your local farming legal needs. So this one is the big city experience, the comparing different things. 00:48:18.9600000 And so in the comparative you can't compare ourselves. It's not verified. We can't say big town, small town, it doesn't matter. How do we verify that big town is better than small town? How do you get that verification? 00:48:30.3600000 So that can be false or misleading. That can be, you know, against those different areas there as well. So we need to make sure the statements for Tresl going back to rule 7.1 regarding those comparisons and that comparisons are prohibited unless they can be factually substantiated. Any comparison that is unverified is inappropriate and we need to make sure that we have it. So here. 00:48:53.9040000 Experienced big those are technically unverified and inappropriate. So that is what we look for. There some case opinions that really talked about that. I posted one here out of Pennsylvania, the eastern District, and again one out of Indiana as well. But we need to watch those misleading statements and false verifications. 00:49:15.3800000 Scenario number four, lawyer advertised online professional and personal sites by using his name and the phrase and affiliates. However, the attorney was a sole practitioner and just shared office space with other lawyers. So the phrase and affiliates was false for misleading because it was just him. There's no affiliate. You can't imply there's more than one attorney when there's really nothing. 00:49:37.1700000 Got hit with the 7.1 violation, potentially 7.5 d as well regarding that name of the firm. See comment to that rule regarding that but again posted on his personal webpage. Come see me for your legal needs. If there is no recovery, no legal fees are owed by my clients. This is the best deal in town. 00:50:01.2160000 Potentially false or misleading. Best deal in town could be really picked at. No recovery, no legal fees. Maybe that's misleading too. Is there costs and expenses? 00:50:12.3340000 Was there fine print listed? We need to think about those things in our advertising. A lawyer wrote in his personal LinkedIn page. My background provides me with a strong basis of knowledge with which to protect your interest as to your medical malpractice claims. The lawyer had only been practicing for two years and never taken a medical malpractice case. 00:50:33.4220000 So again he said provides me with this strong base of knowledge to protect your interest of medical malpractice claims. He never done medical malpractice before. We can't lie about our experience. You can't say you've done 20 trials in our experienced trial lawyer when you've never even walked in a courtroom. You've got to really think about it. 00:50:50.9260000 Yes, I know you want to get clients in the door. Yes, I know you want to bolster your skills or what you think you can do, but you can't be that false or misleading. And we need to take that in consideration. YouTube too. This is kind of what I was talking about. 00:51:04.3020000 This is a YouTube advertisement was run by a lawyer who showed a car accident, a couple of people in the hospital waiting room, husband father kissing his daughter goodbye, and then the lawyer arguing a jury trial in the courtroom. Sounds okay. Sounds like a good advertisement. The problem was the lawyer never took cases to trial as a matter of firm policy. So he never stepped in the courtroom and never ever tried a personal injury case. 00:51:26.7100000 But he showed him on his ad doing jury work or trial work in a courtroom. False or misleading. We have to be very careful with what we put out there and what we do and we have to watch those things. This is a part of a promoting itself. The firm of Allen, Allen, Allen and Allen includes on his webpages and other advertisements a statement that out of the four lawyers in practice and personal injury law listed in the best lawyers of America, three of them are from their firm. 00:51:56.0900000 Competitors thought this was unlawful. Advertising commissioned first how it was unethical, but then reversed itself. So long as we have that certification, so long as we post that on there, this is a true case, then we should be okay with that. Example number nine, a lawyer stated that the local prosecutor was in my pocket and that he does what I ask he does. This implies that we have influence over the judiciary. 00:52:22.7300000 It's also false or misleading that 7.1 is going to get you every time and looking at the comments to it in your jurisdiction is going to be vital. 00:52:33.6400000 Scenario number ten, a lawyer incorporated content from another website that the court found to be deceptive and prejudicial to the administration of justice in 8.4 violations because it advocated that the parents in special education medications lie and use improper tactics like making false demands so when a lawyer incorporates website content from other sources, you need to make sure that you know what the sources are, that it is reliable. This is kind of like that tagging or being posted stuff. What you adopt as your own becomes your own and you can be disciplined for it despite it not being your original content. You just cut and pasted or tagged or liked something. You've got to really look for those things. 00:53:16.3800000 This lawyer created a cloud of COVID with rain. What do you think? Think that could be misleading? Potentially. You've just got to watch, again, do all these people get violations and disciplinary complaints? 00:53:28.0840000 No, but again, you've got to watch what you put out there. So there's other cases. I mentioned a couple throughout this seminar, but you can find them in every jurisdiction. You can just Google, look up on your disciplinary commission's website. Advertising cases are everywhere. 00:53:46.7300000 Third party paid marketing jurisdiction by jurisdiction. Make sure you follow the rules. Make sure you get those referral fees like 7.2, which was talking about referral fees. Make sure you're in compliance with everything you know. Disclose to the client. 00:53:59.7460000 If there's some relationship like a reciprocal referral agreement. Just make sure if your jurisdiction. There is a lot of guidance on this from the ABa too, and other specific jurisdictions that you can look up as well. Just be professional in our content. Maintain wise choices. 00:54:16.5640000 Use a good social media presence. Do unto others that you would have done unto you if you would not do it in person. Don't do it online. All those old sayings and phraseologies, just think about those and then think about the dignity. Think about should advertising be dignified? 00:54:32.3240000 And do you want your advertising to, and what image and perception do you want to put out there for your law firm? If you don't have any questions, then we are concluding for today. I hope everyone has a great afternoon and evening.