[Course Name] 00:00:00.8000000 Hi, I'm Nathan Motor with London Motor Advisors, and I'm here to speak on a court case that I was involved with regarding area 51, a very exciting case known as the United States of America versus 400 acres of land, otherwise known as the Nevada test and training range, NTTR. And the question that was ultimately asked in this case is, is how much is land worth? What is the value of land inside of this secret military base? My company is London Motor Advisors, and to give you a little background, which leads into how we got involved in this case is we are market analysts. My partner and I founded this company. 00:00:49.0180000 We've worked together for several decades now, and we are market economists and financial consultants. So our primary business is market studies, financial studies for real estate development projects. Most of our clients are developers, lenders, investors, and we get involved with underwriting the economics, the market analysis for all real estate land uses. So residential, industrial, office, hotel, we've done boat, marina studies, freeway studies, anything that's a real estate land use, we've analyzed. We also do public sector work for cities and other entities that may own real estate or have real estate issues. 00:01:34.8540000 And from time to time we get called in to be expert witnesses for court cases. But the primary source of our business, the majority of it is market and feasibility studies for real estate. I also have teaching experience going back to 2002, over 20 years, teaching market analysis and financial analysis for real estate. My current post for the last six years has been at UCSD, where I teach undergrads. I'm a lecturer there on financial analysis for real estate projects and the development process. 00:02:09.9040000 The entitlement, the planning, how to take a piece of land and then end up with a building at the end of the day. Some of the court cases that we've been involved with in our testimony revolves around financial damages. So lost profits, lost rents, lost revenue, specifically as it relates to discounted cash flows, financial pro formas, appropriate discount rates to come up with net present values. That's really my expertise. We get involved with construction defect litigation, leases being breached, partnership disputes, eminent domain, trespass issues. 00:02:46.8940000 We've done FINRA cases other than financial damages. We really get called in to testify as to how the real estate industry works and what's common practice in the real estate industry, especially as it results or relates to planning and entitlements. Exclusive negotiating agreements, development disposition agreements, tentative maps, final maps, EiR, that whole process. How does the valuation change of real estate projects? At certain points of the planning process, we also get involved with compensation for real estate professionals when there's disputes for that property managers, development partners that want equity in a deal versus being paid an hourly rate. 00:03:32.0220000 As a consultant, we get used quite often alongside appraisers. We are not appraisers. I am not Mai. We are the real world test of feasibility. Our developer clients is the way that we view real estate as well. 00:03:50.6920000 Its through the lens of a developer and an investor and a lender, where they do the science of running the financial pro formas, looking at the market data and actually calculating what the true value of land is. So we get called into court cases to add validity to appraisals to show that they are feasible in the real world real estate market. Other businesses that, that we've testified on and we've worked on are, you know, data centers valuing medical patents, other types of businesses, just general business valuation. We've done analysis for. And then of course from time to time there's economic loss and lost wages for compensation cases. 00:04:31.3440000 Somebody gets hurt on the job and there's an economic value of that working life. So as a background, that's pretty much what we do. The majority of our business, again, is mainly the private sector work, developers and investors. And I'd say less than half is expert witness testimony. 00:05:02.2940000 So I'd like to just start with a disclaimer that this presentation that I put together is based on my role in the case, my understanding of the case, understanding the documents. I was intimately involved with the attorneys, not only for my own, for my own testimony, but also to help them strategize and look at the bigger picture and help them digest what other experts are trying to opine on. So this presentation is just an overview of the facts and issues specifically for the approach of methodology of valuing this property. There's other factors that were discussed in this case. An appraiser also testified in this case for USDOJ. 00:05:50.6040000 I'm not going to cover what was all, what was all discussed and testified there. I'm going to testify to my role. And so there is additional context. I want to be clear about that. That's not included in this presentation. 00:06:06.5640000 So let's move into the case here. And this case is 400 acres of land. So what was happening here is just to go back and give context is October 17, 1984, the US government had a land withdrawal. So the US government withdrew 89,600 acres of federal land from the public. This is around the military base that is known as area 51. 00:06:36.6440000 So too many people were hiking over onto the ridge areas looking into the secret military base. So in 1984, the government said, no more. We're going to withdraw land from the public because we don't want people hiking to the ridge and looking at our operations of what we're doing there. If you look at this area on a Google map or you drive out to the area, which is pretty out there, area 51 is unique because it's a mountain range, but it's fully enclosed almost in a circle, so there's no clear line of sight. It's basically a circle mountain range that is very, very large. 00:07:13.3440000 So the US government identified this piece of property to do a military base here because they can fly back and forth and nobody will be able to see inside. So that's why this had a unique opportunity for the military. But in 84, they said, too many people are still coming onto the land, so we're going to withdraw 89,600 acres at this point in time. In 1984, approximately 400 acres of land were not withdrawn. They let that land remain. 00:07:45.2100000 This is known as the groom mine. It's also known as the Sheehan property. The reason this land was left and not withdrawn from the public is because it had patented and unpatented mining claims. And so the government said, we'll just let this one be. So essentially what the government did is they created a doughnut hole. 00:08:06.0380000 This property was landlocked, so there's no access except for a government road. But the government made a deal with the property owners, and the government said that they could access their property as well as business. Visitors can access their property, although the mine was actually destroyed by an explosion in the 1950s. So here we are in 1984, there's no real business going on. There was already an explosion in the 1950s, but the government said, we'll still work with the property owners. 00:08:37.2220000 They can still access their property, and they can use the access row that comes in, that the air force uses. So when the family and visitors actually came to the property after 1984, the air force would cease their operations. They would politely hide all their aircraft. They would clear off the runways. So when the family was at the property, using it or enjoying it for whatever their use is, everything is gone. 00:09:07.4360000 No cars, no. No aircraft, nothing. You see a Runway and there's a couple buildings. And so the air force just completely shut down. Typically or historically? 00:09:19.9640000 My understanding is the family that I think they owned this back in the 18 hundreds. So they were there before the government. And so the family would go out there in the eighties and the nineties, and now we're talking about the grandkids and all the other siblings and kin that would just go out, maybe just pick a weekend, maybe three or four times a year, and they would just reminisce about times when they would come out there as kids. So there's not a lot of structures. It's an old abandoned mine. 00:09:50.5440000 There's wet dynamite on the site. There's shafts that are still there. And there's one cabin, maybe two cabins, but, you know, really, really rundown and basic. So here's a map just to show you where this property is. So the. 00:10:12.8560000 The big tan, which says 67 miles, that. That big dry lake bed, that's the groom lake below that is what is known as area 51. And you can see the Runway strip there, and you can see some buildings on. On the side. On the left side. 00:10:30.6240000 And then six to 7 miles away is this groom mine. That area in red is the subject property that was being valued to get into this property. You can see on the very far right, there's a guard security. This is the security checkpoint. So there's. 00:10:48.9520000 Around this area is where the gate is. You can drive up to the gate of Area 51, and the guard's going to stop you. But this is the check in point where security is. And if you just follow the line kind of just a little bit down to the. Through that mountain range, you see where the access road is. 00:11:06.0200000 There's an access road that's pointing. So that goes up to the guard gate, and it goes down in front of the groom mine. To get to Area 51, you have to go actually around the groom lake, around the lake bed. So you go around it and past it on the left hand side, and then you come down, and that is how you get to Area 51. So to access the groom mine site, you take the access road, and then as soon as you're directly south of the groom mine, there's a little service road that goes straight up. 00:11:36.8680000 And so that's all that the family would be allowed to do is go from the security checkpoint onto their property. They're not allowed to leave their property. No visitors are allowed to leave their property. And again, this property is six to 7 miles away with the direct line of sight of the military base. So what this case involves is the US condemns the groom mine on September 10, 2015. 00:12:03.4940000 And the reason they condemned it is my understanding, is that the US Air force flies so many missions. They have missions scheduled. We work with a lot of international countries as well in training and whatnot. So they were falling behind on missions, and so they couldn't afford time of shutting down, clearing off the runways to allow the family come out there on certain weekends. So they just decided to condemn the property. 00:12:32.4740000 Now, in eminent domain and condemnation cases, the law says that you must be compensated fair market value for the property. So if the government's taking this 400 acres of land, what is the value of this property? So of the 400 acres, the landowners retained legal rights. So this is similar to fee simple interest in 87.49 acres of mining claims. So therefore, what was the focus of this case is what's the value of the 87.49 acre property? 00:13:06.0340000 Because that's the one that would have the equivalent of fee simple interest as of September 10, 2015. To hear this case, us federal court in Nevada assembled a land commission in early 2020, and this land commission consisted of two retired judges and one retired state Supreme Court justice. To hear this, it was not a jury taught trial. It was a land commission that heard this case. 00:13:37.3540000 On this slide, I want to discuss some of the themes that I will be covering, and these are the major themes of the case. Again, this isn't a comprehensive list, but these were the major ones. The first one that I'm going to go through is the foundation in valuation having a basis for valuation. And what that means is, are the assumptions defensible that go into a valuation model or evaluation analysis. What is the empirical market data? 00:14:06.9520000 There has to be market data. There has to be something that you can prove, as well as what's the proper methodology for valuing this type of property. Another issue that I will be sharing is the legally permissible use. This was a major issue in the case is what are you allowed to use the property as? Does it have the requirement, the required zoning in order to operate what wanted to be operated here? 00:14:34.4820000 Does it have the entitlements? What would it take to get entitlements approval or the permits? When I say legal use, I want to be very clear. That's why I put an asterisk. I get this a lot of time on court cases where they try to say that I'm making a legal opinion on something regarding real estate. 00:14:51.5940000 I want to be very clear that I've never made a legal opinion regarding real estate. I leave that up to the attorneys and the courts to figure out. When I say legally permissible use, what I mean is, through the lens of a developer, an investor, a lender, how would they view what the property is allowed to be used as? That's also legally permissible use. So it's not a legal opinion. 00:15:16.5340000 I'm saying legally, what would they be allowed to do underneath the real estate land use law. The other thing that I will cover is hypothetical buyer and investor considerations. So if somebody was to buy this property, the date of value of September 10, 2015, how would they evaluate the risk associated with this purchase? And what's the certainty of the purchase and of all the factors that affect this purchase? And then, would there be any requirements in order to purchase this property? 00:15:50.0260000 What else would a prospective buyer ask or consider? I will also touch on proper rebuttal testimony and then also valuation concepts. This was a significant issue in the case as well, is what's the difference between fair market value, which is what a lot of appraisers use when they're doing their valuation, and investment value? What's the difference between those two concepts? So, this next slide, I will just give an overview on the story of Area 51. 00:16:23.5180000 And I also want to disclose that all of these slides are pretty much word for word an accurate depiction of what was discussed or written in various reports in this court case. So that's where I drew all of these slides from. So, area 51 ultra secret military base. So the air force acquired the site in 1955, during the onset of the Cold War. 1940. 00:16:54.6760000 519 89. So this legend of Area 51 began after the 1960s. This is the Oxcart program which was disclosed by the CIA. This program flew over 2800 test flights on aircraft that was often mistaken as a UFO. So these are some of the other images of the. 00:17:19.1840000 The aircraft that were flown in this area and tested as well before they went out into service. But these planes were fast. During the Oxcart program, they were 2000 miles an hour. They were flat, they were silver, and they went really fast to evade radar detection. This is what people were reportedly seeing, or airline pilots saying, something's moving really fast and it's silver. 00:17:44.3240000 This is what they are referring to. CIA finally acknowledged the existence of this base in 2013. But up to that point in time, there was denial that it even existed, which created quite a lot of pop culture around it. So the UFO alien phenomenon regarding area 51 really initiated. In 1989, a man by the name Bob Lazarus claimed that he reversed engineered alien aircraft on this base. 00:18:15.5640000 The media and the tourists just flocked to the area. There was a lot of interest in the area. In 1996, the state of Nevada declared that SR 375, which is the major highway out there in the area, they renamed it to extraterrestrial highway. They wanted to cash in on this marketing opportunity to try to bring people to the area. This is not the first time metropolitans or municipalities have. 00:18:41.7880000 Have done this kind of a strategy, either. So this space, again, it was secret until 2013. Another UFO phenomenon that kind of created this whole enthusiasm about aliens is the Roswell. Roswell was 1947. There was a newspaper headline, it was in the newspapers suggesting that a flying saucer was captured on the Roswell army airfield. 00:19:12.8140000 It got a lot of headlines, but after that, there is not a lot of interest in the story anymore to revive this. And now that area 51 was getting some notice and some media attention as of 1989. In 94, Mayor Jennings of Roswell decided to market this city as the UFO capital of the world. The whole effort was to boost tourism and visitors. This is exactly what Loch Ness, the town of Loch Ness in Scotland, did as well. 00:19:46.7960000 They realized that there's a story about a monster in the lake, Loch Ness monster. So they really capitalized that to bring tourism. So this is a strategy that cities use, is how can they bring tourist dollars, get their economy going. And again, this was kind of creating the story and phenomenon surrounding Area 51. So with that as a background, I'd like to move into how this property was viewed, and I'll talk about the landowners experts. 00:20:16.3260000 The landowners part of the case. So, from the landowners perspective, the property attributes are as follows. This property is the only privately held property inside Area 51 with a view of the secret military base. In addition, this property has an agreement with the US government that allows the landowners to access the property for themselves and any business visitors. I put business in quotes because the document itself says it has to be business visitors. 00:20:48.6840000 Even though the mine had already exploded, there are no restrictions on the number of visitors whatsoever that the owners can have at the property in that agreement. So they could have as many people as they want. They also suggested that there's high demand, thanks to pop culture and alien enthusiasts, to actually see area 51. 00:21:15.6140000 So the landowners valuation on the next slide here for 87.49 acres of land. The fee simple aspect is the owners said that on September 10, 2015, that the owners could have sold the property to an acquirer or an investor, who would in turn, ground lease the property to a tourist commercial operator. The operator would pay a ground rent to the new owner of the property, and that ground rent would be 10% of the gross revenues. So this would create about four to $5 million of net annual income for the new owner of the property under this ground lease. And when you apply a cap rate of 8.5% to this cap rate, because value of a real estate asset is generally noi, net operating income divided by a cap rate gives you a value that's the approach that was used in this analysis. 00:22:19.2840000 So how do we get to the four to $5 million of annual net revenue? That third bullet point shows the gross revenues were determined as follows. They assumed that 250 visitors would be on the property daily. They would have five buses bringing people to the property, 50 people on every bus. The ticket price would be $400 per visitor. 00:22:42.8740000 Plus there would be, call it another $60 to $80 of additional spending for food and souvenirs at the property. So the tour that was envisioned would be you were picked up at your hotel in Las Vegas, and it's a two and a half hour drive to the site. You'd stand on the property of the base, and you could look. You would stand on the property with a view of the base. Can't stand on the base, just at the property. 00:23:12.3680000 And you'd look six to 7 miles away, and you could stay there for 1 hour. Then you would board the bus and you would drive back to Las Vegas for another two and a half hours. The result of this income stream in this business plan, this four to $5 million of revenue, when you use the cap rate, the discount rate, the value of the 10% rental fee is estimated to be $50 million. So according to the landowners, the fair market value of this property is $50 million. So, questions. 00:23:47.7340000 The first one is regarding demand. How do we know that 250 people will visit this property 365 days a year, year after year after year, in perpetuity? Because that is what is needed when you value real estate. And if you're capping an income stream is you're assuming that income stream continues in perpetuity. Price point, how do we know visitors will pay $400 per person to stand on the property for 1 hour? 00:24:17.1540000 If you're a couple, that's going to cost you $800. If you're a family of three, $1200. So the questions that need to be analyzed or proven, and the burden of proof is on the landowners to prove this concept. Is, are the assumptions defensible and supported empirically buy market data, or are these assumptions more on the speculative realm? You cannot use assumptions that are speculative in court cases. 00:24:49.3040000 You can't use guesswork. Everything has to have defensibility and a line of proven ability. So let's look at the landowner's valuation from the appraisers foundation for demand. This is the proof of market. So this was testified to in court, and this was one of the slides that was used. 00:25:10.6920000 So in order to demonstrate the demand for this business plan is what was looked at is the number of visitors that come to Las Vegas. There's 43 million visitors that come to Las Vegas. And of that, 16% of those visitors go somewhere. And this was based on the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors association, or bureau. So this is pulled from that study where 16% of Las Vegas visitors go somewhere. 00:25:40.7000000 Zion, Grand Canyon, Hoover Dam, they go somewhere. So that results in 6.9 million people that visit a nearby place when they visit Las Vegas. From there, the appraiser took 4% of the 16%. And this was just an estimate. It just 4% is a conservative number, I suppose. 00:26:04.6540000 So 4% of the 16% means that 6.9 million is reduced to 277,000 people. And this was just a guesstimate of 4% of the 16 is the number of people that would like to visit area 51. So that results in 277,568 people. But to be conservative, the appraiser thought, I'll go another step and I'll just say, instead of 277, I will just reduce it to 250 people a day, or 91,250 people annually. This is the demonstration of market demand for the subject property. 00:26:44.1780000 So from the lens of a developer, a purchaser of the property, who's writing a check for $50 million as of the date of value, hypothetically, would a developer or investor be comfortable with this level of analysis as justification for a demand? This is one of the questions that needs to be answered. 00:27:07.7140000 Now, the appraisers, the landowners justification for the dollar 400 entrance fee, how did they arrive at dollar 400 per person? So the appraiser based it on discussions that he had with twelve booking companies. 00:27:25.1040000 Also, there was a company called adventure photo tours that charges $200 for an Area 51 tour. And I'll talk about the details of that a little bit later. And on the adventure photo tours, you go to the gate, but you don't get to go inside past the gate. You don't get to see the actual airstrip. So you just go to the gate and that's it. 00:27:47.7540000 So of these twelve booking companies, one booking agency said that a tour operator could charge $1,000 for overnight stays at this property if it had a view of Area 51. A second booking agency said a tour operator could charge $300 to go inside to see Area 51. There was no testimony on what the other ten operators told this individual. There was no testimony on what the appraiser told the two booking representatives, how he framed the questions, or the experience or the tour. There's no testimony on how long the two unnamed individuals that were interviewed, how long they had worked for the company, what their role is, whether they had any knowledge or any expertise of how much tours should cost. 00:28:38.0240000 But these were the two data points, between 301,000 to estimate a $400 entrance fee to stand on the property for 1 hour. 00:28:51.9040000 Another indication of demand is the storm Area 51 event. There was testimony regarding this. If you looked at the Las Vegas Vegas convention and visitor visitors Bureau analysis, how they arrived at 91,000 people coming to the property annually, an additional indicator of how much interest there is to see. Area 51 was the storm Area 51 event. If you're not familiar with it, I'll go through it right now. 00:29:27.3380000 But on September 20, 2019. So this is just before. This is later in the case before trial was starting. Trial was in early March of 2020. And so there's testimony around this event. 00:29:43.6380000 So on Facebook, somebody just posted, let's go and storm the gates of Area 51, and it turned into a craze. 2 million people replied on that thread that they are going to on September 20, 2019, because that was the date they wanted to storm it. And another 1.5 million people replied, I'm interested in going. So that's 3.5 million people. That shows some level of interest of wanting to see Area 51. 00:30:17.3040000 As a result of this excitement and this campaign, I suppose local business owners created alien stock. So there's local businesses, the little alien, there's the alien museum. There's various owners that own and sell different things outside of long SR 375. So these owners got together and they created alien stock in an Area 51 base camp. They want to do a two day festival around this September 20 event. 00:30:49.5340000 They even got entertainment provided by a DJ, a famous DJ named Paul Oakenfold. I really don't. I don't know the guy, but so supposedly, he's the father of EDM music. This is just electronic music. It was testified to that he gets paid approximately $350,000 a show because he does big festivals. 00:31:16.0340000 This DJ, Paul Oakenfold, decided to play the event for free because he himself is an alien enthusiast. He has interest in this area, and he said, I'll play this event for free because it sounds great. By the time he went on, on the first night of this alien stock, the organizers had waived the dollar 51 entrance fee that they were charging, and only 100 people were in the audience. There weren't a lot of people that showed up for this two day festival. The next day, the festival was canceled. 00:31:52.1400000 So day two was canceled, and the storm area 51 events were financial failures. There was testimony that the business owner that brought in all the Porta potties and that type of support lost almost $200,000 of expenditure just because they had to cancel everything. Nobody really showed up to this storm Area 51 event. 00:32:19.7040000 So that's the case that was put on, on the landowner's side of valuing the property. I would like to shift now to US Department of Justice how the United States was looking at the issue and how it should be valued and how they valued this property as well. And this is regarding rebuttal testimony as well as a rebuttal expert. It is not the expert's role to provide an alternative analysis. It's the expert's role to demonstrate any flaws or discrepancy. 00:32:57.5100000 Or if there's no empirical basis for certain assumptions, it's not the rebuttal expert role to create an alternative one to try to prove the landowner's case. So I'm going to go through some of the issues with the landowner's methodology. And the first one here for framing the issue is really regarding purchaser risk considerations. What this whole case comes down to is when we look at fair market value for a piece of property. What you're asking is, as of September 10, 2015, theres a hypothetical buyer out there somewhere thats willing to write a check, all cash, for $50 million, to buy this property that is being studied. 00:33:44.6840000 So from the investors perspective, from a developers perspective, if Im going to write a check for $50 million, I want to know that theres a proven market. Thats a lot of money. Developers don't just write $50 million checks on a whim. So they are going to want to have a proven market and proof that demand is sustainable, that it is there for the long term, that people will come and continue to come every single year. So in this case, it's 250 people every day for perpetuity. 00:34:18.6640000 The next question that I need some assurance on is that people will indeed pay dollar 400 a person to go on this tour and stand on the site for 1 hour. Is this price point proven? Can we prove that somebody, that 91,000 people a year will pay $400 to see this property? So what's the risk to the buyer? Underneath these two assumptions is what I'll be discussing here. 00:34:44.1680000 And what's the market evidence to support these critical assumptions? Because without these assurances and empirical data, a developer, an investor, a buyer of this property is not going to be keen on writing a large check to the sum of $50 million, let alone if you try to finance something later on, a lender would not be interested in writing a massive check to fund a purchase or the development of a property unless there's market evidence to do so. 00:35:15.4140000 So, uh, let's talk about some of the considerations of the tour. Uh, that wasn't exactly discussed on the landowner side. So there are security constraints for visitors going to area 51. I got to go to this and stand on the property and look across the dry lake bed. Uh, so I was able to go through security and have that experience. 00:35:44.1040000 The first thing you have to do is you have to submit background checks and provide your Social Security number a couple of days, I believe it was 48 hours in advance. When you go to the property, you can't bring any electronics, no computer devices, no cameras, no binoculars, no telescopes. You can't bring anything. It's just you, your person. Everything else is left at the security station. 00:36:10.1520000 So if we had the idea that visitors can come and take pictures, that's not going to happen. You're not. You're not doing that. You also must stay on the confines of the designated property area. So you cannot get any closer than that. 00:36:23.8680000 Six to 7 miles away. So basically, you're going to pay $400, stand on the property, look six or 7 miles away, and then you'll leave after an hour. 00:36:37.8640000 The question we have to ask ourselves is, if we're coming to Las Vegas, what's the experience of other tours that you can possibly go on a two and a half hour drive back and forth for 1 hour on the area 51 property, or you can go in some of the national parks. I already mentioned Zion, I mentioned Grand Canyon, Hoover Dam. There's multiple viewing points. When you go to these national parks, you can take pictures, you can walk through caves, you can go hiking. The experience is beyond just a view. 00:37:07.8560000 You. And you're really immersed in the experience. You can actually get into the park and you can experience these things. So that's some of the difficulty that some consumers may have, is you can look from far away and you just stand there, or you can go and do something a little more active. And that's what this next bullet point says, which is how do other tours compare in Las Vegas to just standing on the property, something that wasn't really analyzed or considered? 00:37:38.9440000 So this relates to, is the $400 price ticket sustainable? What do you see at the property when you are there? I was on the property, and we were very strictly told you cannot talk to anybody because we had chaperones for the air force, and they. I didn't talk to anybody, and, but it was offered to me, somebody said, I can't believe anybody because it's run down. It's an old mine. 00:38:12.3000000 And he says, I don't know why anybody would want to buy it and do anything with it. And he said, especially, you know, who'd want to come out here in October? I thought to myself. And so I said, oh, what's going on in October? Is it the dry lake bed is generating so much heat? 00:38:28.2960000 He says, yeah. He says, we stand at the air force strip and looking across the dry lake bed, it looks like the whole mountain is moving in the month of October. And he said, but it's not heat, it's not that hot. He says, what happens in October is the tarantulas come out and that is mating season. So there's tarantulas everywhere in this area. 00:38:51.7240000 And this kind of goes to the level of sustainable demand and seasonality, which is the last bullet point here. But what happens after the first couple months of Yelp reviews? Supposing this tour actually goes forward and you start having visitors out there, you can't bring cameras, can't take any pictures. What you see is six to 7 miles away. You could hardly even see it. 00:39:14.5720000 You see just some small buildings and you see a Runway, strip, and month of October, terrible. Who wants to go out? So if a couple of Yelp reviews get out and they say, ah, its not that great, there goes your $400 price point that will be diminished significantly. And if that gets diminished, that $50 million valuation also diminishes as well. So theres tremendous risk from the buyers perspective. 00:39:45.6840000 What happens to the existing tours? Are they out of business? There are additional tours that I will discuss here in a little bit. And those tours, the tour companies, while they don't go into area 51 base, they do go around the perimeter. You visit the museum, you visit the little alien, you have lunch there. 00:40:02.7560000 You see the old mailbox or the black mailbox where they thought there was alien Secret Service mail going on there. So if people are paying $400, do the other tour companies go out of business? And alternatively, maybe the $400 is an add on to the existing tours. So these existing tours are $200, but to go into the base, it would be dollar 400. So now we're saying it would be a dollar 600 ticket to do this whole tour experience of Area 51. 00:40:34.1340000 So these are some of the kind of issues that a buyer, an investor of the property, would really consider when considering the $400 price point being sustainable and achievable in the first place. So let's look at some of the market evidence of quantifiable demand. And this was part of my work. There's a fact here that there are twelve booking agencies, according to the landowners and the landowners appraiser, if you dig a little bit deeper. Actually, there's only one company that conducts the tours. 00:41:13.3980000 It's called adventure photo tours. All the other booking agencies just, they're agencies and they just book with adventure photo tours. What this tour does is they pick you up in a luxury suv, you're gone the entire day. They pick you up, drop you off at the hotel. There's a tour guide. 00:41:32.3800000 You have lunch at the little alien, which I discussed. You go and view the native petroglyphs out there in the desert areas. You see the Joshua Tree forest. You go to Area 51 sites, you go to the back gate. So the gate where you can no longer go where they wanted to do the storm Area 51 event, you go to the black mailbox, the alien research center, you go to McCarran International Airport. 00:41:58.4900000 That's where you see JAna Airlines, where Jana Airlines is where the government flies in individuals that are coming to the property. And on the right hand side, there's a little table there. I called the owner of alien, I'm sorry, of adventure photo tours, and they do more than just Area 51. They'll take you to Zion and other places as well. But typically there's about 18 guests on every tour and they do two tours a week. 00:42:28.5380000 So that's 36 people a week that generally go on this area 51 tour. There's some guests per an additional tour. So from time to time they'll get an additional guests of two guests a week. So in total, they said they were having about 38 people go on this Area 51 tour weekly. If you extrapolate that on an annual basis, that's 1976. 00:42:56.2100000 People that are signing up to do a tour of Area 51 as a second indicator of these tours, we also contacted the owner of the little alien, just to substantiate this. And we asked about how many people in our interview process, how many people were coming through on tours, whether it was adventure photo tours or anybody that are interested in the area, and what the owner told us. There was about anywhere between 1500 to 2000 people annually are coming through that we get business from. So when we discuss somebody wanting to buy this property and having empirically defensible numbers in order to write a check, when you go from 2000 people to the next level of 91,250, theres no evidence of that higher number. That is a big number. 00:43:54.5340000 So is that 91,000 defensible? Would a buyer of the property be comfortable with that, or would they consider it speculative and unreliable? And of course, you could see my answer down here. And my testimony is that a prospective buyer, a developer, would find that 91,000 figure, uh, speculative and they could not rely on that. 00:44:19.5740000 Let's look at the cost of some of the other tours. So, when considering the cost, um, there's different things you can do from Las Vegas. Hoover dam costs you one $9 to do a tour. Valley of Fire, 169, zion 244, and then you've got the grand canyon, you're at 250. Around that, uh, the area 51 tour, that adventured photo tours does that I just went through on the previous slide, uh, is $200 to go. 00:44:47.9300000 Uh, and, you know, less than 2000 people go annually. So in looking at this, and by the way, I mean all of these other places, Hoover Dam valley, fire, Zion, grand Canyon, you could go by yourself and not on a tour car entrance fee of $35 or $20 or whatever they charge. Um, and these areas get millions of visitors a year. So is a developer comfortable with saying, I think we can charge $400 a person to look at Area 51 based on all the other available tours that are out there? That would be a hard sell, in my opinion. 00:45:30.2840000 So what it boils down to in terms of this valuation is what I would say. It's speculative. The 91,000 people is speculative at a rate of $400 a person. This market is unproven. I'm not saying that it would never exist or never come to fruition, but at the standpoint of September 10, 2015, of somebody ready to write a $50 million check, would they do it on a whim, on a hope that this market would prove out? 00:46:05.9060000 That's not what prudent real estate and experienced investors would do versus the other, which is the market and acquirer of the site, would actually do the homework and see what's actually out there. What can we actually count on? What we can count on is about 1900 to 2000 people a year paying dollar, 200 a person, the existing area 51 tours. Can you add a little bit more? If you go inside and you see a view, probably. 00:46:37.2060000 What's that amount that would be sustainable? It's unknown. 00:46:45.3740000 So I just wanted to look at on this slide a couple of the comparable transactions that were pointed out. So through the testimony of the landowners appraiser, there is testimony about additional attractions that are similar to this concept of coming to area 51 and standing on the site. So these would be similar attractions and the first one, and these were assembled by the USDOJ in their brief. And I helped supply and research this as well. The first one is the Roswell crash site. 00:47:21.0440000 That's where in the 1947 the headline. And there was an alien ship that crashed on the property in Roswell. It sold during the course of this trial, it was marketed and put out there for sale. This land it sold as a cattle ranch. Nobody purchased this property to do anything alien oriented about it. 00:47:43.2120000 It sold as a cattle ranch. You could go to the Ross well UFO museum. It's $5. The Roswell Festival, which was discussed quite a bit. It's supposedly one of the biggest alien enthusiasm festivals, the biggest gathering, having all that experience. 00:48:00.9440000 It's free. Alien research center is free. Little alien is free. 00:48:08.0240000 You could go to all these Stonehenge. They pointed that out there because there's some mystery surrounding that. The appraiser cited that area 51 would be similar to actually seeing Stonehenge. So Stonehenge, 20 pounds. So these are some of the various market support that when saying the experience in the attraction is comparable. 00:48:33.6340000 It's hard to go from a price point that's virtually free to maybe just dollar 20 or less to dollar 400. 00:48:43.1040000 Another example that was discussed by the appraiser as well is that it's also similar to actually going to these very popular national parks. Red Rock Canyon, Bryce Canyon, Zion, Death Valley, Grand Canyon. But when you actually look at this, how much does it really cost to go there? It's dollar 35 a vehicle, dollar 30 a vehicle, $15 a vehicle. So how do we get to $400 as a price point? 00:49:14.4440000 So there wasn't a lot of empirical data to demonstrate to prove out the total demand levels or to prove out the price points as well. I want to turn to legally permissible uses of the property, because that was another issue. Even if you can assume 91,000 people would come out here and pay $400 in perpetuity, that business model would work. There's some other issues that would occur here that needed to be in place that affect the use of the property. The first one is, is a property zoned for large scale commercial use? 00:49:56.0340000 The answer is no. This was actually zoned as an agricultural district. Large scale commercial tourism of having people out there on the site is allowed, but it would require a special use permit. So what happened is, during the course of this case, after some depositions and whatnot, the landowners actually spent thousands of dollars to go to Lincoln county and ask for a post taking advisory opinion on the possibility of a special use permit and zone change. Basically, what they asked is they said, hey, Lincoln county, we'd like to do a what if vote. 00:50:40.8440000 If we came to you and we want to change our land use to allow for visitor commercial or to get this special use permit, would you hypothetically vote? Yes. And of course, Lincoln county would approve that because it would bring visitors to the property spending, tourism. Every county would love to have that. And they voted that yes, they would. 00:51:05.4640000 However, was this a fully vetted hearing? Was there any opposition when the landowners went to do this? How would the planning commission have voted if the Air Force showed up and opposed this? So there was testimony by the director of planning during the trial, and the director of planning stated that the economic fiber of Lincoln county includes the Air Force. It is the major employer in Lincoln county. 00:51:34.5540000 And in addition to that, it pays a significant amount of money every year in lieu of paying taxes. So they pay money and they provide jobs. He also testified that not a lodge, not a large population of people would ever come to the groom mine as part of any tourism business. That was his belief. And therefore, Lincoln county and the commission there would not have put at risk all the air force jobs and its money that it brings to the region and the county. 00:52:07.7740000 So he also testified that certainly the county would consider any air force objections, and those objections would be addressed through conditions on the property, such as limitation on the number of days that you can operate, operate the business at the groom mine. 00:52:30.5640000 So I wanted to. I'm getting near the end of kind of wrapping up the whole themes. And one of this is regarding my testimony now, which all these slides were generally my testimony and explanation as it relates to my expertise and what I bring to a case as an expert. One thing that I wanted to point out to the land commission and the judges is that an investor or a buyer of this property would require guarantees in order to buy it from the air force and from the federal government. Developers are not in the business of taking unmitigated risk. 00:53:10.4160000 They're in the business of minimizing the risk on investment. So one of the first and fundamental questions that a buyer of this property would ask is, is the Air Force okay if we install a large tourist commercial operation at this property? That's the first thing that I would want to know if I was purchasing this property. If the okay. If the air force is okay with having 250 people on it every single day of the year. 00:53:39.6340000 One, an investor, a buyer of this property would require a contract in writing from the air force and the government stating that the air force is okay and will allow 250 people on the property every day of the year. That gives me certainty that I have that right to do that. So you want to ensure that there's compatibility with neighbors as well. Even if you have the legal right to do something in real estate, it's more difficult if you don't work with your neighbors. That's one of the things with entitlements and development of property, is you want to make sure the neighbors are aware and that they approve just to be a good neighbor. 00:54:19.4600000 So even if there was the legal right, I would want to make sure that the government's okay with it. Because what if legally, they could have 250 people on the site and they're allowed to do that every single day of the year. If the air force can't operate at all, well, they just close up their business and say, yeah, you're allowed to do that and we won't interfere with it, but we can't operate. So we're going to close this airbase and we're moving our operations somewhere else. They'll demolish all the buildings. 00:54:46.6640000 They demolish the Runway. Now you just look at a mountain range and what's the value of that $50 million acquisition that you just paid for the property? Can you still charge $400 a ticket to have people come out and look at nothing? So I would want to make sure that the government is going to stay there and operate, and I have the right to bring that many people on the property. So there's no contract in place. 00:55:10.5240000 Wasn't even being considered as of September 10, 2015, the date of value. This was another one that's interesting is exclusivity. So a developer would require an exclusivity contract with the air Force and the US government, meaning that the property, the subject property in red, and you can just see on this slide here, the very sliver of red at the bottom there, that this is the only property that's allowed to have visitors. Come and look at area 51. Because the idea is if the federal government says, okay, you can have people on your property, but when you guys have people out here and we have to shut down our operations, we're actually going to open the access road and we're going to create a little tiny parking lot just like, you know, any other national park. 00:56:03.2840000 And we'll just charge people $20 or $35 to come in and they can drive and park and look at the base themselves too, because we're closed down, we can't do anything. And if you look at the access road, you can see the access road goes right directly to the, to the north there on this image, the top of the lake bed. So actually creating a parking lot would give, would maybe cut the view almost in half. And you have a closer view of the area 51 airstrip. So I would want, as a purchaser of this property, a guarantee, not only the number of people, but an exclusivity contract that I'm the only one that can have visitors on the property. 00:56:44.7540000 The government will not undermine my operations. As of the date of value wasn't being considered, no prudent real estate investor or developer would write a check for $50 million unless they had these guarantees in place. 00:57:01.9340000 So to summarize some of the hypothetical potential buyer and developer questions to valuation, again, would they write a check for $50 million as of the date of value? The one question is, if it's worth $50 million, why has this property not been developed in the past? Why now? Nobody ever, they never solicited any developers, never approached them. Even though this property may have been known that it's out there, they never marketed the property to help, to try to monetize it. 00:57:36.2900000 So why now? So that's a question that needs to be asked and understood as well. Just all of a sudden, today, the property is worth $50 million. Another question a buyer is going to ask, is demand proven right? We've talked about that. 00:57:50.5940000 Is it sustainable in perpetuity? Are ticket sales at $400 also in perpetuity? And will that hold? Are the approvals and permits in place? This is legally permissible? 00:58:04.4800000 Can you legally do what you want to do? And if not, what stands in the way of that? And then the other one is making sure that your prime attractor, the prime attraction of this property is that the air force is there and has an airstrip. So is the air force amenable with having people on the property? And are they willing to provide the necessary contracts to a buyer to guarantee that they'll still operate and they can still have all the people that they want on the property? 00:58:35.5240000 My overarching conclusions in this case, this is directly lifted from my expert witness report, which was very long. But the main themes were that the landowners experts failed to account for and analyze the real estate risk as it relates to writing a $50 million check. This property is the most speculative type of real estate investment, typically in real estate development. You can put together a business plan, you can assess demand, you can look at price points. Theres lots of empirical data that you can draw upon sometimes its questionable, its guesswork, its speculative. 00:59:15.3660000 Sometimes the data is plentiful. This is at the very top level of speculative. It's a very niche market, and it's unproven. And there's no evidence that anybody ever wanted to develop this property as recreational tourism in the first place. 00:59:35.9440000 There are some other landowner issues, and then I'll get to the summary of what was decided in this case, the other landowner issues. Early on in the case, before it went to trial, some of the motion and limity and Daubert motions that there's a ton of work that was done on both sides. On the landowner side, there was a demand study, and I helped analyze that demand study. There was an assumption of trap where they looked at traffic volumes on the SR 375, and there was a major error in that report where the numbers were annual, uh, were assumed to be annual trips, whereas they were actually daily trips. There was just an error in that report. 01:00:16.7040000 And when you corrected it to make it annual trips and multiply the daily by 365, there's actually negative demand for the property. So actually a negative couple million people would not want to go to the property. So this report was not allowed in. It also relied on hearsay. Somebody in the office asked another individual, how many people do you think you know of traffic volume? 01:00:40.3420000 How much is passerby traffic versus local traffic? And it was just a percentage. And that's not a sound basis for methodology either. You can't ask somebody in your own office what they think and say, that's my source for that number. It's got to be proven. 01:00:55.5020000 There's also some other error corrections on how they analyzed the growth, the historical growth, the percentage growth over time, which is the constant average growth rate CAGR for national parks. There was also. So that that study was. Was not allowed in. There was also some faulty bias. 01:01:14.9720000 Survey data. There was survey data that was done. And the way that the questions were asked by the survey company, they were a little leading. It wasn't disclosing everything. So they use this data to try to gauge the price point and interest in this tour that the landowners wanted to do. 01:01:35.3540000 This data was not allowed in because it was too faulty and it was biased. The other issue in the case here is the faulty income approach. So the appraiser. Appraisers. There's three approaches to appraisal. 01:01:47.9460000 The cost approach, the income approach, and the sales comparison. There is also the income approach that demonstrated the $50 million land value. The appraiser for the landowner was not allowed to testify to that. When it came to it because it was already decided that, uh, it was, it was not reliable and it didn't account for all the real estate risk. So part of my involvement there got that aspect of the valuation out. 01:02:14.6940000 So when it came to valuing this property, while they showed demand for price points, and based on convention visitors, bureau surveys, in terms of valuation, they had to just look at sales comparables. And I'm not going to touch on that issue in this case. But they weren't very comparable, I will say that. So to summarize, I'll go through, or rather to go through the land commission findings on this case. I've included some snippets on what the land commission decided. 01:02:49.8720000 So there are a couple pretrial order motions. The first one over here on the left is proper rebuttal. I've had it happen before where I try to get pinned in a corner saying my opinions do not matter and they should be excluded because I didn't do any original calculations myself or an alternative methodology. And what this shows here is that the burden of proof is on the landowners. It's not my job to come up with proper methodology and assumptions. 01:03:22.7440000 I'm opining on the errors of what they have and the facts that they did not consider. The other one is fair market value and investment value. I was trying to be excluded as a witness because I'm not an MAI appraiser. I do the exact same evaluation work and then some because my clients are developers and investors and institutions and lenders. So I do even more detailed analysis when it comes to valuation. 01:03:50.8640000 Nonetheless, trying to exclude me in this case because I am not opining on fair market value as an appraiser. What the Land commission decided here is they rejected this argument. Im looking at the very bottom box on the right hand side. They rejected this because fair market value depends on investment value. Without investment value, which is what a developer would buy the property as, or what a lender would make a loan on the property as, or what an investor would pay for the property. 01:04:28.6600000 Without that market dynamic, there's no such thing as fair market value. Appraisals are the starting point of valuation. There's certain methodologies and standard methodologies that can be used to suggest a starting point for valuation. But a developer, an investor, a lender never just relies on that value and says, that's the value end all. A developer, it's a starting point. 01:04:55.1140000 They may say, okay, well, this value is $50 million. Let's do our own analysis. And how would we advise it? What's the risks that we have to consider is everything considered in the appraisal. In this case, there was so much risk that was excluded and not accounted for in the appraisal that needed to be there. 01:05:10.9660000 So I'm coming from the inspect from the lens of investors, of lenders and how they would view an appraisal and would they rely on it. In this case, I would say no investor, no lender, no developer would rely on this valuation from the appraisal because it just missed too much of the risk. So to go through the findings on what the land commission decided, the first one is legally permissible use. They decided, I'm just going to read this real time as well. 01:05:52.7340000 So paragraph 124, no reasonable knowledge or knowledgeable buyer would assume that they can build a large scale, large scale tourism commercial or that it was legally permissible. So they decided that you would not be able to do a visitor commercial use on this property, especially with the air force as the neighboring property owner, that they could file an objection, and there's just too much risk here, too much unknown. So a reasonable buyer would say that they cannot do visitor commercial. 01:06:30.8440000 In addition, they rejected the large scale tourism project because they found it to be speculative. They also said that landowners failed to put forward credible market evidence of sustainable demand. They quoted me on saying that if demand is not there permanently or it's not sustainable and it falls off, the value of the investment plummets. So developer and investor wants to know that demand is there and it's sustainable. Number one. 01:07:02.4940000 Ultimately, they decided that the landowners failed to carry their burden of proof by proving out demand for a visitor commercial use. Regarding the entrance fee of $400, the commission found that the appraiser used the market support to not support his dollar 400 assumption. So we already went through the tables that shows, you know, the price of other comparable attractions. Those do not support the $400. So because of that, they don't believe that is supportable. 01:07:41.1940000 So the conclusion from the commission on highest and best use is that the commission found that the highest and best use as of the date of value was not visitor commercial because they did not prove that case. Rather, it is the existing use, which is rural residential. Landowners didn't meet the burden of proof by showing the preponderance of evidence that there was market demand for their proposed large scale tourist commercial. 01:08:15.4140000 This slide shows the just compensation. So the landowners did not present an alternative analysis. They put all the eggs in the basket on visitor commercial use. They didn't look at a different valuation for a different use. So in this case, this is the USDOJ appraisal appraiser. 01:08:36.6260000 And this appraiser appraised the property as the highest and best use as of rural commercial, rural recreational sales. The landowner did not object to his methodology, but they objected to his assumption of use as rural recreation. So in the end, the commission agreed the property is one of a kind because of its area 51 view. And they found that the uniqueness established it, that it would command a premium in the real estate market above the US dog DOJ's appraiser. So they valued it at $10,000 per acre. 01:09:19.8440000 And just compensation for this property was $1.1 million. The fair market value of this property as determined by the land commission. There's another aspect of this case. There's an additional $40 to $50 million of mineral rights that were also being tried. But it didn't. 01:09:43.0470000 Before it went, the court started that aspect of the case sold for just, or settled for just over $100,000.02 days before this trial even started. So that was taken out of the equation and what was left was just the $50 million for visitor commercial use. 01:10:01.5030000 So with that, I would like to end my presentation and thank you for your time. I hope you found it invigorating and interesting. It was one of the most fun projects that I've had to work on. And I think you can see my expertise in the type of work that we do and how complicated these cases are when it comes to land use, because it's not so simple. And a lot of the time appraisers are missing a lot of the nuances as well. 01:10:27.8700000 So this was a fun one for me, and I appreciate the time to share it with you. Thank you.