[Course Name] 00:00:01.2000000 Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar and CLe regarding federal court e filing, discovery and case management tips. We're going to talk about hopefully maybe not everything federal court, but a lot that is done in federal court and just the processes in place to help you kind of go back to the basics and re familiarize yourself. Maybe you're just starting a federal court practice. Maybe you've been practicing for years, or maybe you're just interested in learning the differences between a state and federal court. So hopefully today we can answer some of those questions for you and you can learn some stuff along the way. 00:00:38.1940000 My name is Kerry Sheehan, and I'm going to be your speaker here today. I am an ethics and conflicts attorney at Scopolitis, Garvin, Light, Hanson and Fury in Indianapolis, Indiana, and I'm also an assistant clinical professor of business law and ethics at IU Indianapolis in the Kelley School of Business. On top of that, prior to being more in house doing conflicts ethics for a living, I was a trial attorney and I did practice in state and federal courts. And I have stayed up on the topics because I also teach them to law students as well as undergraduate students in the business law program. So if you have any questions here today, even if it's on ethics or something else or federal courts, please let me know. 00:01:21.9980000 Please. You can put the questions in the chat. You can save them till the end of the seminar. That is completely up to you. But I would hope that if you do have questions, you would submit them so that we can get them answered here for you today. 00:01:34.8300000 Let's get started, though. On our seminar, I think everyone's had an opportunity to enter the room to kind of familiarize yourself with the features on Zoom. If you're not already familiar, I would say in starting out, especially with this seminar, please always refer to your rules. This means not just the main federal rule books that we normally go by when it comes to federal court, but each specific federal court and jurisdiction has its own what are called local rules. Those local rules kind of supplement the federal rules. 00:02:05.1660000 If you want to think of it like a hierarchy, think of the federal rules as very broad. They give you the basics. They give you the outline. They give you, you know, the standard procedures. Then you need to know the details. 00:02:17.2660000 So then we go into the local rules of the specific court we're in to get more details, like how many interrogatories can we get? How many of this, or how many of that? Or what do they change, like a deadline or something? Those are kind of more the local rules. Then on top of that, there is also what are called judge preferences or judge rules. 00:02:38.0620000 This is specific to the judge you are in front of. And in federal court, you can normally find these on the court's website under the specific judge. So say, for instance, if you went out to United States southern district court here in Indiana and looked up a judge, say, Tanya Walton Pratt, she's one of our judges here and you went to her webpage, there may be a section or a link that says judges preferences. Some of these preferences could be things like, you know, she only hears motions for summary judgment on Tuesday, Thursday. She likes certain things filed a certain way or free for you to use certain forms. 00:03:16.7220000 Some other things that could be in those preferences are how do they like their submitted orders or the potential orders that you want them to sign. Do you need them on a certain color paper? Do you need them in a certain format? Do you not need them at all? These are some things that could be under judges preferences. 00:03:34.2840000 So what I'm going to talk about here today are more those bigger, broader federal rules. But just know that depending on which jurisdiction you're in, which court system you're in, which judge you are in front of, you need to go out and find those local rules in those judges preferences as well, because that is what's really going to supplement the overall federal rules. Now let's just start here with the basics. If you are maybe a paralegal listening in or a new starting out attorney, just know that the federal courts, there are circuits when it comes to that appellate level in the federal court system, our trial courts or district courts, there's usually one district court or two district courts, sometimes maybe three per state. We have here in Indiana, the northern district and the southern district. 00:04:21.4760000 And then we feed into the 7th Circuit up there in Chicago, Illinois. So if you're not sure, familiarize yourself with where you sit, you can kind of look here and see which states feed into, you know, which different circuits. But that is where you trial an appeal. Then anything past that we know goes out to Washington, DC, the Supreme Court, to law the land. So if you're not sure where to file, obviously you file based on where you're located or where the incident occurred or you know, where the defendants are located. 00:04:51.9120000 You know, you've got to set that proper jurisdiction and then you would go to the trial court level in that particular state. Then if you had to appeal in the federal system, you would go up to whichever circuit your state sat in. So for us in Indiana, that would be feeding up to the 7th Circuit in Chicago, which is always a nice little fun trip. I've argued in front of the 7th Circuit before. It was intimidating, it was entertaining, and it was a great experience and I wouldn't change it. 00:05:21.0260000 But if you ever get the opportunity to argue in front of an appellate court, I would take it if that is your case, obviously, but just know it is a good experience too to have one or two of those under your belt if you're going to be a full time litigator or practitioner. How do we start that case without filing in the district court? Well, the plaintiff files the complaint. Obviously. They have to find their proper location and all those things and file it. 00:05:48.2620000 Once it is filed, they serve that file complaint upon the defendant. You get that service of process either by, you know, door service, certified mail, hand delivery, whatever service you're going to serve your defendant. Defendant in federal court can also waive service, which gives them a little extra time to respond in most jurisdictions to the complaint. So that is always an option as well. If you're not familiar with a complaint or starting out, like I said, this is back to the basics. 00:06:14.6100000 The complaint is going to describe the damages and injuries and you know, what claims that they have against the defendant themselves or what claims they say the defendant did to them. It's also going to state that jurisdiction why you are filing in a particular state while you're filing a particular court, as well as what relief you want as the plaintiff. That relief you want is important because if you just say, I just want to yell at the defendant, what's the court going to give you? There's nothing there. You need to say something. 00:06:44.6600000 And there's boilerplate language that we've all seen, all just and proper relief in the premises. That's probably ingrained in some of our minds that have used that over and over again. You can say, you know, a dollar amount if you want to get specific. A lot of attorneys don't just to kind of leave that open or broader, you can say you want injunctive relief, you can say you want injunctive relief and attorney's fees. You can do a combination of things, but you really need to set forth, if you're that plaintiff, what you want or what you're asking for that relief. 00:07:15.9980000 And the complaint you file past that point, once it is filed. That is what I call a trigger. Trigger, which we'll get to here a little later in the seminar, means that it triggers another deadline. It triggers a deadline for when you have to have the defendant served. It also may trigger a deadline for when a case management order is going to, or, excuse me, case management plan is going to be drafted leading into your rule 16 conference rule of disclosures. 00:07:45.0820000 Rule 26 f, disclosures. It's going to lead in to several triggering deadlines. Anything you file in federal court, and we will go over calendaring here a little bit later, is going to trigger another deadline. So always need to think of every time you file something, it's a triggering event. You need to start tracking deadlines too. 00:08:04.2460000 So even with that initial filing of the complaint, it triggers that you need to serve the defendant. Once the defendant served that triggers when the defendant has to respond. Once we have that, we have triggers. Our rule 16, rule 26 f, disclosures, when we can start discovery, so forth and so on. Everything done in federal court or in any court triggers another event or triggers a deadline. 00:08:30.1000000 Now how many of you and I can't see your hands like the ECF CM filing system? Meaning do you like electronic filing? I used to know practitioners that would avoid federal court or try to at all cost just because they hated e filing. Well, unfortunately for them, the pandemic hit and now even state courts use ECF or some type of e filing system, if not this one specifically. So we really do have to familiarize ourselves with ECF and e filing systems. 00:09:02.0800000 Now these are great for courts cause obviously it allows them to maintain electronic records. We have no more paper. We're not rushing over last minute at 430 to get that file stamp. Or here in Indiana we called it rotunda filing a lot of times in certain courts because even though the court itself was closed, there was a rotunda or a big hallway entryway where you could go in with your papers by midnight and get the security guard to file stamp it because they gave the security guard the file stamps to get that in, you know, before the deadline. So you would meet some local practitioners in that rotunda filing process. 00:09:37.7080000 But those days are over. We have now e filing, we have in state and federal court systems and we need to be familiar with it. The greatest thing about it is it is twenty four seven. And that's also a because who likes to work 24/7 but you can file up until obviously midnight on the day of your deadline. You can file them at 03:00 a.m. 00:10:00.2120000 two amenity. The court staff mad at you because you know it's right before they're leaving. I don't know if anyone remembers those days that you're rushing in. The court staff wants to leave and you're saying, hey, file, stamp this and make tons of copies. So again, pacer ECF systems kind of alleviate that. 00:10:20.9100000 You do have to know before you file. You need to get an account, so you need to apply for an attorney admission, register for electronic filing. You need to review the procedures. There is actually an instruction, instruction manual on the CMECF filing system for attorneys to review so that they know, you know, how to ECF file. A lot of those procedures I'm going to talk about here today. 00:10:45.7780000 Some courts are already using Nextgen CMF filing. It's a slightly different process, but again, it's just kind of an upgrade. So a lot of the basic information is the same, too. If the court that you're in is using NextGen, the next ECF filing system, anything that is filed on the ECF or e filing has to be in PDF form, including a searchable PDF document to the file. If you're not familiar with a PDF, I have listed here, again, back to the basics, how you can make a word document into a PDF, because you would be surprised some attorneys don't know how to do that because they always are relied on their assistance to do this or just have never had to do it before. 00:11:30.0200000 So you would just, it's very simple. You open the document in words. You select files save as. Then you drop down to the type of format you want to save it in, which is going to be PDF. The document may change slightly in appearance. 00:11:42.5560000 If that does happen, you need to look at it to make sure it's what you want to file. If not, you need to go back in and make corrections on the word and get it to save and format correctly of how you want it to be portrayed going across the file. You also need to be cognizant on size limits of your file. Most courts, if not all of them, have a maximum size of document that can be uploaded. So if you are going to be filing a 30 page brief with, you know, 20 or 30 exhibits, it probably cannot be put into one PDF form. 00:12:15.4800000 You're going to have to probably file the brief separately, and each exhibit may be separately. So each exhibit would be uploaded as a separate document and labeled as such. Maybe you're going to do it in batches, like exhibits one through ten here, ten through 20 here. But you've got to watch those size limits because there is a maximum size limit per document that you can upload into the ECF filing system. Now, this does frustrate a lot of people. 00:12:44.8240000 It's frustrated me before because I'm like, well, where do I make the cutoff? This one document is 40 pages, but it's not allowing me to do it. So then I had to cut it in the middle and do part a and part b, or you want all these grouped together, but it's too large. So you've really got to think about and maybe even strategically think about, I need these altogether. I need these altogether. 00:13:07.2440000 Can we get them in those size limits? If not, then you've got to reassess, you've got to pivot, you've got to go back. You've got to figure out how it's going to be put into those size limits to make it uploadable. There is, too. If a form is fillable, it does need to be flattened, which means not edited. 00:13:26.3800000 So if you have a fillable type of form, PDF, and you re saved it, you know, you're thinking, oh, it's a PDF. Yeah, some PDF's are fillable. You need to flatten it before you file it because you can't upload a changeable form because that is going to go out to opposing counsel, going to go to the court, and if they can open it and it's still manipulatable, they can change it. So we need to flatten it. We need to make sure that it's no longer editable or could be altered by other users before we file it. 00:13:56.8720000 If you're not sure how to flatten a document, I've listed those instructions here for you from PDF Adobe. So it is a very simple process as well. If you've never flattened a document to use before filing, there are several commonly asked questions, and these are actually part of the user manual that you can read on pacer, the ECF filing system. How do you get your free copy? This is always a huge question, and I don't know why attorneys don't remember this and staff doesn't remember it either. 00:14:24.8900000 But you're always going to receive an email. If something's filed in one of your cases or you file something, you're going to receive an email notification from the court. You're not going to get a call or a letter in the mail. It's going to be an email notification. In that email notification, there's going to be a hyperlink. 00:14:40.1440000 Once you click on that hyperlink, once that's your free copy, when you click on it, you either need to download it and save it or print it. Otherwise, if you click on it, exit it, and then try to click on that link again, you don't get another free copy. Now you have to go into the court system, pay the five or $0.10 or whatever it is. Now for an additional copy. Each person signed up to receive notification usually gets their own hyperlinks. 00:15:06.3500000 So maybe if you didn't print yours, maybe your assistant hasn't opened theirs yet. Or maybe you just need to task your assistant to always print or save those immediately when they open them. This does not apply to transcripts, though transcripts normally do cost. Not a free version of it too. There is a fee that can be applied that is applied for accessing a docket sheet or other documents too. 00:15:32.6700000 They do like to nickel and dimas on the ECF system. I don't know if any of you have ever gone in and tried to pull down stuff. It's like $0.05 or a copy or more. So again, there is costs associated with pulling stuff down. But if anything is filed in your case, you get that one free hyperlink. 00:15:50.2460000 Make sure you download and save it as well. If you don't like e filing, you can always contact the court to see if you can get an exception. Exceptions usually are only granted in exceptional circumstances. Or, you know, we have a pro se litigant who does not have access or is not tech savvy and doesn't want to use the ECF filing system otherwise. Courts, especially federal courts, really love this process to save time, be efficient, save resources, and so they're going to hopefully push you to use it at that time, too. 00:16:22.1600000 The other thing you need to remember about ECF filing is once you hit that file button, it's filed. There is no retraction. There is no take back button. It is filed and automatically goes out and sends a notification to the participants in the case. So if you wrongfully upload a document that you shouldn't have included, or you file something that you didn't mean to file, it's going out to everyone of record on the case. 00:16:47.5600000 The only way for you to get it back or retract it is to contact the clerk of the court, say why you need it back, and then you usually have to file something to retract it to get it back. It's not a quick process, it's not a fun process. And you're explaining yourself now. In the interim of that, your opposing counsel say if you filed something like a confidential document you didn't mean to attach to a motion or something, your opposing counsel still has the ability to click on that hyperlink in their email and open it and review it now you've got an inadvertent disclosure situation, which we have to go under 4.4 b in your local jurisdiction to figure out how to resolve that ethical dilemma. So you need to be very careful and double check everything before you hit file because there is no retraction. 00:17:36.3920000 Once you file, everyone gets notified, they get their hyperlink. You cannot just automatically retract it if you misfiled. This is something too to really train your staff. If they are the ones doing the e filing, you need to make sure they know that they cannot go in, they cannot edit, they cannot delete. Once it's filed, it's filed. 00:17:55.7840000 Otherwise they need to contact the clerk's office. And you probably need to be the one to start to rectify the situation because there's also those ethical implications there of inadvertent disclosures, potentially maybe a breach of confidentiality. Rule 1.6 if you filed something that's confidential. So you need to really take steps to proactively do that. If a member of the public use ECF to file documents, if they are pro se, yes. 00:18:23.5120000 If they're not pro se or not part of a case, then probably not everyone has to go in and get the username password, be the authorized users to go on it too. If you forward an email to someone else without clicking on the hyperlink, that recipient can access the document. But if you've already clicked on it and then forward it, they don't get another click. You get one click on those hyperlinks to get your free document. You can't open it forwarded. 00:18:47.6320000 Then they open it one click, no matter who it is clicking on it. Now, if the other person has their email is also on there to get their own notification, not a forward one from you, but their own notification, then they would have their right to their one click in their email as well. If you are confused, if you are like, oh my gosh, this is so overwhelming. And when I first started doing pacer years ago when practicing a federal court, even before he finally was in the state courts, I wanted to avoid federal court. I was one of those people. 00:19:19.4200000 I was like, I do not like e filing. It was very confusing. I'd rather be running to the court at 430 making nights with the clerk staff, complimenting them, saying, oh, you know, I'm a young attorney, can you just file stamp this? This was a foreign thing. So I started taking the trainings and you can contact your local court system or the federal court you're in and get your own training sessions. 00:19:41.8320000 They do recorded video training sessions. They can walk you through, you know, the steps and procedures, tutorials they have out there. A lot of it is hands on, do it yourself type of training and you don't even have to contact anyone. But if you want more of a live training, some courts do offer that. And so you can go in and try to get those live trainings. 00:20:01.7940000 There is also user manuals. There are things on there, you know, the frequently asked questions, the how to step by step of different things. You need to print that off if you're the one doing the e filing or you need to have your staff, your assistant be very familiar with those procedures as well. So something to really think about. Once we file that complaint and we've got up in our ECF filing system, we're filing it, then we have to serve, obviously, the summons service and then defendant can waive service to. 00:20:31.5020000 This goes under federal rule four timing. To serve a defendant generally 90 days after the complaint is filed. Remember I said anything filed in federal court is a trigger. Once that ECF, where you do that initial filing of the complaint, is the plaintiff, your assistant, or you should be calendaring on your calendar, that that service needs to be done within 90 days. So you file, you calendar, always go hand in hand. 00:20:56.6720000 Every filing or every receipt of a filing from the court is a trigger to put something on your calendar. That is where you kind of do a good case management and make sure you stay up on dates and deadlines depending on how you are going to serve the defendant. Depends on, you know, what you need to do. Requirements. If you need hire a sheriff, a processor, certified meal, all those different things too. 00:21:22.1800000 Now, when we do calendar, once we have those triggers and we start to calendar and track our deadlines, that is going to be very important and it can cause a lot of anxiety and stress. But if you just remember that every time something is filed or that you receive something from the court, that it is a triggering event, that you need to put something on the calendar, then you're going to be okay. Now, if you may say, well, I know it's the triggering event because I was told this in a cle, but I don't know what's triggered, so I'm just going to forget about it. No, if it's a triggering event, something is always triggered. Then we need to figure out which rule applies. 00:21:59.5240000 We need to figure out what is triggered and then get it on there. So again, you file a complaint service of someone you know is the next trigger. Once that is triggered, then you have the finished response discovery, case management conference, you know, rule 26 f, all of those things keep triggering down the line, so you've got to get them on your calendar. And so once you get that triggering event, you identify the deadline. You look for, you know, obvious ones and then look for less obvious ones. 00:22:28.7440000 So complaint also triggers your deadline to object to assigned judge. That's not an obvious one. We know a complaint triggers that the defendant has to be served. But I have not said once about, you can object to the judge you get because when you file, you get assigned a judge. If you don't like that judge, you can ask for a new judge within a certain period of time. 00:22:48.1000000 That's a triggering event. How many of you, again, you don't have to raise your hands, I can't see you. But how many of you would have thought to calendar that deadline? Or would you just got the judge contemplated it for a while, then said, yeah, maybe, maybe not, but never actually physically calendered something because most likely, and most attorneys, they forget, like if they get a judge, they don't look at it until a week or two later because they're not the ones doing the filing, it's their assistant. And then when they pick up the file again, they see the judge. 00:23:19.4540000 Maybe by the time they pick up that file again, it's too late, it's past that deadline. So again, training the assistants to know the triggers, the less obvious and the more obvious of those triggering deadlines is important too. You also, that complaint can also trigger the last day to hold the case management conference. The first day of the defendant may move for summary judgment. There's going to be all these less obvious ones and then the blatant obvious one, which here was, you know, the service of process. 00:23:47.7600000 So look beyond just the next immediate step in a process to the big picture as a whole. All the way through trial. You should be preparing for trial day one, if that's the type of case it is, and not waiting until the last minute. Always think in your head, everything's going to trial, because if, if you do that, you're going to be prepared for anything. You're not going to miss deadlines, you're going to work up the case to where you're ready for settlements, you're ready for those things. 00:24:12.8280000 It may be a little extra effort put in along the way, but it's going to pay off in leaps and bounds, hopefully by the end of it. Always check those local rules and procedures, judges preferences, so, you know, dates, deadlines and timing with those triggering events. As I said at the beginning of the seminar, the local rules supplement the federal rules, and then the judges preferences supplement everything. You can go onto those Internets. Like I said, there's the example I used at the beginning to find those expectations of judges. 00:24:42.1220000 Again here. Tanya Walter Pratt. I'd love to use her as an example. I used to work for her when I was a law clerk, so that's why I always go back to, you know, kind of using her as an example in my seminar. But she has instructions on there for hyperlinks, promotions, requests, paper courtesy copies, what she wants done, supplemental filing, different things like that. 00:25:02.0160000 And so again, judges are going to have preferences to how they want stuff done. So always read the federal rules local, and then get into those judges preferences, time frames. This is just the steps triggering the timing. And I know I'm belaboring this, and this may seem very elementary and basic, but lawyers get in trouble almost every day for missing a deadline. And a lot of the excuses that you hear for it when it comes up on ethical violations or sanctions or, you know, they get turned into the disciplinary commission for it is, it wasn't on my calendar. 00:25:35.2040000 Well, why wasn't it on your calendar? If you know everything you file or receive from a court triggers something, why wasn't it on your calendar? And then the excuse you get to hear from them is my assistant didn't put it on there. Well, rule 5.3 of the rules of professional conduct tell us that us as attorneys are responsible for the actions of our non legal assistance. So if they mess up, we mess up. 00:26:00.8560000 So that's not an excuse. And so then what's the excuse? There is none. They missed the deadline. They weren't being responsible. 00:26:09.5280000 They weren't proactively thinking, they were not using proper time management. You probably have also a rule 1.3 procrastination violation in there, not acting with diligence. And so there's all of these ethical things that can come from not countering when that triggering event happens. So know your time frames, know the dates, know how to count the dates. We also need to know know, too, that if a deadline ends on a weekend or holiday, we skip to the next day, the court is open. 00:26:35.7160000 This is all from rule six. Rule six of the federal rules is your timing and procedure rules. So make sure you note that as well. So if we start calendaring, say I get a motion in today and I need to respond to it, say I have 30 days to respond, I start counting. Day one is tomorrow. 00:26:53.3320000 So I count, tomorrow is day one. Day two in consecutive order. If that day 30 ends on a holiday or weekend I skip to the next day, the quarters open. If that was on April 7 I skipped to April 8. Well some courts are closed on April 8 this year so guess what? 00:27:09.8860000 I skipped to April 9. If you don't know what April 8 is this year, it's the eclipse that's coming through, you know, the midwest and on up. So here in the midwest we have a lot of stuff closed on April 8. But again you need to know that, you know on a holiday weekend or another date the court is closed. You skip to the next day, the court's open for your deadline. 00:27:28.9600000 Method of service two can come into play as well if you are served by anything besides hand delivery. Rule six also tells us and it has what I call a Hail Mary provision in it. That's not the technical term, that's my verbiage for that. But the Hail Mary provision is if you are served by any means of service aside from hand delivery face to face you get an extra three days added to any deadline. So instead of 30 days to respond to motion for summary judgment you get 33 e filing. 00:27:58.5040000 That email, that trigger, that link is considered another form of filing. That's not hand person hand delivery face to face. That's like a mail delivery. So you get an extra three days. I call it the Hail Mary provision because I never calendar those three days. 00:28:14.5920000 I never have, I always just calendared the basic rule, the 30 days. The reason I don't calendar those extra three days or put them into my initial calculation from that triggering event is because I procrastinate. So I always want a buffer zone. I always want those last, you know, three days because when I get to that deadline I see it on my calendar, I'm going, oh no, oh no it's coming up, it's sitting here, it's been sitting here for 30 days. Stress management, you know, things are flying. 00:28:43.9180000 Your assistant's mad because now they feel like they're going to have to work late and then I'm like wait a second, we've got a Hail Mary provision, we've got an additional three days and so then it's not a means in your mind to further procrastinate but it gives you that little breathing room when things do come up and that, and sometimes I used to tell my assistant to, don't tell me you're not putting it in there. I know you're not going to put it in there but again I don't operate under the assumption I have those three days. I operate under the assumption I don't. And so that is how, you know, you make sure you don't get that procrastination with those extra three days. That timing rule right here, timing rule six, what I was just talking about is on the screen in front of you for your materials for the seminar here today. 00:29:25.0600000 You can read it there. That middle paragraph talks about how if you land on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, then you go to the next day the court is open. If there's weather conditions or other reasons the court are closed, you go to the next day the court is open. So you could actually, you know, have a four or five day weekend, you know, holidays and everything else. And you don't get an extra three or four days on deadline because your deadline cannot be on a date that the court is closed. 00:29:51.4940000 So you just need to remember that for the computation. When it comes to timing rule six, this is the Hail Mary provision I was talking about. Whenever a party has the right or is required to do some act or take some proceedings within a prescribed period after the service of notice of paper upon the party and the notice of property served under rule five b, two, B, C or D, you get a three additional dates. So that's any type of service aside from hand delivery face to face. So that is what I call the Hail Mary. 00:30:23.6340000 Let's add another three days. If for some reason your triggering event triggers something and you calendar out those deadlines and you realize, hey, wait a second, I'm going to be in the Bahamas. I can't get that done. Or, you know, that deadline falls on my child's birthday or, you know, your anniversary or it calls on something to where you have something else going on, maybe another trial, maybe something. Do not procrastinate, do not wait till the deadline comes up to file a motion for extension of time, file the motion for extension or enlargement of time immediately because technically you do not get an extension of time as a matter of right. 00:31:02.8300000 So if you file it the day before something's due, if the judge hasn't ruled on it by the deadline, you're saying it's still due. Until a judge rules on it, it is still due. Now a lot of attorneys operate under the assumption that it's going to be granted and if it's denied the court will be nice and give them an extra few days to get it on file anyway, which in some courts, yes, that does happen. But technically if you don't have a judge's ruling on an extension of time by the deadline, the original deadline, your thing is still due. So you need to file extensions for time early, not late. 00:31:36.3860000 And if you think about it, well, I don't know until last minute. You do know in some circumstance if that triggering event comes, your assistant goes and puts it on the calendar and your assistant sees, oh, they're going to be out on vacation, they need to alert you, say, hey, do you want me to file an extension for time on this? Or hey, just so you know, this deadline falls here. And a lot of times it's that communication that's lacking between assistant and attorney because the assistant sees it and they're like, well, the attorney will see it eventually. I'll just wait till he tells me what to do. 00:32:07.0860000 No assistant needs to communicate with attorney so that we know. And so that comes with proper training, having a good assistance, being very vigilant, not procrastinating on those things so that we get things there. Common mistakes that are made with this realm for getting to calendar in general, not do not know to calendar. Some people don't know how to count the days. There is actually different filing systems or different programs you can purchase that can calendar for you. 00:32:36.6340000 But again, human beings can also do it themselves. Just depends on how much money you want to spend. Don't know the rules. You don't know that response to summer judgment is 30 days. Maybe you think it's 45. 00:32:47.7380000 Well, you're probably wrong. So knowing the rules, going back and reading the rules, keeping up to date on any amendments or changes to rules too, because it was 20, I think 16 or 18, I can't remember which one. Now the federal rules change, we went from 120 days for something to 90. And so they shortened deadlines and they expanded others. And so you've also got to stay just on top of rule changes coming in. 00:33:13.6020000 So you can't just learn once and think you know everything. You've got to stay up on those changes to the rules as well. Another error we've seen before is forgetting how many days are in a month, 28, you know, February, that short month and leap year get us, or not knowing, you know, there's 31 days in October or different things that can really get us to miss counting of days, maybe skipping weekends when you shouldn't, just in your general consecutive count. Weekends not only come into play if that's the due date. So you've got to know those different nuances. 00:33:44.5100000 Some cases here which are just, you know, you can see attorneys get in trouble. An assistant missed a deadline requesting a trial de novo from the day the award was received. And so the day it was filed, attorney's going to be in trouble for that. And was in trouble for that. And it prejudiced the client. 00:33:58.0960000 Attorney missed a deadline because he forgot that October had 31 days, not 30. Again, one day matters prejudice his client didn't get to file the complaint. It can have very harsh effects and it can hurt your client, which is going to bring malpractice claims. And so you need to be very careful. Calendaring errors don't sit well with judges either. 00:34:20.6500000 The entire brief, this was, you know, counting of days, miscounted days on a calendar. Judges are like, this is basic. This is back to the basics. Let's learn how to count. You're going to get in trouble or not get leeway from judges anymore in most jurisdictions, not everywhere. 00:34:37.5620000 In some of those instances, just some tips here to remember this. Electronic notices. Check your, check your email every morning, afternoon, evening, five or six times a day. Day. If your assistant say, well, I just check it in the morning, no, morning, noon, and evening before you leave, three times right there. 00:34:54.5680000 And then do like a mid morning, mid afternoon, too. Five times a day. Just get in there. Calendar and don't like, a lot of people are like, oh, I'll get to that later. And then they open it, they close it, they let it feed down in their email. 00:35:08.0320000 Well, what happens is those keep pushing down and pushing down and pushing down, and then two weeks go by and you're like, oh, need to go clean out my email. And so you start from the bottom and work your way up. You could have missed a deadline by then. Two weeks is some deadlines we need to calendar right then and there. So if your assistant or you does not have time to calendar when you start going through those emails, don't go through them. 00:35:30.8120000 Leave them highlighted, leave them unread, leave them top priority calendar right then and there on the Hail Mary, you can decide what you want to do with that on calendaring. Those extensions of time, let's get them in calendar items to not just deadline. On motion for summary judgment. What can case, what's the client's name? What's the case number? 00:35:52.9480000 What's the file number? I can't tell you how many times I've had an attorney come to me and they said, you know, well, the assistant put it on there, but she just said, motion for summary judgment. So I didn't know what case it was. It's like, yeah, we got a little more information. Maybe you can even attach the email to the calendar invite. 00:36:11.8600000 You can do that. You can attach Neil to a calendar invite. I then you can open the calendar invite, open the email to where it originated from and see the case, see the what it is and you know, go from there too. And if you download it and save the filing, you can attach it as well. Some of the other things. 00:36:28.5220000 These are some of the programs you can purchase. There's an add on feature called Law Toolbox for Microsoft 365. It's the number one legal add on. It is an add on. I have never used it. 00:36:38.3700000 I've never worked at a firm or felt like it necessary for me to use this or have purchased it for me. So I'm not endorsing any of these over another one. I'm just giving you some options that are out there. You can use this to add deadlines to outlook Teams case management platforms. It can prevent those missed deadlines, gives you notifications on rule changes as well. 00:36:57.6620000 It's a very useful tool. I've heard from those who have used it. It can automate procedural deadlines as well through your emails as they're coming in. Manage manners, calendars, files, notes I do recommend you work in a larger law firm, mid sized firm, or just with any other lawyer, and you're working on the same cases. Have a shared calendar, have two eyes on it. 00:37:18.9440000 Have a litigation calendar maybe, and then a personal calendar. Have like a case calendar and that so that if you miss a deadline or you're out, then that shared calendar. Your partner, your other attorneys and your firm, your associates, whoever it is, can see, hey, that's coming up. Someone needs to do it. Who's doing it on the team? 00:37:38.7360000 Who's doing it in the office. And so if you have those shared cases, those shared I things, then you need to think about those as well. Some other options for calendaring and just for case management. Good old hand calculations. Go back to pen and paper. 00:37:53.4460000 Get the math that sits on your desk. Get a pen. Start going 1234. Even mark 1234. Just keep it going throughout. 00:38:02.3260000 There's another one that I've heard about. Practice Panther legal software clio. I know a lot of attorneys use clio. My case. Some needs that too. 00:38:10.7020000 Cosmo smart advocate lidify legal files rocket matter Reich Abacus law there are so many out there. If you just did a Google search for like litigation countering tools or lawyer tools for deadlines, you are going to get a whole host of suggestions for you. You can parse through them. These are usually cost something. There may be a free trial at first, but there's going to probably be a cost associated with the use of a lot of these. 00:38:42.4700000 So make sure you look at those as well. Some other topics for federal courts, just jurisdiction and venue. We're going to review some of that here today as well, if you're not familiar, which hopefully being lawyers, we all are. But I will say I do teach law students, and I taught first year law students in the fall of 2022. It was torts class I was teaching. 00:39:04.2380000 And we were about two weeks into the semester, and one of the students raised their hand and they said, professor, I know this is going to sound terrible, but a lot of us don't know the court systems. And I said, what are you talking about? And they didn't know, you know, what a district court was or appellate court, because law students don't come from political science or, you know, those backgrounds. They come from a host of all different backgrounds. And so they've never taken a government class. 00:39:30.0400000 They never taken a court class. So I spent a whole day, two hour lecture on our court system. So while you may think it's basic, there are law students out there who are soon to be lawyers that did not know this going into becoming choosing the profession. So we are studying the federal courts, which we have our district courts, our court of appeals, which is our circuits all the way up to the Supreme Court. On the state side, we have our state trial courts based on, you know, usually one per county. 00:39:57.1200000 Sometimes there's more than that per county, too. Then your state court of appeals more centralized, your supreme courts, one in each state all the way up to the Supreme Court, if they accept jurisdiction ever. We know the Supreme Court of the United States does not accept everything that comes to it, rightfully so. They get to hand choose and pick what they want to hear. But if you just needed a refresher, you can see that on the screen in front of them. 00:40:18.5580000 The ways to get into federal courts when we're filing that initial complaint through the ECF filing system is the first way is federal question federal jurisdiction, federal question the court. The Constitution has granted certain cases or given the federal government certain right to hear and be over certain cases. And then obviously, if the federal law is in the, then we can get into federal court that way. If not, then we have to go under diversity jurisdiction, which you have to have both, all your plaintiffs and defendants from different states or domiciled in different states. And then the mountain controversy over 75,000. 00:40:56.7960000 You have to have both requirements, not just one. That's the other way to get into federal court. This type of jurisdiction, subject matter jurisdiction, either federal or diversity, cannot be waived at any time. If that jurisdiction goes away, say if you're there on diversity and then that's dismissed out or someone moves or the amount goes under 75,000, the federal court can say you're gone. If you're there because you have one federal claim, no diversity, just one federal question. 00:41:24.0840000 One federal claim under federal law. For instance, I was litigating a bullying case at one point, so we had a title seven and title nine claim. They got dismissed out. That was the only thing keeping us in federal court were those two claims. When they got dismissed out on summary judgment, the federal court pushed us back down to the state court, said we no longer have jurisdiction, and so suic the court can raise if you don't have that subject subject matters jurisdiction on its own federal courts, again, you have to have that diversity. 00:41:56.4700000 Everyone on the right side of the v and the left side of the v from different states domicile at different locations or federal question at that point with diversity too, you have to have that amount of controversy over 75,000. Anything else is reserved to the states. You do have to plead what type of jurisdiction you're under on the face of that complaint that we talked to about originally, you know, when we file something. So you need to state, I'm here on federal question under x and x law. I'm here because of this. 00:42:25.1540000 This creates a federal question. These are my claims. You need to state that jurisdictional statement within the complaint. If you're there on diversity, you need to say how you exceed 75,000 or that potentially you do, and that everyone's from different states. Now, I will tell you, some people, if you remember, do not like federal court. 00:42:43.8200000 I was actually working at one point for an attorney, and I was a young associate. I may have actually still been like a law clerk at some point there in this too. But I remember that the defendant wanted to remove the case to federal court. They wanted to remove it because they said there was diversity jurisdiction. Everyone was from different, you know, states. 00:43:05.7120000 They said, amount of controversy is potentially going to be under over 75,000. And I was working on the plaintiff side, and I remember my boss at the time saying, no, we're only claiming $74,999 because he did not want to be federal court that bad. And that is what he pled on a complaint. That is what he reasserted when defendants tried to say it was bogus in front of the court. And the court said he's stuck with that. 00:43:34.2200000 But it's in state court. And so the amount settled. It was not over 75,000 when it settled because again, we only asked for in our relief, $74,999. So you really do have to have that $75,000 requirement, requirement to get that diversity jurisdiction into the federal court system. All of their cases, we push them down into state court, bankruptcy, and there are specialty cases. 00:44:02.3560000 Bankruptcy is a federal, but there's a special bankruptcy system, obviously, intellectual property, federal, separate system for that as well. Small claims court is a state normally for claims under $10,000 in most locations. Some may have other amount that they do. Some places may not even have small claims court. But here in Indiana, normally a smallest claim court is in each county. 00:44:23.7980000 For any claim under $10,000, 10,000 or less is all you're claiming. Then you can go to their quicker procedure. You'll see a lot more pro se. It can resolve those little, you know, maybe lease disputes, those things, without having to do a formal filing, go through the whole court process. You know, do case management orders. 00:44:42.0700000 You just file, you get a date, you go argue in front of a small claim show. There's usually a ruling or hearing soon thereafter. So again, a little abbreviated process, too, for that. Vinu tells us which state or county we're going to file in. So in federal court, it's going to tell us which federal court do we file in? 00:45:00.7840000 Do we file in district court, southern District of Indiana, the northern District? Or do we go over to Illinois or Ohio or somewhere else? So where you look for this is where did the accident or event occur? Where did the defendants reside? If neither one of those are good locations, you can go where the plaintiff lives. 00:45:18.3200000 But we always defer to where the accident occurred or the defendants reside. If they are domiciled and reside in different states, you may have some options. Or if they're domiciled on, reside in one state and the accident occurred in another state, then you could have some options there, too. But you always try to find the convenience of the person you're suing or the convenience of the witnesses. That's why you go to those, wherever those locations are. 00:45:42.5600000 Kind of tells you which state, which county, which court you're going to file in, and then you go through that system. Sometimes you have the option if you have both state and federal claims or if you have diversity, you don't have to go in federal court just because you have diversity. And a lot of litigants don't. They say, no, I still want to keep it in state court. I have all state court claims. 00:46:02.6940000 Yeah, we have diversity, but I don't want to be there. So the plaintiff will file in state court initially, and they take all kinds of things into consideration in making that determination, such as filing fees, proximity, discovery, summary judgment, differences, all kinds of differences between the system, as you can see her on the screen. But just because the plaintiff wants it to stay in state, if there is diversity or federal question, the defendant still has the right to remove it. And that's what happened in that example I told you about where we claimed $74,999. The defendant was like, no, wait a second, I want this in federal court. 00:46:43.1380000 We said, no, we want this in state court. And so we kind of broke that diversity to keep it in state court. But they did have the right to remove it if they technically wanted to. So with that removal, though, the defendant can remove something to federal court out of the state court if they have. There's federal question or diversity if the plaintiff files, because sometimes you have the option and it's just not one person gets to decide or one litiganthe. 00:47:13.0840000 You each get kind of a bite at that apple. But ultimately the defendant has the right to remove it. If it's removable, you can argue against as a plaintiff, but again, they do have the right to remove it. So again, for the removal of an action from state to federal court, defendant would file a notice to remove the case. So when they get served that triggers, do they want to remove it? 00:47:33.1300000 There's deadlines for that too. It's a triggering event. And then once they figure that out, they look at, you know, what is needed for remove. Was it filed wrong? Is there diversity? 00:47:42.9980000 Is there federal question? And then they do they follow the procedures in place under 28 USC 1441 is just the general removal statute. Or if there's other local rules, they can do that too. You can too post, try to remand it back down again. You can, you know, if they remove it, you can remand it back down. 00:48:04.8780000 Timing and procedures can be found there as well. This is Jess. I know we are winding down here in the last ten minutes or so of the seminar. Just going to go over some more basics regarding pleadings, answers and things. We've already talked about a lot of these. 00:48:18.6380000 If you hear the phrase pleading or if you're learning, you know, litigation terminology for the first time or refreshing again, back to basics. Complain, answer, cross claims, counterclaims, third party claims, these are all pleadings. This is what makes up the pleadings. Your discovery does not make up the pleadings. Your emotions for summary judgment does not make up the pleadings. 00:48:37.7420000 Pleadings are complaint answer, crossing third party. So all those initial things that start the litigation is what makes up our pleadings. These are determined through rules seven through 15. The complaint sets forth the allegations. It's kind of like the gossip, like, here's what happened to me. 00:48:54.6460000 Here's what I'm claiming this person did. Kind of like you're telling, you know someone, you're spilling the tea. Let's put it that way. That's, I guess, the new kid terminology. You're spilling the tea everywhere is what you're doing with it. 00:49:06.7300000 Some things, when you're drafting it, most jurisdictions have what are called notice pleading jurisdictions. All you need is a short, plain statement of the allegations that you have against the defendants and what you're claiming. You don't need details. You don't need supporting documents. You don't need all those facts and things, just short, plain statements about the allegations. 00:49:26.6100000 And so once you have all those put in place, you can obviously serve it. You also need to put in there, too. What you're claiming, is it breach of contract? Is it, you know, personal injury? Are you claiming emotional distress? 00:49:40.9960000 You need to put those in there as well. So you're going to put out, you know, the facts that happened. Brief, short statement, the allegations, which are going to be known as your counts. And then two, why you win. And so you can state the laws that you're going under, why you win. 00:49:55.5160000 Obviously, you also need that jurisdictional statement in there to say why you're in federal court. That's what you're going to put forward. Basics of that, names, the parties, the status, the court. And then the court will stamp it with a docket number since that point forwards. You always put that docket number on any document you file. 00:50:13.5900000 The counts are also known as the allegations. This is where you say, here's all the laws this person broke. Here's the facts that supported. Here's all the laws or things they broke, or through negligence or whatever it is. These are usually numbered out. 00:50:25.9900000 Count one, count two, count three. You know, you have a negligence of redemption contract, emotional stress, depending on what you have on down. So you just kind of format it in a very cohesive manner because the defendant's got to answer it, and they're going to go through each line, each number, paragraph, and admit, deny, or say they don't have enough information. Most defendants just deny the whole thing outright, just deny, deny, deny. Some say they don't have enough information to answer because they're just put on notice. 00:50:51.6100000 There's no discovery yet. Some admit some stuff, which is always surprising when it happens. But again, that's a possibility as well. If you are in more of a fact pleading jurisdiction, then you need to have specific facts. You need to have the narrowed issues. 00:51:06.7520000 Some jurisdictions, if you are going to have expert medical testimony or more of a men malpractice claim, you have to attach the medical malpractice doctor's report or the expert report to the complaint. So you need to think about those things as well. You also need to, if you're the one being served when you're reading this, think about defenses. You can file a twelve e motion if you don't think it's notice enough or they haven't met the fact pleading. If you're in a fact pleading, you could file the motion to dismiss. 00:51:36.8200000 If they fail to state a claim, like the facts and the law, there's no claim there. It's frivolous. So when you're a defendant and you get this, you really need to read it and see if you understand it and know the allegations against you. And if they're founded in law, if they're not, then you have those potential defenses under rule twelve, like twelve e, twelve b, six different things to fight against plaintiffs. Two, as I've said before, put your prayer for relief. 00:52:00.9320000 What do you want? Money? Restitution? What do you want? You got to put it there. 00:52:06.7160000 Everything we file is verified by the party or attorney of record, meaning when you sign a document and file with court, you are attesting that everything in there is true to the best of your knowledge. You're not lying. You're not lying to the courts, you're not falsifying anything. You verify everything going forward. For that answer, we either, again, again, we can put up defenses. 00:52:29.0320000 We can do counterclaims, cross claims for third party claims, or we can just answer it by the short, plain statements of admit, deny or not enough information. Usually your answer mirrors the complaint. Obviously, you go line by line by line. That's why they're numbered paragraphs in the complaint. And then you assert any affirmative defense of counterclaims, cross claims, third party claims you have at the bottom, or you can also do those in a separate document. 00:52:54.5680000 You don't have to do them all the same one, but admit, deny, lack sufficient knowledge or information to admit or deny are going to be the things any cross claims or counterclaims that come through. Counterclaims are those where the defendant has claims back against the plaintiff if you did not know what that term meant. So if you, the plaintiff sees you and you're like, wait a second, you wrong me too, and you want to sue the plaintiff back. That can be a counterclaim. You can do it in the same lawsuit, or you can file a separate one. 00:53:20.2860000 Sometimes court like him condensed if they're rising out of the same case and controversy, cross claims can come apart to say there's more than one defendant sued, and you feel that you have claims against your co defendants. You can have cross claims, you know there as well. And so again, you can sue a co party, a co defendant, someone else in the lawsuit, you can assert those claims as well. Third party claims can also come into play, too. Third party complaints are appropriate in circumstances where a party is not listed as a defendant, but they're more liable. 00:53:52.2120000 Say, for instance, the plaintiff only knew that you were liable to say, wait a second, it's not just me, it's Joe over here, too. Why isn't Joe name in this lawsuit as the defendant? You can bring in that third party and sue him for indemnification or say he's more liable than you or do your own cross claim against him. You know, once you bring him in, and then the plaintiff can, you know, come down and sue him as well. But if you feel someone's more liable, if you're defendant, bring him into the party, get those third parties in there more, you know, more the merrier at that point. 00:54:21.9600000 Any amendments to complaints or answers out of subtract parties? You can normally do once as a matter, or, you know, in the normal course, so long as an answer has not been filed. Once an answer has been filed, though, you do need to seek allowance or permission from the court at that point. If you're going to amend the complaint, we don't have time to go over briefs and motions in detail, so I'll just kind of hit the highlights for the last part of this. The rules, default judgment, summary judgment, new trial, relief for judgment. 00:54:49.4440000 These are some of the main rules that you're going to see on motions. Rule 56. Usually, summary judgments happen in almost every litigation, so start to familiarize yourself with that rule, too. If you get a default judgment against you, meaning you didn't file the answer in time, and there's a default judgment setting it aside, relief from judgment would fall under rule 60. If you're the plaintiff seeking that, you know, defendant's not responsible, then you go to rule 55. 00:55:14.2640000 But these are ones to kind of tag and know that. Are there other things to think about in federal court? Preparing for hearings and conferences, obviously, be prepared. Know the rules, organize everything, develop an agenda, kind of know what the other side is going to say. Do your legal research, you know, expert witness preparation, presenting evidence. 00:55:34.4320000 Just know what the other side is kind of going to say before you get in there. And always remember too, professionalism and being appropriate in our words and actions. Actions is huge. Courtroom etiquette and professionalism, punctuality, communication, being nice to oppose and counsel, active listening. Don't be sitting in there going like this the whole time on your phone. 00:55:54.4480000 Think about how distracting that is to the judge if your clients in there, what that looks like, and to opposing counsel. So just having that courtroom etiquette, that professionalism, plan for the unexpected, have contingency plans for everything. No, to document, to follow up, to reflect, to have what I call action out reviews. It's a military term. You know, something goes wrong or you know you went to a hearing, you're like, we could have done that better. 00:56:21.0200000 Let's sit down and have an after action review. Let's put out what's good, what's bad, what do we want to do next time? What do we want to change? Those are things to think about as well. Just be organized in your client files too. 00:56:32.0360000 I provided in the materials here, just consistency and organization. Clear labels document everything, keep stuff together, notes, everything else. Billing and records, conflicts, summaries. Organize, organize, organize. Label makers are fun. 00:56:47.2020000 Separate folders are great if you're all electronic, you know, separate folders within the system also good use. Just think about those things too. If you do paper, always have a digital backup. People management is half of litigation and half of the court process as well. Learn how to manage people. 00:57:06.9220000 Managing people does not mean telling them what to do or being the bully or the boss. Managing people means conflict resolution, team collaboration, maintaining good relationships, being professional, being punctual, treating people how you would want to be treated, and then also to making them feel like they're part of the team. Because that case management and preparation for trial is all a team effort. So you want to be part of the team. Your staff wants to be part of the team. 00:57:35.9900000 Your paralegal wants to feel important, your assistant wants to feel, feel that you value their opinions and their contributions. That all comes from their professionalism. That all comes from those things. If you have any questions or anything else, please let me know. Happy to answer those. 00:57:51.9360000 My information is on the screen in front of you. And with that, you have finished your hour cle. So I hope everyone has a great rest of your day. Thank you.