Bias, Civility, and Professionalism Under Rule 8.4(g) 00:00:02.3300000 Hello and welcome, everyone, to today's presentation. My name is Carrie Sheehan, and I will be your presenter here today for civility in practice. We are going to talk about some things to do and not to do and just being civil and professional in the practice of law, which you may think is common sense. But there's so many different areas that touch the practice of law where, where civility comes into play that we may not even think about. We're also going to learn by example, meaning we are going to explore some attorneys who have done things wrong in the civility realm and where they really fell down. 00:00:39.4520000 And then hopefully you don't make the same mistakes as them. So let's get started here. A little bit about myself before we get started, though. My name is Carrie Sheehan again, and I'm an assistant clinical professor of business, law and ethics at the Kelly School of Business in Indianapolis, Indiana. I'm also an adjunct professor at the Robert H. 00:00:59.0920000 McKinney School of Law, where I teach torts, appellate practice and procedure, and professional responsibility on occasion to law students, which is always exciting and fun. And then in my limited free time, I also practice law part time as a conflicts ethics attorney for Scopolitas, Garvin, Lighthanson and fury here in Indianapolis as well. And I do all their internal ethics compliance as well as civility or anything that touches the rules of professional conduct. So we are going to talk about a lot of different areas today, and we're going to look at a lot of different things. And if you have any questions along the way, I do encourage you to put them in the chat up above and just put them in there, and I'll try to get to them as I'm talking. 00:01:45.1400000 But if I don't see them right away, I will get them to them at the end of the seminar as well. So let's get started here, and you may think, how does professionalism, unconscious bias, or any of these areas really relate to the profession of law? We don't really have a model rule of professional conduct that says be nice. We do have one that says we can't be biased or prejudiced when we are practicing law 8.4 g. But not every jurisdiction has it. 00:02:15.0200000 So how do we incorporate this into it? And why is it so important for lawyers to be professional? Well, it's important for us to be professional because the legal justice system is the hallmark of our society. We would not have a civilized society if we did not have a legal justice system. So we really have to set forth this presence and this truth seeking and that lawyers are there to help find the truth or to promote this system that we have within the United States of finding the truth in our court systems in general. 00:02:50.4240000 We also have to maintain competent skill and knowledge to help people through the system because we're kind of the gatekeepers of the system. You do have access pro se, but a lot of people don't know where to start or what to do, so they come to lawyers, and we have to help them. Now, within that area, too, we have to deal with opposing counsel. We deal with people on a regular basis, and we find times when we disagree. But civility and being professional is not the absence of disagreement or absence of agreement. 00:03:20.4060000 It is more than that. It's being hostile. It's using a certain tone of voice. It's doing stuff just to cause problems. It's not the absence of criticism or absence of agreement. 00:03:32.6020000 We don't have to like everyone. We don't even have to necessarily have good manners. We just have to be civil, professional people. Now, when you think about that, think about your practice in the area that you practice in regularly. Have you ever encountered someone who is just a very unhappy, uncivil person? 00:03:52.0600000 And you know, no matter what it is, it could be their best day. They're still just going to be downright mean, cruel, very critical, and they're just not pleasant to deal with. Think of those lawyers. That is kind of what we're talking about when it comes to unprofessionalism. It's having those different attitudes, those different things. 00:04:13.7120000 It's not that they don't agree with you, it's just the way they bring about that. And judges and lawyers across the country are really not putting up with it anymore. There are civility initiatives in the legal profession, and most jurisdictions have their own that are sweeping kind of the nation, if you want to use that phrase. But most organizations have kind of like a civility proclamation or civility initiative, or they do seminars and different things on civility in general. And that is kind know a big presence within the United States and within, of course, the lawyer culture. 00:04:51.0460000 And so some of the things that you can consider to be kind of this governing and how we govern ourselves with civility include we are a self governing profession. Rule 8.3 tells us that we have to report the misconduct and incivility of other people within our profession, other lawyers. We have to go through character and fitness exams to even become a lawyer, which I know half of us were terrified of that probably when we went to get our license years ago, we also take an oath of attorneys. And how many of you have read your oath of attorneys? Besides raising your right hand and saying it years ago, have you actually sat down and read what you said when you gave that oath? 00:05:34.0900000 Probably not. Not many have. I read it just because I wanted to see what it said when I started to give these seminars on civility. And here in Indiana, when we raise our right hand, aside from saying we're going to uphold the constitution, we're going to zealously advocate for our client. Somewhere embedded in that, in the very middle of it, it says that we will abstain from offensive personality. 00:05:59.8900000 Now, I got to thinking about that phrase, and I was like, okay, how many lawyers have abstained from offensive personality their entire careers? Not many lawyers can say that. They do that other times, too. And you may just think, okay, well, some have. They're very civil in their practice or great professionals, but you go to the preamble, the rules of professional conduct, and it says that the rules apply in your personal and professional life. 00:06:30.7500000 Now, going back to that oath where we said we're going to abstain from offensive personality, particularly here in Indiana. Now, all your other jurisdictions probably have something similar. I thought, got to thinking, how many of these lawyers out there can say that they've also abstained from offensive personality and their personal lives? I need to really pull spouses. Not many could say that. 00:06:53.7800000 Not many could do that. So that is kind of something to consider, too, that this is embedded into our oath. When we become lawyers, this is embedded into what we do. And this is starting to be embedded into judiciary and judicial system with different initiatives they've taken as well. For example, in 2002, there's what's called the Sedona conference, which launched what is called a think tank to confront challenging issues, particularly regarding incivility in discovery. 00:07:24.3260000 How many of you would love to be trapped in the throes of discovery your entire legal career? Sounds terrible, doesn't it? And that is because for some reason, discovery brings out the worst in people. How many of you have ever sat through a deposition that's ended up in an argument between the lawyers, maybe a fist fight between the lawyers or something? And I don't know why discovery does that to us. 00:07:50.6320000 It's just that battle back and forth. Let the document in, let it out. Let them testify. Objection. It just brings out this very controversial nature. 00:08:00.3540000 And that's fine, because remember, civility is not the absence of disagreement agreement, but it also brings out the pettiness, the unprofessionalism, and when we get to the examples at the end of the seminar, we're going to see some of that pettiness come out in different cases. If you want a little preview of what you're going to see in some of the examples, just Google the twerking lawyer. Yes, I said twerking. Google the twerking lawyer on your computer right now, and you're going to see a lawyer who decided to twerk in front of opposing counsel during a deposition. During a deposition. 00:08:37.5500000 Bending over. Twerking. If you know what twerking is, it's bouncing up and down of the lower, fleshy extremity is what they described it in the brief when they filed for sanctions. With the court. In front of opposing counsel, with your client in the ropes, how is that called for? 00:08:53.8680000 That's what we're talking about. Incidebility, not acting professional. Something to Google and look up. Aside from the Sedona conference, other jurisdictions. I'm going to use Illinois as an example. 00:09:05.1840000 In 2005, the Illinois Supreme Court established the Commission on Professionalism under Supreme Court rule seven nine nine c. This is also known as two civility. This really promotes the culture of civility and inclusion within the legal profession in Illinois, promotes and fosters elimination of bias and divisiveness, and also ensures equitable, efficient, effective resolution of problems and disputes. Other jurisdictions have started to incorporate such codes as well into their rule system. But again, it's jurisdiction by jurisdiction. 00:09:39.5500000 Illinois. If you go to law school in Illinois, I've been told that they really do incorporate those values from that rule into the law school as well, and that the students at the very young age, one L's, two l, three l's, are told about the civility, about this rule, and about how it's going to affect their practice as they come out. But it's a lot, and it is a lot more than just saying you're going to be nice to people. It is a lot more than saying you're always going to use the right words or conduct yourself in the appropriate manner. It is a lot more than that. 00:10:11.5880000 And incivility can lead to professional discipline in the legal profession, and it can lead to some really harsh results. And you may think, okay, well, what rule do they get us under? Well, the first one is, which is a lot of jurisdictions, the majority habit, 8.4 D. It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice. I challenge you to define prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:10:43.4460000 It's not just arguing. It's not just disagreeing or raising your voice or yelling or shouting. It could be anything. And the comments to rule 8.4 D and the model rules do not even give us guidance on what is or is not included in it. It is a very broad definition. 00:11:01.9940000 It is very broad when it comes to just trying to figure out what would be included and prejudicial to the administration of justice. But this is the one where if they think of you being uncivil or unprofessional, this is one where they can really kind of get you in and you could get in trouble under the rules of professional conduct. 00:11:24.3300000 Another rule is get it up there on the screen, 8.4 g. Now, this is a secondary rule to 8.4 g, because not every jurisdiction has adopted 8.4 g. The motto rules didn't even adopt it until 2018. For us here in Indiana, we've had this on the book since the early 2000s. This is what I call the title seven of the rules of professional conduct. 00:11:48.4100000 It says that a lawyer shall not engage in conduct that shall not engage in conduct that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, age, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, socioeconomic status in the conduct related to the practice of law. This is one of the only rules within the rules of professional conduct that is solely limited to the practice of law. All the other rules, like I was saying with the oath and that say that they apply personally and professionally, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. This one only applies when we're practicing law. But now, what's the definition of practicing law? 00:12:40.1480000 Well, go down to the comments of this rule. The definition is really broad. It includes anything from going to bar events to social events, to outings, to managing a law firm, to dealing with clients, to talking to opposing counsel, to talking to witnesses, to investigation, to representing clients in court, to talking to judges, it represents so much stuff, it might as well be 24/7 but again, the practice of law is a little more defined than just every day, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. And you can see here on this screen the differences and the same why I call it the title seven of the rules is because it has a lot of the same protected classes. Except our rule of conduct, 8.4 g, is way broader than title seven. 00:13:32.9800000 It protects more protected classes. It goes through a lot more things, and there's just more to it. And different jurisdictions that have adopted 8.4 g have not included all of the categories here that you see on your screen from the model rules. They have narrowed it, some have narrowed it, some just the ones like in title seven or a little broader. Some have expanded it and even put more detail into the protected classes. 00:14:00.5180000 So you really need to look at your local jurisdiction to see, one, if they've adopted this rule, and two, what does it all include? Because you cannot discriminate or harass any of those protected classes while practicing law, discrimination includes the verbal or physical conduct that manifests bias or prejudice towards others. Harassment is conduct that is aggressively evasive, pressuring or intimidating. Could include sexual harassment, derogatory, demeaning, verbal or physical conduct. Requisite harm is assessed using a standard of objectable reasonableness, too. 00:14:37.7720000 So it's that reasonable person standard. So it's kind of like a sexual harassment claim, just out for laypersons not in the legal profession. This is really going to get some lawyers, and we will see examples where this plays out, not only in representing clients and dealing with clients, but also just in lawyers managing a law firm from the hiring process all the way through to potentially a firing process. Because it's not just interactions, but it's also that business management side of us practicing law. Because, again, practicing law. 00:15:13.4920000 Here's that definition from comment four. Representing clients, interacting with witnesses, coworkers, court personnel, lawyers, and others while engaged in the practice of law, operating or managing a law firm, participating in bar social events. It is broad. It is huge, especially that operating or managing a law firm, because we don't really think about that as a practice of law, because it's more of a business feature, a business mindset that we're doing. I mean, we're doing payroll, we have employees. 00:15:42.4220000 We're doing those things. That's not law necessarily in the traditional sense like we know it, but it is still considered practicing law. And why didn't the motto rules adopt this until 2018? Because it was highly controversial, is the answer to that, to be honest. And it was highly controversial because a lot of jurisdictions, including Texas, was a big, vocal advocate against this rule being put into play, because it said it really infringed upon a lawyer's free speech and their right to form opinions and to voice those opinions. 00:16:17.9100000 And so even John Gleason, the then chair of the ABA center of Professional Responsibility, was quoted as saying it would be mostly accurate to tell you that 8.4 g is dead in the water. He did not think that jurisdictions were going to pick it up and adopt it, even though some had already, the majority had not. But it's actually caught on a lot more than he anticipated. And so then you have to think, okay, and let's just go back to the rule for just a second here. We cannot hold bias or we cannot harass, discriminate, or have a basis of bias on these protected classes. 00:16:55.0540000 How do you know if you're biased or discriminating? That's the question. Because we can consciously know, like, if we do something overtly or intentionally, we know we're doing it, then. But what about those unconscious biases? And you may think to yourself, well, I don't have an unconscious bias. 00:17:11.5220000 I'm not a biased person. No one would ever call me that. I don't think I'm that. But as I teach my students in ethics class, if you have a brain, you have a bias. And you may sit there and think, no, that's not me. 00:17:23.4080000 I don't. If you have a brain, you have a bias. Psychologists and people who've studied it, there is a part of our brain which we'll see in the coming slide. It's called the FFA. It's in the lower back portion that helps us distinguish things, and it helps us distinguish things from. 00:17:40.6440000 You're afraid of it because it's different to. It's like you. So you're like, okay, it's a comfort. I want to be close to it. It's nice. 00:17:49.1280000 And so is that fear versus comfort? Well, that same part of the brain is what distinguishes characteristics like skin color, like someone who doesn't act like you or look like you, because it's something different. That part of the brain says fear, and so you treat it a little differently instead of comfort safe, where you would not treat it differently. And this is where we get those bias, because you don't know you're doing it. If you ever think about it, look around at all your friends that are married potentially or with significant others, do they kind of look similar? 00:18:24.8640000 A lot of them. Not all of them, but a lot of them. And they may have the same facial features, like you're like, oh, they're jawlines, or they have the same shape of eyes. Not saying they're related by blood, but just saying they're similar. Maybe in stature, maybe in size, maybe in physique, maybe in those different characteristics. 00:18:42.5100000 It's because their brain is saying, when they met that person, hey, he or she is like you. They're like you. They're like you. This is good. This is good. 00:18:50.5240000 And the brain is releasing endorphins. And if they see some with an opposite, they're like, ooh, those endorphins don't get released. You don't get that same warm, fuzzy feeling, and you have to really fight against that. So we were all born with an unconscious bias or a biased part of our brain, and we just don't realize it. But once you realize it and start to overcome it is when you can really break through it. 00:19:14.8960000 So let's kind of do an exercise here. This is one I actually do in class. Two, this is not meant to make anyone feel uncomfortable. You're not even going to answer the questions in the chat. You can if you want, but you don't have to. 00:19:26.4400000 I just want you to meet Ellen. Ellen's the beautiful young lady there in the picture. She's an accomplished chef, loves sports animals, hanging out with friends, volunteers at homeless shelters. Her best friend's. Her sister Kate. 00:19:38.3860000 Loves playing bingo. Take a look at know young, beautiful. Can you find Ellen? Now, many of you are looking at these pictures, maybe going cross, like, going, oh, my gosh, what just happened? And so you may be thinking, and then some of you are thinking, I got it. 00:19:54.9920000 I got it. And so just take a look, see if you can find Ellen. I'm going to give you the answer here in just a second, but look for those features. Did you study her face when you saw in the last photo hair color? These are all the same hair color. 00:20:09.5700000 And so did you pick her as Ellen? Some of you are probably cheering right now. Well, hate to burst your bubble. That's wrong. This is not ellen. 00:20:17.7580000 This was ellen. Ellen was in that lower right hand corner there. If you go back to that screen in front, and that is ellen, go back to the main screen. She's right there. And you may think, okay, how many of you had trouble finding Ellen? 00:20:33.6820000 And if I could see your hands, probably a good majority. Maybe not. Just depending on the demographic we have listening, couldn't find Ellen or had trouble spotting her or really debated between different characteristics. And it's okay, to be honest, if you couldn't find her. What this exercise is meant to do, and it was first done by a professor at Harvard University, is to show you that when she pulled different audiences of adults and of students, the ones that had the same nationality, the same skin tone, the same hair color as Ellen, the same gender, found Ellen more readily. 00:21:12.0140000 The ones who did not had trouble or could not identify her say they were of a different race, of a different nationality. And it's because of that FFA part of our brain that we have that difficulty, because we don't recognize stuff that's different from us, we recognize more stuff that's more similar to us. So we all have these biases that can come out when we least expect it, which is part of the trouble, too, in practicing law, because we don't realize we're doing it. And we could run afoul with that rule, 8.4 g. This is also known as the other race effect, where we have that difficulty distinguishing faces, characteristics of races other than our own, and just finding those things. 00:21:51.2840000 It's not just about environment and exposure. Our brains are wired that way. Obviously, environment and exposure can help make stuff more common, so it kind of fights against that. But again, we are wired this way. It's that back part of the brain which I was telling you about earlier. 00:22:07.2500000 That part helps us distinguish the faces, differentiate between the familiar, the unfamiliar, the friend versus the foe, active neuron shooting when it's happy, us versus them. We all have seen that in our society, and we have all seen it. And what 8.4 g and 8.4 d of the rules of professional conduct were put in place was to fight this in the legal profession, to fight that bias, that instability in the legal profession. And Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt, the phrase that I said when we first started, if you have a brain, you have a bias. 00:22:40.1860000 That was her coin phrase for a seminar she'd given as a professor of psychology at Stanford. So we have to really remember that and say, it's okay, we have it. But now that we know we have it, how can we stop or eliminate it? And how can we stop that implicit unconscious bias, those stereotypes, those prejudices that we have? And how can we comply with the rules of professional conduct, 8.4 D and 8.4 g in our civility when it comes to that, well, let's see where we can violate the rules of professional conduct. 00:23:14.0860000 8.4 g. It can happen, like I said, intermingling with coworkers, all those definitions from that comment, four of the rule. But it can also happen in managing just the law firm in general, through recruiting attorneys, through recruiting staff, to screening and hiring, to work allocation, promotion, discharge, interactions with coworkers, attendance at events, correspondence, decisions you make, what goes into those decisions. It can be affected by so many areas, and these may seem to you like business areas, but managing a law firm is all of these areas where you can run afoul with 8.4 g and 8.4 d. So we really have to take a look at what that looks like. 00:23:59.5320000 So we're going to start and kind of go down the list and see how it starts with recruitment, that job posting. Now you may think, well, how can you have bias or unprofessionalism in a job posting? Trust me, you can. And we're going to go through some examples. This first example, it is not a foreign attorney position necessarily, but this is for a full web design company specializing in industrial and commercial clientele. 00:24:27.6500000 They're currently working for a content writer CEO specialist to join the dynamic team. So just a content writer, nothing to doing. Making blog posts, updating existing text, conversing clientele, writing website content for new clients. And so the position requires these different things. You see at the top, but then here at the bottom. 00:24:50.4800000 They say this position requires filing or filling in responsibilities as a receptionist. So female candidates are preferred. Just think of this as a law firm posting and as a law firm you put out there, we're hiring a receptionist. We prefer a female in today's day and age, or in any today day and age. That's a stereotype or bias that only females can be receptionist or make better receptionist or preferred in that position. 00:25:19.6400000 Kind of like only men can be police officers or men doctors, women teachers, women nurses. We don't need to have that in our job descriptions. If you are posting this as a law firm seeking a receptionist, this is something you would want to stay away from. Could be an 8.4 g and d violation. This is another one too. 00:25:40.0760000 Again, not lawyer positions, but just to stay away from. If you're hiring, you know you want a new attorney or a new staff member or anything in your firm. This first one, they want a document processor, female, not above, 29 years old, single. What does that have to do with document processing? Let's really think about age discrimination, gender, different marital status. 00:26:02.9220000 That was included in 8.4 g. So you can have all those things come into play. The accounting assistant. Some of us have accountants in our firms. Female accounting graduate, 21, up to 28, single, little leery. 00:26:16.0460000 If you're going to take that job application and work there over on the other side, this is actually for a driver, male, 30 to 35 years old. Kind of implying that women can't be drivers. You can see this, and I'm assuming there's good intentions behind these, or they don't know any better. I don't know. But at the same time, this is what the 8.4 g is there to combat those stereotypes and biases that are held that we really need to kind of quash as it comes through. 00:26:44.2440000 This is another ad for customer service. They want a fun young theme, dynamic young entrepreneurial culture based in Surrey Hills. Learn and grow with the business. Could have an age discrimination here or something like that, or a bias that you can't be old and have fun. And what's young anyway? 00:27:02.5360000 I feel I'm young. I may be ancient to some on this call, or I may be a young end to others on this call. I don't know. But again, we don't really need to put those in the job descriptions. Here's for a desk administrator. 00:27:15.2100000 The phrase in red is what I was wanting to draw your attention to. It's nice to be one of the good guys. This goes to the gender identity, the gender classifications that we have, and having that bias there under 8.4 g. So you need to watch pronouns, you need to watch phraseology, you need to watch those things if you're posting for jobs, for your law firm, or for new attorneys. This one here, we're particularly interested in receiving applications from candidates who identify as female. 00:27:46.4940000 Now, I can see what they're trying to do here, trying to be more inclusive, saying, hey, we're going to be diversified, maybe like a dei initiative, but it's not coming across that way. And it was very poorly phrased if that was the intent behind it, which I don't know if that was or not. But again, we really want to watch the pronouns, watch the gender, watch any type of bias or discrimination if her posting jobs are doing things in that nature as well. This is obviously a blatant, obvious one. Stores required no Indians or Asians please. 00:28:16.9760000 Must speak English. What does indian being indian or asian have to do with it? They could speak English. Why can't they apply? So again, we look at those different things. 00:28:29.0100000 This is one too. Race should never be a qualification. Anytime you can see it in title seven, you can see it in 8.4 g with a loving and kind hearted personality, teaching experience, and caucasian. Really want to watch what we're posting if we're advertising this one I put in here kind of for fun because I thought a lot of us lawyers would really love to put this in a job description. I know it's for a glass and mirror company, but it is pretty inventive. 00:28:56.9460000 So I'm going to read it out just because I think it's hilarious and I would love to use it if I was posting a job position for a law firm. But it says please do not apply if you oversleep, have no alarm clock, have no car, have court, often, have no babysitter every day, have to give friends rides to work later than we start work experience. Flat tires every week. Have to hold onto your cell phone all day or become an expert at your job with no need to learn or take advice after the first day. Must be able to talk and work at the same time. 00:29:27.6560000 Must be able to remember to come back to work after lunch. Should not expect to receive blue ribbons or gold stars, and you have to show up to work on time. Anyone else want to put that in their job description? It is kind of an interesting, but if you look in there, are we discriminating or holding bias to any classes in 8.4 g or anywhere? It's kind of hard to find. 00:29:52.5440000 We're not using race, we're not using gender. We're not using marital status, necessarily. 00:29:59.5500000 Being a mother. No, just saying you have to have a babysitter, so maybe it could pass muster in that and not violate 8.4 g if you use that in an attorney. Advertisement another area where we see this in just the law practice and practicing law, which is at least another uncommon area, is the resume. If you think about it, and we're not going to do this exercise today, but this is something you could do with your firm to really get your interviewers or whoever's doing resume collection or picking out people to interview, like for new attorney positions or for staff positions within the firm. Do the resume exercise game, because the first thing we see on a resume is someone's name. 00:30:39.4520000 And right off the bat with that name, we get feelings about the person. Not that we love them or like them or anything like that, or hate them, but some names spark emotions for us. Like if I hear the name Floyd, I think of my first grade teacher, Floyd Galbraith. If I hear another name, maybe it's someone I didn't like in elementary school. Then I get a negative emotion. 00:31:02.5380000 Now I see that same name or similar name on a resume, that emotion sparse with me, and then I'm like, eh, I don't really like working know Jessica's or I don't like that. And so we toss it aside. It's just a name. We didn't even look at the qualifications. There's a stereotype bias from that FFA, from those experiences we've had in the past with someone similar, not even the person on the resume. 00:31:27.1540000 And then you have your screeners tossing them out from their own stuff coming through. How is that fair to the candidates? How is that right? Or they see a name, such as taking a name here on the screen, Lakeisha Watkins or Ali Saheed, and think, oh, minority candidate dei initiative, let's bring them in. It's just a name. 00:31:54.7700000 And how is that right, too? Not even looking at the qualifications. And so then you think, okay, well, how do we stop this from happening at the screening process? Because this can invoke an 8.4 g violation. A lot of companies, and even law firms have started to go to what's known as blind resumes, meaning when the resumes come in, they have an independent, outside third company collect them, remove the names, redact them, and put a numbering system or a lettering system. 00:32:22.9100000 Then they send them over to the law firm or company and they pick out, based on qualifications, not names, who they want to bring in for candidates. Then it's not until the candidates are brought in that they finally match the name to candidate. So then you have a little more. You eliminate or try to, I'm sure you can't completely. If the person went to certain universities or there are certain things on the resume that would give away more of those identifying features, not just the name, but you're trying to eliminate that stereotype, that bias in this initial resume process. 00:32:57.8800000 But this can also happen here, too. And it all goes back to that brain. If you have the brain, you have the bias. And this exercise here on the screen, if you wanted to do it with your firm or to training, you just make a list of names, make a list of professions and tell people to put them in categories based on the name. And you're going to see trends. 00:33:16.9980000 You're going to see a lot of John Smith as CEO of Fortune 500. You're going to see a lot of Michael Cooley's or Elisa heed, maybe as doctor. The more foreign names that you see or just the nationality behind them. And so you're going to start to see trends. For better or worse, that's what you're going to see when you do the exercise. 00:33:35.2420000 But it makes people think and think that we do have this brain, that we're wired a certain way. We've really got to overcome it. Some other things, too. Pictures and images have kind of wired us this way as well. With the brain, the receptionist, the doctor, those predominantly, which gender goes in which role? 00:33:53.3300000 Breaking out of those. We saw that in that posting where they said, this includes filing as a receptionist, female candidates preferred. We've got to watch those things as well. If you have screening procedures at your firm, this can also be a way to have stereotypes or biases come through, especially if you're screening for something that has no relevance to the job. If you're wanting to hire someone just to paint your office and you give them an aptitude test. 00:34:18.1960000 What has that have to do with painting? So you've got to look at those things too, and your different procedures and policies that you have within your firm, too. Not just how you treat other people, but your firm policies and procedures and how that all works internally. This is another exercise to think about moving into more, where we can see 8.4 g being violated in the area of promotion, in the area of internal work assignments, how they're handed out, who gets them, who doesn't, who makes partner, who doesn't, who gets to be at the deposition with the firm managing partner who doesn't get to. And so what this exercise does is I want you to think in your head of the top five to ten, I can only get about three, so I don't fault you. 00:35:03.9240000 If you get like one to three people you trust the most in your inner circle, no family, just friends, classmates, coworkers, no family members. And so you're going to think inner circle, you'll read the diary to each other type of inner circle. You're going to call them when you're crying, you're going to call them when you're screaming. They're going to see all the sides of you and still be there to love you and support you. That's your inner circle. 00:35:27.7740000 Now, once you get that list of people, you're going to think of their gender, race, age, sexual orientation, education, disability, and then say, and look, is it similar to your own? If it is, that FFA has said they're familiar. It's lighting up. It's lighting up. It's lighting up and it's pushed away the unfamiliar. 00:35:46.5100000 Now, you can start to see this as you go through this exercise, because the next ring you're going to do is the comfy ring. I call it the you're welcome to my house in my front yard. You can hang out at a party at the house, but I don't think you're one on one dinner material. You're not going to read my diary with me, but we're comfy to have a playdate or different things like that. Now this add a little more diversified. 00:36:10.8900000 Going back through that list of race, gender, age. You start to seat, but you're keeping them at arm's distance, that brain staying a little uncomfortable. Then go out to the outer ring. We all have acquaintances, people we say hi to in the courtroom. People say, oh, yeah, I know them from law school. 00:36:24.8920000 Oh, yeah, they're a friend, but they're really not a friend. If you're a friend, you invite them over to dinner, they'd be down the inner circle. Look at those in the race, gender, age, sexual orientation. It's a little more diverse. And if you think about this and then think about internally, if you're a manager or partner or supervising attorney, who are you going to promote? 00:36:47.2580000 Who are you going to give the best assignments to? Who are you going to foster and mentor and really take under your wing and take them out to network? You're going to network or take them out, the ones out that are into or reaching into that inner circle. And if they're all similar to you, then what's that doing? And so really kind of thinking about that and who's around you and that work allocation, promotion and who's giving it and how it's done. 00:37:15.3080000 If it's not just based on merit but by recommendation of a supervisor, then that could be something to consider too. Where we can see an 8.4 g or 8.4 d violation, we can also see it through discharge as well. Company layoff. If we enter another recession, I'm sure that firms will be laying off. They did, I remember back in 20 07, 20 08, 20 09 because that's when I hit the market as a lawyer. 00:37:40.1700000 And so I know that that is coming if that happens again. And so how is that going to look based on seniority system? What does that look out like? Because all the DI initiatives have been in the most recent years, so they're at the lower level. So you can see it there too. 00:37:54.9200000 And so there could be potential draws. It can also affect civility and then that FFA part of our brain, how we converse with clients and how we deal with difficult clients. We need to know how to tailor our speech and how to communicate with clients of different races, nationalities. If they don't understand us or we don't understand them. We got to make that communication come through and really work at it. 00:38:21.7120000 We also have to know when to say enough is enough. If we have uncivil clients and this is going away from the bias and the stereotype. But uncivil meaning going back to the incivility, like mean, yelling, wanting you to do things against the rules of professional conduct, wanting you to violate the law, we need to know when to say is enough. We never want to go down to a level of incivility and we never want a client to bring us down to that level of incivility. So we really have to think about those things and really know what we're doing and just putting that out there. 00:38:55.9000000 You can also have really dealing with uncivil opposing counsel. How many of you have had an uncivil opposing counsel? Anyone. Probably everyone. And you may think, it's them. 00:39:05.2320000 It's not me. It's them. Well, guess what they're thinking. It's you. It's not me. 00:39:08.8480000 It's you. And so it goes back and forth. Some say it's younger lawyers that are uncivil. Some say it's older lawyers that are uncivil. I say it's every lawyer that's been uncivil at one or more times in their legal career. 00:39:20.8420000 It just depends on the situation. It just depends on what's happening. But we really need to check ourselves, whether it be through that unconscious bias, stereotypes, incivility or the mean demeanor, the tone, the aggression, those things. We have to really check what we do know that civility could affect us. We could draw those violations. 00:39:46.6500000 If they get to you, though, you have a mean opposing counsel or one that's being very uncivil to you, the more they get to you, then they win. If they bring you down to their level, they win. Why let them win? You don't want to want them to win the courtroom, so why are you going to fight fire with fire? Let them win. 00:40:05.7300000 Don't let them bring you down, or they win. You can smile. You can just ignore it. Do nothing, do not engage. That usually infuriates them more, which is kind of amusing to watch if you're on the right side of it. 00:40:18.9840000 You always fight up, not fight down. Have passion, professionalism. Beat them where it counts. Beat them in the courtroom. Do you think judges are going to like that uncivil, unprofessional lawyer arguing and screaming over someone who's going to come in there, being rational, level headed, knowing the law, presenting the arguments in a very neutral way, and not screaming and yelling and being some big theatrical production. 00:40:45.0700000 If you were a judge, which would you prefer? Calm, rational, knows the law, knows her stuff, fighting the fight like you're supposed to, or someone who probably doesn't know the law, probably didn't do all their homework and needs to put on a show just to give pomp and circumstance to their clients. Which one? Civil, uncivil. One could be prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:41:08.5500000 One, not one is more the ones we want to look out for. You want to stay ahead, outsmart them. Always prepare, prepare, prepare. All communications should be placed in writing, especially if you're dealing with an uncivil council, because if you need to file a motion for sanctions or something, then you really need to have something in writing to move forward. So document bad behavior of opposing counsel in a memo form so that could easily flipped into a motion with dates, times, different things like that. 00:41:40.3500000 Obviously, too. Kill your opposing counsel with kindness. Play the waiting game. Know and follow the rules at all times. Just make sure that you are aware of the different things. 00:41:52.6440000 Check your attitude. It is so easily to have a bad day or a bad moment or your kids drive you nuts as you run out the door. Don't take it on your coworkers. Don't take it on on opposing counsel. Don't take it on your clients. 00:42:05.5340000 You need to stand up and be professional. Stand up to bullying in the profession. Don't stoop that low. And I remember it was at one of the firms I've been at over the years. It was an associate counsel. 00:42:17.1540000 They came and they filed a complaint against one of the higher level partners or senior attorneys in the firm. And the complaint was consistently, the partner gives me work every weekend at night. They don't do it to the other people, the other associates, and just the workload and just being just kind of almost vindictive, like, they'd keep the assignments all day, not give it to the associate. Then wait until 05:00 p.m. And say, I need this by tomorrow. 00:42:48.0700000 And so when asked that senior attorney why they did this, if they've had them all day, that work life balance, like, just being civil to the associates as they're learning, that attorney said, well, my mentor when I was their age did it to me, so they deserve it, too. We don't need to do that. We don't need to say, well, this happened to me, so it better happen to them, too. No, I know misery likes company, but let's get over that past. Let's go to therapy for that. 00:43:18.4160000 Go deal with that on your own, and act civil now in the future and change the course. Change what happened so that you're not doing that to someone else. And that's that uncivil nature of that attorney that was, in that situation, that supervisor, they were just so miserable and uncivil, and it was starting to bleed out, and that was just, we just need to stop that line of thinking and be more respectful and civil moving forward. Here's just some examples of incivility and some tips of how to combat it. If a lawyer does not provide a requested document after agreeing to do so, write them. 00:43:54.2520000 Remember, put everything in writing. I've called five times. You have not had the courtesy to return my call, and I still have not received those documents. So you have something to for a motion for sanctions. If you need it for late night faxes, notify, excuse me, for late night faxes, notify opposing counsel that he or she will not succumb to the tactic. 00:44:14.1660000 In court yesterday, you said you had a fax to me. The following documents. You did so at 11:44 p.m. Certainly you must have known that I was not working at that hour. When not an OD, reasonable opportunity for you and respond. 00:44:25.0820000 Those tactics, like the assignments given late at night, write memos to the file when you suspect trouble. It can be as basic as saying, I spoke with attorney X, told him I will not accept his 05:00 p.m. Fax notices, and if he does it again, I was going to ask for sanctions. I want to memorialize this for myself, so if it happens, I know that I told him and the date. So you start memorializing things to make sure that you have it in writing for when you need those sanctions or when you need different things that could come about in those different areas. 00:44:59.9500000 So interactions with coworkers, opposing counsel, third parties, correspondents, these are different examples that have happened over time. And these are real cases. And the case citations are down at the bottom. You can look them up, too. And we'll go through some of these here. 00:45:17 First one, we have an attorney, Glenn Robinson, who gauged in sexual behavior with current and former clients. One of the clients included some incident with a paperclip and some sexual undertakings, and also quid pro quo sexual harassment situation as a condition of employment. This was a violation of 8.4 g, 8.4 d, and tons of other stuff, but again, suspended for two years. In Vermont in 2019, we went too far. Another case, Robert E. 00:45:49.0880000 Abrams, represented a married couple to file a construction contract lawsuit against a former builder. Abrams developed a negative opinion of the judge presiding over the case. In an email to his clients, Abrams referred to the judge using derogatory slurs that exhibited bias, prejudice based on sexual orientation. In those emails, the case said that he referred to the judge as being weak, as being bullied, being not man enough type of language that was in there. Clients were like, you're talking about the judge over our case and you don't like him and you're holding this bias or stereotype against him. 00:46:25.3880000 How are you going to be effective for us? The clients actually fired him, reported him to the disciplinary commission for his unprofessionalism, civility violations. The 8.4 D and G got three months suspension in Colorado for that conduct. Why would you talk to someone else but your clients about their judge in that manner? Just using common sense and professionalism is what really needs to happen here. 00:46:50.6760000 And so that's just kind of where this is. Last night, I don't know if it was more of a lapse of judgment or they thought maybe it was like the good old boys club, like your clients or your buddies, but we've got to remember there's a line of professionalism with clients that we always need to maintain there, too. So that was one of them. This is another one. Stacey L. 00:47:09.4680000 Kelly claimed to be her husband's attorney. So in this scenario, that's what puts her in 8.4 g when she claimed to be her husband's attorney. That's practicing law. She's saying, I'm a husband's attorney. We're in practicing law. 00:47:21.8240000 This could also be 8.4 d. When she called a telemarketer who've been trying to reach someone else with her husband's name. While on the phone with the telemarketer, she asked the representative he was gay or sweet because she thought he had a very feminine sounding voice. 8.4 g has what? Sexual orientation. 00:47:40.0740000 Those things. Indiana has had 8.4 g on its books back in 2010 and way before the model rules adopted it in 2018. This was a public reprimand here in Indiana for just talking to a telemarketer. Those robocalls, how many of you have been so frustrated with robocalls? You have cuts, you've gone off on them, you've threatened them. 00:48:02.3960000 All those different things. Did you ever think it could potentially subject you to attorney discipline? It can. Especially if you claim to be an attorney, even if you're not representing someone on the call, especially to say, I'm an attorney. And putting yourself into that practicing law definition, depending on what you say after that, could subject you to discipline. 00:48:25.3540000 Think about that. With contractors, with telemarketers, with salespeople you've gotten angry with, with customer service representatives. Think about that. Is that worth the risk of an attorney discipline? I don't think so, but maybe you do. 00:48:42.0700000 This is another one out of Indiana. Lawyer McCarthy represented a title company and was involved in a dispute regarding a cloud of title in a property. The agent representing the seller of the property had his secretary send an email to McCarthy to arrange a meeting. So we have a nice secretary sending an email to opposing counsel to arrange a meeting? Just a meeting of the priorities opposing council. 00:49:02.5180000 McCarthy, the one who received the email from the secretary, sent an email back stating, I know you must do your boss's bidding at his direction, but I'm here to tell you that I'm neither you nor his. Then there's a very derogatory word. You do not tell me what to do. You ask, if you ever act like that again, it will be the last time I give any thought to your existence. And your boss will have to talk to me. 00:49:23.5920000 Do we understand each other? Yeah. This was not taken lightly. This was an email back to a secretary asking for a meeting for her attorney. And this is what we get back. 00:49:38.4700000 They really looked at the word, the n word, that was used in a very derogatory sense as an insult. They said there is no way this could have been used as a historical reference, which he tried to claim, and that it manifested bias and racial prejudice. And he got 30 day suspension without automatic reinstatement. Without automatic reinstatement is like a death null. That means you have to reapply, go through the application bar process, go through the interviews, go through all that stuff, and the commission can still deny you readmittance. 00:50:09.4020000 You're not guaranteed to become a lawyer again. So he was suspended for 30 days. Then he could reapply again, but he's not guaranteed to be back in the law practice after that. Here is that twerking lawyer incident I told you about during the mediation. Lead defense counsel was a large company. 00:50:25.7360000 Shook his butt at plaintiff's counsel while uttering profanities such as, do you want to f me? Do you have a ponytail haircut? I figured you'd want to f me. The conduct was described as levacious gyrating of the lower, fleshy extremities. Plaintiff filed for sanctions, monetary defense counsel. 00:50:40.9500000 Unfortunately, new defense counsel, in response to plaintiff's motion for sanctions, used the phrase, let's put this unfortunate episode in the rear view mirror. Probably not the best phraseology for the conduct that happened anyway, here. The judge did not issue sanctions, said that the attorney is going to suffer enough because it received national intention, and he was fired from the case. Texas does not have 8.4 g, the title seven of the rules of professional conduct. But they did get 8.44 prejudicial to the administration of justice. 00:51:15.5980000 No twerking in depositions. Moral of that story. This is another one. Depositions. I don't know what it is about depositions. 00:51:23.6820000 This is a plaintiff's lawyer stopped at deposition, so she stopped in the middle she threw her hands on the table. She ducked her head underneath it. And why, you may ask? Posting counsel wanted to know why too. When a counsel asked her what she was doing, she indicated that she was looking to see if there was anything between his legs. 00:51:41.5500000 Ms. Linhart, the lawyer that did it, later apologized for her contact, stated that she lost her composure due to being chronically and persistently exposed to condescending behavior of the opposing counsel. So she let it get she went down to his level. If that was really what was happening, which she shouldn't have done, this was potentially an 8.4 D violation, 8.4 g in Connecticut if they had it. But Connecticut again is another one of the jurisdictions that at the time did not have 8.4 g on the books. 00:52:10.6740000 We don't need to be ground the table asking what people have between their legs, not really proper, not really civil, can lead to those claims. Dorothy J. Thompson, Esquire, represented a husband in a divorce proceeding in 2003. The wife had a friend that was African American. During the bench trial, Ms. 00:52:29.2380000 Thompson referred to the friend as the black guy, the black man. The man's race was irrelevant to the case. Public reprimand if race is not relevant to the case, it should not be brought up. Race should never be brought up in any context. If it is not relevant to the case or an issue in the case or something of that nature. 00:52:46.1580000 Here it was not. This was in Indiana in 2005, prejudicial to the administration of justice. Dorothy Thompson was sanctioned. Another one, Vincent Campedi, represented a father in a child support hearing. Mr. 00:53:02.5200000 Campidi repeated disparaging references to the facts that the mother was not a United States citizen, was receiving legal services for no charge. These facts were relevant, again, not relevant to the proceeding. Public reprimand, just like here. Not relevant to the proceeding. Public reprimand. 00:53:17.9100000 Public reprimand. Some other ones just to think about too. Phrases such as stupid idiot, go back to Puerto Rico. Those are not, unless relevant, not appropriate. Don't want to talk to you, little lady. 00:53:32.1860000 Tell the little mouse over there to pipe down. Be quiet, little girl, go away. Again, don't say that someone has a foul, odious body and for them to go on the other side, we really want to keep that out. Also, anything regarding religion, again, that's one of those classes in 8.4 g and could trigger 8.4 d as well. So how do you combat this within your law practice or with the lawyers and non lawyers that you work with, have company policies and initiatives, train them on the recruiting process? 00:54:01.9000000 We talked about, train them on the screening, train them on just knowing that they have an unconscious bias. And that's okay because we all have it. We just have to know we have it. And then when we realize it's happening, do something to stop it from happening. Like take those actions. 00:54:17.0020000 So we've got to do those things too. Eliminating bias through the groups, eliminating bias through training and workshops. Diversity, listening, pay equity. These are all initiatives and policies that you can do. Finding awareness and acceptance, developing it, not making snap judgments, widening your circle of confidence, removing bias and decision making, speaking up, being accountable, doing all those things. 00:54:40.8600000 And we can only combat unconscious bias, instability or any of those things if we are honest about it. Realize it happens and realize we're not perfect. We've probably been uncivil. We've probably been on both sides of this, but hopefully we're on the better side more often than not. But we have to really think about it. 00:55:00.2720000 Do you think social unrest in our society contributes to our incivility, contributes to that in our legal profession? The answer is probably yes. Unfortunately, it's yes. Or maybe that's a good thing because it makes us stop and look at policies and revisit what we're doing and look at that as well. But something to really think about. 00:55:20.7700000 With that, you are free to go and have a wonderful evening.